troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
YMMV: Attack of the Clones
  • Accidental Innuendo: Padme: "My goodness, you've grown!" "So have you", says Anakin, his eyes fixed squarely on Padme's chest.
  • Alternative Character Interpretation: A lot of the romance subplot actually begins to make sense if you interpret Anakin as (un)intentionally using the Force to manipulate her emotions, causing her to fall in love with him. This isn't actually too far out there because its not like we haven't seen Jedi casually Mind Rape people to get what they want.
    • Though the EU (especially the comics) don't take it as far as Mind Rape, they clearly present Anakin's obsession with Padme as extremely unhealthy, possessive, and dysfunctional. What is unclear is whether or not Lucas intended to imply this interpretation, or whether he was genuinely trying to write them as a romantic couple and that somehow fell through.
    • Why she seems to somehow forget what Anakin did to the Sand People, including killing their children, between him telling her this and when he murders the Jedi Younglings in Revenge of the Sith. Though to be fair, a great deal of time passed between movies two and three, during which the Clone Wars raged. While it would seem hard to believe she completely forgot what happened, it can't be denied there was likely a lot on her mind prior to the attack on the Jedi Temple.
      • Hadn’t the Tusken Raiders just brutally kidnapped, tortured, murdered, and possibly raped his mother? After all, similar behavior never stopped women from falling in love with John Wayne in numerous Westerns.
      • Here's the problem with Sand People/Tusken Raiders: They're survivors of the cataclysm caused by the Infinite Empire that reduced Tatooine to a giant desert. As a result, they're extremely paranoid, violent and anti-technology, and will attack anyone using any of it, even a housewife caring for moisture vaporator(Basically a machine to make water out of humidity). The only person who ever managed to talk with them was Revan, and that was because he used a translator droid; even then, they were extremely hostile. Padmé doesn't know any of that, neither does the rest of the galaxy. All she knows from the Sand People is that they're mindless desert savage tribe who, in her time in Tatooine from years ago to present time, tried shooting Anakin as a child while he was podracing, kidnapped and killed his mother, as well as cripping her husband and killing all rescuers, for no clear or good reason. It's not illogical for her to think they're Always Chaotic Evil, or Anakin; he grew up in Tatooine, and probably heard of the horrible things Sand People do. She WAS horrified by Anakin's act, but the mix of his mother's murder and the fact the Sand People seem to be nothing but monsters lessened the horror from the act(And unless you played the games, you'll also reach the same conclusion. I know I wasn't particularly sorry for them). The younglings, however, are another case entirely. The Jedi Younglings are another thing entirely. They are kids, sentient and innocent, and Anakin killed them in cold blood when he didn't even need to. He could have just as easily taken them into custody and let Palpatine try and convert them to the Dark Side. Unlike the first time, Anakin doesn't have a good enough excuse.
      • The reason behind their savagery doesn't exist in the context of the movies. Unless they gave moviegoers a copy of Knights of the Old Republic, it's irrelevant (and besides, the game was released about a year after the movie). In the context of the film, they're a hostile race who cannot be reasoned with. I'd argue they're more akin to animals than to humans.
      • As stated below, that excuse creates quite the unfortunate implication: Genocide is okay if the people you're killing have wronged you and appear to be nothing but monsters.
      • Considering they'd do the same to Tatooine's inhabitants if they could, it's a complicated situation in the saga's context. Revan only got close enough to talk because he stole the clothes from other tusken he killed (Which is a big taboo for them, and he doesn't tell them WHERE he got it. If you do it in the game, they'll attack you and you'll be forced to kill the whole settlement). The Tusken Raiders just shoot anyone who get near them for no good reason; it's not even a territorial dispute, because most of Tatooine is vacant, so it's not like they're an oppressed people. Genocide is never okay, but would you shed a tear if someone decided to kill all the Hutts? As with the Tusken, we have very few, if any examples that Hutts can be good and friendly instead of slaving criminal bosses PlanetOfHats, but the Sand People at least have a Freudian Excuse.
      • It could also be that she's just as messed up as Anakin, but much better at hiding it.
    • The Gungans choosing Jar Jar Binks as their delegate in the Senate was less reward and more a way to finally get rid of him.
  • Awesome Music: If you didn't think Anakin and Padme dialogue's showed they were in love, their theme "Across the Stars" hopefully did a better job of that.
  • Broken Base: Was AOTC better than, worse than, or about the same as The Phantom Menace? Fans can't agree.
  • Complete Monster: Palpatine.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Lucas apparently finally recognized Boba Fett's massive popularity with fans, so he retroactively gave the character a much more important role in the story and gave us Jango Fett, his father/clone who looks and dresses just like him but actually gets several awesome action scenes.
    • Unfortunately, having a set in stone backstory as part of the main story takes away a lot of Boba Fett's mystique. To say nothing of the Narm that comes from seeing him as a kid.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: Anakin's guilt over murdering the children of the Sand People becomes extremely disturbing after the next movie, in which we see one of his first deeds after turning to the dark side is killing younglings at the Jedi temple.
    • Also Anakin, when complaining of his nightmares, says he'd much rather dream about Padme. When you know what happens in the next movie...
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
  • Magnificent Bastard: Count Dooku. After all, he is played by Christopher Lee!
  • Memetic Mutation: See the above Hilarious in Hindsight. Star Wars fans have noticed Django and Jango Fett's names have identical pronunciations and have created mash up photos of the two franchises.
    • "Begun, the [X] wars have."
  • Narm Charm: Many found this to be the case, often due to crossing over into So Bad, It's Good, especially Anakin's "I hate sand" speech.
    • Part of why the "sand" speech is rather charming is the realization that Anakin is 19, has no experience with romance, and his childhood crush is standing very near him wearing an outfit that displays a great deal of "soft and smooth" skin.
  • Never Live It Down: Anakin hates sand. And loves Padme because she's not sand. Yeah, that speech really could have been written better.
  • Romantic Plot Tumor: At least to some degree between Anakin and Padmé. Probably made more glaring by some of their scenes being really toe-crunchingly awkward. While by no means the worst tumor in film history, being a Star Wars film is the reason that the trope was originally called "George Lucas 's Love Story".
  • Rooting for the Empire: Actually invoked by George Lucas. The movie introduces the sympathetic Clonetroopers, who save the Jedi and rout the movie's villains. Then comes the finale, and the movie reminds the viewers that they had been rooting for what will become The Empire by playing the Imperial March.
  • So Bad, It's Good: Hayden Christensen's acting, especially when he has to be romantic.
  • Take That, Scrappy!: Lucas finally admitted that Jar Jar was a horrible character, and in making him responsible for enabling Palpatine's rise to totalitarian power, just wanted to give viewers one last reason to hate him. He later had a statue put up in his studio of Jar Jar frozen in carbonite, so at least he can laugh at himself.
  • Throw It In: Nick Gillard mentioned that he had worked on developing a signature lightsaber style for Mace Windu but Samuel L. Jackson had already devised the very smooth and efficient style you see in the film. "It's Sam Jackson, he has a style all his own."
  • Uncanny Valley: Seen Temuera Morrison? Cool. Seen a million Temuera Morrisons in CGI? Yeah.
    • Considering the nature and purpose of the clone army, one could make a case for it being an Intended Audience Reaction - a million-strong Temuera Morrison army is never going to not be Uncanny Valley, and considering the dubious origins of the army and their eventual hand in eliminating the Jedi, taking advantage of the Uncanny Valley to highlight that there's something off about all of this seems to be a feasible thing to do.
  • Unfortunate Implications: Padmé's lack of concern for Anakin's violent tendencies shown in Episode II seems to imply that, for this supposedly ethical politician, mass murder isn't too bad when it involves Anakin killing an entire village of Tusken Raiders.

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
20720
26