Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion YMMV / YoungJustice

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
Kindle4Light Since: Oct, 2011
Jan 25th 2019 at 4:38:12 PM •••

Question on this item in folder Season 3:

  • What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids?: The new series on DC Universe is clearly meant for an older audience. While the first two seasons definitely had their edgier content, they had to be censored for the kids due to being on Cartoon Network. But now, as a streaming-exclusive series, it does not.
    • Greg Weisman referred to the content as "PG-13 towards R" as opposed to "PG towards PG-13" , and the first five minutes make it clear; we see a 14-year-old girl being trafficked as she's completely helpless, sees corpses around her, forcibly turned into a monster, and then accidentally killed by Black Lightning, much to his horror. That's just the beginning.
    • The first three episodes alone of Season 3 contain multiple examples of Family-Unfriendly Violence; including people being stabbed or shot to death with visible blood getting spilled, and a teenage girl getting her face burned off by a monster (though fortunately, she instantly and completely regenerates from her injuries, but it was still a very gruesome sight).

Does the above really apply if it never meant to be for kids to begin with?

Arctimon Since: Nov, 2009
May 3rd 2014 at 7:06:03 PM •••

Some of the Narm entries (especially the later ones) seem like they're delving into the realm of just complaining for the sake of it. One in particular is about the JL not having a more prominent role...even though the show isn't even directly about them.

Kind of hesitant to remove them since it is a YMMV issue. Can anyone take a second look at them and voice an opinion?

Hide / Show Replies
DrPsyche Since: May, 2012
May 29th 2014 at 4:17:46 PM •••

Ah the Age old YMMV problems, by it's nature it's subjective, but taken to extremes any attitude can be written down because it'a all opinion based (broad statement, don't bother taking it apart it's not important).

I do agree with you though, whether or not these are examples, we should probably clear up the venom in them.

As for whether or not these examples count, try see if you can find discussions about the incidents around the web. See if they're generally shared complaints that a good few fans hold.

Edited by 66.75.122.216
TheOtherSteve Since: Jan, 2001
May 29th 2014 at 4:31:03 PM •••

Just about all of those entries were added by billthetaylor. Yeah, it looks a lot like a one-man hate thing, but we should probably check with him first.

Eagal This is a title. Since: Apr, 2012
This is a title.
Oct 15th 2013 at 5:51:05 PM •••

Per the UI page, not Unfortunate Implications without an accompanying link to prove it's not just one person complaining.

  •     Unfortunate Implications 
    • The show at one point had a tie-in toyline at the McDonald's burger chain. All four male members of Young Justice were included in the line, as were Superman and Batman. Guess who was excluded from the line? You guessed it, Miss Martian and Artemis. To add insult to injury, they were replaced by Black Manta and Captain Cold, the latter of whom hadn't even had a speaking role on the show yet.
    • The Young Justice Halloween costumes only feature Robin, Kid Flash, and Superboy — the three white boys. The two girls on the team and the black boy are left out.
    • The series' promotional materials, the tie-in comics, and most fanart depict the half-Vietnamese Artemis with a more "white" complexion and bright blue eyes; Word of God on the former two is that it was due to a miscommunication. The actual show has her with noticeably darker skin than her Caucasian teammates and dark gray eyes.
    • In "Beneath", Dick is explaining to Batgirl, Wonder Girl, Miss Martian, and Bumblebee that he put together an all-female team to investigate Queen Bee because her persuasion abilities don't work as competently on women as they do on men. Batgirl then asks Dick if he would've "felt the need to justify an all-male squad for a given mission?" At which point the rest of the squad gives Dick a dirty look and sheepishly asks "there's no right answer to that, is there?" When he logs out, Batgirl quips that Queen Bee's not the only one who can mess with men's minds, and the team laughs. Half the fanbase appreciates Batgirl for calling Nightwing on the unintentional assumption that an all-male squad is normal, while an all-female squad needs to be explained; the other half thinks she's being a Straw Feminist and giving Nightwing grief for no reason.
    • Any episode that deals with international politics tends to fall into this, especially for non-American viewers. "Targets" portrays "North and South Rhelasia", paper-thin expies of the two Koreas, as being run by essentially bratty children who continue to fight with each other for no particular reason until Lex Luthor steps in as a white savior, points out that they have no reason to fight, and persuades them into making peace... through a promise of selling advanced military tech to both sides. "Image" presents Qurac as essentially the culmination of all neoconservative propaganda about what Iraq would be like post-invasion with a leader who is Definitely Positively Democratically Elected and beloved by his people and supports the United States until the supervillain who runs Bialya brainwashes him into wanting to hand his country over to her, at which point the heroes need to intervene to save Qurac from itself. The tie-in comic has the democratic leader replaced by Sumaan Harjavti... who is in league with Queen Bee, willingly.
    • The fact that the one black guy in the show in a relationship has to call his girlfriend "woman" at least once.
    • Arsenal's comment about getting a reward (and Cassie willingly giving him one) has reminded many a fan of the sexist trope in which a hero would get abrupt kisses from women after saving the day as a "reward".

Edited by 173.74.35.129 You fell victim to one of the classic blunders!
Eagal This is a title. Since: Apr, 2012
This is a title.
Aug 4th 2012 at 8:32:43 PM •••

Query:

Why were the edits reversed concerning Blue Beetle being regarded as The Scrappy and Brent Spiner not being a very good VA?

Edited by Eagal You fell victim to one of the classic blunders! Hide / Show Replies
GamerSlyRatchet Since: Jan, 2011
Aug 8th 2012 at 10:58:38 AM •••

Blue Beetle being regarded as The Scrappy seemed like a very unpopular, mostly unknown opinion. He is nowhere as universally hated as Lagoon Boy, a perfect candidate of such title. The YMMV page often describes popular opinions across the fanbase, not one or two people having a problem with something. The current positioning in They Changed It, Now It Sucks! seems more fitting, even if still a bit unpopular.

Brent Spiner can be a very good VA, but this specific performance is very polarizing. I guess that can be left there, but it did seem like an unnecessary dig at the voice actor was added in.

Latest blog update (November 5th, 2022).
Eagal Since: Apr, 2012
Aug 8th 2012 at 2:01:58 PM •••

Works for me.

You fell victim to one of the classic blunders!
SeptimusHeap MOD (Edited uphill both ways)
May 18th 2012 at 4:14:00 PM •••

For the 2nd time, stop edit warring around this item.

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman Hide / Show Replies
GoldStarz Since: May, 2010
May 19th 2012 at 3:38:36 PM •••

T He eidt war stopped a while ago, people were deleting it because they didn't like it, but it has since been resolved until you 'solved' it.

Lionheart0 Since: Oct, 2009
Jun 1st 2012 at 1:43:18 PM •••

Honestly there wouldn't be an edit war if you hadn't ended it with a Take That!.

SeptimusHeap MOD (Edited uphill both ways)
May 9th 2012 at 1:21:34 PM •••

Too undetailed to be an example - please see How To Write An Example:

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman
SeptimusHeap MOD (Edited uphill both ways)
May 9th 2012 at 1:20:24 PM •••

These entries are being the subject of an Edit War. Don't readd them in any shape or form without sorting things out here first:

  • Contested Sequel/Replacement Scrappy:
    • The series as a whole is viewed as such by a lot of Teen Titans fans.*
    • And now fans of the late, great DCAU hate this series for its toyline effectively cancelling the long-running Justice League Unlimited toyline. A toyline that hasn't had a show to help support it for five years. The lesson? Fandoms do not let things go.
    • Almost every new season 2 character was viewed like this before the episode even aired due to some characters not appearing the TV spots. There are also people complaining that the personalities of the new members of the Team are no different from the eight we saw in season 1.
      • It's still like that with some fans.
    • Lagoon Boy is shaping up to act as a Replacement Scrappy for three of the first season's main characters. He never stops complaining about being overlooked and under-appreciated but doesn't seem to have earned anything like Red Arrow had, he has mostly underwater powers with a goofy-looking form when we swells up like a blowfish that seem inferior to Aqualad's powers, and is dating Miss Martian, making him a shipping wars target from fans who prefer her paring up with Superboy. Oh, and he also has a lame catchphrase ("Netpune's Beard", a Call-Back to Aquaman which seems much worse than the previous season's eyeroller "Hello Megan") and stupid sounding underwater hip lingo.
      • To be fair to Lagoon Boy, notice, unlike Aqualad (whose tattoos are permanently on his skin) his tattoos only appear when he's using magic, meaning that he's actually more skilled at Atlantean sorcery than Aqualad. And yeah, he's arrogant, but not a much as Red Arrow.
    • He gets the worst of it due mostly to the Die for Our Ship, but he's not the only one. You've Kid Flash fans complaining about Beast Boy due to the fact that the latter has picked up Wally's habit of collecting souvenirs. And then there are also people who complain that he's not like his counterpart in Teen Titans. And people see the show's Wonder Girl as a Replacement Scrappy for Artemis. Even the Tim Drake Robin isn't spared- there are plenty of people wanting 13-year-old Dick Grayson back.

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman
jenicaaladima Since: Aug, 2010
Aug 31st 2011 at 8:54:08 AM •••

IT'S COMING BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

3 weeks left!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I swear to God I'm dying to know what episode 11 is.

Top