The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Ok, Well, I accidentally zapped it. Sorry.

Alright, I was fast watching episode 3 of Angel's 3Piece!, and who would have guessed? More skeevy moments with the lead girls, now semi-naked, and even a red-face from the main character about the situation, and that was in the first two minutes into the episode.

Other than that... ehh... I dunno, I don't think I saw more fanservice-y moments with the little girls from what I've checked. I'm not sure what to think right now, by the way.

edited 24th Jul '17 3:08:04 PM by Lightmaster

That doesn't sound that bad. Half naked young girls in swimsuits are pretty normal in anime tbh. I'm pretty sure Eromanga-Sensei is worse.

Remember Values Dissonance and all.

edited 25th Jul '17 9:08:51 AM by ReynTime250

Where did we draw the line/what did we exactly cut Ro-Kyu-Bu! for? Was it just the high level of skeevy bath scenes?

Start here, I think. We had a lot more material to work with for Ro-Kyu-Bu than we do here, since nobody's translated the Tenshi no 3P! manga yet, but the gist of it is that things got a fair bit more explicit than just skeevy bath scenes.

edited 24th Jul '17 11:48:58 PM by Pyrite

So we should assume that if things get out of hand (I.E. the main character having romantic feelings for either the three main girls or her little sister) in top of the skeevy moments, is where the 5P council would draw the line? Hmm... I suppose we need to wait how this series develops in the next episodes. I'm not sure.

The key question to ask is if minors are being sexualised or if paedopandering is present - if so, it's grounds for cutting. Whether or not it crosses the line will usually be decided upon formal review, so if you think there's cause for concern the first step is to flag it.

edited 25th Jul '17 9:08:32 AM by Pyrite

I think I have already flagged it twice by using the Report button, Some of the content I saw in all three episodes (the double entendre in episode 1, the skeevy moments I already alluded to in episode 2, and the other skeevy moment in episode 3) could be a good ground for cutting, I don't know. I suppose that's for the 5P staff to decide, not us.

Huh, yeah, it's on the reports list twice.

This and this need more votes.

Ok, since I screwed up Baldr Sky, how do I fix that? Just make a new page?

Also, it seems that someone reported the Dork Age film wrong. They reported it rather than taking it to discussion or ATT.

Flag it again.

The DorkAge.Film report was sent by ~slicervanguard27 who should repost it in Ask The Tropers.

Baldr Sky's page was long deleted, the proposal was to bring it back.

Either way you need it flagged.

Okay, my status for Angel's 3Piece! this week. Oddly enough, no fanservice-y moments, except for a minor scene at 17 minutes in. Nothing in this episode was remarkable or that rises concern about the content. Surprisingly, I felt like this episode was somewhat cozy, even if I didn't hear the audio. I dunno, that's how this episode felt.

We'll see how the show behaves next week,

For a restoration petition, you go to the empty page and make a report on it. So I put it back on the list and gave it an angel to start.

edited 31st Jul '17 12:21:22 PM by Adannor

I see it, thanks.

Is there anything here that can be checked off as "done".

Mekko Rarekko seems to have been properly executed.

I asked not to boot it off so I can check examples linking to it for pornyness. Which analysis I've been too busy to undertake lately.

What a weird coincidence: I've actually read Mekko Rarekko and inexplicably hadn't noticed it was on our docket. I found it surprisingly compelling, if a bit contrived and horribly depressing. I cannot understate that last part. It is brutally miserable.

It also violates our site guidelines like nobody's business. Pretty much a guaranteed cut, and I see the rest of the panel agrees. Whether the examples from it should remain elsewhere, however, is its own question.

Strange that I missed the gay furry misery porn doujinshi. That's basically my wheelhouse.

edited 2nd Aug '17 8:54:12 PM by JHM

It was cut, I'm just planning on combing the examples relating to it from other pages when I have the time to dedicate to the check-up.

edited 2nd Aug '17 11:25:33 PM by Adannor

I'm aware. I just find it funny that I had read this and independently come to the conclusion that this shit would never fly on this site and somehow missed the unanimous "cut" verdict several months prior during my tenure here.

Anyway, I assume the issue here is if some of the examples which cite it are themselves inappropriate? I would be glad to help in whatever capacity.

Making a tally of all the stuff that still needs votes:

• Awkward Silence, Boyfriend to Death, F.A.T.A.L., Literotica, Oneiroi Series, Playboy, A Serbian Film, The Story of O: Two angels.
• Baldr Sky, Cibus Esculentus Madoka Magica, Emmanuelle, Gokujou Drops, Jailbait (2014), Kichikuou Rance, The Last Sovereign, The Phoenix of the Wasteland, Squid Ops, Umibe No Onna Noko: One angel.
• Amat Omnes^note Also a stub and will prolly be cut as such; the question for the 5P is whether the work is suitable enough to allow a restoration as a proper article if it comes to pass, The Ass Goblins of Auschwitz, Here Comes The Three Angels, Holey Matrimony, Killing Stalking, Masou Gakuen HXH, Microcosm, Sad Satan, The Vagina Ass of Lucifer Niggerbastard, Yandere I Love You So I Want To Kill You: No votes yet.
• The Human Centipede Love At First Bite, Saikin Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga, Stockholm, Tsugumomo: One devil.
• Breakfast Club, Fish In The Trap^note Also a stub and will prolly be cut as such; the question for the 5P is whether the work is suitable enough to allow a restoration as a proper page if it comes to pass: Two devils and one angel.
• Tales Of Schlock: Two devils.

Cibus Esculentus Madoka Magica (one of the entries has a vote already), Here Comes The Three Angels and Sad Satan are in the CVR twice. I also wonder where ~Harmonious Fusion is.

Well, we've been kind of discussing Here Comes The Three Angels for several pages now, and it's now up to episode 5. It seems like the show is occasionally getting skeevy, but hasn't crossed fully into the territory that made us cut the author's Ro-Kyu-Bu!...yet. The LNs aren't translated so there's no way of seeing the content level from those.

I only know bits and pieces about Eromanga Sensei (just added to the queue), but the things I know are skeevy. There's a twelve-year-old girl who's an erotic writer, and she has a friend of the same age who loudly proclaims her love for dicks just to get a rise out of the older brother. There's also an elf girl who's 14 and likes to play the piano naked or something? I dunno.

edited 7th Aug '17 1:25:05 PM by Assassin-sensei