- All-Star Cast: Adam Devine, Alexandra Daddario, Shelley Hennig and Robbie Amell.
- He Really Can Act: Many critics and the public expressed their surprise at how superb Adam Devine was as a leading man, and how endearing and charming his portrayal was, considering this was way out of his usual character type. Some even compared him to Tom Hanks in Sleepless in Seattle.
- Playing Against Type: Adam Devine was previously typecast as the jerk in a lot of movies, and this is his first leading role as a nice, lovable guy in a movie. This may be due to his highly acclaimed role in Modern Family, in which he plays a very similar character. This led to a huge He Really Can Act response for his performance.
- Production Posse: Director Ari Sandel, Robbie Amell and numerous producers and cast members previously worked on The Duff together.
- Written by Cast Member: Adam Devine co-wrote the movie.
Trivia / When We First Met