"Planet With", an original Anime and Manga project by Satoshi Mizukami

Sure... I'll add that once I'm done with college.

And added the Needs Wiki Magic Love entry for Planet With. Although I may or may not going to help with adding the tropes in the page especially on it's YMMV page but I'm not sure what to add and my grammar sucks :/

I wouldn't worry so much about poor grammar. At worst, you would have to correct it yourself or somebody else would correct it for you. What I find more pressing when it comes to editing a TVTropes page is that you give a proper explanation for a trope and that what you're troping does count.

Yeah... And tbh, I was actually a bit scared getting banned just because of my poor grammar (Given I'm not a native English speaker) and I have to use Get Help With English Here thread for help.

Anyways, back on topic. Do you think the show ran on Grey-and-Gray Morality?

No, it's either White and Gray Morality or Good Versus Good.

Makes sense... Any more tropes that could match nicely for Planet With? I've been thinking of adding Ms. Fanservice for Shiraishi because of her awesome costume that she had where she merged with Generalissimo, Public Bathhouse Scene for Episode 8/9 because Benika is shown in a hot springs along with the General, Meido for Ginko, Freudian Excuse for Benika's backstory, Wangst or Despair Speech for Souya's emotional breakdown (This applies for Tearjerker as well)... Theres a lot.

Edited by ElfenLiedFan90 on Sep 5th 2018 at 10:09:06 PM

Wangst for Souya is okay, but I associate it much more strongly with Yousuke.

You might be right... But I'm cool with Souya Speech being classified as Wangst since I'm unsure which trope that I should classified as.

Also, I'm not sure about which YMMV trope for people who were turned off by CGI at first.

The thing about Wangst is that that's a YMMV trope that requires people to be annoyed with a characters struggles due to them being unsympathetic and/or ridiculous. Personally speaking, I found Soya's upset over feeling unsatisfied with fulfilling his revenge since his planet's still gone understandable, especially since until that moment, he kept it to himself.

Uncanny Valley would be fitting for the CGI thing.

Edited by WolfThunder on Sep 5th 2018 at 8:35:04 AM

Ah that makes sense... I think Despair Speech would fit better or Heroic BSoD I guess.

Also, something new I learn about the Wangst trope... Thanks.

No problem. And yeah, Heroic BSoD would work.

I'll see what I can do on posting some examples mayne! I'll try at my best to do it.

And just one note... I actually reserved this anime too for Complete Monster and Magnificent Bastard discussion dates. For CM Uhhhh... I dont think no one counts unless if you say that what the dragon did isnt mitigating but given that the Siriusan attacks the other planet first... Yea. And as for MB, maybe Generalissimo, Shiraishi or Takashi I guess

That implies a degree of dignity and competence that none of those characters have been afforded. Remember that tropes like Magnificent Bastard and Complete Monster are just tropes with specific definitions, not badges of prestige. Not every show you like has to have them.

In general, beware of shoehorning and try to read trope descriptions carefully before adding them.

I see.

What about Fandom Rivalry? In Reddit I occasionally see post that compare this show to Darling in Franxx. Something about this show being the true successor to Guren Lagann and not Franxx. But I guess this show doesn't really have a big enough fandom to cause a rivalry

Also Ensemble Darkhorse for Nozomi and Torai

Edited by TheMainCharacter on Sep 7th 2018 at 1:31:20 AM

Hmmmm... You may have a point there.

I forgot. What does Torai do?

Torai is the firefighter guy. He's a good egg.

Oh yeah! i remember him being a nice guy towards Souya... that and he's also the one who fights against the former member of his group who joins the Sealing Faction... Yea.

Also, any link regarding fans fighting with ditf fans regarding this show being a spiritual successor of TTGL? I will try to make a writeup for it.

I think you are way overestimating this show's presence in online fandoms.

Nah, I just wanted to ask about what The Main Character said regarding Fandom Rivalry so yeah... And tbh, I still think the show is underrated that it could warranted a Needs More Love entry I guess

That's also an odd take on the series. Its really not on the pro-violence side. Row row, fighting the power is unnecessary if you spread kindness and peace.

Edited by Zeromaeus on Sep 7th 2018 at 8:01:44 AM

Speaking of that. I could make an entry for What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids? for Planet With. Given the style of the anime really reminds me of other shonen animes truly for children such as Inazuma Eleven, Cardfight!! Vanguard or Future Card Buddyfight. But there are some depressing moments that the show had and the show isn't afraid to go dark sometimes. Also doubled with What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs?.

Not really? It goes a little dark, but in an introspective way rather than an inappropriate one. Some of it would fly over a kid's head, but it's nothing there that I'd consider damaging.

The drugs one works though. A man-sized cat with human teeth eats a teenager from space to turn into a mecha. That's a little out there.

Then there's all the Nebula Weapons.

I'd say go ahead and start putting some YMMV up, if we have some entries.