Carlyle's review of Bratz, especially Korey and Leon's reaction to him casually bringing up Jon Voight.
Leon's fart noises in the review of Over Her Dead Body.
The Disaster Movie review, which begins with Korey trying to commit suicide because the movie was so bad. It's also notable as the first time the lowest rating possible, a "Fuck You", is put in place.
The Bangkok Dangerous review where most of Korey and Cohost's time is spent mocking Nicolas Cage's awful narration and absurd looking hair piece.
The Lakeview Terrace review where Korey notes that the white man and black girl couple isn't quite as much a stigma as the black man and white girl couple, culminating in him suggesting the same concept except with Sam Jackson and a white woman being menaced by an angry Queen Latifah.
In the review of the Friday the 13th reboot, it's hypothesized that it's not that Jason Vorhees doesn't want people smoking weed on his property. He just don't want them smoking his weed.
LEOG, Volume 1, Issue 18, where most of the first hour is spent trying to recap Batman R.I.P., and how they completely lose it at any possible moment, but especially when they bring up "Weapons Grade Crystal Meth".
The review of Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Pt. 2 especially when Korey explains why he thinks the movie is "Better Than Sex". It has Cyrus and Leon in the background humming The Battle Hymn Of The Republic dressed as Hogwarts students. But, the real kicker is when Co-Host 3000 rises from below in the background dressed as Darth Vader and humming the Imperial March.
Korey, Professor Jeff and Jason started a Loading Bar playthrough of Skyrim, in which they decide to make their character a Khajiit and name him "Garfieldius", cue to cat jokes and Jeff and Jason trying to convince Korey to kill everything in sight.
Made all the better in Star Wars: The Old Republic when Jason and Jeff decide to pick "Garfieldius" as the name of their overweight smuggler.
Jason gets increasingly bored and frustrated during Professor Jeff's now legendary "speedrun" of Super Metroid. On part 10 (of 2), to pass the time and to punish Jeff he begins reading an abysmal fanfic, in which a teenage Samus is impregnated by Ridley. The sombre tone in which he narrates the entire thing (including spelling errors) causes Jeff and everyone watching to crack up.
The readings actually start on Part 7 (listed as Session 2: Part 3), where Jason reads a fanfic based around the characters of Super Smash Bros., where Samus and Zelda form a lesbian relationship. One notable section has Link asking Yoshi for his opinion on the matter, only for Yoshi to fail in offering a response, as he canonically cannot speak cohesively.
Jason: (reading) "Yoshi tried to answer the question-" (starts to laugh) "...but he couldn't, since he had no ability to actually speak whatsoever."
(Jason and Jeff break out laughing)
Jeff: It's the authenticity that really sells it, ladies and gentlemen.
All of the Twilight film reviews. Each one is priceless in its own way.
The guys complaining about how Ravenna didn't let the king have any sex before killing him in the audio review for Snow White & the Huntsman.
The Sinister review. Four words: The Return Of Carlyle!
The Happy Hour playthrough of Sleeping Dogs (with guest commentator Brian Brushwood) is a highlight, especially the section in Part 2 where Jason Murphy continuously dies in the rooftop battle, leading to Jeff taking over and completing the battle in one attempt.
In the audio review of Marmaduke, Co-Host jokes that the theater was so empty that the theater patrons literally had to call someone back from his break just to set up the projector. The situation was so surreal that Korey brought it up again in the audio review of Escape From Planet Earth.
Their audio review of Beautiful Creatures is pure gold from beginning to end, with the entire crew showing off their terrible "genteel Suthuhn" accents, as well as making so many puns about "ticklin' the ahhh-vories" that Brian ends up terrified anything he says will be interpreted as homoerotic innuendo.
Korey: Oh, Leon, those were the days, boy, when Cyrus was sittin' on the porch with Brian, fanning themselves in their rocking chairs, and you and I were out there in the field pickin' cotton.
Leon: Yeah, that's why I got mad watching Django Unchained, I was like, "Hey, ain't nobody ever come here and shoot up these guys for me!"