Follow TV Tropes
It's been a while since I've paid any attention to this, so I need a reminder: how does someone bring something to the attention of the P5, if we're talking about a proposal rather than an existing page?
Through the 5P policy thread.
Parent Service is coming across as pretty greasy at the moment, and may need a walk through the Trope Repair Shop if we want to turn it into something other than who/what tropers find sexy in kids' shows.
Yes, we should remove Evil Is Sexy from Orphan. We are not calling small children sexy.
edited 3rd Jan '16 8:40:24 PM by shimaspawn
Parent Service has enough invocations, discussions, lampshadings, and Word of God examples to support a page, but it does need a good scrubbing.
So does this mean Lolita now violates the Content Policy?
Lolita is exempt due to being academically significant and demonizing pedophilia.
edited 16th Feb '16 6:48:43 AM by Karxrida
No. That was decided years ago, when Fast Eddie was in charge.
Fast Eddie had to be hit over the head with a sledgehammer regarding Lolita , but after that it was voted to stay. Paraphrasing one person arguing for it to be kept, the main character's attempts to justify his behavior just make him look more and more terrible. That's why it's not going anywhere.
What about Kodomo no Jikan?
It's not a matter of Admin Fiat so much that anybody who read it can tell it violates the Content Policy to a horrid degree. The story makes an attempt to condemn pedophilia, but clearly supports it by the story's design as well.
Admin Fiat just happened to happen, but there's no need to reevaluate it when it blatantly would never make it.
Bingo. There's so much loli fanservice that it completely undermines the overall intent of the story. It didn't help that the page at one point was loaded with scanlation links pointing to said fanservice and other not-so-savory stuff. Attempts were made to clean the page up and get rid of any inherent creepiness to its tone but it was deemed unsalvageable.
The only way I could see it and some other cut works brought back would be as example-less stub pages, much like what was agreed upon with FATAL.
edited 17th Feb '16 10:31:26 AM by Willbyr
edited 2nd Sep '17 1:09:36 PM by YasminPerry
Best Known for the Fanservice is very pervy. I'd clean it up, but most of the examples make me go ewww.
This is probably old news, but has Valkyrie Drive: Mermaid been looked at? It's apparently about lesbians who gain superpowers by having sex with each other, and the sex is at least explicit enough to frequently show bare breasts (unsure about genitals though).
edited 13th Jun '16 8:33:31 PM by HamburgerTime
No genitals in that show.
Valkyrie Drive does go a bit further than your typical ecchi (direct fetish-pandering, on-screen sex, etc) but as previously mentioned:
1. Never shows genitals
2. Aired on public Japanese television (albeit censored)
3. Everyone involved in sexual activity is 16 or older.
However, I'd be for a P5 investigation if it makes others feel more comfortable...except for the fact that we don't have much of a P5 right now. There was a selection process thing announced a few weeks ago, I dunno how that's going...
edited 16th Jun '16 2:19:37 PM by Assassin-sensei
Lover and Beloved seriously needs a good hard look, example-wise, but I'm not sure what's best cut and where. I obviously don't think that we should torch the examples section, or even necessarily cut most of the examples assuming that they fit, but some of those descriptions are way out of line,
On Valkyrie Drive: Mermaid, one of characters is actually 15 years old (the dark-skinned one from the page image), but everyone else in the series is over 16 (I believe). There is a supplementary material what gives a Fridge Horror of sexual activities being done to a 9+ year old, but nothing of that kind is actually told in the side story, and even after a five year time skip, nothing explicit is told in it.
edited 21st Jul '16 7:04:58 AM by TPPR10
The Rock Cocks has floated up in the queue. While the comic doesn't seem to be porn enough to just nuke it without P5, some of the stuff on the pages is over the line
The NSFW character pics and Tumblr link need to be snipped. As for the comic itself, what little I've seen of it gives me a Plot With Porn impression...Oglaf levels of explicitness, for sure.
edited 10th Sep '16 8:35:49 AM by Willbyr
Ok, snipped the direct site links. I left the link to patreon as that frontpage is SFW and links to the actual comic, so it kinda works as a gate check.
Pics cut: a lot of nudity here◊, naked bum there◊ and there◊
edited 10th Sep '16 9:01:01 AM by Adannor
Ok a bit of a question - does wicks cleanup for P5 cuts go here or in some of the wick cleaning threads.
Anyway, I'll drop off the Related pages for Squad Broken and ryona genre (damn that's a lot of inbounds) as a memo to look through.
edited 7th Dec '16 11:54:08 PM by Adannor
Wick cleanup is not usually within the scope of 5P work at all, seeing as we still allow examples for 5P-cut works.
Yes, but there's still the rule that the examples themselves must be not about the sex parts.
And ryona is a genre. That's a bit of it's own deal - do we need that pointing out from works in which a female gets some battle damage?
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?