These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: Godzilla (2014)
Alternate Character Interpretation: On how heroic this incarnation of Godzilla is. Is he actually concerned with protecting humanity, or is he just acting as a predator against the Muto that sees humanity as a pragmatic ally?
The Making-Of volume specifically singles out the MUTO's as the 'dark/evil' side of nature, suggesting that while it might have sounded a little hokey to actively brand Godzilla a 'hero' in-film, this was very much the intention for Godzilla. Also, the film does have a number of instances where Godzilla could cause property damage, but avoids it; the exception is the scene at the bridge, where he's actually provoked.
While this is easily averted for the film itself in the Japanese market (Toho themselves heaped praise upon the movie), it's played straight with Godzilla's redesign, which a decent portion of the audience over there consider to be weaker, or, for some people, fatter, than the original.
The movie has gotten a pretty bad rep in places where Godzilla hasn't been established as a pop-culturally relevant franchise, and so most people have grown up with the previous American reboot instead. Being that one of the main focuses of the film was to approach it from a "fan perspective" and distance it as much as possible from the '98 movie, it's easy to see why this strategy backfired in places where audiences harbored no love for the Japanese Godzilla, especially since reviews agreed that its faithfulness to the source material was one of the movie's main selling points. Basically, the two movies' receptions are inverted compared to countries where the brand has had a history.
The film did really poorly in the South Korean market. Box office analysts have compared the South Korean market for this movie with Pacific Rim and noticed how it was an unusual outlier considering Godzilla did better than Pacific Rim in every other territory.
Base Breaker: Ford and Elle Brody, whose relationship drama and generic personalities steal screentime away from the Big G.
Replacement Scrappy: Ford Brody's Base-Breaking qualities are intensified after he replaces his father as the protagonist of the film.
When this leak of Godzilla himself was posted online, fans were split. Many believe he looks like he should and that he retains most of his most notable features. On the other hand many don't like the more "human like" eyes of the design, his small teeth, the sauropod-esque feet, and the gills on the side of his neck. Not to mention the mightily revamped sound of his roar....
When word came that Toho had seen the full film several weeks before release and thought it was great, fans were split on whether that praise amounted to anything. Some fans thought that it was proof that the film would be great if the original makers of Godzilla thought it was so, while others pointed out that Toho have also put their seal of approval on lesser Godzilla films like All Monsters Attack and even (initially, at least) Godzilla (1998).
Viewers tend to be split between the camps of "strong entry in the Godzilla series that carries the spirit of the 1954 original" and "weak due to boring human leads and too little Godzilla," with a middle grouping of "good overall, but could have used more Godzilla presence." This spread even to professional movie critics.
There are some that complain that the film is nowhere near as dark and grim as the trailers made it out to be.
The short amount of screen time Godzilla got compared to the human characters. Those who didn't mind it point out that the amount of screen time Godzilla had in the Showa Era films were relatively similar to this film. Those who did mind are divided between whether Godzilla became a secondary character in his own movie, or felt his on-screen presence was sufficient but could have been balanced out by making the human characters more interesting.
The way the movie keeps teasing the audience by cutting away from the monster battles to the humans. The teasing either makes the climax all the sweeter or sours the whole experience. Many believe the impact of Godzilla's first full-frontal appearance in Hawaii, about to fight one of the Mutos, was weakened by cutting away to Ford's family watching snippets of the fight on the news after it happened. The climactic San Francisco battle is directly shown but still heavily intercut with the humans, especially the soldiers. In contrast, the Japanese movies tend to have longer battles with less interruptions.
The smaller focus Godzilla got compared to the Mutos. This might be understandable for a sequel where Godzilla is already established, but not for his origin story. The Mutos drive the plot much more than Godzilla does, despite what the trailers would have one believe — they're the real "antagonists"; it's them who Bryan Cranston's character is freaking out over. He doesn't even know about Godzilla.
The design of the Mutos. Some think they're too bland with their drab black/grey color, especially since Godzilla is the same color and they fight several times at night. Other like them for how utterly different they look from any previous kaiju, looking nothing like a man in a suit.
Although there's really no argument in the hard-core part of the fanbase, some of the more "flexible" fans and general monster movie lovers are divided on whether this movie is better or worse than the 1998 film. Frequently argued-over topics include which one's more fun, has more memorable characters, what their actors are given and how well they pull it off, gives more screen-time for the titular creature, and which depiction of Godzilla is more serviceable to modern, non-fan audiences.
Joe Brody is considered to be the best human character in the movie, and to some, the franchise as a whole. Being played by Bryan Cranston probably has something to do with that. The real reason he's listed as part of the ensemble is because he dies in the first half of the movie, but gives a memorable performance in that time.
The nameless Badass Driver bus driver who not only passes through a military/police barricade, he drives like hell when Godzilla has an explosive skirmish with the military.
Sergeant Morales has only three scenes but he is liked for being amicable and polite even in the face of danger.
Fandom Berserk Button: Saying that this is a remake of the 1998 film doesn't sit well with Godzilla fans. Same thing goes for when journalists or critics say that the '98 film was "the last Godzilla film" until this one, out of apparent ignorance of Godzilla Final Wars and the rest of the Millennium series.
A minor one with Man of Steel, with jokes about how Godzilla's battles with the MUTOs apparently caused less property damage than Superman's battle with Zod.
There's one with Pacific Rim revolving around debates over which stylistic approach is best for a Kaiju film, the fantastical and lighthearted one for Pacific Rim or the realistic and dark one for Godzilla. Although there's a sizeable portion of people -including Del Toro himself- who'd love to see a crossover.
The Godzilla fanbase In general is either friendly with Pacific Rim fans, united in their love of kaiju — or would like them to piss off because Godzilla is a genuine Japanese kaiju property, not an imitation, and would so totally own all the robots and creatures in that film.
Harsher in Hindsight: In the earliest stages of the film, Toho required Gareth Edwards to have the film take place mainly in Japan. Edwards says that the Fukushima plant leak, which happened after this stipulation was given, made it where the team had to be extra careful in being respectful to the victims of that leak.
Back in 1985, Warner Bros.'s Pee-wee's Big Adventure featured a brief scene where Pee-wee rides through a film set where Godzilla is fighting King Ghidorah. 29 years later, WB is now making an actual, full Godzilla movie.
This◊ image making fun of the 1998 film with Snickers' "You're not you when you're hungry" campaign is funnier now that there is an official Snickers commercial made to promote this film.
Godzilla's feet are rounder, sauropod-like and with relatively short talons, which is what they were like in Bambi Meets Godzilla.
In The Amazing Spider-Man, Captain Stacy jokes about not being "the mayor of Tokyo" in response to Peter Parker's claim that Dr. Connors has turned into the giant lizard monster roaming around New York, in a Shout-Out to Godzilla. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 ended up being a direct box office competitor with the old menace of Tokyo himself in May of 2014.
In Lilo & Stitch, a scene featured the titular alien Stitch (while in Hawaii) making a scale model of San Francisco then smashing akin to a kaiju rampage. Godzilla would eventually come to both Honolulu and San Francisco in the movie. Additionally, both films feature Elvis' "(You're the) Devil in Disguise".
When Godzilla's appearance was more clearly revealed to the Japanese by the Asia trailer, Japanese fans complained that he looked too fat. While this led to the obligatory jokes about him eating too many Snickers' bars (see above), a Fiat commercial released soon after these complaints first popped up implies that it's more because he had been "craving Italian" lately.
Holy Shit Quotient: The final battle in San Francisco is awesome. Special props needs to be given to the use of the Atomic Breath, which actually garners a "HOLY SHIT!" from one of the soldiers that sees it In-Universe, and it's especially awe-inspiring when it's used to decapitate the female Muto.
Hype Backlash: Strangely enough, from professional movie critics - while one side derided it as yet another blockbuster, many critics demanded more Godzilla fighting.
I Am Not Shazam: The movie features a Covert Group called MONARCH. However, it was misidentified by the public as being named "M.U.T.O." in the months leading up to the film's release. This confusion can be blamed on the M.U.T.O. Research website set up as part of the Viral Marketing. M.U.T.O. stands for "Massive Unidentified Terrestrial Organism" and refers to the Kaiju that is being researched. But some of the responses included phrases like "Please stop wasting M.U.T.O. resources" or "M.U.T.O. assures all personnel", making it seem like the name of the organization. Inversely, another few of text responses refer to certain activities being "reported to MONARCH," but this whole confusion led people to speculate that MONARCH referred to either A) the codename for an individual within the organization, or B) the name of some fictional security software.
It does star the Trope Namer himself, after all. The first official teaser trailer leans on this heavily: all it really reveals about the film's plot is that Godzilla's in it, he causes loads of destruction and this upsets and frightens many people (i.e. the simplest, most basic elements of a Godzilla story). This was tantalizing enough to shoot the trailer to more than 10 million Youtube views in a week.
Similarly, most fans didn't expect Godzilla: Smash3 to be particularly good when it was first revealed, but the game was still closely examined because it gave the best yet view of the new Godzilla design.
Among non-fans and even people who actively dislike Godzilla, Bryan Cranston has become enough of a draw for them. Jeremy Jahns mentions this in his review of the teaser:
"Yeah, that was Bryan Cranston. Okay, well... I'll watch the movie. I was on the fence with the big lizard tearing shit through a city, but you bring in Heisenberg and — alright, I'm there."
Come on, did anyone really think they were going to kill the Big G off before he could defeat the Mutos? It's slightly more convincing when he collapses and lies dormant after his victory, but this is a character that lived through being nuked.
Subverted with Joe Brody. Some viewers didn't think he would actually die from his wounds, believing that a character so prominently featured in the trailers wouldn't be killed off in the first act.
Already in the comments section for the trailers there are loads of comments on how Walter White/Heisenbergwill face off against Godzilla, or defeat him using Meth and Ricin. Hell, there are even tons of comments theorizing that Walter White escaped to Japan and created Godzilla to kill Skylar!
This GIF◊ of the very end of the second trailer, which shows Godzilla being viewed out of a door that is closing, has spread across the internet with various funny comments, usually along the lines of Screw This, I'm Outta Here!
The Twitter hashtag "#demandtoknow" has been repurposed for some quirky contexts. ThisCinema Blend article, for one, says:
"At best, this is a legit scary movie. At worst, this is a borderline traumatic experience. Forget about WB and Legendary Pictures gambling with a hefty budget: is Godzilla gonna have to give us some therapy? #demandtoknow"
This video takes the audio of the first official main trailer and syncs it up with footage from Attack on Titan.
"[Gareth] Edwards channels poppycock" is a largely nonsensical insult from an infamous negative review by Tony Macklin that has become a common Appropriated Appellation among Godzilla fans.
To hide a good fight that many people wanted to see is now being known as "a Godzilla 2014" or to "Godzilla 2014" something.
Godzilla's noticeable avoidance of collateral damage wherever possible led to many people praising him as a better hero than the Destructive Savior version of Superman in Man of Steel.
MisBlamed: Legendary Pictures, Warner Bros. and Gareth Edwards were all criticized for "lying" about the second trailer being released by February 14 of 2014, with accusations of Invisible Advertising being bandied about afterward. Except that none of the people actually involved with the film ever said anything of the sort. The rumour started with some random Lebanese news website, which claimed that the trailer would come on Feb. 7. Then movie news sites and Godzilla fan sites parroted that and then got the date changed to Feb. 14 along the line, and Godzilla fans subsequently got overhyped and then overly disappointed as a result.
The way Godzilla finishes off the last Muto, which sort of looks like a Kiss of Death, can be seen as unintentionally silly.
The scene where the military investigate the nuke graveyard and find the female Muto escaped... leaving a giant hole in the side of the mountain and is clearly marching to Vegas in the midday sun.Failed a Spot Check of epic proportions.
There is nothing more hilarious than the line which explains that M.U.T.O stands for "Massive Unidentified Terrestrial Organism"...and then the same character immediately points out "except it can fly, so it's not really terrestrial." I guess MUFO "Massive Unidentified Flying Organism" isn't as catchy?
Narm Charm: There's charm in some of the above Narm moments, but moments where it works for the better are also plentiful.
The Muto courtship scene, where the male offers the female a nuclear warhead, comparable to the Spaghetti Kiss from Lady and the Tramp. Yes, it's kind of silly and clashes a bit with the mood of the film, but it also shows a more sympathetic side to the monsters.
Some of Godzilla's mannerisms make him come off as less an unstoppable juggernaut acting on nature's behalf and more a grumpy old man who simply wants everything to be done with. Surprisingly, this sort of works; his bouncing between the two gives him a large amount of sympathy and personality while reminding the audience he's a walking engine of chaos, both frightening and endearing the audience.
In the aftermath of the monster battle, the news banner declaring Godzilla to be "Savior of our City?" can feel a bit over the top, but what takes the cake is some San Francisco people cheering Godzilla. It doesn't last long, but it seems more like a reference to the cheesy films of the 60s and 70s, rather than the grim 1954 original that inspired the rest of the film.
Nightmare Retardant: Some audiences have described Godzilla's redesign as looking less like a terrifying force of destruction and more "pudgy and cute". Others are of the opinion that the traditional upright stance he assumes still carries unwanted "man in a suit" vibes.
Popularity Polynomial: After his last film in 2004, Godzilla has received very little public or internet attention. But once footage and trailers for this film started being released in December of 2013, Godzilla started trending very often on social network sites, leading to revived interest in the franchise specifically (hence why many of the films were brought back into circulation after years with no home video releases) and the Kaiju genre in general (hence the sustained interest in Pacific Rim and the Continuity Reboot for Gamera).
Signature Scene: Thanks to the popularity of the teaser trailer, the HALO jump and the shot of Godzilla emerging from the ashy remains of several buildings as his silhouette is seen roaring managed to become this for that movie well before it even came out.
Special Effects Failure: The film has a brief one in some rather obvious CGI insects in the scene were Dr. Brody and his son revisit their Japanese home to get information on Godzilla. While not as bad as some of the examples in the franchise, it's still incredibly jarring in contrast to the rest of the film's effects.
The sticky white substance that the male Muto left behind on the wrecked nuclear submarine in Hawaii. It's supposed to be saliva, but it resembles semen, a resemblance that is easy to catch onto considering the plot involves the male trying to mate...
The pregnant female. Imagine a woman who is pregnant with several dozen babies and whose belly is translucent and glowing, and you wouldn't be too far off. There's also the scene where the eggs can be seen getting emptied out of her womb through the see-through skin.
Tainted by the Preview: Thankfully subverted. The "Smash3" tie-in game initially showed that Godzilla's spine did not light up when he charged his Atomic Breath, and the developers said this reflected how it was in the film. Fans weren't happy with this. However, when the game was released, the spine-glowing was restored - and it was eventually revealed that the spines do glow in the movie.
They Changed It, Now It Sucks: There are fans who don't like how they changed Godzilla's roar, or design, or even atomic breath (which may seem weaker or less substantial than usual, partly due to how small it looks compared to Godzilla's bulk, and that its appearance is more akin to the Showa films' vapory blast◊ rather than the more solid energy beam◊ of the Heisei and Millenium films.)
Joe Brody, who is regarded by critics and fans as the movie's best human character, dies in the first third of the film. His son, Ford, who replaces him as the human protagonist, is viewed to be less interesting by comparison.
Some feel Godzilla himself falls under this, as Muto drives most of the plot and Godzilla is only present to combat the creatures' existence.
Sally Hawkins' character also has shades of "They Wasted a Perfectly Good Actress," since she doesn't have much to do except help Serizawa with plot exposition.
The multi-legged monster from the very first teaser. All we ever see of it is one brief glimpse in the teaser, it never appears in subsequent trailers, and it was eventually confirmed to not appear in the final film. It wasn't even given an actual name.
They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: Some critics feel that the Green Aesop and the nuclear geopolitics allegory that Gareth Edwards talked so much about in interviews leading up to the film's release were not as fleshed out as they should have been in the final product.
Too Cool to Live: Joe Brody. Narrowly subverted with Godzilla himself in the final battle.
Ugly Cute: The Muto's, when the two of them nuzzle each otherís faces after meeting up in San-Francisco can get this reaction from some people.
The Examinerwrote a piece speculating that the reason Godzilla seems fatter in this movie is for him to be a critique of the excesses of American greed and consumerism.
Breitbartnotes that "only Barack Obama's Hawaii, Harry Reid's Nevada, and Nancy Pelosi's San Francisco are destroyed" and jokingly speculates that this was intended as a Take That against the Democrats.
The Woobie: Joseph Brody - the guy had to manually lock down the Janjira facility with his wife inside, who had followed his suggestion to investigate the facility in the first place. He is overwhelmed with guilt by this, which costs him a stable relationship with his son, much of his sanity, and respect from the scientific community, leaving him to suffer fifteen years of bitter loneliness as he searches for the truth. And when it seems like he could actually save thousands of lives with the knowledge he's attained on the Muto, he dies.