Discussion NeverLiveItDown / StarWars

The Star Wars Clean-Up project began in early 2020 and was labeled as a short-term project. Furthermore, there hasn't been a proper discussion on the discussion thread since February 2022, and any further comments made since have received no reply. Given these factors I'm assuming the clean-up is done, but if that's the case why are the Star Wars and Star Wars pages still locked? Shouldn't they be unlocked now? Or at least the discussion thread needs more people monitoring it so people can request edits more easily

I've removed this entry for the reasons stated here and here. Putting it here in case more discussion is needed:

• Some people (Tumblr, predominately) aren't so quick to forgive Kallus after his characterization in "The Honorable Ones," never mind accept a possible redemption arc from him, mostly due to practically escorting Tua to her assassination while taunting her back in "The Siege of Lothal" (also not forgetting that he's burnt down Tarkintown, blockaded Ibaar, etc.). Most of the same people also think that the arc should've belonged to Tua or someone else that hasn't been already depicted as villainous as Kallus, although some have pointed out that this trope and arguments will likely be applied and addressed in-universe later on in Kallus's character arc.

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman

Okay the TLJ segment seems to be less "These moments are unfairly exaggerated" and more "Here's a list of minor quibles". In additon I'd like to question why Luke being tempted to kill Ben isn't on the list. The way fans talk about it makes it seem like Ben's recount of the events were true (I.E Luke did it on a whim without remorse)

.

Edited by JoelASalt

Is some one going to make a folder for Solo and the other anthology films as that movie has a lot to live down. (The origins of Han's last name, The Darth Maul twist, L3-37 the fact it was the star wars to be a Box Office Bomb etc.) I don't why anyone hasn't added it yet.

I am one with the force. the force is with me

Would the fandom's hostile reaction towards The Last Jedi count for this as a meta example, or would that be better suited to a different trope or fall under Rule Of Cautious Editing Judgement?

One cleanup thread later... Hide / Show Replies