Follow TV Tropes
The Jerk Sue section.....is all of that necessary? There's listing a trope as an example, and then there's righting a damn essay.
It's quite apparent that you don't know what WR Iting an essay entails.
I have to agree, it's too fucking long and has pretty much crossed into Darth Wiki territory. I'm cutting it and replacing it with a much shorter abridgement.
Since when is Jerk Sue a Dark Wiki page? A year later still doesn't seem to be...might be some potential in the idea though
Jerk Sue is not in Darth Wiki. They were saying that the example was written in Darth Wiki style (=not-appropriate-for-the-main-wiki style, in other words), though.
Pretty much that. It had stopped being something you'd write on a YMMV page and became something better placed on either Wallbanger, So Bad Its Horrible or Dethroning Moment Of Suck.
Thing is, the large majority of all that was true. You can confirm the crowd responses on Raw, even if you remove the admittedly judgmental tone of the article, but why would you? This is audience reactions, your mileage may vary and you're entitled to your own opinion, so long as its based on something that actually happened. Some of that stuff was factually inaccurate and that should have been trimmed but just arbitrarily cutting the whole thing makes us seem like the sound guys trying to find kids to mic when the crowd decides to take a dump on Cena and bring up his charity acts to shame us for booing him.
Not that I think I've ever booed John Cena at any WWE event I've been to, I am in his supposed target audience. Look through the edit history and see I've removed or corrected a few negative opinions about John Cena. I'm not bringing this up for the sake of complaining, just that legit complaints should be allowed to stay in some capacity.
This stuff at least seems worth saving.
You don't get the argument being made; all of that there is already too much and too long. Putting it on the page is just going to attract misuse and blow out the page with complaining. It doesn't matter if it's true or not, it just brought nothing but toxicity to the page.
Plus, most of the entries seem like "Jerk". Never mind that Sue tropes that attract problems are best left out.
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?