The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Yeah, I Googled the title and of the links on the first page, at least half were porn sites, so that doesn't bode well for its future.

I actually managed to find some gameplay videos on youtube, that just blur out the porny bits. They go without Fortissimo subtitle, but footage seems to be same.

Soo. There certainly are futa demons, but I'm not actually seeing loli factor on pornhub. The demon in particular is very shaped up.

Okay, more search. Plugging "rondo_duo loli" into chan.sankakucomplex.com booru gives us Snow White, who looks kinda young. Still has some shape to the chest, but yeah, somewhere borderline.

Overall: we got no translation of plot to go on with and judge the full VN, there is pleenty of porn and one questionable character. I'd say that leans over to the nope.

edited 25th Nov '17 12:03:07 PM by Adannor

Should the Sonic fic Prison Island Break have a page? To quote it's summary on FF: " Sonic, Shadow, Silver - and the rest - are in an AU where they are incarcerated in Prison Island Penitentiary. Will they escape? Will they survive? How? 3, Abuse, Anal, AFFO, Anthro, CR, D/s, M/F, M/M, Oral, S&M, SH, Slave, Tort, Violence". From what I've heard, it's essentially just a lemon fic with mild story surrounding it and a lot of rape and violence.

What about School Days? Most characters are high schoolers, but I'm pretty sure one of the games contains Makoto being lewd towards a younger character. Looking over the Character page, Kokoro seems to be the character.

We've discussed School Days and its spinoffs before. The concerning content came from Summer Days, so tropes about it were removed, but I believe School Days and Shiny Days were determined to be fine, especially since JAST released a censored version of Shiny Days.

edited 26th Nov '17 2:40:19 PM by Assassin-sensei

So no to the Rondo Duo thing, I guess. I don’t have a defensive reply.

…which gives me another request: can there be a media page for Liru The Wolf? She isn’t primarily seen in her H-games, since other results still show on safesearch.

edited 26th Nov '17 3:24:03 PM by QuazzleTheQaz

The Characters page for School Days still mentions examples. They should be deleted, right?

We have Magical Pokaan. If you have any other non-porn works starring her, feel free to make the pages for them.

edited 26th Nov '17 10:20:37 PM by Adannor

How do I create a media page?

Dropping the angel head on Squid Ops. It's weird, but not overtly porny.

Not a topic for this forum section, go ask for instructions and all the finicky details in Ask The Tropers.

edited 3rd Dec '17 11:48:34 PM by Adannor

Should Prison Island Break be purged or is it okay?

I'm reading it. So, far, so edgy, or rather wannabe-edgy. The writing is pretty weak, too, but I have yet to get to the really nasty bits. That said... Tails is described on multiple occasions as a "fox cub," which puts his age into question in a way that could very well make this unsuitable under site rules.

EDIT: And given that said character features in two very graphic scenes of sexual violence, the whole "kid" thing definitely pushes it into potential devil-head territory. I wouldn't call the fic as a whole porn, but those scenes are *definitely* written to titillate.

edited 15th Dec '17 3:30:30 PM by JHM

OW THE EDGE

Any case I'm not sure, this just seems to be a really edgy badly written dark fic going by the tropes but it's not straight up porn. I'll say keep unless there's some pedophilia in there.

edited 15th Dec '17 2:41:20 PM by ReynTime250

See my edit above. While it might not be in violation of certain terms, in theory, it may be in violation of others.

So, just wanted to bring it up, but there's been some pages on the list for over a year.

Who among the P5 are still around and haven't voted on some of these?

edited 15th Dec '17 6:56:59 PM by Ramidel

~Adannor, ~Dr Psyche, ~Harmonious Fusion and ~Discar

And of those, I'm not certain we can rely on Harmonious Fusion. ^note No forum posts since April, and very sporadic wiki edits in the meantime, last one in November.

Prison Island Break reads like PWP to me. Despite the Tvtropes page, it just seems like sparse plot around an edgy OOC lemon fic. According to the Tvtropes page, the characters are aged up however skimming through 20~ chapters I couldn't tell. Tails still reads like a kit and the others still seem like teens.

Looking at the Oneiroi Series. It looks fine. There's a plot and much more to it than the sex scenes. The underage stuff and the incest stuff isn't a fetish so much as it's supposed to squick people out.

Taking a look at Dragon City. Nothing on the tropes page indicates porn, and the report reason just lists a bunch of thumbs up.

edited 17th Dec '17 4:15:43 PM by DrPsyche

Thumbs up what, though?

Don't you usually zap a report that has no information?

Some recent reports:

Bountiful Boobs: A ridiculous story about a high school girl with big boobs that her friend can't stop groping, but it has no actual nudity and an actual plot.

Caillou Finds a Dildo: This is bizarre, but we don't cut bizarre. Caillou doesn't actually use the dildo. He finds it, turns it on, and it starts vibrating. It doesn't say that he used it sexually in any matter. Then his dad comes in with a 12-gauge and kills him. I have no idea how this hasn't been reported/removed from FF.net yet.

Pink De Pink: Not actually hentai - it was serialized in the seinen magazine Young Champion Retsu. Most of their series are sexually-focused/push the limits of ecchi, but they've run a few cleaner series such as Bakuon!!. Banned from Batoto due to adult content.

Porno Superstar: Explicit sex in every chapter, though the genitals aren't drawn.

Sensual Trigger: Actually skimmed through this one since it was so short. It has a Skinemax vibe to it, and I can't find any information about it being serialized in a magazine (if it was, it'd probably be josei). Every chapter has at least one sex scene - three out of five of the chapters have multiple - of varying levels of explicitness. There are breasts, buttocks, fluids, and partial views of female genitals, but no explicit penetration.

Where the Dead Go to Die: As I understand, there are some graphic child rape scenes in this, though they are meant to disgust rather than titillate.

It seems that Prison Island Break hasn't actually been flagged yet for us to vote on despite being brought up here. Furthermore, having read even more of it... I'm pretty certain it violates our guidelines, big time. It's basically very dark, violent pornography with at least one character clearly written as a young teenager.

(On a quality level, the fact that it's poorly written and at points really transphobic and, perhaps ironically, homophobic just makes it all the worse, but whether or not the porn in question is *good* doesn't really count here...)

Reported it to be put on the tool.

Can we PM a person who reported the content? I have a question for them.