- Noah realising that his friends' happiness is more important than his own, and that no amount of time travel will make Avery love him.
- During all the time loops, Carrie was always there to talk to Noah, despite the two of them barely talking in years.
- "She said she wished things could be different."
- After hearing Avery's reaction to Ethan saying that he loves her, Noah fights back tears after he realises that Avery doesn't love him at all.
Tear Jerker / When We First Met