Really, any Death Battle that is a close call where the (eventual) loser nearly takes the win is a CMoA.
Haggar vs Zangief. Two paragons of Manliness falling off a building at terminal velocity while both perform a spinning piledriver on eachother. It ends as a swirling ball of Briefs, Boots, Trousers, and Men impacting the ground.
Vegeta vs Shadow. Super Vegeta throwing the effing moon at Super Shadow.
Mario vs Sonic. Two of the greatest rivals in video game history fighting each other to the death. And it is as every bit as glorious as it sounds. Especially the montage where they start bringing the Final Boss music of Super Mario Galaxy 2.
Wily vs Eggman. Probably the highest scale Death Battle in the series history with tens of animated robots attacking each other. And it is awesome!
Link VS Cloud Strife.
Animated with 3D graphics rather than sprites, exceptionally close, no way to tell who would win, and possibly the longest battle yet. What's not to like? Except the result, for Cloud fans?
The final exchange of blows is the crown jewel: Link blocking the Omni Slash, slashing Cloud on a Single-Stroke Battle, bombing him and finishing with his Meteor Move.
The reason for the out come? USE STRATEGY, KIDS!
Batman vs Spider-Man. While it was ultimately Spider-Man's victory, Batman outsmarted him throughout almost the entire battle, giving Spidey barely any breathing room.
Batman destroying all of the lights inside the skyscraper because that is exactly the kind of thing he would do in the situation he was in.
Spidey rapidly firing web balls until Batman is knocked back on a giant web and finishing him off by using himself as a human slingshot.
Spider-Man: HAVING FUN YET!? IT'S ALL OR NOTHIN'!!
Spidey's own reaction after kicking Bats' ass also counts as one.
Spider-Man: Sorry about that.
There's also the idea that Spider-Man was keeping up with the quips the entire fight, even during the portions when he was losing. He really wasn't scared of the Bat.
The reveal of Goku vs. Superman. At first, there is darkness. Then, as a familiar voice chants the name of his most famous attack, a peculiar shape is partially shadowed by the glow of energy gathering. When the beam is finally released, the shape is revealed to be the symbol of the world's most famous superhero. This makes Wiz and Boomstick go absolutely wild.
Think there was a Schedule Slip with the battle between Superman and Goku? That's because they've been researchingeverything about these characters, doing their most thorough analysis yet to provide the ultimate, irrefutable, and unquestionable answer to this most ancient of fandom rivalries, with the release date of 12-21-12, just to expound the significance. As of 12/21/12, there has been a Schedule Slip. This is because Lange is taking a while to animate the fight. However, it's thanks to this slip that we are let in on some info about this Death Battle that's never been done in any Death Battle before: Half-hour. That's right, this Death Battle is going to be about 3 or 4 times longer than the average Death Battle!
All of Son Goku vs. Superman. All of it. Easily could have served as a series finale. Highlights include:
The first thing before the death battle actually begins? The famous "World of Cardboard" Speech itself followed by superman going all out.
How the battle went from lighthearted and comical to the two heroes having a friendly spar to getting more and more heated by the minute the more serious both became and the soundtrack and animation (dark clouds, the blackness of space) helped set the ambiance. Even Goku's voice darkened after his final transformation.
Every time Goku transformed beyond the initial Kaio Ken.
Goku's Beam-O-War with Superman's heat vision bolstered by the soundtrack playing at the time.
The climactic battle-ending punch of Goku's Dragon Fist VS Superman's Infinite Mass Punch.
Goku slamming Superman to the ground with his Power Pole and then Superman grabbing said Power Pole and using it to slam Goku (Who was on the other side of the pole) into the ground.
Both warriors firing energyattacks at each other from near point blank range. By point blank we mean at the face!
Superman smashing a car onto Goku's head in a Shout-Out to Superman's earliest comic cover.
And as a meta continuation of the above praise for the episode, consider this: less than twenty-four hours after it was originally posted, the number of Facebook recommendations for Goku vs. Superman (~49,000 as of the 21-hour mark) was higher than all the other episodes of Death Battle combined (~46,426).
Another meta example for the above, just the sheer amount of research and math they put into determining the limits of their strengths. They've Shown Their Work before, but this took it Up to Eleven.
The main theme for Goku vs Superman, created by The Blake Robinson Synthetic Orchestra. It really gets everyone who waited so long for this legendary fight all hyped up, and almost makes the whole episode seem like an epic movie.
He-Man vs. Lion-O
He-Man lifting an entire freaking mountain to hurl at Lion-O.
Lion-O retaliates by completely destroying said mountain with a well-placed blast from the Sword of Omens, equally as awesome.
Also, the fact the fight plays homage to both shows from playing their theme tunes to giving them voice overs and saying quirky 80's one-liners. It felt very much like a dream battle for both fans. Well, the He-Man ones anyway.
Every time He-Man does something awesome we are treated to his theme "HE-MAN!"
Shao Khan vs. M. Bison
Shao Khan's unrelenting demeanor results in him repeatedly hitting True Bison over the head with the Wrath Hammer, eventually knocking him out of the Super Mode.
' And right afterthat, Bison tries to control him, only for Shao Khan to absorb him with the Soulnado and win his powers.
Boomstick: ... That can't be good.
Sometimes Awesome Moments occur in the actual rundowns of the characters, usually when their ultimate weapons/techniques are analyzed or their greatest feats are listed. For some particularly awesome examples, the rundowns for Doomguy'sBFG, Metal Sonic, and Goku'sSuper Saiyan forms are accompanied by intense music and preceded by dramatic buildup.
Considering Strider won was there any other way the end of the fight could've been animated other than a Ragnarok finish? I think not.
Hayabusa uses all of his melee weapons in the fight at some point and Strider counters by destroying everything except the Dragon Sword, with the use of Falchion.
Strider directs an entire battalion of Option 2 and 3 drones at Ryu, Ryu's response? Effortlessly dice them all into metal chunks before they could so much as even touch him.
While getting your legs blown off in most battles would mean defeat in Death Battle, not so for Fox McCloud. What does he do after becoming Half the Man He Used to Be? Simple. Amp up his jetpack, rocket right into his opponentcausing the momentum to dislodgebothcombatants' jetpacks and sending both fighters to the ground. Upon choking Bucky, Fox whips out his blaster, charges it up and...well, you know the rest.
It helps that Fox's legs are cybernetics so losing them wouldn't be as much of a big deal for him than for others.
Considering that Bucky had killed his closest friend, Slippy Toad, at the start, that was some pretty thorough payback.