Follow TV Tropes
Figured we need a new thread.
This thread is for cleaning up pages the P5 have found to have problematic material. List is here.
You can also report pages that appear too lewd or gushy here. They will be cleaned according to No Lewdness No Prudishness.
For the record, the cleanup guidelines (since sending people around links is not efficient) are:
"Lewdness" is more than just being about something sexual or potentially sexual. Here are some signs of lewd writing:
For further explanations, please read this thread
edited 19th Jun '12 3:52:33 PM by SeptimusHeap
For those who are curious (like I was), the P5 are a group of people who are working on cleaning the Wiki of objectionable content. P5 means "Panel Preventing Perversity, Pornography and Paedoshit".
OT: Is there a wiki page anywhere explaining all this new policy?
I know that, but wiki policies get pages and not posts. Sandbox.What Is Porn is the only thing I can find about that (apropos, where does doscussion about this go? To the About Content Violations Discussions thead?)
edited 6th May '12 6:58:53 AM by SeptimusHeap
Well, this isn't a wiki page, but here's that post BobbyG made explaining the new Content Policy.
The Immodest Orgasm was TRS-shopped for lewdness, and I see quite a lot of issues there.
Also, I hate the name of that manga, it makes trying to talk about it impossible.
edited 8th May '12 11:32:32 AM by Discar
I fixed up the trope names, moved Foe Yay to YMMV, and cleaned the Power Perversion Potential entry a bit but that's it.
Oh, and I deleted a NSFW link.
Not sure what I should do with the Naughty Tentacles entry. Should I just out-right delete it?
Also I think that the page doesn't go into too much detail about the naughty bits, but I think someone else should double check. I'm a bit desensitized.
On second thought, the term Shotacon and the Cute Shotaro Boy entries could be problematic. I'll delete them since the guy in question is girlish looking rather than young, but feel free to disagree with me. Also, he's 15.
Oh, Septimus Heap, be sure to fix your post about the guidelines especially the part about no pedogushing. Lolita was restored, so you should remove that example.
edited 8th May '12 12:16:27 PM by encrypted12345
The mods are discussing bringing back Naughty Tentacles as a stub, so leave that alone for now.
^ Would've been nice to know before I zapped them...
That title is not coming back, for sure.
@Discar: I don't know what you're talking about, there's absolutely nothing wrong with asking people to clean up My Balls.
Cleaned up My Balls
Did you make sure to clean My Balls thoroughly? My Balls seem to need a lot of attention last time I looked.
You removed a lot of Plot details, but they were pretty raunchy plot details. I left them alone since they didn't go into too much unnecessary detail, but if you see a reason to cut them, I have no real reason to object.
@11 but the trope itself might be coming back no? Just under a new name? So leaving in the redlink would be helpful for rename purposes no?
These are the first on the P5 list:
Who's up for cleaning?
Anime.Agent Aika was flagged for content review by the P5. While it does not to be a series that would qualify under the "Primarily Porn" or "Pandering to Pedophiles" guidelines (and was thus zapped from the queue), the work page is overly gushy in regards to the fanservice elements of the series.
If anyone is willing to give this page a once over and de-gushification, I would appreciate it.
I'm surprised no one bothered until now.
Anyways, I deleted the page image and removed most of the gushing about panties. I left some of it alone, so the page can stay a little bit snarky.
Are there any such guidelines written down yet? If so, where?
You want No Lewdness No Prudishness for this.
edited 20th May '12 5:05:24 PM by DarkConfidant
By guidelines I was referring to "criteria for the panel to cut the page". If you are asking about cleanup guidelines, check the link Dark Confidant provided for you.
What Is Porn is unofficial, but I've yet to hear anything official outright contradicting it.
What Is Porn, baby don't cut me, don't cut me, no more...
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?