Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / ThePrincessBride

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 1973 book by Creator/WilliamGoldman, ''The Princess Bride'' is about the trials of true love in the Renaissance European nation of Florin. The story stars Buttercup, a simple yet incredibly beautiful farmgirl, and Westley, the farmhand she enjoys ordering around. Although they realize that they share the incredibly rare thing called "true love", fate conspires to keep them apart, as Westley is lost at sea.

to:

A 1973 book by Creator/WilliamGoldman, ''The Princess Bride'' is about the trials of true love in the Renaissance European nation of Florin. The story stars Buttercup, a simple yet incredibly beautiful farmgirl, and Westley, the farmhand she enjoys ordering around. Although they realize that they share the incredibly rare thing called "true love", love," fate conspires to keep them apart, as Westley is lost at sea.



* AbridgedForChildren: This is the in-story reason Mr. Goldman abridged ''The Princess Bride''. He wanted his kids to enjoy it, and there was far too much boring stuff. However, he did leave in all the torture and death (though he ''does'' warn us about what's coming at one point, telling us that this isn't ''Curious George Uses The Potty''). Mr. Goldman's (in-story) father's Good Parts abridgment fits the trope more accurately. He tried to leave out the scary parts until he was called on it.

to:

* AbridgedForChildren: This is the in-story reason Mr. Goldman abridged ''The Princess Bride''. He wanted his kids to enjoy it, and there was far too much boring stuff. However, he did leave in all the torture and death (though he ''does'' warn us about what's coming at one point, telling us that this isn't ''Curious George Uses The the Potty''). Mr. Goldman's (in-story) father's Good Parts abridgment fits the trope more accurately. He tried to leave out the scary parts until he was called on it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AltarDiplomacy: The ailing King and Queen of Florin want to marry Prince Humperdinck to the Princess of Guilder to ally with the two rival countries. Humperdinck breaks off the engagement when it turns out during a banquet that his fiancee is congenitally bald, and comments that he'd always planned to just conquer Guilder instead.

to:

* AltarDiplomacy: The ailing King and Queen of Florin want to marry Prince Humperdinck to the Princess of Guilder to ally with the two rival countries. Humperdinck breaks off the engagement when it turns out during a banquet that his fiancee fiancée is congenitally bald, and comments that he'd always planned to just conquer Guilder instead.



* WorldsMostBeautifulWoman: Buttercup -- though at first, she's only in the top twenty. The first couple of chapters are in fact a lengthy parody of the trope, as the narrator somehow has access to a list of "Who was the most beautiful woman in the world at any given time," and on what qualifications, pays careful attention to Buttercup's rise through the ranks, and even gives anecdotes on what happened to the ''previous'' holders of the title (in order: chocolate, smallpox, and [[SelfFulfillingProphecy wrinkles brought on by worrying about how to hold on to the title of "World's Most Beautiful Woman.]]") In the end, despite the beauticians working on her while she's Humperdinck's fiance, it's her maturity and sadness that puts her over the top.

to:

* WorldsMostBeautifulWoman: Buttercup -- though at first, she's only in the top twenty. The first couple of chapters are in fact a lengthy parody of the trope, as the narrator somehow has access to a list of "Who was the most beautiful woman in the world at any given time," and on what qualifications, pays careful attention to Buttercup's rise through the ranks, and even gives anecdotes on what happened to the ''previous'' holders of the title (in order: chocolate, smallpox, and [[SelfFulfillingProphecy wrinkles brought on by worrying about how to hold on to the title of "World's Most Beautiful Woman.]]") In the end, despite the beauticians working on her while she's Humperdinck's fiance, fiancée, it's her maturity and sadness that puts her over the top.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Discontinuity is now disambig.


* {{Discontinuity}}: The entire fairy tale was supposed to be completely fictional, but later anniversary editions of the book have forwards in which William Goldman goes to Florin and Guilder to visit the exact places where events took place - which have become popular tourist spots. [[invoked]]

to:

* {{Discontinuity}}: CanonDiscontinuity: The entire fairy tale was supposed to be completely fictional, but later anniversary editions of the book have forwards in which William Goldman goes to Florin and Guilder to visit the exact places where events took place - which have become popular tourist spots. [[invoked]]

Added: 384

Changed: 16

Removed: 388

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dramatic Irony happens when the audience knows something the characters don't. This is simply an ironic Anti Climax


* AntiClimax: Inigo has spent years training himself in the art of the sword, learning from every master he could, completely, single-mindedly focused on hunting down his nemesis so that they can engage in a FinalBattle... which barely even happens. They cross blades a couple of times, and then, before Inigo can finish cutting out Rugen's heart, the man just drops dead from fright.



* DramaticIrony: Inigo has spent years training himself in the art of the sword, learning from every master he could, completely, single-mindedly focused on hunting down his nemesis so that they can engage in a FinalBattle... which barely even happens. They cross blades a couple of times, and then, before Inigo can finish cutting out Rugen's heart, the man just drops dead from fright.



* RevengeIsSweet: Inigo Montoya tracks down and kills Count Rugen, the six-fingered man who murdered his father. While the book [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome does not shy away from the negative side effects of fixating on a decades-long revenge quest]], Inigo still finds the revenge itself quite satisfying. Finally achieving his lifelong goal does leave Inigo wondering [[NowWhat what to do now]], but Westley solves that problem by suggesting Inigo could fill the recently vacated role of Dread Pirate Roberts.

to:

* RevengeIsSweet: Inigo Montoya tracks down and kills Count Rugen, the six-fingered man who murdered his father. While the book [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome does not shy away from the negative side effects of fixating on a decades-long revenge quest]], Inigo still finds the revenge itself quite satisfying. Finally In the movie, finally achieving his lifelong goal does leave Inigo wondering [[NowWhat what to do now]], but Westley solves that problem by suggesting Inigo could fill the recently vacated role of Dread Pirate Roberts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No potholes in page quotes


->''[[BlatantLies "As a matter of fact, everything Morgenstern wrote is historically accurate; read any decent book on Florinese history."]]''

to:

->''[[BlatantLies "As ->''"As a matter of fact, everything Morgenstern wrote is historically accurate; read any decent book on Florinese history."]]''
"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a self-contradiction.


->''[[ImmediateSelfContradiction "As a matter of fact, everything Morgenstern wrote is historically accurate; read any decent book on Florinese history."]]''

to:

->''[[ImmediateSelfContradiction ->''[[BlatantLies "As a matter of fact, everything Morgenstern wrote is historically accurate; read any decent book on Florinese history."]]''

Added: 329

Removed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TreatedWorseThanThePet: Buttercup is much nicer to her horse, [[ADogNamedDog Horse]], than she is to pretty much any other living creature - most especially Westley, the FarmBoy who cares for Horse and for her father's cows. At one point she orders Westley to stay up all night cleaning Horse's stable and polishing his saddle.



* TreatedWorseThanThePet: Buttercup is much nicer to her horse, [[ADogNamedDog Horse]], than she is to pretty much any other living creature - most especially Westley, the FarmBoy who cares for Horse and for her father's cows. At one point she orders Westley to stay up all night cleaning Horse's stable and polishing his saddle.

Removed: 1341

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AluminumChristmasTrees: Goldman hangs a lampshade on this in the framing story, complaining that he had to argue with his editors about Max and Valerie being "too Jewish" for a medieval fantasy story -- as though crotchety Jews were invented in the Catskills in 1952. He also relates a similar battle he went through with the "bifocals" line in ''Film/ButchCassidyAndTheSundanceKid'', fighting a studio executive who didn't know and didn't care that Ben Franklin invented bifocals nearly a century before the movie's period.
** All four of the fencing masters mentioned by Inigo and The Man in Black are real historic figures.
*** Rocco Bonetti is credited with bringing the Italian style of fencing to the British Isles and was the target of a hilariously one-sided hatred from British-born fencing master George Silver.
*** Gerald Thibault D'Anvers was a famous fencer, mathematician, and alchemist, who attempted to create his "new" fencing based on geometric principles.
*** Ridolfo Capo Ferro was another fencer, who famously advocated for being able to outrange one's opponent as the most important principle of fencing, and therefore was a warm proponent of excessively deep lunges and very long swords.
*** Camillo Agrippa was another proponent of geometric fencing and is also credited with creating "modern", thrust-centric fencing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: The entire life of Inigo Montoya from ''The Princess Bride'' is a massive TakeThat to the classic "I live only for revenge" character/plot.

to:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: The entire book contains quite a few, but especially when it comes to the life of Inigo Montoya from ''The Princess Bride'' Montoya, whose character arc is a massive TakeThat to deconstruction of the classic "I live only for revenge" character/plot.



** In the book only, Humperdink doesn't take his humiliation and defeat well, and promptly orders his men to pursue Westley, Inigo, Fezzik, and Buttercup. The book ends on a SequelHook that notes that Inigo's wounds reopened and worsened during the attempt to escape pursuit, leaving his survival in doubt.

to:

** In the book only, book, Humperdink doesn't take his humiliation and defeat well, and promptly orders his men to pursue Westley, Inigo, Fezzik, and Buttercup. The book ends on a SequelHook that notes that Inigo's wounds reopened and worsened during the attempt to escape pursuit, leaving his survival in doubt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The trope is averted in the final pages, though, when Buttercup uses sheer force of personality (and her "queen training") to cow the guards that try to stop the heroes' escape.

Added: 320

Changed: 37

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolHorse: Prince Humperdinck breeds white horses, which Fezzik steals to facilitate the heroes' escape.

to:

* CoolHorse: Prince Humperdinck breeds powerful white horses, stallions, which Fezzik steals to facilitate the heroes' escape.escape after the climax.
--> '''Fezzik''': "When I stumbled into the stables and found these pretty horses I thought four was how many of them there were and four was how many of us there were too, if we found the lady -- hello, lady -- and I thought, Why not take them along with me in case we ever run into each other. ... And I guess we did."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
has to have cause grammar


* {{Discontinuity}}: The entire fairy tale was supposed to be completely fictional, but later anniversary editions of the book have forwards in which William Goldman goes to Florin and Guilder to visit the exact places where events took place - which has become popular tourist spots. [[invoked]]

to:

* {{Discontinuity}}: The entire fairy tale was supposed to be completely fictional, but later anniversary editions of the book have forwards in which William Goldman goes to Florin and Guilder to visit the exact places where events took place - which has have become popular tourist spots. [[invoked]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TreatedWorseThanThePet: Buttercup is much nicer to her horse, [[ADogNamedDog Horse]], than she is to pretty much any other living creature - most especially Westley, the FarmBoy who cares for Horse and for her father's cows. At one point she orders Westley to stay up all night cleaning Horse's stable and polishing his saddle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Nice Hat is no longer a trope.


* NiceHat: Princess Noreena of Guilder has hundreds of hats, described in the unabridged book in excruciating detail for three pages. They're all extravagant and very useful for hiding her bald head.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To wit: Narrator Goldman talks about a wife and kid he doesn't have in real life (not to mention saying the story is actually satirical non-fiction). Narrator Morgenstern says that the story happened before Europe but after America. Narrator Father never informed his son that the story came from a historical text and he skipped over all the (lengthy) boring parts.)

to:

** To wit: Narrator Goldman talks about a wife and kid he doesn't have in real life (not to mention saying the story is actually satirical non-fiction). Narrator Morgenstern says that the story happened before Europe but after America. Narrator Father never informed his son that the story came from a historical text and he skipped over all the (lengthy) boring parts.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NothingIsScarier: The last level of the Zoo of Death is a long, dark hallway, entirely devoid of the horrific beasts of the other levels. The idea is to lure the intruders into a false sense of security so that they are bitten by the ''extremely'' venomous spider hidden in the doorknob at the end. Inigo finds the apparent lack of beasts and traps even more worrisome than the previous two levels, and Fezzik is so terrified of what's going on that he bursts through the door at the end -- without touching the handle, squashing the spider in the process.

to:

* NothingIsScarier: The hallway to the last level of the Zoo of Death is a long, dark hallway, short and well-lit staircase, entirely devoid of the horrific beasts of the other levels. The idea is to lure the intruders into a false sense of security so that they are bitten by the ''extremely'' venomous spider hidden in that lives under the doorknob at the end. Inigo finds the apparent lack of beasts and traps even more worrisome than the previous two levels, and Fezzik is so terrified of what's going on that he bursts through the door at the end -- without touching the handle, squashing handle. Inigo notices the bewildered spider in crawling around on the process.door as he follows Fezzik through the now doorless doorway and steps on it without realizing it was deadly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RevengeIsSweet: Inigo Montoya tracks down and kills Count Rugen, the six-fingered man who murdered his father. While the book [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome does not shy away from the negative side effects of fixating on a decades-long revenge quest]], Inigo still finds the revenge itself quite satisfying. Finally achieving his lifelong goal does leave Inigo wondering [[NowWhat what to do now]], but Westley solves that problem by suggesting Inigo could fill the recently vacated role of Dread Pirate Roberts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking Epiphora

Added DiffLines:

* {{Epiphora}}: After Westley leaves Buttercup's farm to seek his fortune, he sends her frequent letters, and to make up for all the times he didn't say the actual words, he ends every sentence with "I love you."
-->''It is raining today '''and I love you'''. My cold is better '''and I love you'''. Say hello to [[ADogNamedDog Horse]] '''and I love you'''.''

Added: 144

Changed: 271

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AndNowYouMustMarryMe: The ScarpiaUltimatum version. If the "Dread Pirate Roberts" does not respond to the messages that Humperdinck purports to send, Buttercup must marry him.

to:

* AndNowYouMustMarryMe: The ScarpiaUltimatum version. If the "Dread Pirate Roberts" does not respond to the messages that Humperdinck purports to send, Buttercup's message within a certain time, Buttercup must marry him.go through with her marriage to Humperdinck. (The letters never go out, since Humperdinck is well aware that Westley is a prisoner in his dungeon).



* ArrangedMarriage: Expected, given the time period. Buttercup doesn't even ''like'' Humperdinck, but she's lost all hope of marrying for love.



* AuthorFilibuster: Parodied; the original version[[note]]which does not in fact exist[[/note]] was apparently riddled with these, but the 'editor' didn't realize until adulthood because his father only told him 'the good bits' as a child. The editor promptly cuts all of them from his annotation, as they apparently completely bog the novel down in irrelevant minutiae and pompous tangents, but his descriptions of them are entertaining in their own right -- for example, the editorial on the removal of chapter 3: 56 and a half pages to cover Queen Bella inviting Princess Noreena to meet Prince Humperdinck, including traveling both ways, out of which fifty pages are spent describing the two of them packing and unpacking their luggage.

to:

* AuthorFilibuster: Parodied; the original version[[note]]which does not in fact exist[[/note]] was apparently riddled with these, but the 'editor' Goldman didn't realize this until adulthood because his father only told him 'the good bits' as a child. The editor He promptly cuts all of them from his annotation, them, as they apparently completely bog the novel down in irrelevant minutiae and pompous tangents, but his descriptions of them are entertaining in their own right -- for example, the editorial on the removal of chapter 3: 56 and a half pages to cover Queen Bella inviting Princess Noreena to meet Prince Humperdinck, including traveling both ways, out of which fifty pages are spent describing the two of them packing and unpacking their luggage.



* BolivianArmyEnding: The end of the novel explores the logical aftermath of the heroes' escape. Inigo's injury worsens and the entire army of Florin is after them. [[spoiler:They survive, though.]]

to:

* BolivianArmyEnding: The end of the novel explores the logical aftermath of the heroes' escape. Inigo's injury worsens worsens, Westley relapses, and the entire army of Florin is after them. [[spoiler:They survive, though.]]



* BullyingADragon: Vizzinni actually ''physically'' threatens Fezzik, which will give one an idea of just how cowed Fezzik is by him.

to:

* BullyingADragon: Vizzinni Vizzini actually ''physically'' threatens Fezzik, which will give one an idea of just how cowed Fezzik is by him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut.


* FoeYay: Invoked InUniverse, as both Vizzini and Inigo both get "excited" when they realize The Man in Black is a WorthyOpponent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ContemptibleCover: There exists a mass-market paperback edition that came out about two years after the book's first release in 1973. [[http://www.goodshowsir.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Princess-Bride.jpg The cover art]] depicts a nearly-nude woman surrounded by skulls, snakes, tentacles, and other horrifying objects. Apparently, not only did the artist not read the book beforehand, he must not have even seen a ''plot summary''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguity Index wick cleaning.


* MismatchedEyes: Noreen, the Princess of Guilder, has one eye that's "bluish" and one that's "greenish."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no idea what the removed sentence was referring to


** Interestingly enough, there ''was'' a period of time that could be said to be "after America" and "before Europe"; specifically, the 1500s, between the discovery of the Americas, and the Thirty Years War (which started in 1618), which so redefined the terms of the relations of states that it has been claimed to be the beginning of "Modern European History". (The story takes place in the late 19th century.)

to:

** Interestingly enough, there ''was'' a period of time that could be said to be "after America" and "before Europe"; specifically, the 1500s, between the discovery of the Americas, and the Thirty Years War (which started in 1618), which so redefined the terms of the relations of states that it has been claimed to be the beginning of "Modern European History". (The story takes place in the late 19th century.)Australia, though, wasn't known to Europeans until 1606, and Britain didn't start [[SentencedToDownUnder sending convicts there]] until 1788.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed as Bald Women has been disambiguated


* MarriageOfConvenience: Buttercup to Prince Humperdinck, which he argues is a practical matter of him needing an heir and a wife whose appearance he won't be embarrassed by at court (his parents' pick, the princess of Guilder, was {{bald|Women}}), and he's willing to lift her and her family out of poverty for it. [[spoiler:Actually, he plans to murder her and frame Guilder as a PretextForWar.]] She goes along with it because she believes Westley to be dead, and neither expects love out of it.

to:

* MarriageOfConvenience: Buttercup to Prince Humperdinck, which he argues is a practical matter of him needing an heir and a wife whose appearance he won't be embarrassed by at court (his parents' pick, the princess of Guilder, was {{bald|Women}}), bald), and he's willing to lift her and her family out of poverty for it. [[spoiler:Actually, he plans to murder her and frame Guilder as a PretextForWar.]] She goes along with it because she believes Westley to be dead, and neither expects love out of it.



* NeverBareheaded: Princess Noreena of Guilder is never seen without one of her many hats. After a sudden breeze blows one-off, it turns out [[BaldWomen she has good reason]].

to:

* NeverBareheaded: Princess Noreena of Guilder is never seen without one of her many hats. After a sudden breeze blows one-off, it turns out [[BaldWomen she has good reason]].[[HairstyleMalfunction she's bald]].

Added: 284

Changed: 14

Removed: 280

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bald Women is now a disambiguation


* AltarDiplomacy: The ailing King and Queen of Florin want to marry Prince Humperdinck to the Princess of Guilder to ally with the two rival countries. Humperdinck breaks off the engagement when it turns out during a banquet that his fiancee is [[BaldWomen congenitally bald]], and comments that he'd always planned to just conquer Guilder instead.

to:

* AltarDiplomacy: The ailing King and Queen of Florin want to marry Prince Humperdinck to the Princess of Guilder to ally with the two rival countries. Humperdinck breaks off the engagement when it turns out during a banquet that his fiancee is [[BaldWomen congenitally bald]], bald, and comments that he'd always planned to just conquer Guilder instead.



* BaldWomen: Prince Humperdinck briefly considers marrying a princess of Guilder, but angrily rejects her after a sudden breeze blows off the hat she wears and reveals her to be bald.[[note]]It's implied he did this on purpose because he really wanted a war with Guilder.[[/note]]


Added DiffLines:

* FakeHairDrama: Prince Humperdinck briefly considers marrying a princess of Guilder, but angrily rejects her after a sudden breeze blows off the hat she wears and reveals her to be bald.[[note]]It's implied he did this on purpose because he really wanted a war with Guilder.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Film only.


* PunchPunchPunchUhOh: Westley does this to Fezzik, who very kindly lets him get some strikes in so that he can feel he's doing well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The even newer edition for the 30th anniversary contains additional commentary about the film, as well as everything contained in the 25th-anniversary edition, resulting in three forewords. One more foreword and the 'Good Parts' version will be thicker than Morgenstern's original version!

to:

The even newer edition for the 30th anniversary contains additional commentary about the film, as well as everything contained in the 25th-anniversary edition, resulting in three forewords. One more foreword and the 'Good Parts' version will be thicker than Morgenstern's original version!supposed original!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FairytaleWeddingDress

to:

* FairytaleWeddingDressFairytaleWeddingDress: In the book, Buttercup goes through several potential wedding gowns, with the final one being so elaborate that it can't be described, only inferred. In the film, she looks like a literal angel in a snowy white, medieval Italian-style gown with scads of silver embroidery and a delicate diamond crown.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Vezzini:''' A common ordinary seaman bests the great Inigo Montoya with the sword? [[PunctuatedForEmphasis In-con-ceiv-a-ble]].

to:

-->'''Vezzini:''' -->'''Inigo:''' A common ordinary seaman bests the great Inigo Montoya with the sword? [[PunctuatedForEmphasis In-con-ceiv-a-ble]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBigDamnKiss: For Westley and Buttercup's first kiss, the narrative goes on at length about how, since the accidental invention of the kiss, people have been divided over what mathematical equation will best describe the perfect kiss; however, there have been five throughout history that everyone agrees "deserve full marks." The narrative then declares, "Well, this one left them ''all'' behind."

to:

* TheBigDamnKiss: For Westley and Buttercup's first kiss, the narrative goes on at length about how, since the accidental invention of the kiss, people have been divided over what mathematical equation will best describe the perfect kiss; however, there have been five throughout history that everyone agrees "deserve full marks." The narrative then declares, "Well, this one left them ''all'' behind."" The novel puts it at the beginning of the story, while the film puts it at the climax.

Top