Stephanie has a new boyfriend, a pro ball player. DJ tries to tell Steve that she's dating Matt.
Tropes
- Accidental Kiss : Steve and Matt both try to kiss DJ at the same time.
- Acting Unnatural : Stephanie and Kimmy try to act casual after spying on DJ.
- As Himself: San Francisco Giants right fielder Hunter Pence guest stars as himself, dating Stephanie.
- Big Damn Kiss : Steve and DJ.
- Call-Back : To DJ and Steve's prom.
- Credit Card Plot : Matt gives Jackson his credit card.
- Eating Pet Food: While trying to teach Tommy tricks, Max gives him dog treats.
- Freudian Slip : DJ keeps saying "Steve."
- Heroic BSoD: Caving under the pressure of all the stadium heckling her, Stephanie bombs the song, yells at the public and breaks up with Hunter as security escorted her out of the stadium when she realized what she has done and tried to go back to Hunter.
- Jerkass: The guy who was sitting behind the family. Sure, he didn't have the obligation to give the ball he caught to Max, but he didn't have to be a jerk about it in front of the kid. He also started to heckle Stephanie as soon as he realized she was Hunter's "Jinx".
- The Jinx : Stephanie is accused of being this towards Hunter Pence.
- Love Triangle: DJ, Matt, and Steve.
- Never Tell Me the Odds!: Twice.
- Overcomplicated Menu Order : Lola is high maintenance. She doesn't like the ketchup, relish, and mustard on her hot dog to touch.
- Recycled Plot : Wasn't there an episode of Cheers where Eddie hit a slump because he was dating Carla?
- Rule of Three : The Kiss Cam lands on DJ and Matt three times.
- Shameless Self-Promoter: Kimmy sneaks in a banner in case she appears on the JumboTron.
- Slut-Shaming : DJ worries about kissing two guys on the same day.DJ: Am I a floozy?Stephanie: Anyone who uses the word floozy can not be a floozy.
- Trademark Favorite Food: Hunter's favourite is pizza. He even carries his own pizza fork around his neck.
- Unfortunate Names : Stephanie's boyfriend's name Hunter Pence sounds like "underpants, which is what Kimmy calls him.
