The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Well, that and works that play to the fetishes in a pornographic way, of course.

Yeah, but because of the pornography part, not because of the fetishes.

Thanks Bara. I see folks here being like 'should I flag this? This feels weird' when the weirdness is just fetishy stuff like crossdressers and furries. Unless the furries are having wall to wall crossdressing sex...

@Pyrite

If I remember correctly May has an active sex life with her boyfriend but it is never shown on page(my experience is with the manga).

Rally is the real fanservice magnet and considering she can pass for old enough(real age 19) to run a gun shop and have a bounty hunting license that puts this into 'is this porn?' territory.

edited 4th Jun '12 8:43:59 PM by Shadis

Gunsmith Cats? Porn?

...You're kidding, right?

edited 4th Jun '12 8:47:32 PM by Raidouthe21st

If you're referring to , he was more saying that it definitely isn't pedophile pandering, not saying that there's any real chance it could be porn.

edited 4th Jun '12 8:49:23 PM by FinalStarman

Final Starman is right I was saying the question to ask is 'is this porn?' anyone who has read it will know the answer to that is no.

You remember correctly on that count, Shadis.

@4373: There's also a couple references on the YMMV page too. Although I'd expect to keep the Memetic Mutation one, since even though the game started it, it's sort of relevant to the franchise as a whole.

Since I can't speak for any of the other members of the panel, all I can say is that I personally did not feel it was porn or pedophile pandering after my review of several chapters, and thus I gave it an angel vote.

Since there has been no real information out there on Kamisama Dolls and no one has voted one way or the other, I thought I would go ahead and take a look at it.

Preliminary Report:

• Unlicensed (manga), available for streaming at Crunchyroll
• ANN lists objectionable content as intense, though based on the genres listed *
  action, comedy, drama, romance, science fiction, supernatural
  it doesn't suggest heavy sexual content
• The Other Wiki lists demographic as seinen, Disclaimer
  English Wikipedia's veracity with regards to demographics has been disputed
  Other Manga in Same Magazine
  Jormungand, Black Lagoon, Binbou Shimai Monogatari, RahXephon

Starting with ep. 3 now.

First update: If the first minute and a half is any indication, the "intense" objectionable content rating is for violence. Dude got stabbed, his buddy got his arm cut off.

Second update: Nothing to report other than the younger sister is a bit of a bro-con, which within itself is not cutworthy.

Third update: Minimal sexual content. Not really any fanservice to speak of so far.

Onward to ep. 8.

Noted. Thanks.

edited 5th Jun '12 9:38:42 AM by tdgoodrich1

If it's on crunchyroll , it's licensed.

The original Kamisama Dolls manga is in Monthly Sunday Gene-X which is definitely Seinen. So yes, Seinen.

Re: Kamisama Dolls ep. 8

Update the first: Beach episode. Difficulty: In the middle of a typhoon. Only brief fanservice from a college-aged girl.

Update the second: Little sister is still a bro-con. Nothing to report.

Onwards to ep. 10.

Update the first: Nothing to report, other than a new character calling out the little sister for being a bro-con.

Update the second: Nothing to report. Verdict to follow.

Figured as much. The Other Wiki said it also ran Black Lagoon. Definitely seinen.

Verdict: Keep

• Definitely not porn
• Not much fanservice based on what I saw
• Younger sister (~12-13) is not sexualized
• Most problematic material was the little sister being a bro-con, which is played more for laughs than anything else

edited 5th Jun '12 10:46:48 AM by tdgoodrich1

Shoot, I accidentally flagged Chocolate Milkmaid, while it's already been resolved. Needs to be zapped from the tool.

Now, Moonlight Lady is porn. At least the anime.

edited 5th Jun '12 12:06:03 PM by lu127

Is Gunsmith Cats even on the voting tool? I'm pretty sure it's not porn or pedoshit, even though I haven't actually read it.

No, Pyrite just brought it up because he had some doubts about it.

Oh, ok. Well, somebody who knows more about it can say if it needs to be flagged or not. I plan on checking it out soon, a friend of mine was recommending it to me. I trust his judgment, even if he does like Love Hina and My Little Horsey: Voice Acting is Sickening.

Anyone played the Moonlight Lady game? Typically, the anime would not be worse than the game, but weirder things have happened, so I want to be sure.

edited 5th Jun '12 12:57:24 PM by Discar

I've never heard of Moonlight Lady, but in my experience, hentai anime adaptations are generally worst than the visual novels they're from since the only reason they make them is because of the porn.

Anime adaptations of V Ns seem like they can have plot or porn but not both.

Yeah pretty much. Anime adaptations of 18+ games are basically always either focus on the plot with no porn, or are hentai that focus on the porn with a bunch of the plot cut out.

AFAIK, it's an eroge with a supernatural horror plot involving Mind Control and a ceremony to awaken/summon some sort of enigmatic abomination from hell... I think.

Re: Moonlight Lady

VNDB Page: http://vndb.org/v240

ANN Page: http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=2709

Hope those help.

The anime is porn. Maybe it has a more coherent plot than most hentai, but it's still porn. It basically boils down to the male lead sleeping with everyone, the maid aggressively sexually harassing her mistress and they are all preparing for an orgy ritual. All of these are shown in graphic detail. Can't speak for the game.

edited 5th Jun '12 12:48:32 PM by lu127