Nightmare Fuel / Batman: Arkham Knight

"Shhhh... it's ok to be afraid."

Arkham Knight isn't just the Grand Finale for the Arkham series, it's the scariest Batman game ever made.

  • Scarecrow is back. This Halloween will certainly not be safe for trick-or-treating...
    • He's got a new look. And you thought he looked creepy before... As a matter of fact: his mere appearance made the trailer he appears in to be considered inappropriate for children. That's how creepy he is. In fact, this might be one of the reasons the game got an "M" rating.
    • Even worse if you consider the first game. The last time we saw him in the game? He was being eaten by Killer Croc. As horrifying as his mask is, whatever's underneath it might be even worse.
      • It's even worse than that. Dialogue between a set of watchtower mooks, as well as other random mook chatter, implies that his mask isn't a mask. It's his face, his real face, which he did to himself.
  • The moment when Scarecrow forces Gordon to unmask Batman. Instead of looking angry, defiant, worried, or any other understandable expression, Bruce's face looks completely blank. As if all the trauma he's endured as both Batman and Bruce Wayne, all the fighting he's done against the endless criminals of Gotham, have left him hollow and shell-shocked, not a trace of the playful playboy billionaire left. In a way, Bruce's real face is more frightening than his Batman mask.
  • Fear Toxin is literal nightmare fuel.
  • At the end of one of the trailers, we have Arkham Knight with Batman on the ground, with a gun to his face, and the screen cuts to black as we hear a gunshot.
  • Imagine being a Gotham cop. No, not in the same vein as Asylum (where you at least had an island to blockade off) or City (where you could just monitor the wall) or even Origins (the department is still in control of the greater Gotham area). Now you're isolated, in a city that's overrun with criminals on what's supposed to be a night of the year made of terror, capped with the most frightening super-criminal of all threatening to make your worst fears real.
    • The one cop in the very beginning of the game probably suffered the worst out of all the cops and firefighters (which is saying something). Before anything bad happens to Gotham, one cop decided to take a break at a diner and have a quick meal. However, before he gets his meal, one random man walks up to him and asks for him to talk to a man in the corner of the restaurant to stop smoking. When the cop goes up to the man, the man turns out to be a Scarecrow thug who sprays Fear Toxin into the cop's face. Hell (literally) breaks loose as the cop starts hallucinating everyone in the diner as walking zombie abominations that try to eat him and each other. The cop then brings out his gun and starts shooting them in panic. Mind you, these are hallucinations, which means that the cop is shooting innocent people who have also breathed in the Fear Toxin! The poor cop doesn't get better until far later on into the game and even then he is obviously traumatized. And this was only the start of the game...
      • You want more? Well, according to the game's files, the guy who sprayed the gas in the cop's face was Jason.
      • YMMV: You don't have to shoot at the hallucinations. The Nightmare fuel here is that you as a player reacted and traumatized the cop all by yourself. It seems Scarecrow is even able to get to you.
  • Look at the second picture in "Story Synopsis".
  • Arkham Knight is this in the most definite manner imaginable. Arkham Knight is supposed to be less known, while on the contrary... He knows more about the Batman than anyone else in Batman's rogue gallery. He's versatile, durable, resourceful, cunning and above all extremely dangerous. He may appear to be the secondary antagonist to Scarecrow. But in all favors he must be much more wily than Scarecrow, The Master of Fear himself. And it's implied that he might have followed Batman since his first early beginnings in Arkham Asylum and the horrific full on destruction in Arkham City. It may explain why he downright mocks Batman both in his armor's appearance and for embroidering the Arkham emblem on himself. The helmet and style of armor shows him destroying Batman's heroism in Gotham and the emblem of the Arkham symbol is a reminder of the two worst nights in Batman's entire crime fighting career which are Arkham Asylum and City. Now the question begs for the previous titles... Who and what is he? Where is he? And finally... What became of him? What drove and caused him to have unfiltered, seething, unbridled, aggressive rage against Batman?
    • We know now. He's Jason Todd. That begs the question: What could possibly possess one of Batman's former allies to side with Scarecrow?!
      Jason: What's the matter? Lost for words? I expected more... I'm hurt.
      Batman: Joker sent me the film... I saw him kill you.
      Jason: Don't you dare lie to me! How long did you wait before replacing me, huh?! A month? A week?! I trusted you...and you just left me to die!
      Batman: That's not what happened!
      Jason: You always told me, Bruce... focus on what I want to achieve... and it'll happen. Well, you want to know what I want now, huh? I want you, dead.
      • During the second hallucinatory flashback to Jason's torture, Joker at first has him strung up by his wrists as he circles him with a branding iron. After some more talking, Joker lets him down. Jason's wrists are free at this point, he could have made an attempt to escape or attack Joker during this moment. Instead, what happens is Jason cowering on the floor pleading whilst desperately trying to crawl away as Joker moves in with the iron. In a way, it's merciful we don't see all of what Joker did to him. To have him that terrified and broken is just chilling.
      • Possibly the worst of all is when we see how Jason appears to die.
    Joker: What's the big secret, huh~? His name. Tell me.
    Jason: ... Of course, sir... It's—
    • Even during his final boss fight you get some disturbing hints of this. In your final battle against Jason, whenever his militia men are unconscious or not present, he'll start taunting and ranting at Batman. A lot of it is the standard "you're going down" trash talk, but there are a few lines he'll deliver that are downright terrifying, one in particular revealing how fractured his mind has become.
    Jason:: I can still hear him laughing. He's still in my head!
    • What's worse is that while the tie-in comics explain that Jason was kidnapped as a part of Joker's plan in Arkham Asylum, and that Harley inadvertently named Jason's alter ego, those comics were made after the game. The original plan by Rocksteady was that Jason searched for Joker to kill him, and was captured. The resulting torture Jason endured? All just to teach Batman a twisted lesson. Think about that: Joker tortured Jason for over a year, ultimately just to kill him (or so he thought), because Joker didn't want to share Batman.
  • Some of the later missions against the Arkham Knight definitely qualify as this before you get the hang. Namely, the Cobra. The Cobra is a huge tank with search beams that can only be destroyed by sneaking up behind it and waiting until the target focuses so you can fire the cannon. One mission has you playing hide and seek with four of these, and if you destroy one then another is inevitably drawn to your location. Worse still, they can take out the Batmobile in TWO SHOTS if they get you directly. This leads to frantically driving away if you get spotted, which can easily bring you into the line of vision of another Cobra tank.
    • The mission to destroy the Cloudburst is even worse. It's hide and seek against seven cobra tanks, and the Cloudburst itself is the worst of all, as it has four weak points you need to sneak up and shoot, and whenever you get one it chases you for longer and longer periods through the city. Then you have to take potshots at the tank itself while dodging missiles, while the Arkham Knight gets increasingly furious over enemy radio transmissions.
      • Getting trapped in the sewers with the Arkham Knight, who is driving a giant drill. You basically have to let him spot you, chase you, and not get caught while you lead him into a trap. And each time you succeed, the area to move in gets smaller and smaller...
  • The fact that, despite the Nightmare Fuel in the previous games, they got a T rating. Knight somehow got an M. All we know is that it has something to do with blood...
    • It may have something to do with the game reenacting The Killing Joke. There's a hallucination where you watch Barbara lying on the ground, bleeding out her back, gasping for breath... it's one of the more disturbing moments of the game, and that's saying something.
    • It was actually because of Jason's torture scenes. While the game was pushing it with its take on The Killing Joke and Professor Pyg, these scenes apparently took the cake and bumped it up to M. That is how disturbing those scenes were.
  • The "Gotham is Mine" trailer has a fair bit of nightmare fuel, given that it focuses on the villains. Of special note is the Riddler's face. Looks like he's gotten worse since the last game.
    • Poison Ivy and Firefly are back as part of the Villain Team-Up too. Similar to Riddler, their physical appearances have taken a turn for the worse as well. Firefly in particular has no helmet, just goggles and a gas mask, with his horrifically burned head on display.
      • Though, one could argue that Poison Ivy's appearance seems less freakish compared to her previous design, as she now looks more human.
  • The opening cinematic, revealed in the E3 2015 trailer, begins with the grinning corpse of the Joker being pushed into a cremation oven; rather than the camera cutting away, as it would've done in previous T-rated games, it instead lingers as the rising flames bloodily melt his skin and muscle into a charred, blackened husk. When it finally ends, we get to control (in first-person view) a police officer being dosed with Fear Gas at Pauli's Diner, and seeing him hallucinate it as a hellish, crumbling place ravaged by cadaverous demons; terrified, he begins pumping rounds into the crowd in a panic, not caring if they might be innocent civilians, until a monster finally lunges straight for him. Definitely a sign that this game will be a significant step up in terms of horror.
    • While the opening cinematic shows the Joker's cremation, the lyrics to Frank Sinatra's "I've Got You Under My Skin" make an eerie foreshadowing of what will happen to Batman with the Joker blood still in him:
    I've got you under my skin.
    I've got you deep in the heart of me.
    So deep in my heart that you're really a part of me.
    I've got you under my skin.

    I'd sacrifice anything, come what might,
    For the sake of havin' you near,
    In spite of a warnin' voice that comes in the night
    And repeats, repeats in my ear:
    Don't you know, little fool, you never can win?
    Use your mentality, wake up to reality.
    But each time that I do just the thought of you
    Makes me stop before I begin,
    'Cause I've got you under my skin.
    Joker: This... is how it happened. This... is how the Joker died.
  • The very beginning of the Joker hallucinations, with Joker seemingly popping out of no where to shoot Batman at point-blank range. The game then goes into a flashback before returning to the present, leaving you to wonder what the hell is happening to Batman.
    • Upon returning to the present it only gets worse as we're treated to a first person shot of Batman coming to in the basement of the collapsing Ace Chemicals plant, greeted by his hallucination of Joker slowly saying Bruce, Bruce. Even though it's only a hallucination, and that the living Joker didn't really care about Batman's secret identity, it's still very unsettling to hear Joker address Batman by his real name, because it's basically saying, "You know that guy who thrived on a toxically intimate Foe Yay relationship with you; he's back, he's inside your head, and he know everything".
  • The quarantined blood transfusion recipients. Not only are they starting to behave and look more and more like the Joker, but they're degenerating from the inside as well — Batman identifies their disorder as a variant of Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease, meaning their brains are literally rotting apart as dementia and psychosis set in.
    • Which makes you wonder... is Batman's brain rotting apart too?
    • It makes you wonder if it was a special interaction between Joker's blood and the TITAN that caused it, or if it was just the TITAN alone in its advanced stage. If it was the TITAN alone causing this, was Joker's brain rotting apart before he died in Batman: Arkham City? And what about the little girl in the A Matter of Family DLC? What about Dr. Young's experimental subjects?
      • Here's something else to consider: what if it's not the TITAN? The mutated Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease these people have came from Joker's blood. What if Joker was already sick, and his chemical bath is what kept him alive?
    • During the flashback introducing the Joker's infected, there's a mild Jump Scare when Batman shows up out of nowhere beside Jim Gordon. Batman's even frightening to his allies.
    • On a related note, the Jokerification of Batman. From Joker's brief hijacking of Bruce's body in the Stagg Airship encounter with Scarecrow, to his increasingly erratic behaviour during and after the Panessa Studios encounter with Harley and Adams, then finally the Joker's takeover hallucination during the endgame, the entire concept is horrifying. Even when in free-roam, Batman hallucinates Joker's face on posters and billboards, and even in carvings in the architecture, and this is not helped by Joker appearing absolutely everywhere, usually with a snide remark and a comment about their shared mental state.
      • Also, Joker's face can appear on the statues in at the cathedral near Wayne tower.
      • Related to the above, after Scarecrow injects Batman with his fear toxin, and Joker finally takes over Bruce's body, he starts cackling about his 'second coming'. While the idea of a second coming of Joker is shown to be pretty damn horrifying, there's another layer of horror in this scene — how does anybody else watching, unaware of what's really going on, perceive this sudden mental shift? The player sees Batman replaced with a hallucination of the Joker, but the average Gotham citizen sees billionaire philanthropist and beloved humanitarian Bruce Wayne, unmasked, reply that he's glad to see his loved ones hunted down and killed while the city burns, then begin to laugh insanely in an apparent psychotic breakdown.
    • On another Joker related note, any time Hallucination!Joker speaks, there's this chorus of cackling Joker voices in the background that never stops.
    • The way Joker appears and disappears at will is a mix of Nightmare Fuel and Paranoia Fuel. Whenever you move the camera, Joker seamlessly slides onto the scene as if he was there the whole time. And when he's said what he has to say and you move the camera around again, he simply vanishes, as if he was never there. There is literally no way to tell when the Joker will show up to taunt you.
  • Combined with Funny Moments: as you slowly use the Nimbus cell to replace the power core of the Batmobile, the Joker tries to make Batman give in to the fear toxin, first, by telling him to take deep breaths, then pretending to sleep; and then, when the Nimbus is being slowly placed into the Batmobile, he sings a grotesque version of "Rock-a-Bye Baby" that goes like this:
    Rock-a-bye Batsy, I'm getting free.
    Soon you'll be the one trapped inside me.
    So keep taking breaths, great lungfuls of fear.
    Soon Bats will be gone, and I will be here.
  • During the final hallucination, when you play as the Joker, you get a twisted clown version of the Batmobile. But that isn't the scary part. The scary part is when the game wants you to fire on a room full of mooks using LIVE ROUNDS. This scene is especially unnerving and unsettling if you don't often play M rated games, but it's also worth mentioning because you've spent the entire game as a protagonist who refuses to kill and uses nonlethals. The scene is jarring to say the least.
  • Stagg's notes, complete with the chambers of his test subjects. Cruelty doesn't even begin to describe it.
  • Almost everything about Professor Pyg. His entire "Monster Machine" operating theater, a dank, slimy concrete chamber, is hidden underneath an unassuming beauty salon, where he holds fresh captives captive in giant birdcages while performing surgeries and singing along to opera music. Pyg himself is a hideously deranged, schizophrenic villain, euphoric to the point of religious mania while he talks of beauty and perfection, and his Dollotrons are gruesome bandaged creatures with all traces of free will, pain receptors, and genitalia cut away. Pyg only barely seems to understand he's done anything wrong, mewling and snuffling about how "Mother" will be ashamed if he's locked up.
    Pyg: Pyg happy, Pyg glad, Pyg gets to play with flesh, make it look pretty after death!
    • The above quote comes from the screen you see if you die fighting him. It's the only death screen available for that section, and it has Pyg reaching into the screen with a knife.
    • One of the side stories revealed by a riddle shows that not even children are safe.
    • Hell, the entire concept of Pyg's Dollotrons themselves. For example, there's at least 30 Batman has to fight his way through to apprehend Pyg himself - that's at least thirty people kidnapped, gruesomely maimed and rebuilt into a hideous mockery of the human form. Worse is the aftermath that isn't explored - Batman, as usual, only knocks out the attacking Dollotrons rather than killing them, possibly with the vague intent of saving their lives. But what happens when the GCPD roll up and find them? Is there any amount of mental therapy or reconstructive surgery that can bring a person back from that? Would the person even be able to go through with reconstructive surgery after that kind of ordeal? Is there even a mind left to save? And what, if anything, is left underneath those masks?
      • Even better: maybe there are minds left behind those masks... their bodies are just under control by Pyg thanks to the surgical alterations he made. The first Dollotron you encounter was begging Pyg to stop his surgery, which is followed by Pyg commanding the future Dollotron to say "thank you" for hurting him (he does, with obvious effort not to). What if these Dollotrons are innocent people who were not only forcibly altered in appearance and function, but also with no control over what they're doing? Not to mention looking at the imprisoned Dolltrons (who are all just standing around lined up in two separate rows) with Detective Vision presents you with Condition: TERRIFIED.
      • You see his victims holed up in the GCPD later, and one of them is a woman who has been reduced to a sobbing mess. She was the same when you rescued her.
      • It's possible to break a Dollotron's mask through an environmental takedown. Whatever the fuck is under there, it's probably for the better not to see it. Part of it is a strange mass of lumpy flesh at the top of the head.
    • What makes Pyg even more disturbing is that he doesn't think he's doing anything wrong. He sees himself as a good person, and he honestly thinks he is helping the people he kidnaps by making them "perfect". He is SERIOUSLY mentally disturbed. He's not just doing it For the Evulz like, say, Joker or Mad Hatter.
    • One must question what caused Pyg to believe his life's work are the Dollotrons. He makes them into this genderless zombie, immune to anything that doesn't force them into unconsciousness. He regards failure as a horrifying realization, and sobs to himself about Mother getting angry with him. What did Pyg go through to make him believe all this?
    • Let's just put it this way. If you're a villain who's insane to such a disturbing extent, to such an unholy level that even the Joker admits that you're completely crazy, you're pretty goddamn scary. That's pretty much Professor Pyg - so unsettling and terrifying that even Joker, as Ax-Crazy as he is, as much as he's doing everything For the Evulz, as terrifying as he was in life, pretty much says that Pyg's crazier than the rest of the bunch.
  • The game's design of Man-Bat may be the most disturbing yet, if only for how much more human than normal he looks — his emaciated, nearly hairless body, milky-white eyes and mouth twisted into a yawning howl all show just how agonizing Langstrom's transformation was (As seen from image above*). Even his introduction is a Jump Scare; as Batman grapples onto a ledge, Man-Bat appears out of nowhere, screeching and trying to claw at his face. Worse, it's also possible for him to suddenly appear on skinny construction bars. In real life, he would be easily spotted.
    • Now the proud "welcoming face" of this page!
    • It gets worse. Later, when you go to his lab, you descend into a lonely, dank place with notes everywhere, a screen showing two brief videos... and Dr. Langstrom's dead wife on the floor. If you watch the videos, first you'll see a cute loving video with the two discussing his research, and then the second one starts to document the treatment... except it goes horribly wrong. It's horrifying imagining Francine's last moments: watching her husband writhe in pain, then (as the sounds imply) watching him transform into a half-man, half-vampire bat... then being killed by him. The final video shot is of her face, after her body falls to the floor. If you look at the floor in present time, the camera is still pointing at her. And you can see the bruises on her legs and the large bruise on her neck where her husband likely bit her... The whole scene is only made worse by the ominous yet sad music. Doubles as a massive Tear Jerker.
    • Think that's bad? Go back to Langstrom's lab later in the game. Francine's body is gone, the screen has been smashed by something, and the words "Forever My Love" have been written in what looks like blood.
    • And just when you think Kirk either escaped from or was let go by the GCPD, you find him still in his cell. The most likely explanation? Francine is still alive, but only because Kirk was contagious.
    • Setting the PS4 or XBox One clock to 10/31 shows that even if you captured Man-Bat earlier in the game, he'll appear in the previous jumpscare. Going back to GCPD, you find that his cell has been destroyed from the inside!
    • Man-Bat's screeches and howls are very unsettling. You'll know when he's around by listening for his bat-like roars up in the sky.
  • Scarecrow injecting Barbara with his fear toxin and forcing her to commit suicide right in front of Batman. That was the moment both Bats and the player realize that Scarecrow's not screwing around this time. He really wants Batman to suffer. Granted, it was a hallucination caused by Scarecrow's fear gas and she was really alive, but it's still painful to watch.
  • As the Scarecrow is about to let Barbara fall off the ledge of the construction site to her death, just to twist the knife in Gordon for "failing" him, she defiantly tells him, "You don't scare me." In response, he leans in and quietly whispers, using the same reassuring tone a parent might give to a child woken by a nightmare, "Shhhh... it's okay to be afraid." Just one line, yet it shows the absolute depths of his evil more clearly than any speech he ever gives to Batman.
  • Throughout the game, Batman brushes off or does his best to ignore the growing presence of Joker both metaphorically and literally (given the nature of his affliction) eating away at his mind. Then you corner Scarecrow for the first time, and we see just how much frightening hold Joker has over his mind at this point, culminating in a hallucination wherein a horde of Jokers are egging him on to shoot Scarecrow, even though the gun is all in his mind. He pulls the trigger.
    Joker: Look at him... No different than the creep who killed your parents. You need to do something. You need to stop him.
    Batman silently aims a hallucinated revolver.
    Joker: Yes, good... Good... Gooood...
    Batman shuts his eyes. A click of the trigger is heard before he's returned to conscious reality.
    • Even the gameplay in this sequence is terrifying! Chances are you'll only be using the standard 'attack' button against your foes. but if you try to stun them? You attack. If you try to dodge? You attack. The only button that doesn't attack is counter, which lets you let them off easy with broken limbs and devastating injuries.
    • Just seeing when Joker first gets control of Batman. The complete change in his body language is just downright unsettling. To say nothing of hearing Joker's voice coming out of Batman's mouth.
    "Look at me! I'm amazing! And this body... I can't believe how strong it is!"
  • Batman's final fear gas hallucination shows a even further mutated Killer Croc in the near future, almost akin to a Kaiju; he's become gigantic, seems unable to speak, and has grown attributes such as a tail and spiny monitor lizard frills on his shoulders. It's a rather disturbing reminder of just how worse his incurable condition can get.
    • The mutations themselves are bad enough to look at, but Alfred theorizes in Arkham Origins that Croc is in near-perpetual agony because of them. If it was already painful when he was still recognizably human, it must be pure torture for him now.
    • In Batman: Arkham Asylum, he was so powerful and relentless that Batman himself barely staved him off by exploiting the shock collar meant to force him into compliance — he had no chance of subduing Croc physically, and only managed to survive by detonating the ground underneath his feet, dropping him into a huge chasm. Croc has progressively gotten tougher and stronger since then, the collar is long gone, and it's not likely he'll fall for the same trick twice. When encountering Batman in the sewers in City, the only thing that stopped him from ripping the bars apart and killing him right then was smelling Batman's disease and deciding to wait for him to die instead. Oracle considered fighting him to be suicidal during the events in Asylum; the proper word now would probably be futile.
    • Even worse, Croc's appearance in the "Season of Infamy" DLC shows that it wasn't just a flight of fantasy — it's already happened to him.
    • The mission proper details just what happened to him during the capture described in his Gotham City Story; after being stalked for months in the marshlands, subdued by a team of armed soldiers (many of which didn't survive the encounter), and given a massive tranq dose, he was hauled off in the enormous "Iron Heights Penitentiary" airship, the closest place strong enough to hold him. When he eventually threw off the effect of the sedatives, he proved strong enough to bring down the zeppelin by himself, and now lurks inside the wreckage in the bay with an army of freed prisoners.
    • When Batman goes deeper inside the airship, he finds out just why Croc has mutated as badly as he has — it was an adaptive response to the agony of the sadistic medical experiments Warden Ranken was putting him through, including sawing off his hand to see if it would grow back, all in an effort to reproduce and weaponize his condition in Iron Heights' other prisoners. Worse still, Ranken shows no signs of repentance or remorse for what he's done, only disgust with his charges and fury at their rebellion. Batman's very justified in calling him the true monster.
    • While Killer Croc's voice was slowly changing from raspy to a growling tone, he sounds utterly monstrous here. His voice at this point is just a pure Guttural Growler, sounding like it physically hurts him to try to speak anymore now; nevertheless, it just goes to show that Croc's lost any remaining trace of humanity he had left at this point.
  • The moment when the last remnant of Joker, fighting for dominance in Batman's mind, has to come to terms with a terrifying reality — he will, eventually, fade into obscurity or get lost in the shuffle, his presence no longer feared by Gotham, his name no longer admired and hated by his fellow criminals. Unlike every other defeat he's faced before, he's gone for good this time, and can't ever return to bedevil Batman again; he's only a bad memory, sealed away in the brain of a dying man, isolated forever. When Batman finally arrives to lock him away for good, the once-arrogant villain who sneered "I can't stand groveling" is begging and pleading, near tears, unable to lose Bruce again.
    Joker: I need you...
    • Additionally, the walls of Joker's cell have some... unsettling words scraped onto them, such as "NO ESCAPE", "ONLY THE DARK" and "HELL". Worse still, smaller, more personal scrawled messages like "I HATE FRANKIE" and rows upon rows of "I'M NOT A JOKE" suggest this was actually all Joker's work, carved in private fits of rage and self-loathing.
  • By the game's end, Batman and Bruce Wayne are dead to the public. But something is still patrolling Gotham and preying on criminals. And whatever it is... doesn't play fair.
  • The Arkham Knight's first audio log showcases Scarecrow interrogating Barbara for Batman's identity. When she refuses to talk, Scarecrow menacingly threatens to inject her with his fear toxin, explicitly detailing the severe long-term damage the toxin can do. Thank God the Arkham Knight intervened when he did.
  • A game with the Scarecrow as one of the main villains is a game thick with Mind Screw. Within a few hours of playing, you'll find yourself questioning what's real every time Batman ends up alone. Some of the more unpleasant hallucinations include:
    • Flashing back to the Joker crippling Barbara Gordon and taking photographs of his handiwork.
    • A room full of KO'd mooks stumbling to their feet and turning into giggling Joker clones while you aren't looking.
    • Jason Todd's physical and psychological torture by the Joker, who torments him with Batman "replacing" him with another Robin.
  • Remember the Scarecrow nightmare sequences from Asylum? They're back as DLC, and they're as terrifying as ever. The nightmare missions have you driving the Batmobile through a hellish, twisted mockery of Gotham that looks like something straight out of Silent Hill while being pursued by a towering Scarecrow, who attacks with fireballs and Eye Beams. At the end of each one, you must fight Scarecrow himself to escape. And each Nightmare has Scarecrow being more aggressive in his attempts to kill you. It's a small mercy that the Batmobile gives you the firepower to fight back. Plus, some of his taunts are downright terrifying.
    "Feed him to the crows!"
    "Your parents are in Hell and you're about to join them!"
    "Bring me his soul!"
    "And the darkness closes in."
  • The final hallucination. Pretty much all of it but here's an itemized receipt:
    • As Joker in a first-person shooter situation, some stone statues of Batman go full Weeping Angels on you, complete with Brown Note musical cues at all the wrong times.
    • Before that, as FPS-Joker, gunning down the Rogues can be... disturbing. Cobblepot bargains vainly for his life, Nigma tries to take a hostage, and Dent tries to stop you. Depending on your mood, you can listen to their gibbering, or gun them down without a second thought while a hellish version of Only You plays over and over.
      • The most unsettling part about that sequence was, from the way they're talking, you can infer that from the Rogues perspective, they're still seeing Batman. Riddler takes a hostage saying "there might still be some things you won't do," and Dent tries appealing to your human nature.
      • And before that, there's the hallucination where Batman takes on an army of Jokers. Seems tame to begin with, until you look more closely at the one special he can use during this fight: the "Joker Takedown". It showcases the most brutal takedown animations seen in the game, with Batman using either lethal or permanently crippling force in all of them - curbstomping Joker's face into the ground, snapping his back over his knee, slamming his heel into the small of Joker's back and the fight itself ends with Batman necksnapping Joker at his own insistence.
      • And then right after Joker shoots and kills the Rogues, he walks outside to see Gotham, burning down before him, relishing the sight as his finest work. Then does Alfred speak up... sounding utterly fucking terrified.
    Alfred: Please listen to me! After all the good you've done for this city, think about what you're doing!! Sir, I'm begging you! Master Bruce...Batman! You have to listen! Think about your family, Bruce - your father, what would he say if he saw you like this?! Please, please stop this rampage!
  • YOU. Yes, you. After four games and twelve in-universe years of brutal vigilante justice, Batman has a well-deserved reputation as someone who can and will smash your face and break your bones at his leisure. Throughout the course of the game, you vindicate that reputation with interest. Average thugs can freak out at your mere presence.
    • The militia, however, are not as Batman-wise as the average Gotham thug, and begin their invasion with high morale. As you continue dismantling their efforts bit by bit, they begin to wise up, and deploy increasingly powerful countermeasures until they're throwing everything they've got at you. It isn't enough. Enemy chatter goes from impressed, to concerned, to fearful, and then outright panic as their army slowly crumbles to dust through the efforts of a single man. By Game's end, the stragglers are lost, alone, and stranded, in a foreign warzone with no support and no hope of rescue, while fully aware of just how vulnerable they are. You don't need to be cowardly or superstitious lot to fear Batman; he's enough to give you nightmares regardless.
    • One particular example of this is when Batman believes he's chasing the Arkham Knight but it's just a regular mook with a voice modulator. Batman then uses the Batmobile to interrogate him by having the wheel just very slightly from crushing the mook's head and revs the engine as he screams in agony and Batman demands answers.
      • Granted, the mook was REALLY asking for it when he brought up Barbara's current predicament as the Arkham Knight's prisoner, with the implication that the Knight would probably do something...horrible to her. Dial up Batman's Adult Fear to Eleven. Fortunately, it was heavily implied that the Arkham Knight had no intentions of letting Barbara getting hurt, due to the former being Jason Todd.
    • The final scene drives this home. After Batman conquers the hallucination, he manages to break free with help from the Arkham Knight, and turns the Scarecrow's fear toxin on him. We then see Batman through Scarecrow's eyes - he looks like an unearthly red-eyed demon, with bats for a cape and bats coming out of his body, while the background is a hellish red sky. Scarecrow is afraid of YOU - the one person who can conquer fear, along with anything else the bad guys throw at you. And after playing through the game, it's something of a CMOA as you think - of course he's afraid. He ought to be.
  • One of the story logs you can find shows what happened to Solomon Grundy after City. He had been given a special cell in the city morgue that not only has four extra strength locks on it, but they're WayneTech caliber. Even then, that's not enough when the lone coroner realizes that the large body in there is very much alive!
  • On the subject of Solomon Grundy, one of the riddles is based around him, and the solution is a small room under Perdition Bridge in Drescher, which contains candles, lots of rubbish on the floor, a wanted poster of Solomon Grundy...and a record player, playing a creepy, distorted version of the 'Solomon Grundy' nursery rhyme, sang by a young boy on an endless loop. What makes this even more unnerving is the room is too small for Solomon Grundy to put together himself. He physically couldn't fit in the small space; Batman barely can. So the question remains, who put all this stuff here? It almost looks like a shrine, but who in their right mind would be worshiping Grundy of all people? Well, guess what: we never find out.
  • If you die during the section where Oracle helps you defeat the drones, instead of one of the villains taunting you, you will be greeted with a cutscene of Barbara at GCPD, and all of a sudden, the militia comes in and shoots everyone in sight, and there is screaming in the background. It's really scary when you think about it.
  • As if the Joker hallucinations weren't bad enough already, there's the Fridge Horror in that we don't know how much of it is the mutation and how much is Batman's own subconscious. Bits like the Joker's extremely predatory attitude to the vulnerable Catwoman and his telling Batman to leave Nightwing to his fate because of the lack of respect he showed by leaving and taking on his own costumed identity become even worse if you consider that Batman himself might be the origin of those thoughts, and the Joker aspect is merely giving them a face and a voice.
    • Joker being Shipper on Deck for Bats and Selina, telling him to enjoy all the happiness he can before he pulls his Grand Theft Me. Then he will kill Selina, in Bruce's body no-less.
  • The detonation of the Cloudburst, which uncannily resembles a volcanic eruption — as seen from street level, the gas cloud surges out like a pyroclastic flow, consuming everything and everyone in its path; in mere seconds, a dense, roiling shroud has already settled over the entire city, glowing and spitting static electricity. All mechanisms not running on Nimbus technology stall completely. All the enemy chatter goes quiet, save the frightened, overwhelmed reactions of militiamen. Gliding over it, in almost total silence with no music, feels like death itself.
    • Not to mention that all the militiamen and random thugs have been each replaced by a hallucination of Joker laughing. Their echoing, nonstop laughs make the atmosphere even more dreary and hopeless as it already is. Even zapping the Jokers away won't be satisfying since they don't even make a sound as they are zapped and the unsettling laughter still continues.
    • For extra creepiness, in between Ivy's sacrifice and ´completion of the next objective, not a single living person can be found on street level. Normally busy places like Grand Avenue and Chinatown are suddenly quiet as a grave with thug corpses littering the street. Only after completing the next objective do enemies slowly respawn on the street.
  • Just the realization that in the end, Batman's third Scarecrow hallucination from Batman: Arkham Asylum, the one of him being wheeled into Arkham on a gurney, mentally ill himself, with the Rogues in charge of the Asylum and aware of his true identity, came true. Bonus points in that both the hallucination from the first game and the reality from the final game were both induced by Scarecrow. Scarecrow successfully made one of Batman's worst fears a reality.
    Scarecrow: Do you know what happens when a man refuses to be controlled by his fears? He must face them.
  • Johnny Charisma's Game Over sequence has him pressing the detonator to blow up the whole stage, and himself. That's right, you're basically getting a close-up of someone committing a suicide bombing. If you look closely, you can even see his body break into Ludicrous Gibs.
  • Although it's a cameo only in the A Matter Of Family DLC, you can find in the amusement park, a freaking Starro parasite (though fortunately contained). So that means that in this Crapsack World of Gotham with mobs, supervillains, terrorists, cults and other more down-to-earth threats... there exists something capable of creating a Cosmic Horror Story. Yeah.
  • In the "Nightwing: GCPD Lockdown" DLC, you start off at the Penguin's base in Blüdhaven. There, you'll find a giant aquarium tank that belongs to, you guessed it, Tiny. Get close to the tank and the enormous shark will appear out of nowhere and slam into the glass.
  • In the "Season of Infamy" DLC, the "Shadow War" mission chain has you encounter Ra's al Ghul, who has finally been revived too many times. Not only has he withered away severely, but despite being treated with a constant flow of the Lazarus chemical, he hasn't healed the wounds from his fall in City, leaving his ribs and organs showing in the two sickly holes in his torso. And if you chose to heal him with the new Lazarus strain, he's now quite psychotic, happily cutting down Nyssa and calling her a traitor. There's nothing of the old Ra's left by now.
    • "Shadow War" in itself is considerably Bloodier and Gorier than even the main game, possibly made as such since the game already had an M rating by the time it was being developed. The Elliot Memorial Hospital has dozens of corpses strewn about the place and a considerable amount of visible blood spilt about the floor as well, and choosing to help Ra's with the new Lazarus juice that Batman found rewards you with a "lovely" scene of Ra's cutting his second daughter Nyssa down, complete with horrid flesh-cutting sounds and Nyssa's wound spilling blood.
    • Within the hospital, you'll eventually come across the morgue, where several shelves have been left open to expose the corpses they contained. Two of the bodies belong to the waitress from Pauli's Diner and the bearded man who informs Officer Owens about the "smoker".
    • After beating the mission, you can go back to the hospital and find a hidden tape. It turns out that Ra's let Batman live because Talia loved him and promised he could be a worthy successor, so allowed Talia to bring Batman before him. If Batman failed, then Ra's would give the League to Talia, saying that she would lead without mercy. Batman was in way over his head in Arkham City, to the point that if it weren't for Talia, he would've died there.
  • The climax of the Mad Hatter's side mission, "Wonderland", has Batman falling into a Hatter hallucination once again: this time around, he's shrunken down and forced to fight enemies in a giant pop up book, all while a massive Mad Hatter peers down at him. Keep in mind, the guy was already creepy enough, so seeing him as a fifty-foot tall giant looking over you like a child with a picture book is surprisingly terrifying.
  • The "In from the Cold" mission with Freeze shows several dead militia soldiers frozen in ice. Also, the cryo-generator that Freeze was using to keep Nora safe becomes unstable and explodes. The type of the explosion they use? The Cloudburst firing. And the final battle has Batman in a no-win situation: the Batmobile is fighting in an open area against an unlimited number of drones, and the ice is on the verge of giving out under the sheer weight of the machines out there.
  • Jason being the new guardian of Gotham, and he doesn't play by the same rules as Batman.
    • Imagine this: You are a criminal in Gotham City. For ten years, most punishment you'd get for any crime was a beatdown and some jailtime. Now, with the Batman seemingly dead, you might get motivated to commit more crimes. You do something illegal with a bunch of pals, and suddenly, a hooded figure, wearing the Batsymbol, comes the fuck outta nowhere, slaughters everybody else, and moves onto you...
    • Better yet, the same fate might fall upon supervillains, as Black Mask demonstrated. Given that Jason lacks any empathy towards criminals, even Harvey might get killed by him eventually.
  • One of the Gotham City Stories details Jason going after Joker and how he was captured, and... let's just say he actually had a pretty good reason. Infant Immortality went right out the window on this one.

"Welcome to your own personal hell. Please stay a while."