In TV Land, murder by suffocation is quick and easy. Simply hold a pillow over someone's face; your victim will struggle for all of ten seconds and then expire. A child could do it.
The same applies to attempted murder by strangulation, though a person being held by the throat (say, the hero's girlfriend) is more likely to survive. Drowning is also quicker in media than in reality, but a character who falls into the water will probably manage to thrash and splash
for several minutes before going under, and even someone who is brought to shore unconscious can often be revived.
A pillow over the face, on the other hand, is a death sentence. Anyone so treated will struggle for about five seconds, squirm for about five seconds more, and then go limp. Once dead, they will be dead for real, with no possibility of revival.
While there is some justification for this (characters murdered by pillow are often weakened, sick, or injured), this trope employs considerable
artistic license. An ordinary pillow is quite porous and will allow some air to get through, so even if it were pressed as tightly against the victim' nose and mouth as possible (despite struggling and all) it will still kill much more slowly than other methods which entirely cut off the victim's air supply.
Unmarked spoilers abound,
this trope being about a foolproof method of inflicting nigh-instantaneous death
and all. Watch yourself.
Often associated with Sickbed Slaying
. Compare Instant Sedation
, Instant Death Bullet
for similar examples of the unrealistically quick dispatch of a human being.
- Subverted, in the show's usual way, in Black Lagoon. Revy seems to try killing her father this way, but simply uses the pillow to muffle the blast from her gun.
- Batman: Dark Victory - Alberto Falcone is killed by his sister Sofia in exactly this manner. Semi-justified in that Sofia is a very strong woman and Alberto is very frail - she didn't suffocate so much as crush him.
- The "instant strangulation" trope is averted in the 2008 remake of Unknown Soldier. The main character uses a makeshift garrote to quietly kill a Child Soldier and thinks to himself how it takes a long time to strangle a person, even a young boy. Even he's surprised, and he's a doctor.
- Averted in If Thems The Rules, when Buck attempts to smother an ill Tom Riddle, it takes a while for Tom to start blacking out and is struggling the whole time.
- The Hindi film, Omkara, being a direct remake of Othello, has this in the end. It's a lot longer than five seconds. The scene actually goes on a painfully long time, but in the end, you know what happens.
- Greta is killed this way in Blood and Black Lace.
- In Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby, Cal tries to do this to end his friend's suffering. Since Ricky Bobby isn't suffering at all, just napping, he fights Cal off.
- In Vanilla Sky this is mixed to a disturbing degree with Out with a Bang.
- Esther does this to Danny in his hospital bed in Orphan. He doesn't die, but is left in worse shape than he was before.
- In The Naked Gun, a hypnotized doctor is about to suffocate Nordberg with a pillow before Frank Drebin interrupts him. The doctor throws the pillow at Drebin as he flees, and it inexplicably sticks to Drebin's face. It takes him several seconds of struggling to rip it off.
- Subverted in The Godfather Part II when a hitman is shot dead just as he's about to carry out a Sickbed Slaying.
- The Grey Zone: In the opening, the Sonderkommandos smother one of their own with a pillow as a mercy kill.
- Played with in John Waters' Desperate Living: it doesn't take more than a few seconds for maid Grizelda Brown (Jean Hill) to kill Peggy Gravel (Mink Stole)'s husband, but then again a 400lb woman sitting on a man's face ain't exactly a pillow...
- A Song of Ice and Fire has Daenerys Targaryen doing this to someone who has been rendered a Soulless Shell.
- Done by Bromden to McMurphy in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, as a Mercy Kill.
- Native Son features a particularly extreme version of this trope. Not only does the victim die from suffocation by the pillow, but the person killing her didn't even realize what he was doing. What's more, a third person in the room didn't realize what was going on because the sound of the smothering was so negligible.
- In The Remittance Kid by J.T. Edson, one of the anarchists sneaks into a hospital disguised as a priests and uses a pillow to smother a wounded accomplice before he can talk to the police.
- In The Mallorean, Silk smothers a number of people offscreen as vengence for the death of a fellow spy, in order to Make It Look Like an Accident. However there's no indication given that it was instantaneous or easy. Then he runs short on time and has to start using knives...
- Death Comes as the End doesn't follow this exactly (not a pillow, but lots of bed sheets). Maybe in Ancient Egypt the pillow wasn't invented yet.
- In Stephen King's It, this is how 5-year-old Patrick Hockstetter kills his baby brother Avery, but he does it by pressing the baby's face into the pillow rather than holding a pillow to his face.
- The Sickbed Slaying of Alan Venters in Trainspotting is carried out by this method.
- Clive Cussler's Night Probe features a murder carried out by this method to facilitate its concealment. The victim is sufficiently frail and weak that his death is not unexpected in any case, and is too feeble to put up a significant struggle. The murderer uses theatrical makeup to conceal the bruising on the inside of the victim's lips from the pillow pressing them against his teeth.
- Angel tries this on Wesley at one point, but it doesn't work. (Some fans speculate that this was deliberate; he could have killed Wes easily in other ways, but he was really just making a point.)
- On the other hand, Giles pulls off a Vulcan nose-pinch grip to kill Glory's host.
- In the episode before, Buffy also does this to Dawn during her Heroic BSOD dream.
- Boardwalk Empire subverts the vorpal part by showing the impracticality of the method: Eli tries to kill a survivor of the woods massacre when he reappears, badly wounded, by smothering him with a pillow in a hospital. It takes a very long time, though, and Eli is clearly exhausted by the time prohibition agents come bursting in - with the survivor wheezing, but still very much alive.
- Subverted on Chuck: Casey plays up this trope when a villain attempts to smother him in his hospital bed. Said villain falls for it, removes the pillow... and promptly gets a bonsai tree smashed over his head.
- Used on CSI NY, a mother unknowingly did it to her own daughter. She believed the girl in the bed was the driver of the car in which her daughter died, however, there was mistaken identity as to who survived and who died. The girl tried to tell her mother, but she didn't get it.
- Deep Space Nine. Even in the future they do this, with a killer trying to smother a comatose Quark before he wakes up and identifies him from an earlier attempt. The episode was a homage of murder mysteries, so perhaps he had tradition in mind. Regardless, the Sickbed Slaying gets averted when Quark's brother walks in and starts screaming, causing Odo to arrive with a bunch of guards. When Rom realises he's saved his brother's life (meaning he doesn't inherit the bar) he starts screaming all over again, waking Quark up from his coma.
- Monk: The killer does this in the opening scene of "Mr. Monk and the Very, Very Old Man." Not as much of a stretch as some other examples, since the man was in fact very, very old. We don't see exactly how long it takes him to die, but the death is apparently quick and clean enough that no one at first suspects foul play.
- In Nip/Tuck, after a plane crash, Julia thinks that her mother is dying and euthanizes her with a pillow. It turns out not to be her mom after all. Whoops.
- On Orphan Black, Grace attempts this on Helena. Subverted; Helena survives and turns the tables on Grace by strangling Grace to unconsciousness.
- Played with on The Pretender when Miss Parker pretends to kill Jacob (Sydney's comatose twin brother).
- In third season of PrisonBreak Lechero is killed by this trope.
- Subverted on Scrubs during an Imagine Spot. J.D reflects on the fact that the new Chief of Medicine is very friendly and personable with her coworkers, but very cold-blooded toward the patients. In the Imagine Spot this is illustrated by her realizing that one patient's insurance won't cover any more time in the ICU, so she responds by attempting to smother him with his pillow. He survives and she keeps trying again while shouting Why Won't You Die?.
- Played with on Seinfeld: George is in the hospital and is in "so much pain" that he asks Jerry to end his life this way. Jerry says "You mean like this?" and puts the pillow over his face for a second, and George starts yelling.
- Happened near the end of season eight of Smallville to a depowered supervillain.
- In The Tudors Margaret uses a pillow to kill her husband, the king of Portugal. He does struggle quite a lot, but the attempt is successful.
- Twin Peaks, Leland Palmer suffocates Jacques with a pillow in a few short seconds; granted, the man was already injured and in hospital, but it was an extremely quick suffocation nonetheless. Made all the worse by the fact that they referred to the act of smothering with a pillow as strangulation in the following episode.
- Used in Weeds, after switching off the life support fails to have the desired effect. "Shane, get mommy a pillow."
- In Revenge, after Michelle Banks paralyzes Aiden with a poison, this is how Victoria finishes him off.
- Wiseguy. In "Postcard From Morocco" Carole does a Heel-Face Turn and decides to secretly gather evidence on her lover and co-conspirator, Mafia boss Rick Pinzolo. While they're in bed together she presses him for information on a contract killing he arranged, them after he falls asleep takes out a tape recorder. Turns out Rick is only pretending to be asleep, as he suddenly grabs the pillow and smothers Carole to death.
- In the Haven episode "Magic Hour Part 2", The Bolt Gun Killer finishes Noelle off this way after tracking her down after shooting her in the woods. She was bleeding out and probably would not have survived without medical attention anyway.
- In The Blacklist, Reddington kills Lizzy's father this way.
- Subverted in the Swedish series Crimes Of Passion - a murderer sticks a pillow over Amateur Sleuth Puck's face, but after leaving, she regains consciousness.
- Capcom's unreleased Kingpin has the "strangulation is instant death" version of this trope with the death of the mobster Jimmy.
- Othello: this is how Othello kills Desdemona, though she's able to wake up and give a short speech before keeling over again.
- James euthanizes his wife this way in Silent Hill 2. May be justified since she was extremely terminally ill with what appeared to be a respiratory ailment, but this may vary, both for James and the player.
- BioShock 2. Eleanor, the victim, gets better, but she is technically dead long enough to damage you...
- Project Zomboid Bob can kill his injured wife with a pillow as a way to escape the tutorial, but not before giving one of the most tear jerking last words ever.
- Hitman Contracts has one mission where you can kill one of your targets using a pillow. Amazingly, the rather long and loud struggle does not wake his wife sleeping next to him.
- On a later mission, you can drown one of the targets as he floats on a pool. Similarly, the guard nearby doesn't bat an eye to his struggle, which is even louder.
- Averted in Dominic Deegan - when a pillow is used (backed with a spell that makes it cling to the victim's face) it chokes the attacker unconscious but, removed in time, causes no further damage.
- Marco tries to do this to Quinn in Sealab 2021, once Quinn falls into a coma. A nurse catches Marco, though, who insists he was just trying to take the pillow off.
- Barney doing it to Homer in The Simpsons in a spontaneous parody of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It does nothing and the characters are kind of confused by it.
- In the episode of The Simpsons which parodied the life of Henry the 8th, Homer is killed very hastily and very cleanly this way by Marge.
- Homer also does this to one of the recurring aliens in a Treehouse of Horror episode.
- Family Guy: Peter imagines doing this to Lois in one episode. He doesn't actually do this to her though.
- In one episode of Robot Chicken, Woody does this to Buzz when he's effectively lobotomized as a result of Andy using him as a bong.
- In one episode of Batman: The Animated Series one of Roland Daggett's men attempts to do this to Lucius Fox to keep him from spilling the shady practices he knows about the company. Luckily, Batman was waiting for this to happen and manages to get the drop on him. Unfortunately, Clayface has been waiting there as well, as he's looking to bump the mook off so he can impersonate him and get in close to Daggett in revenge.
- Real Life: This has been stated to be a leading cause of crib death in infants, whether inadvertently or deliberately. In the latter case the weight of the pillow itself provides all the force necessary for suffocation.
- This was reportedly how Caligula killed Emperor Tiberius. (Most movie/TV adaptations seem to want to portray his death like this anyway...)
- Nur Muhammad Taraki, who led the original Marxist coup that eventually resulted in the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, was murdered in this way in 1979. Witnesses reported that he took 15 minutes to die.
- Surviving Assyrian records confirm that the "son of a nobody" Hazael murdered King Ben-Hadad and seized his throne. In a plausible variation of this trope, according to The Bible (II Kings 8:15), Ben-Hadad was sick and weak, the murder weapon was a washcloth, and Hazael was careful to soak it first before using it to suffocate him; in effect, one might say he drowned him in his bed.