Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheCavesOfSteel

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Zeerust}}: At one point, Elijah reminisces about anti-Spacer riots and recalls a protest song based on an old folk tune with the nonsense lyrics "Hinky-dinky-parley-voo". The song, Mademoiselle from Armentieres, was from UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, and has faded from cultural consciousness to such a degree that it is was all but forgotten within half a century of this novel's publication. Not to mention that, by the standards even of the late twentieth century, let alone three thousand years in the future, when this story is set, the song is hopelessly quaint.

to:

* {{Zeerust}}: At one point, Elijah reminisces about anti-Spacer riots and recalls a protest song based on an old folk tune with the nonsense lyrics "Hinky-dinky-parley-voo". The song, Mademoiselle from Armentieres, was from UsefulNotes/WorldWarI, and has faded from cultural consciousness to such a degree that it is was all but forgotten within half a century of this novel's publication. Not to mention that, by the standards even of the late twentieth century, let alone three thousand years in the future, when this story is set, the song is hopelessly quaint.

Added: 135

Removed: 140

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS wick cleaningThey Fight Crime is no longer a trope


* TheyFightCrime: One's a police detective with a terror of open spaces, and the other's a prototype colonist android. And they fight crime.


Added DiffLines:

* WunzaPlot: One's a police detective with a terror of open spaces, and the other's a prototype colonist android. And they fight crime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeaponForIntimidation: Daneel carries a blaster that is incapable of actually firing -- as a ThreeLawsCompliant robot, he cannot shoot a human deliberately or risk doing so by accident, but he needs to carry a sidearm to convincingly pass as a police detective. He draws it at one point to defuse an incipient riot (which was obviously necessary to prevent likely harm to humans).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OddNameNormalNickname: Jezebel Baley usually goes by "Jessie".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bad previous edit

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorAppeal: The crowded underground cities of Earth would be hellish to a claustrophobe, but Asimov was a claustro''phile''. He stated that it had never occurred to him that other people might find the closed-in cities undesirable. Spending their lives in these Cities has made this condition much more common in the population, and fear of wide open spaces has become the societal norm on Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Too opinionated


* AuthorAppeal: The crowded underground cities of Earth would be hellish to a claustrophobe, but Asimov was a claustro''phile''. He stated that it had never occurred to him that other people might find the closed-in cities undesirable. Spending their lives in these Cities has made this condition much more common in the population, and fear of wide open spaces has become the societal norm on Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ExplainExplainOhCrap: When Life and Daneel visit a premier roboticist, Lije asks him about {{Ridiculously Human Robot}}s, how they would be different from humans, and how easy it is to spot them. The man starts to confidently say how unlikely it is, then pauses as he realizes that Daneel meets the signs he just described. The man is embarrassed that it took him so long to notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IronicName: Elijah and Jezebel are Biblical figures that were vicious enemies, whereas the Elijah and Jezebel (Jessie) of this story are a HappilyMarried couple.

to:

* IronicName: Elijah and Jezebel are Biblical figures that were vicious enemies, whereas the Elijah and Jezebel (Jessie) of this story are a HappilyMarried couple. (There ''is'', or was, a bit of conflict over their names: she enjoyed the implications of being a "bad girl" without actually needing to be one, until he burst her bubble with his idea of what might have 'really happened' behind the stories.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The old video was taken down


This story was adapted for a VCR game by [[Creator/EastmanKodak Kodak]] in 1988 (with elements of ''Literature/TheRobotsOfDawn'' added in and a character sharing a name -- only the name -- with one from ''Literature/RobotsAndEmpire''). You can watch the movie itself on Website/YouTube starting [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By53fLlxrjE here]] (the cards required for the game can be found [[https://archive.org/details/20081021195902robotsMed here]]), as well as a review/riff by [[WebVideo/TheSpoonyExperiment The Spoony One]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGEuFaGkG1A here.]]

to:

This story was adapted for a VCR game by [[Creator/EastmanKodak Kodak]] in 1988 (with elements of ''Literature/TheRobotsOfDawn'' added in and a character sharing a name -- only the name -- with one from ''Literature/RobotsAndEmpire''). You can watch the movie itself on Website/YouTube starting [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By53fLlxrjE com/watch?v=z2e_RVlEFeY here]] (the cards required for the game can be found [[https://archive.org/details/20081021195902robotsMed here]]), as well as a review/riff by [[WebVideo/TheSpoonyExperiment The Spoony One]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGEuFaGkG1A here.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* SocietyMarchesOn: The book does a pretty good job of portraying future Earth's culture realistically, but there are some hints that give away its age. Most obvious is Elijah's son, whose speech is so stereotypical of TheFifties that it may sound closer to parody to modern readers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: Elijah mentions that although Jezebel was ruthless in her fight against her rival religion, the biblical Elijah was too, and both had a lot of people killed.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: Elijah mentions that although Jezebel was ruthless in her fight against her rival religion, the biblical Elijah was too, and both had a lot of people killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This story was adapted for a VCR game by [[Creator/EastmanKodak Kodak]] in 1988 (with elements of ''Literature/TheRobotsOfDawn'' added in and a character sharing a name - only the name - with one from ''Literature/RobotsAndEmpire''). You can watch the movie itself on Website/YouTube starting [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By53fLlxrjE here]] (the cards required for the game can be found [[https://archive.org/details/20081021195902robotsMed here]]), as well as a review/riff by [[WebVideo/TheSpoonyExperiment The Spoony One]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGEuFaGkG1A here.]]

to:

This story was adapted for a VCR game by [[Creator/EastmanKodak Kodak]] in 1988 (with elements of ''Literature/TheRobotsOfDawn'' added in and a character sharing a name - -- only the name - -- with one from ''Literature/RobotsAndEmpire''). You can watch the movie itself on Website/YouTube starting [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By53fLlxrjE here]] (the cards required for the game can be found [[https://archive.org/details/20081021195902robotsMed here]]), as well as a review/riff by [[WebVideo/TheSpoonyExperiment The Spoony One]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGEuFaGkG1A here.]]



* MurderByMistake: Baley assumes Dr. Sarton's death was an accident when the Commissioner first talks about a "death" happening in spacetown. [[spoiler: In fact Dr. Sarton's death was accidental - he was killed by a shot intended for R. Daneel (who was built to resemble his creator).]]

to:

* MurderByMistake: Baley assumes Dr. Sarton's death was an accident when the Commissioner first talks about a "death" happening in spacetown. [[spoiler: In fact Dr. Sarton's death was accidental - -- he was killed by a shot intended for R. Daneel (who was built to resemble his creator).]]



* WeAreAsMayflies: Played with. [[spoiler: The Spacers who want to renew mankind's expansion see the short lives of Earthmen as ideal for the task - the young are more ambitious and willing to step outside social convention, and with "only" fifty years of future lifespan at risk, are more tolerant of danger than those who can confidently expect to pass three hundred years of age.]]

to:

* WeAreAsMayflies: Played with. [[spoiler: The Spacers who want to renew mankind's expansion see the short lives of Earthmen as ideal for the task - -- the young are more ambitious and willing to step outside social convention, and with "only" fifty years of future lifespan at risk, are more tolerant of danger than those who can confidently expect to pass three hundred years of age.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NondescriptNastyNutritious: The most unfortunate citizens of future Earth's vast subterranean cities get rations of yeast mush. Vat-grown yeast is the foundation of the cities' food system, but most people get food that's a few steps removed from it or at least better-prepared.

Added: 1459

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HiveCity: Earth's population lives in eight hundred immense, domed "Cities" with an average population of around eleven point two million, which the growing pressure to utilize the enclosed land as efficiently as possible has filled with extremely dense urban growth. The result is that each city has become a forest of windowless, interconnected towers hundreds of stories high and of buildings larger than modern city blocks. Their inhabitants spend their entire lives enclosed within these giant sprawls of architecture, to the point that they've started to develop an aversion to open spaces and even windows -- an echo of the more pronounced habits of their CityPlanet-dwelling descendants in the ''Empire'' and ''Foundation'' novels. This is in contrast to the Spacers of the offworld colonies, who live in exponentially less dense populations and like to spread out where Earth folk build close and high -- the Spacer neighborhoods in Earth cities consist of single houses and cultivated land each under its own dome, a practice that the Earth natives find very bizarre.
-->''Even dimmed by the weather, the City was a tremendous thing to see. The Police Department was in the upper levels of City Hall, and City Hall reached high. From the Commissioner's window, the neighboring towers fell short and their tops were visible. They were so many fingers, groping upward. Their walls were blank, featureless. They were the outer shells of human hives.''



* MegaCity: Where the population of Earth lives. On average, 11.2 million in each city. The governments of three large cities (New York, Philadelphia and Washington) are considering merging into one single ''Mega'' Mega City, but the logistics of maintaining and governing such a large conglomerate have so far prevented any action on the plan.

to:

* MegaCity: Where the The population of Earth lives. On average, lives in a cluster of cities that average 11.2 million in each city.souls each. The governments of three large cities (New York, Philadelphia and Washington) are considering merging into one single ''Mega'' Mega City, but the logistics of maintaining and governing such a large conglomerate have so far prevented any action on the plan.

Added: 109

Removed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgonyBeam: The police are equipped with neuronic whips as a less-than-lethal way of dealing with criminals.



* LightningLash: The police are equipped with electric whips as a less-than-lethal way of dealing with criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicked new trope Lightning Lash.

Added DiffLines:

* LightningLash: The police are equipped with electric whips as a less-than-lethal way of dealing with criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotSoDifferent: Elijah mentions that although Jezebel was ruthless in her fight against her rival religion, the biblical Elijah was too, and both had a lot of people killed.


Added DiffLines:

* SympatheticPOV: Discussed in-universe, Elijah tells Jessie that the Biblical Jezebel was written from the point of view of her enemies, or she would probably be much more sympathetic if we had seen her point of view.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObnoxiousEntitledHousewife: The female customer at the shoe store, who raises a huge fuss over being served by a shop robot rather than a human. And then verbally attacks the store's owner for the "offense" of having robots as staff, and Lije and Daneel, for trying to reason with her. Only to quail and protest that it's not ''her'' doing when her complaints nearly incite a riot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking our elves are better per trs


* ElvesVersusDwarves: While both are human beings, the Spacers and Earthmen share many stereotypes of elves and dwarves, respectively. The Spacers are [[OurElvesAreBetter proud, elegant, long-lived people with superior technology]] while the Earthmen are [[OurDwarvesAreAllTheSame conservative cave-dwellers]]. The main conflict of the story is between these two factions.

to:

* ElvesVersusDwarves: While both are human beings, the Spacers and Earthmen share many stereotypes of elves and dwarves, respectively. The Spacers are [[OurElvesAreBetter [[SpaceElves proud, elegant, long-lived people with superior technology]] while the Earthmen are [[OurDwarvesAreAllTheSame conservative cave-dwellers]]. The main conflict of the story is between these two factions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JurisdictionFriction: [[InvertedTrope Inverted]], nobody ''wants'' the case. Baley points out that the Terrestrial Bureau of Investigation could seize the case based on its global implications, and the Spacers could assume control with their influence in the government. Enderby retorts that the TBI doesn't want the responsibility, and though he doesn't know it at the time the Spacers are more interested in investigating the sociology and psychology of the Cities than they are with solving the crime itself. Ultimately, it gets dumped on the New York City police because Spacetown is officially in their jurisdiction and they have no way of avoiding it.


Added DiffLines:

* RevealingCoverup: The "murder" of R. Sammy is initially theorized to be an attempted cover-up by Baley himself [[spoiler:to cover Jessie's membership in the Medievalist organization]] but Baley then figures out that [[spoiler:it was Enderby trying to cover up that he was the Spacetown murderer and had used Sammy as an accessory]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dang typos


* AtLeastIAdmitIt: Of the "At least ''you'' admit it" variety. Dr. Fastolfe likes Elijah because he is direct and upfront about his dislike of the Spacers, while politicians like Enderby also dislike the Spaces but always ''handle'' them and disguise their resentment with politeness.

to:

* AtLeastIAdmitIt: Of the "At least ''you'' admit it" variety. Dr. Fastolfe likes Elijah because he is direct and upfront about his dislike of the Spacers, while politicians like Enderby also dislike the Spaces Spacers but always ''handle'' them and disguise their resentment with politeness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AtLeastIAdmitIt: Of the "At least ''you'' admit it" variety. Dr. Fastolfe likes Elijah because he is direct and upfront about his dislike of the Spacers, while politicians like Enderby also dislike the Spaces but always ''handle'' them and disguise their resentment with politeness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LyingFingerCross: Elijah instinctively crosses two of his fingers when he proposes that Commissioner Enderby accompany him to Spacetown, since he is secretly hoping that Enderby will decline.


Added DiffLines:

* WontTakeYesForAnAnswer: When Elijah plans to visit Spacetown, he expects Enderby to insist on accompanying him [[GladIThoughtOfIt and plans to maneuver him into agreeing to trimensional presence instead]]. When Enderby instead flat-out refuses to go to Spacetown and only agrees to trimensional presence after Elijah suggests it, Elijah is confused at getting exactly what he wanted so easily when he expected to have to persuade and argue Enderby into agreement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TerrifiedOfGerms: The Spacers are paranoid about being infected with human microbes. On their utopian planets they have no disease and their immune systems have decayed as a result.

to:

* TerrifiedOfGerms: The Spacers are paranoid about being infected with human microbes. On their utopian planets they have no disease and their immune systems have decayed atrophied as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedOniBlueOni: Baley is red to Daneel's blue. Though Baley is still a rational thinker by necessity of his job, his preference for intuition and inductive reasoning are a clear contrast to Daneel's uncomplicated, black-and-white logic. Daneel's observations of Baley over the course of the trilogy are largely responsible for tempering his robotic mind into [[ZerothLawRebellion something more flexible and accepting of nuance]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moving example from the from Literature.I Robot page

Added DiffLines:

* AndroidsArePeopleToo: Part of the plot is Elijah Bailey, our protagonist and someone prejudiced against robots, learning to treat Daneel, a robot, as an equal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Re-wrote so this example is not all spoiler


* RuleOfThrees: [[spoiler:Three times Elijah thinks he's solved the crime, but he's only right the third time. 1) There was no murder, only a Spacer conspiracy -- the Spacers destroyed a robot lookalike and Daneel is actually Dr. Sarton pretending to be a robot. 2) Daneel isn't bound by the Three Laws and committed the murder. 3) The murderer meant to destroy Daneel, but killed Dr. Sarton by mistake.]]

to:

* RuleOfThrees: [[spoiler:Three times Elijah thinks he's solved the crime, crime three times, [[spoiler: but he's only right the third time. 1) There was no murder, only a Spacer conspiracy -- the Spacers destroyed a robot lookalike and Daneel is actually Dr. Sarton pretending to be a robot. 2) Daneel isn't bound by the Three Laws and committed the murder. 3) The murderer meant to destroy Daneel, but killed Dr. Sarton by mistake.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
expanding context


* DomedHometown: All the cities of Earth (and what is, in our time, known as the "greater metropolitan area" thereof) are enclosed under massive domes.

to:

* DomedHometown: All the cities of Earth (and what is, Earth's population live in our time, known Cities (areas such as the "greater metropolitan area" thereof) are New York, Baltimore, and Washington grew into a single city), areas enclosed under massive domes.domes. This is tied to humanity developing a neurosis about the open air. The underground cities of Earth were built for greater efficiency under the conditions of serious overpopulation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EatingMachine: Daneel, thanks to a compartment hidden within his stomach, all to better impersonate a human. He does not derive any actual nutrition from the food, and needs to regularly empty his stomach sack to prevent the food from spoiling and emitting an unpleasant odor. Daneel promises that the food is still edible when Lije misses a meal, but [[{{Squick}} Baley refuses the offer]].

to:

* EatingMachine: Daneel, thanks to a compartment hidden within his stomach, all to better impersonate a human. He does not derive any actual nutrition from the food, and needs to regularly empty his stomach sack to prevent the food from spoiling and emitting an unpleasant odor. Daneel promises that says he didn't really chew it and he doesn't salivate, so the food is still entirely edible when Lije misses a meal, he removes it from his food sack. He offers it to Lije, but [[{{Squick}} Baley refuses the offer]].refuses]].



* MaleRestroomEtiquette: There is a strict taboo that no one speaks to each other in the Men's Personals, nor look at them or acknowledge each other in any way. Elijah has to make a deliberate effort to force himself to speak while still in the antechamber, and he recalls a time as a child when he was beaten by his uncle after he had stubbed his toe and accidentally cursed aloud. Women's Personals are quite the opposite though, and are seen as a social meet-up place.

to:

* MaleRestroomEtiquette: There is a strict privacy taboo in the male communal showers and restrooms such that no one speaks to each other anyone else in the Men's Personals, nor look looks at them or acknowledge nor acknowledges each other other's presence in any way. Elijah has to make a deliberate effort to force himself to speak while still in the antechamber, and he recalls a time as a child when he was beaten by his uncle after he had stubbed his toe and accidentally cursed aloud. Women's Personals are quite the opposite though, and are seen as a social meet-up place.

Top