Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / QuestionableContent

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tai drops a little LSD, smokes some weed, at best someone used to these, like Tai, can remain relatively functional, and she was around a bunch of books most of the day, Faye was an alcholic, in a shop full of things that spray hot liquids, Dora would have been liable for any injuries Faye caused to herself or others being CoDs owner, she isn't liable if Tai knocks a book off the shelf onto someones head.
** In addition, Tai has always been shown to do a good job, so she probably gets some leeway. Faye, on the other hand, spent her entire time in CoD being a bitch to the costumers and to her colleagues. Showing up drunk at work was the last straw.

to:

** Tai drops a little LSD, smokes some weed, at best someone used to these, like Tai, can remain relatively functional, and she was around a bunch of books most of the day, Faye was an alcholic, in a shop full of things that spray hot liquids, Dora would have been liable for any injuries Faye caused to herself or others being CoDs [=CoDs=] owner, she isn't liable if Tai knocks a book off the shelf onto someones head.
** In addition, Tai has always been shown to do a good job, so she probably gets some leeway. Faye, on the other hand, spent her entire time in CoD [=CoD=] being a bitch to the costumers and to her colleagues. Showing up drunk at work was the last straw.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Considering [[AIIsACrapshoot how scatterbrained some of the AIs we've seen are]], do you really think an [=AI=] stove is a good idea?

to:

*** Considering [[AIIsACrapshoot how scatterbrained some of the AIs we've seen are]], do you really think an [=AI=] stove is a [[IncendiaryExponent good idea?
idea]]?

Added: 642

Changed: 137

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Considering [[AIIsACrapshoot how scatterbrained some of the AIs we've seen are]], do you really think an [=AI=] stove is a good idea?


Added DiffLines:

* An [=AI=] can be programmed to be a perfect marksman, and can be constructed to be as physcially able as (or even moreso than) the most athletic and strongest possible human at peak health, and can have instant access to the entirety of human knowledge about strategy and tactics with perfect recall and to be able to apply it faster than any human could, and if equipped with armour like Bubbles' they are also about as durable as a tank. Knowing that, might not it be reasonable to assume that [=AIs=] were banned from military service along the same lines as to why [[FantasticNuke nuclear]] [[OneManArmy weapons]] are banned in warfare?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just complaining about pronouns; not a headscratcher.


[[folder:Tilly-Taffy’s pronouns]]

* the SJW on the Forum are going crazy about Tilly/Taffy's use of pronouns. T/T, for reasons best known to that character, favours “they/their” which most people understand as a plural form. This doesn’t seem relevant in any way to the character’s narrative role, so far. Why doesn’t the character simply use “one”, which is a common usage in British English for non-gender-specific cases (“what might one do?”, for example).... seems to be another case of the PanderingToTheBase which has become increasingly common...
** The use of "they" as singular is increasing in popularity. (In part because [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they#Older_usage it was accepted usage until relatively recently]].) As to significance to the character's narrative role...yeah, it's non-existent, but that may have been the point. You don't always have to make a big deal out of non-binary characters, you know?
** To be fair, the people on the forum who went nuts on this are probably the same people who were constantly asking if Claire still had a penis or not.
** The word "one" would be a worse choice, actually. Sure, "one" is common in non-gender specific cases, but never when you're talking about a ''specific person''. It always refers to people in general. Like if you ask "How often should one shower?" then you're asking how often people in general should take showers. "They," on the other hand, always refers to specific people, like "he" and "she" does. The only difference is that it's usually plural, and even that's not always the case--the singular "they" has historical precedent, and is very commonly accepted these days.

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* what does a Synthetic weigh? Seems to vary as the plot requires, although generally more than a comparable human

to:

* what What does a Synthetic weigh? Seems to vary as the plot requires, although generally more than a comparable human



*** As a police unit Roko might be made sturdier in order to help with crime, alternatively Milleflue might just be lighter and be designed more for a chassis then purpose.


to:

*** As a police unit Roko might be made sturdier in order to help with crime, alternatively Milleflue Millefeuille might just be lighter and be designed more for a chassis then purpose.

purpose.
**** Confirmed when she has to go to Union Robotics after getting kicked by an emu. There is a specific comment about how composite bones are lighter, at the cost of being more fragile. So, yes, Millefeuille has a lighter chassis (or at least a lighter skeletal structure).

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This is so: however, if May is to become a useful member of society again, she should be entitled to a body that actually enables her to be one. The fact that the law is fine with her having such a useless body that she's condemned to a soul-crushing dead-end job, means that she can never improve her situation. It is excessively vindictive to insist that punishment must continue indefinitely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Presumably it does, but there are complications: Yay's speech bubbles are the same shape as those of humans, so Yay must not sound like other [=AIs=], and whereas almost all the characters have the same font, Bubbles has a subtly different one from everyone else, so presumably Bubbles doesn't sound like other [=AIs=] either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Are the unique names part of the AlternateUniverse thing? The names of characters are far from common: Hannelore, Sven, Marigold, Angus, Penelope, Wil (with one L)...we might even be able to count Dora, since that's antiquated enough. Marten and Faye are the closest to "normal" names out of the main characters, as is Steve, although his appearances are not nearly as frequent as they used to be. What are the chances that so many uniquely-named people would cross paths and become a cohort of friends in our universe?

to:

* Are the unique names part of the AlternateUniverse thing? The names of characters are far from common: Hannelore, Sven, Marigold, Angus, Penelope, Wil (with one L)... we might even be able to count Dora, since that's antiquated enough. Marten and Faye are the closest to "normal" names out of the main characters, as is Steve, although his appearances are not nearly as frequent as they used to be. What are the chances that so many uniquely-named people would cross paths and become a cohort of friends in our universe?



* This may be jossed: As well as Claire, the intern in the library, there's also [[http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=1716 Claire the witch here.]]
* Unusual names are possibly just AuthorAppeal since Jeph Jacques himself has a pretty unique name.


to:

* ** This may be jossed: As well as Claire, the intern in the library, there's also [[http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=1716 Claire the witch here.]]
* ** Unusual names are possibly just AuthorAppeal since Jeph Jacques himself has a pretty unique name.

name.
** Sven is a normal name in Sweden, Angus is normal in Scotland, Penelope is a fairly common name too... This headscratcher honestly seems more like confirmation bias. I get that "unique" isn't meant to be taken completely literally in the question, but still, these are fairly common names. It'd be different if they had literally unique names like Svenkel, Klarto or Skrunk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n***As a police unit Roko might be made sturdier in order to help with crime, alternatively Milleflue might just be lighter and be designed more for a chassis then purpose.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* the SJW on the Forum are going crazy about Tilly/Taffy’s use of pronouns. T/T, for reasons best known to that character, favours “they/their” which most people understand as a plural form. This doesn’t seem relevant in any way to the character’s narrative role, so far. Why doesn’t the character simply use “one”, which is a common usage in British English for non-gender-specific cases (“what might one do?”, for example).... seems to be another case of the PanderingToTheBase which has become increasingly common...

to:

* the SJW on the Forum are going crazy about Tilly/Taffy’s Tilly/Taffy's use of pronouns. T/T, for reasons best known to that character, favours “they/their” which most people understand as a plural form. This doesn’t seem relevant in any way to the character’s narrative role, so far. Why doesn’t the character simply use “one”, which is a common usage in British English for non-gender-specific cases (“what might one do?”, for example).... seems to be another case of the PanderingToTheBase which has become increasingly common...



*** To be fair, the people on the forum who went nuts on this are probably the same people who were constantly asking if Claire still had a penis or not.

to:

*** ** To be fair, the people on the forum who went nuts on this are probably the same people who were constantly asking if Claire still had a penis or not.
** The word "one" would be a worse choice, actually. Sure, "one" is common in non-gender specific cases, but never when you're talking about a ''specific person''. It always refers to people in general. Like if you ask "How often should one shower?" then you're asking how often people in general should take showers. "They," on the other hand, always refers to specific people, like "he" and "she" does. The only difference is that it's usually plural, and even that's not always the case--the singular "they" has historical precedent, and is very commonly accepted these days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The insurance in question is probably similar to personal liability insurance in that it pays for damages the policy holder is legally liable for. For most people in real life it's rolled into renters or homeowners insurance so there's a good chance that AIs use a similar system although thye may take it out seperately. The main difference is that since AIs have a much broader range of capabilities than humans do they would have more variation in risk based on how much strength their chassis has which would be reflected in the premiums. Crushbot is noted as having a very robust insurance policy due to the fact that Crushbot's name and job description are both Crushbot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Jossed. Prior to going to jail May didn't have a chassis at all since she was a software-only AI. After leaving jail she was provided with her crappy body through an underfunded government program.

Added: 249

Changed: 333

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Banned]]

to:

[[folder:Banned]]
[[folder:[=AI=] Military Ban]]



** In addition, while in theory [=AIs=] were serving voluntarily, as we see from Roko's experience [=AIs=] can be limited in their actions and many [=AIs=] like May have [[https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4009 propriety chargers]] both of which would make resigning difficult. In addition, there was a clear indication that [=AIs=] were drafted with little or no other life experience, making them in many ways {{Child Soldiers}}

to:

** In addition, while in theory [=AIs=] were serving voluntarily, as we see from [[https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4175 Roko's experience experience]] [=AIs=] can be limited in their actions and many [=AIs=] like May have [[https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4009 propriety chargers]] both of which would make resigning leaving the miltary difficult. In addition, there was a clear indication that [=AIs=] were drafted with little or no other life experience, making them in many ways {{Child Soldiers}}Soldiers}}. In addition, Bubble was part of an early trial program, which from her own admission did not go well. It seems like the intent was to test [=AIs=] in the military, and when the program failed a ban was put into place for the time being.


Added DiffLines:

*** Jossed by May who [[spoiler: stole money to save up and become a fighter jet]], and May's later experiences; [=AIs=] are generally giving a body fitting their first job, and have to make money themselves if they want to change or upgrade bodies.

Added: 540

Changed: 881

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** there is no mention anywhere, of AIs paying for work-related bodies. One of the AIs was an ATM, one was a forklift truck, I doubt they paid for those bodies. Bubbles has never mentioned paying for HER body, and Pintsize’s “military chassis” appears to have been “surplus”. We don’t know anything about the status of the shop AIs at Idoru; Iris knows about the cost/benefit structure, but that’s part of her job. I don’t doubt that an AI COULD, if they saw fit, buy a body for the purpose of some business venture, but that’s nothing new.

to:

** In addition, while in theory [=AIs=] were serving voluntarily, as we see from Roko's experience [=AIs=] can be limited in their actions and many [=AIs=] like May have [[https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4009 propriety chargers]] both of which would make resigning difficult. In addition, there was a clear indication that [=AIs=] were drafted with little or no other life experience, making them in many ways {{Child Soldiers}}
** There
is no mention anywhere, of AIs paying for work-related bodies. One of the AIs was an ATM, one was a forklift truck, I doubt they paid for those bodies. Bubbles has never mentioned paying for HER body, and Pintsize’s “military chassis” appears to have been “surplus”. We don’t know anything about the status of the shop AIs at Idoru; Iris knows about the cost/benefit structure, but that’s part of her job. I don’t doubt that an AI COULD, if they saw fit, buy a body for the purpose of some business venture, but that’s nothing new.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Hannelor's dad and his AI]

to:

[[folder:Hannelor's dad and his AI]
AI]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* Claire seems to exist in a strange quantum state, in which even the embodiment of TheLadette that is Faye, who has no compunction bringing up disgusting (if completely normal) bodily functions, won't bring up anything around Claire, that could have revealed her status.

to:

* ** Claire seems to exist in a strange quantum state, in which even the embodiment of TheLadette that is Faye, who has no compunction bringing up disgusting (if completely normal) bodily functions, won't bring up anything around Claire, that could have revealed her status.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Claire seems to exist in a strange quantum state, in which even the embodiment of TheLadette that is Faye, who has no compunction bringing up disgusting (if completely normal) bodily functions, won't bring up anything around Claire, that could have revealed her status.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wait...Faye and Claire have lived under the same roof for how long now? And yet [[http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4167 Faye is just now learning that Claire is trans]]? Seriously, young women of that age don't share living space for long before the topic of menses comes up. Hard for me to believe that Faye would take that long to learn that Claire doesn't have periods.

to:

* Wait...Faye and Claire have lived under the same roof for how long now? And yet [[http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4167 php?comic=4187 Faye is just now learning that Claire is trans]]? Seriously, young women of that age don't share living space for long before the topic of menses comes up. Hard for me to believe that Faye would take that long to learn that Claire doesn't have periods.

Added: 429

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Hannelor's dad and his AI]]

to:

[[folder:Hannelor's dad and his AI]]
AI]


Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Faye and Claire]]

* Wait...Faye and Claire have lived under the same roof for how long now? And yet [[http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4167 Faye is just now learning that Claire is trans]]? Seriously, young women of that age don't share living space for long before the topic of menses comes up. Hard for me to believe that Faye would take that long to learn that Claire doesn't have periods.

[[/folder]]

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** May now has a new chassis, quite high-spec at that, bought out of what amounts to a whip-round and a kickstarter within a matter of days. Make what you will of that.


Added DiffLines:

** Bubbles’ armour probably qualified as “surplus”, it’s not as though any human soldier could use it.


Added DiffLines:

** now we are shown BodyHub, which seems a much more up-market, commercial operation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AIs seem slightly clueless about the whole issue, at times. Millefeuille turned up for gluteal implementation, without apparently providing herself with trousers that would fit post-op, and Bubbles didn’t advise her of the requirement. Roko’s new body didn’t appear to automatically include clothing other than generic, minimum underwear(and she was asked if she required clothing, implying that at least SOME customers either saw that as sufficient, or made their own arrangements. Now May is shown with the same generic, minimum underwear and is walking about with her old clothes ripped up to sort-of fit her new body; you’d think Roko would know better, and Beeps just seems clueless all round.

to:

* AIs seem slightly clueless about the whole issue, at times. Millefeuille turned up for gluteal implementation, without apparently providing herself with trousers that would fit post-op, and Bubbles didn’t advise her of the requirement. Roko’s new body didn’t appear to automatically include clothing other than generic, minimum underwear(and she was asked if she required clothing, implying that at least SOME customers either saw that as sufficient, or made their own arrangements.arrangements). Now May is shown with the same generic, minimum underwear and is walking about with her old clothes ripped up to sort-of fit her new body; you’d think Roko would know better, and Beeps just seems clueless all round.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AIs seem slightly clueless about the whole issue, at times. Millefeuille turned up for gluteal implementation, without apparently providing herself with trousers that would fit post-op, and Bubbles didn’t advise her of the requirement. Roko’s new body didn’t appear to automatically include clothing other than generic, minimum underwear(and she was asked if she required clothing, implying that at least SOME customers either saw that as sufficient, or made their own arrangements. Now May is shown with the same generic, minimum underwear and is walking about with her old clothes ripped up to sort-of fit her new body; you’d think Roko would know better, and Beeps just seems clueless all round.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She's likely an Arab Christian (though I don't see her as very devout), of which there are many in Lebanon – like porn star Mia Khalifa, incidentally. As to her given name, maybe she was named after someone important to her parents; maybe they really like Django? Brun is ethnically Lebanese, and I don't see her contradicting that, but she doesn't see it as "exotic".

Added: 526

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Bubbles appears to inhabit a military-surplus chassis which she has retained, presumably as some sort of GI Benefit. However Corpse Witch implies, and Bubbles appears to believe her, that the government could reclaim it at will. Droid-06 and Deathbot9000 could be similar cases

to:

* Bubbles appears to inhabit a military-surplus chassis which she has retained, presumably as some sort of GI Benefit. However Corpse Witch implies, and Bubbles appears to believe her, that the government could reclaim it at will. Droid-06 and Deathbot9000 could be similar casescases.
** That is heavily implied to be a controlling lie Corpse Witch used on Bubbles to keep control, as shown with Pintsize, he got a military hardware chassis, and after the laser was removed he was allowed to keep it, Bubbles may have went through the same thing, most of her military functions may have been removed, she is probably allowed to keep her armor for the same reason most retired vets were allowed to keep their uniforms, because that is what she is, a vet, Corpse Witch was, unsurprisingly, talking out of her ass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** A.I bodies seem to be more solid than human ones, our bodies aren't exactly light, but we are not that much denser than water, which is why we float, A.I bodies seem to be made up of carbon fibre "bones" and polymer muscles, with no organs save their HDD brain and Battery heart, let's put it this way you take a lump of meat with bone in it and a lump of plastic with a carbon metal rod in it, the lump of meat will float, the lump of plastic will sink even if they are the same weight generally, so Momo probably weights a little more than the average teen girl, but is dense enough that she sinks.

Top