- Accidental Aesop: The ending of Episode 5 is sort of the logical conclusion to the entire series and films. Screwing around with the timeline keeps fucking things up til you have three older Marty's begging young Marty for help, all from different timelines. At that point, Doc just shrugs and tells Marty to ignore them. Now is important.
- It's actually brought up several times throughout all five episodes.
- Broken Base: There is a certain friction that occurs between those who are longtime fans of the Back to the Future franchise and those who are longtime fans of the Telltale Games company.
- Enjoy the Story, Skip the Game: Many non-gamers have taken interest in the game strictly for the Back to the Future story line — much to the chagrin of the more avid gamers who are, overall, disappointed with the game play of the series.
- Coinciding with the Updated Re-release of the game in 2016, IDW Publishing put out a comic book adaptation titled Back to the Future: Citizen Brown, giving the non-gamers exactly what they wanted.
- Fanon Discontinuity: To main die-hard fans of the original trilogy, this game might as well not exist. Less die-hard fans are fine with it, though. Being an example of No Problem with Licensed Games (and getting many of the original actors back) really helps. It's also the first thing in the series to really utilize Jennifer as a character, and both Edna and Trixie serve to balance out the series' mostly male-dominated cast.
- Telltale has stated that the game doesn't necessarily have to be considered canon.
- Jerkass Woobie: Even after everything, it's hard not to feel kinda bad for 1931!Edna when Marty breaks her up with Emmett.
- And then Crazy Mary!Edna. Humorous insanity aside, it's hard not to pity exactly what The Slow Path, guilt, and loneliness have done to her.
- Moral Event Horizon: (Episode 3) Edna Strickland could have passed for an extremely obnoxious Well-Intentioned Extremist until she has her husband, Citizen Brown, tortured and brainwashed at the end of Episode 3.
- Player Punch: Citizen Brown's possible FaceHeel Turn.
- Seeing Citizen Brown die after being ran over by Edna.
- The Woobie: The Citizen Brown timeline in Episode 3. Everyone seems on the verge of a nervous crackup due to the Dystopia of alternate Hill Valley, Marty seems like he's panicking about 86% of the time, and the only halfway normal person is a Delinquent who would probably be a child psychologist's field day. Even Brown himself comes off as a Tragic Hero.
YMMV / Back to the Future: The Game