Follow TV Tropes

Following

Headscratchers / Questionable Content

Go To

    open/close all folders 

    Not-That-Alternate Universe 
  • It amuses me how nobody's mentioned the little talking sentient AI robots yet.
    • That's because there's an explanation for that provided by Jeph. The world of QC isn't the same as our world. As he said, "You think that'd be obvious with the little robot computers running around, but..."
    • Given the little 'bots seem to be the only regular use of super science it sort of seems like Reed Richards Is Useless.
    • The only one that we see, because the story is about the Marten & co. Perhaps the power stations run on cold fusion and there are colonies on Mars. That doesn't impact the characters' day-to-day lives; the lights work when you switch them on, however they're powered.
    • Uh, robots are used for other purposes. Hannelore's dad lives on a space station (where she was raised), there are robot TRUCKS, a sufficiently human body has been created, and that's just top of my head.
    • I seem to recall Hanners saying "I will move to the moon" at one point in response to somebody's creepy joke or something. We assume she is using a hyperbole, but maybe there really are colonies on the moon! It's like saying she'll move to China, it's silly but still possible.
    • Hanner's also made a comment in one of the strips how her father neglecting her was a reasonable price for bringing cancer-killing nanobots into the world, so it's safe to assume that the QC world is rather advanced. Mostly due to Hanner's dad.
    • Wait, it's an Alternate Universe? I always figured it was just set 20 Minutes into the Future.
    • Given the very contemporary band references, not possible.
    • According to in-comic information the only person doing Alternate Universe science is Hanner's dad, hence the only reason we see anything science-y it's in small amounts. Yes they have bionic robot arms, AnthroPC's, lasers and things but only those things he bothered to make because they were awesome. In the most recent storyline we've encountered a space plane. Surely if space planes were commonplace or known very well the reactions everyone has had towards the space plane would've been different.... No. this was their first time seeing a plane that could fly into space. Clearly this means that all the cool science is being done by this one man and everyone just sorta follows.
    • This also explains why nearly all the super-science is things like sentient AI, space stations, and robot hamsters—it's the kind of thing Hannelore's dad is interested in.
    • It seems odd to me that we've seen robot toasters, humidifiers, and garbage cans but not more obviously useful robot appliances like stoves and fridges. Given how many times we've seen stove related mishaps, I would have thought robot stoves in particular would be mentioned at least once. Also, how is it we've seen a robot scooter and been informed of the existence of robot trucks, forklifts and submarines but there's no sign of a single robot taxi. Even considering it being an Alternate Universe where Reed Richards Is Useless, these seem like weird gaps in tech given the context. It's like all advanced tech in QC is there either becase of Rule of Cool or Rule of Funny instead of Like Reality Unless Noted like with almost everything else in the comic.

    Couch Condoms 
Advertisement:

    Toto 
  • Wait, Toto wrote songs other then Africa?
    • ...yes?
    • ... since when?!?
    • Well...
    • In all seriousness, it's a bit silly to use "Africa" in that scene, given it's far and away Toto's biggest hit. "You like this band's biggest hit?!? ME TOO!"
    • Well remember these are music geeks saying that if it was just regular people then yeah it'd be kind of stupid but it can be assumed that they have heard a decent number of Toto songs that are not Africa

    Marigold's Finances 

  • How can Marigold afford a WoW account?
    • She doesn't have a job or visible means of support.
    • She could have some kind of online employment.
    • It's actually mentioned in some of the initial "Marigold visits CoD" comics that she's the webmaster for her dad's website. Not much other detail is given, but assuming that her dad has a popular/lucrative website it's not unreasonable to believe that he'd be able to pay her a living wage without it being nepotism or her leeching off of him.
    • Also, a couple of times it was mentioned she does other freelance website work.
    • It's also possible to make real-world money off of World of Warcraft, if you play it right. Another thing to keep in mind is that, even with her shabby personal hygiene and near-indifference to her own health, a WoW subscription would probably be only a fraction of Marigold's total living expenses.
    • Marigold has given her WoW name as "MariGoldFarmer" which would seem to support that hypothesis....

    Unique Names 

  • Are the unique names part of the Alternate Universe thing? The names of characters are far from common: Hannelore, Sven, Marigold, Angus, Penelope, Wil (with one L)...we might even be able to count Dora, since that's antiquated enough. Marten and Faye are the closest to "normal" names out of the main characters, as is Steve, although his appearances are not nearly as frequent as they used to be. What are the chances that so many uniquely-named people would cross paths and become a cohort of friends in our universe?
    • Dora, Penelope, Sven, and Angus all sound more "normal" than "Faye" to me, and Wil with one L is less strange than Marten with an E.
    • I always thought Wil was a shortening of something, like Wilhelm or something. Eh. Also, Angus is a pretty popular name, as are Dora, Penelope, and Marigold (though the last two might be a little old-fashioned). Sven is a pretty reasonable name, if not necessarily for someone of Italian descent. Also, he was born in the U.S. (and so, probably, were his parents) so that's not really a factor.
    • Sven's family is also of Swedish descent, making his name a lot more logical.
    • That part's even stated outright in the comic: Mom Bianchi is of Swedish descent and stated that since she was pregnant and had to go through childbirth, she got to decide the name, and Dad Bianchi didn't contest it.
    • In our universe we have people named stuff like Willow, Parker, Jazzmin, and Stefani. I really don't see the problem with Penelope or Sven.
    • What's wrong with the name Wil?
    • Hannelore's parents (especially her father) are weird. Hardly surprising that she got an unconventional name, especially given that her father would more than likely have named her.
  • This may be jossed: As well as Claire, the intern in the library, there's also Claire the witch here.
  • Unusual names are possibly just Author Appeal since Jeph Jacques himself has a pretty unique name.

    Hannelor's dad and his AI 

  • Two things:
    1. Why would Hannelore's dad's name be Ellicott-Chatham at all? I'm not entirely familiar with the American legal system, but from what I know it's the wife who adopts her husband's surname. If he's John Ellicott, then his wife would be either Mrs. Ellicott or Mrs. Chatham-Ellicott. If there's something that says you can hyphenate it however the hell you want it, that'd answer the question.
    2. Why does an AI even have shares in a company, let alone over half a billion dollars?
    • Two answers:
    1. From what I've heard, the married couple may choose who takes whose name.
    • To expand on this, the wife taking her husband's last name is a standard social convention, but it's not a legal requirement in any American jurisdiction. Also, in most American jurisdictions, even a single person can go by any name they want, as long as they're not doing it for fraudulant purposes.
    • Different troper here, just wanted to give a personal example. I'm American, and both my parents kept their last names upon marrying, then decided to give me a hyphenated last name (with my mother's surname coming before my father's; it's often the other way around). Then they up and decided to give my little sister my mother's surname only. So yeah, you can pretty much do whatever you want, I'm just so used to it I never even realized other people might be confused by it. Maybe Jacques thought the same way when he named the characters?
    • Considering that Hannelore's father seems to be more than a little scatterbrained or silly at times, it's understandable that he'd have trouble figuring out what was what. Or he just wouldn't care to figure it out when there is science to be done.
    • He flat out confirms that he doesn't know what his own name is and has been confused since the divorce. It is possible that they both double-barreled their names whilst married and upon their divorce, Hannelore's mother (the savvy woman with a huge interest in her public appearance) instantly reverted to her maiden name whilst her father (intelligent but not worldly and not at all interested in what other people think of him) never bothered to update all the forms and so was still officially Ellicot-Chatham. It probably never occured to him to ever change his name (he has cancer fighting nano-bots to build!) and his wife will have organised it the first time (she is the type to get an idea and have the world re-organised over breakfast) and she wouldn't have cared in the end. Hannelore herself, of course, will have kept the name because she doesn't want to upset either parent.
    1. AI have been granted civil rights long before this scene happens. A whole strip was dedicated to making this clear. As for why he'd want them, presumably for some of the same reasons as why a human would want them.
    2. As for Station owning shares in the company? What if he had to bribe someone who took over the place or something?
    • Or it's part of a ploy to keep Station in line. According to my calculations, based the numbers in strip 2119, Station holds over 600 million dollars of EC-Tech stock. Since Station is linked into everything and could vent the station to space with a thought if he thinks "Meh, my boss sucks", the station staff have every reason to keep it happy. By making sure Station has a financial stake in keeping the station running, EC-Tech has neatly avoided any issues of the robots taking over. If Station tries any funny business, its stock plummets. Of course, what Station actually does with the money is anyone's guess...
    • Momo getting a 'real' job in order to pay for her own brand new chassis is the first time we see a regular character AI getting money. But it seems like it's pretty normal for AIs to have their own money and financial control over it. Pintsize buys stuff all the time (heirloom knives, various costume props, condoms) and Marten's reaction is usually surprise at the strangeness of the items and not anger that his credit card has been stolen (Pintsize is still producing new props when Marten is unemployed, whilst we don't know if he bought it then or earlier it suggests that he has his own funds). Then, as more AI characters are introduced it appears that NOT having a job and your own money is the strange thing.
    • there is a whole issue here, regarding the actual FUNCTION of AIs generally. If an AI has sentience and civil rights, and can manifest in almost any physical form, who or what performs the various functions they were originally (presumably) created for? Why would anyone WANT a sentient assembly arm (Jeremy)?
    • Simplest answer to #1, Hannelore's father was named Ellicot-Chatham at birth, and passed the whole name to Hannelore. He married a Chatham; let's hope they weren't too closely related.
    • My guess: They hyphenated their names when they married. When they split up, she reverted to her original name, while he kept the hyphenated form.

    Hannelore's medication 

  • Why did Dr. Corrine take Hannelore off whatever she was on back in the 500s? She seemed to be doing a lot better!
    • I have three possibilities:
    1. The meds were causing weird side effects that we (the readers) weren't shown. Hannelore was taken off them for her own health.
    2. Hannelore was (seemingly) capable of handling herself fine, rendering the meds unnecessary. Perhaps Dr. Corrine figured she'd been on them long enough.
    3. Hannelore asked to be taken off the meds. I just got off some heavy-duty anti-anxiety stuff myself, and the reasons is that I wanted to try living without what I felt to be some kind of crutch. Or Hanners just didn't like some of the things she wound up doing while medicated.
    • "Doing a lot better" is kind of up for debate. Compared to what we know of her now, she was actually acting pretty out-of-character back then. She might have been handling the OCD better, but if it led to her having wild personality changes, that's not necessarily a good thing.
    • Hannelore was stalking her neighbors and making poor/dangerous choices such as smoking. Doesn't sound like a good outcome to me.
      • To elaborate: She'd been stalking Marten and Faye for some time, and the reason she actually met Marten is because she was smoking in the bar bathroom after being up for four days counting the hairs on her head. Even if those meds were helping her anxiety the effects were...uneven, at best.

Advertisement:

    Slash 

  • Does Jeph not know what "slash fic" means? Because there are a couple points in the comics where characters seem to use it to refer to straight pairings.
    • Slash used to mean any sexual pairing regardless of gender, however it has evolved to mean two guys.
    • I think it's the other way around. It started off meaning two guys, as in the ur-example Kirk/Spock, but has evolved to mean any pairing.
    • Slash originally meant unconventional (particularly non-canon) pairings, the sort of thing that nowadays would be called a Crack Pairing. The use of it to refer to homosexual pairings in particular has shifted the meaning in that direction, but there are still people who use it to refer to crack pairs regardless of gender-combination.

    Retcon 

  • Read this strip and then explain why the word "hump" has been underlined. Is it a replacement of some other word that used to be there? And does anyone remember what the old word was, if that's the case?
    • I think it was ravish. Last I remember it was.
    • Actually, it was "rape" originally. Apparently Jeph realized the Unfortunate Implications of saying that being raped by a woman is "the fantasy of every shy, submissive boy on the planet."

    Dora and Tai and Awkwardness 

  • What was up with this moment of awkwardness? I mean, he got Dora to babysit his kid when he went on a date with another lady, it's not like he's hung up on her, he shouldn't get all exasperated and need "tacos and beer" when he finds out Dora's got a ladyfriend. And why does Dora feel the need to run out and explain in the next strip, for the same reason? I can't find the strip where she hears he's dating someone, but I don't seem to recall her being all that upset about it. It really seems like it should be a non-issue.
    • The reason she gave him for not wanting to enter a relationship was that she was struggling with emotional issues (i.e., the ones that led to her breakup with Marten) and that she shouldn't be dating anyone at all at that time. I was under the impression that he was a bit miffed to see her with someone so soon after she had told him that, and seemed to be okay with it once he got past the initial shock.
    • I recall that, but I thought that was a long while ago. I guess in-comic time has not progressed very much since then?
    • I thought it may have also been the fact that it was a girl. He's not homophobic, but she rejected him, and then ended up with a girl.
    • I can speak from experience to say that this happens. If you see a woman a few times, there is that chemistry, and they claim to want to wait due to personal issues, and turn a round and start seeing g someone else... Well, it's a bummer. Makes you feel inadequate, or something. Now I need a beer.
    • Also, in a "been there, done that" sense, knowing something and seeing something are two very different things. At this point, Dora is in what appears to be a successful relationship, and he is still single; that's gonna sting a little bit.

    Hannelore's period 

  • If Hannelore's OCD is so bad, how does she deal with having her period? I seem to recall this being mentioned at some point in the strip, but I can't remember what the answer was (if there is one) nor can I find the strip in question.
    • The answer was "we don't talk about that day." Plus she's on the birth control pill, which can help reduce the number of periods.
    • More importantly, birth-control pills regulate when your period happens. No surprises and plenty of time to prepare for it.

    Dale's schedule 

  • Is Dale working four different jobs in the same day? How could he possibly have time for that?
    • I- you know, I have no clue. Maybe he has something special worked out with his bosses to give him four or less hours for each job. Maybe he's a temp guy until the normal guy comes in to work.
    • In some cities, it's perfectly common for each shift to be only four hours, with more being the exception rather than the rule. If all his jobs are in the same shopping center (or otherwise nearby), that would help too.
    • It could also help that the scheduled days are done differently; like he works at coffee of doom three days a week and then works dish-washing jobs late at night, stuff like that. He works multiple swingshifts.
    • The scheduling thing is probably a large part of the reason he's got AR glasses that we very rarely see turned off. To keep a copy of his calendar up at all times so he knows when the hell he's working where.

Advertisement:

    Beer Sledding 

  • The Speedbeer storyline. Where did they get the trays?
    • Marten works at a college campus. They probably raided the cafeteria.
    • Plus, half the cast run or work in hospitality businesses. If they didn't have a stock of their own, they'd know where to beg, buy or borrow some.

    Banned 

  • I get that the AIs don't want to feared but why did the activists get AI soldiers banned? How is taking away rights from AIs at all helpful? That makes as much sense as LGBT activists getting the military to reenact Don't Ask, Don't Tell. It seems like the AI activist are taking two steps forward, one step back with their legislation. This is especially confusing to me because it denies several AIs their rights to choose their own career path AND this doesn't seem to exclude non-combative AIs.
    • Besides the simple 'They didn't ask the AIs"...they presumably thought of it as AIs being put in military 'slavery', especially AIs who got combat bodies and had to pay for them, or AIs 'made' for combat. The idea of an AI choosing to become a soldier was foreign to them. Civil rights activists are anti-military? Who knew?!
    • there is no mention anywhere, of AIs paying for work-related bodies. One of the AIs was an ATM, one was a forklift truck, I doubt they paid for those bodies. Bubbles has never mentioned paying for HER body, and Pintsize’s “military chassis” appears to have been “surplus”. We don’t know anything about the status of the shop AIs at Idoru; Iris knows about the cost/benefit structure, but that’s part of her job. I don’t doubt that an AI COULD, if they saw fit, buy a body for the purpose of some business venture, but that’s nothing new.
    • It's a commentary on activists who mean well but don't bother to talk to the group they're trying to help or think through the consequences of their actions. Given Jeph hasn't ever been shy about broaching more serious topics when appropriate it shouldn't really come as a surprise, especially given the current relevance of such groups.

    I've had a bad time, you must obey! 

  • This is something alot of people porbably wonder, but why? why? WHY do people put up with Faye at all? I mean all the shit she does can only be excused for so long, and even then theres pushing your' luck, in fact, the same argument could be applied for Dora but she doesn't have the "excuse" Faye has. personally those two are toxic trainwrecks, but Faye in particular irks me, like when she was with Angus and he had an awesoome super day, getting his dream job and being cool with trying out a LDR (though he made it there and back inside a day so "the city" can't be that far) and she has been supportive up front, but doubtful in the head, then when he breaks the news that "YAY i got my dream job, she RUINS it, by going "see how i was cool with it, I actually super wasn't cool with it, so we are done" basically completely shattering what was probably one of that guys happiest days ever, then she has the utter gall to go get hammered like he did the dumping, why would anyone even want to be near her?
    • This is actually why a lot of alcoholics end up alone; you become stone-ass jerk to hide you own insecurities, depression, et cetera. If you pay attention, you see that Faye doesn't actually have a lot of friends outside of Dora, Hanners and Marten. Essentially, there are some people, often somewhat damaged themselves, who can see the real person behind the facade.
    • Faye is an alcoholic, and Dora has depression — both conditions that lead to things like selfish, "it's all about me and my feelings" behavior. In fact, one of the big signs of depression is an extreme self-focus and obsession about ones' own problems over those of others. This doesn't make their behavior any better, but at least explains some of it. Both girls end up losing relationships because of these issues, as happens to many people in real life (Jeph, for instance).
    • This is exactly why she gets hammered after breaking up with Angus. Remember, her reason for not dating Marten was her inability to rationally deal with the possibility, however remote, of him abandoning her. She's doing better by the time she starts dating Angus, but the prospect of a long-distance relationship inflames those doubts, and she bails. So she's fully aware that her choice to break up with him was because of her own insecurities. It's her self-loathing about her self-sabotaging behavior that she's trying to escape by drinking.
    • OP here, my problem isn't with her symptoms (heavy drinking, depression) its her actions that bother me, early days she was downright threatening to people, regularly actually hitting marten for percived little petty problems, and her big excuse basically amounts to "my dad died and it ruined me" throughout most of the comic, as a sufferer of actual depression, if i pulled any of the crap she pulls, I would downright get my ass beaten or thrown in jail for abuse, which is what she done to marten early days, just marten is too much of spinless git for most of it to actually d anything, and when you are in a group of self centered knobends, nobody notices.
      • Marten is a spineless git (for most of it), and most of the rest are too self-centered to really do anything about it. And even then, they only put up with it for so long: Dora fired Faye, Marten (and others, I can't remember) called her out, and Angus didn't even try salvaging their relationship. That being said, it isn't unrealistic for people to not abandon Faye despite her behavior: I have a cousin who refused to leave her emotionally abusive and controlling boyfriend because whenever she tried he'd play a "I'm depressed and have family problems and had a rough childhood" card. People are dumb like that.
      • This played itself to its natural psychological conclusion: Faye's selfishness led to her drinking on the job, getting caught doing so, getting fired and being hospitalised with an alcohol overdose. Since then she has fallen off the wagon exactly once (she almost fell off more than once, but she ended up not drinking) and her newfound sobriety and new job has led to a major change in her behaviour: she's much less selfish and much more empathetic. She goes out of her way to make friends with Bubbles, who she correctly recognises as being lonely and isolated, even though Bubbles initially does everything she can to dissuade her. It could be that her robot repair job means that she has an outlet for her aggression other than being personally unpleasant, but whatever the reason, she becomes so close to Bubbles that they end up falling in love. Alcohol makes people more selfish; ever since Faye stopped drinking, she's been a lot more attentive to other people.

    Momo flipping off Angus for rejecting Marigold 

  • This is something that's just bugged me ever since the comic was first posted. In this comic, Marigold tries to force herself on Angus, Angus tells her they're just friends, Marigold runs off crying, and Momo flips off Angus! So, it's okay if Marigold does it to Angus, but I presume not the other way around?
    • I think it's just a case of Momo being 100% on Marigold's side and therefore being angry at the guy who rejected and upset her, no matter his reason or intent. In the strips that follow, no other character says anything negative about Angus for turning her down, and there's a couple who specifically say that Angus did the right thing. So it's just one character with a considerable bias against the guy, not the whole strip upholding a double standard about men and women (in this case, at least). Angus is at least, being consistent; he didn’t lead her on, didn’t take advantage of her, and most characters recognise this.

    Tilly-Taffy’s pronouns 

  • the SJW on the Forum are going crazy about Tilly/Taffy’s use of pronouns. T/T, for reasons best known to that character, favours “they/their” which most people understand as a plural form. This doesn’t seem relevant in any way to the character’s narrative role, so far. Why doesn’t the character simply use “one”, which is a common usage in British English for non-gender-specific cases (“what might one do?”, for example).... seems to be another case of the Pandering to the Base which has become increasingly common...
    • The use of "they" as singular is increasing in popularity. (In part because it was accepted usage until relatively recently.) As to significance to the character's narrative role...yeah, it's non-existent, but that may have been the point. You don't always have to make a big deal out of non-binary characters, you know?

    who pays for the AI chassis? 

  • Momo’s replacement chassis was bought by Marigold, apparently for around the price of a car. Marigold clearly couldn’t afford this, from her reaction. Momo (who has no real economic function, in her present incarnation) claims to be paying Marigold back from her earnings as a librarian, but ALSO pays rent AND splurges her paychecks like a kid with pocket money..
    • Marigold clearly was able to afford it, given that she didn't have to noticeably alter her lifestyle after the purchase. It's possible she actually had more than enough money, but was just freaked at the thought of spending so much in one go - remember, her life at that point was pretty much video games and junk food. Momo could still be repaying her with a part of her salary: she doesn't spend on food or other consumables, so even if she paid a portion of rent and splurged once in a while (in fact, IIRC, she's only done that once), there's still probably some left over to repay Marigold.
  • May’s chassis is clearly pretty much at the end of its economic usefulness, but there are no funds to replace it
    • May was probably originally covered by the government given that her previous job allowed her access to military hardware, but they stopped funding her when she got thrown in jail. And given that governments go for the cheapest stuff, it isn't hard to believe they bought a chassis that would just barely do the job it needed to do.
  • Bubbles appears to inhabit a military-surplus chassis which she has retained, presumably as some sort of GI Benefit. However Corpse Witch implies, and Bubbles appears to believe her, that the government could reclaim it at will. Droid-06 and Deathbot 9000 could be similar cases
  • Idoru, in some respects, appears to operate as a quasi-charity, exercising discretion over the allocation of AI to Anthro PC chassis
  • Jeremy and possibly, Seven and Punchbot appear to inhabit some sort of industrial cast-off chassis

     AI chassis construction 

  • AI chassis construction seems to vary wildly. Some, like Punchbot, have “tin can” style construction with rotating joints, gears etc. If Punchbot has any sort of wrapping or dermis, we haven’t seen it
    • I don't remember Punchbot's background ever being explored, but non-anthropomimetic robots with no external dermis or covering seem to be fairly common.
  • May clearly has numerous, visible external articulations (including some sort of race her shoulder runs on) indicating a semi-rigid outer casing, but her face and head seem to be composed of some sort of Mylar covering over synthetic muscle fibres. She also has no visible sexual characteristics - when she appears topless during the “face repair” arc, her “breasts” are just indicative shaping of her torso. The “Sven” scene also shows her topless and nude with no “parts”. Various “service” AIs (such as the Idoru staff) and secondary cast like Melon, appear to be similar.
  • Momo has a covering of some sort of Mylar, with a visible seam around her neck. No other joints are visible. She is implied to be “anatomically correct” but we haven’t seen any of this.
    • Momo's new body is probably specifically designed to interact more easily with others. So it looks as human as they could reasonably manage without being mindblowingly expensive.
  • Bubbles wears a short-sleeved unitard which appears to be part of her dermis, not a garment. She occasionally has hip seams, but this isn’t consistently shown and her general movement and art style suggests that she has synthetic muscles over a skeletal armature. She has a “neck seam” which doesn’t coincide with her unitard neckline. Her generally statuesque design is considered erotic by some, and she's anatomically correct enough for her and Faye to have banged repeatedly for several hours at a stretch. Which raises other questions, but take it as it is.
    • Also, the post-banging scene, and various subsequent appearances wearing athleisure tops proves that Bubbles' unitard is indeed a garment.
  • higher-status AIs like Roko appear to be generally similar to Momo, but no details whether they are “anatomically correct”. Roko has been shown to have a three-toed foot armature with quasi musculature, wrapped in a dermal covering akin to a sock with no visible toes. Bubbles has similar details.
  • Roko’s new chassis is specifically paid for by an insurance claim against Crushbot, which begs the question of whether ALL robots have similar insurance?
  • what does a Synthetic weigh? Seems to vary as the plot requires, although generally more than a comparable human
    • they mostly appear to use normal human furniture, although Bubbles has a special chair at Coffee of Doom, and broke the bed at the apartment.
    • Momo appears to be heavy enough to walk on the lake bed during the “Emily’s Party” scene, but then Marten hoists her out of the water with one arm
    • Roko “faints” at Union Robotics, and Faye (who is depicted as “buff” and presumably, quite strong from her manual job) remarks on Roko’s weight - but the latest robot brought in, is carried on the shoulders of a human office worker with no apparent effort

     Military presence on the station 
  • The orbital facility has military presence despite it being a research vessel, why?
    • Hannelore has mentioned that her father has the ability to drop tungsten rods on Earth-based targets with a few minutes' notice. That alone merits a military presence: no way the U.s. government isn't going to want their own people in a place like that. There's also the possibility that some of their projects are government-funded, military presence therefore being a possible caveat.

     informed poverty and employment generally 
  • the main cast, and the background cast as far as can be determined, appear to live comfortable lives - renting apartments, driving (and presumably owning) cars in some cases, going to bars, patronising coffee shops at $4 a cup, owning guitars and other expensive recreational equipment. Yet, none of them seem to have meaningful employment or at best, work in minimum-wage jobs. The only ones with significant incomes are Marten’s parents (a sex worker and bar owner, respectively) and Hannelore’s parents, a senior corporate executive and scientific genius respectively. Tai’s circumstances make no real sense. Fay’s mother appears to be retired, as does Mrs Augustus (although she presumably also has alimony?)

Yet robots appear to be increasingly prevalent, occupying and colonising low-wage jobs like Shop assistants and bank tellers.

This is hand-waved in that Northampton is a college town, where probably most inhabitants are dependent upon debt and parents; but what do the population of Planet QC do for a living?

  • Between the full cast about 80-90% of them work, most of them are in couples, also, Faye, Marten, Claire and Bubbles all live together, and in another apartment, Dale, Marigold, May and Momo all live together, Tai and Dora apparently have their own place, Hannelore has mentioned she does number crunching on the side as a job (very well paid job usually), even at a relativly low but decent wage (both Marten and Tai work at the college library, Faye and Bubbles own a robot repair shop, Dora owns a coffee shop that is apparently successful) four people sharing an apartment and still having some spare cash isnt completely out the relm of impossible.

    How is Sam's Fingore Faye's fault? 
  • Why is it considered Faye's fault that Sam put her finger on a moving power tool? Yes, Faye left for a little while, but if she'd been standing next to Sam she couldn't have prevented it either. Even Sam says it's her fault.
    • because the power tool in question belongs to Faye’s business, and is on her business premises. Sam is a minor, isn’t trained to use the tool and generally has no business being on the premises at all, until the “sprays” plot

     Winslow is privileged? 
  • So Hannelore is wealthy, and decides after years of friendship, that, if winslow wants, he can have a fullsize body, remember he was in a weird Ipod body for ages, and Hannelore just wanted to do something nice for the AI who has been her buddy for apparently years, so ecstatic about it he goes to show May (who he considers a good friend), dude doesn't have a mean carbon rod in his body, May explodes at him about it, because she is stuck in a clearly less functional body, despite that being her own damn fault, this immediately goes onto an arc about how Winslow is "Privileged" and they go on about it for abit, now the arc ends with Winslow doing a kind thing and helping with a support group for AIs, but, how on earth is Winslow privileged for having a decent friend who wanted to do something nice, why did May, like an ass, make him feel guilty about getting a damn present? Whoopdeedoo, your body sucks, but that was entirely her own fault, it does seem to be trend that anyone does something even slightly nice, or get something nice, they immediatly get called out for, god help them, having good things happen to them.
    • First of all, May is a bit of a dick, so she hardly deals with people using sweetness and kindness. But the idea that it's her fault that she's actually stuck in a useless body ignores the fact that she has served her time in robot jail and, if there is any such thing as justice in the world, shouldn't go on being eternally punished for her crimes. She can't get a better body because she can't get a better job; she can't get a better job because she can't get a better body (and because of her criminal record.) People who think that May ought to go on suffering forever because of her crimes are being excessively vindictive. If crime and punishment are to have meanings at all, punishment has to end at some point, otherwise it's just stamping on people for the sake of feeling morally superior to them, which is incidentally a very good way to create a criminal underclass that assumes that it will never be allowed to achieve legitimate success so it may as well be criminal. Yes, a kinder, less selfish friend than May would have been happy that Winslow had a new body, but May isn't that sort of person; on the other hand, she is justifiably pissed off that the system has condemned her to go on being punished for a crime which, technically speaking, she has at this point more than paid for. May should perhaps have been less grumpy, but she can hardly be expected to be selflessly delighted that Winslow's so much luckier than she is.note 

     AI clothing and modesty, and Union Robotics 
  • any AIs with anthropomimetic chassis so far seen, seem to wear clothing as humans would. They are clearly programmed to do this, whereas “tin-can” robots of the Punchbot type don’t find this necessary.
    • Momo mostly dresses like a young teenage girl, although she has been seen walking around in a towel after a shower
    • Bubbles was visibly uncomfortable about being seen without her armour at first (her unitard appeared to be regarded as underwear)
    • May, aggressive and abrasive as she is, has never been seen undressed with humans (apart from the Sven sex scene, where it was appropriate); but she didn’t appear to be concerned about sitting around topless by other AIs during the Robot Fighting / face repair scene
    • Melon first appeared nude from the waist down, and didn’t seem concerned by this, but she is an outlier by any definition
    • Roko felt the need for clothes after getting her new body
    • now the latest un-named robot brought into Union Robotics for repair, needs to take her trousers off, and seems embarrassed by it; Faye escorts the human colleague away.

So, if repairing robots who have these issues is part of their business, why don’t Union Robotics appear to have any sort of screens, and don’t appear to regard them as required?

     Hypocrisy between Tai and Faye 
  • Story-wise, why was Faye fired after one time of being drunk at work, while Tai had gotten high at her job multiple times before with no issue? It seems unfair for one to get away with it, and not the other. Imagine Dora coming home to tell Tai about firing Faye for drinking, and Tai meanwhile is talking about how Marten and Hanners looked like dragons because she was high on acid all day.
    • Possibly because drunk Faye could do a lot more damage (to the customer's, the equipment and the shop's reputation) than Tai being spaced out in a library.
    • Different employers, different rules. Dora had clearly communicated to her employees that drinking on the job was not permitted. Tai's bosses may not care as long as work gets done and she doesn't do any harm.


Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report