YMMV / Eddsworld

  • Broken Base: Was it a good idea to make Tord a villain or should he go back to being one of the (anti) heroes?
  • Cargo Ship: Sometimes joked about throughout the show.
  • Creator Backlash: Pearl "Prikle" Zhang wants to forget she animated Tom's Tales of Crazy.
  • Designated Hero: In Zanta Claws
    Santa: (Giving them presents) You earned these, kids.
    Edd: But we didn't do anything.
    Santa: Ho ho ho. (leaves)
  • Ensemble Darkhorse:
    • The Rule 63!main cast from "Mirror Mirror" have unsurprisingly become this, because who doesn't want cute girl versions of these guys!?
    • TORD. So much so the fandom was shocked when he left and basically drove him into hiding. ....however, his character did return for the Two-Part Grand Finale.
    • The rejected clones from "Spares" (particularly Tomatoredd) have been getting loads and loads of fan art, especially on Tumblr.
  • Fan Dumb: Flame Bait aside, there has been some who really think that Tom and Tord hated each other just because of their treatment of each other in the series, despite accounts that Tom and Tord barely knew each other around the time Tom joined Eddsworld didn't keep contact following Tord's departure. The episode of 'The End" with Tom defeating Tord didn't help matters either.
  • "Funny Aneurysm" Moment / Harsher in Hindsight: By the crapload, because of Edd's death.
    • In WTFuture, Tom says "Without Edd, it'd be just [Matt] and me, and, well, that would suck." Doubly harsh, because Tom had numerous difficulties picking up the show after Edd's death.
    • From the same episode: it turns out the laser Eddsworld!Tom took to the face gave him cancer.
    • The entire episode can be considered one, considering it's about Edd ten years in the future going into the past to kill his past self.
    • The epilogue for This World of Edd narrates Edd going crazy and killing himself (and Dying Alone); darkly-humorous then. Now...
    • Edd Vs. Cancer, a video that dealt with Edd's cancer in a very light-hearted and optimistic way, becomes much harder to watch when you know what ultimately happened. This is made worse when Matt asked Edd what are the survival rates of his cancer, to which Edd says around "70%", which Matt gleefully shouting "You're going to kick its ass!". Considering what happened...
    • At the end of Matt Sucks, Matt says, "Oh well, at least Edd's dead."
    • In Christmas Visitor Edd's visited by Death himself.
    • This sketch on Matt's channel.
    • "Rock Bottom", which was released about a month before Edd died.
    • Would be hilarious if it wasn't for Edd's death, but in one of the Zombeh Attack flashes one zombie is clearly drawn by Paul (visible differences in style). Now he's the lead animator of the show.
    • One that doesn't have to do with Edd's death, surprisingly enough, but this comic can make it a lot harder to watch Movie Makers, and gives Eduardo a bit more sympathy for his hatred of Edd: his girlfriend died making their movie, and her death wasn't even noticed by them.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: A tough, male character in blue without any eyes named.... Tom?
  • Idiot Plot: Coke is outlawed in the future. Edd has a time machine. He decides to go back in time to commit suicide by killing his past self, instead of, y'know, going to the store and getting the drink. No one calls him out on that.
    • Or, if he's so determined to commit Time-Travel Murder, how about killing the people responsible for banning Coke in the first place and preventing the horrible, Coke-Free future?
  • Les Yay: In The Dudette next door, it is revealed that Kim's true love was Katya.
  • Memetic Mutation: Just a Bit Crazy.
    Edd: Yep.
  • Moe:
    • Edd himself and Jon are very cute cartoon boys.
    • Applies to the rest of the cast as well, to a lesser extent.
  • Nightmare Fuel: Several of their videos.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks: Fans were complaining about Space Face's Art Shift in between the two parts (which happened for obvious reasons). Paul explained this on his blog.
  • Unfortunate Implications: In "The End", Tord the character comes back, not voiced by Tord the RL person, as a flat-out villain. In the climax, it's Tom the character that defeats him, in an episode co-written by Tom the person. Eyebrows were raised, and TomSka had to address the complaints.