Sole Survivor
A robot designed by GLaDOS to be the ultimate helper in Survivor.
First Portal fan character.
- Bad Liar
- Beneath Notice: Sanza points out that this actually makes him a challenge- he's always a target, but he's always the second most pressing target, meaning that he makes his way through the game even though he should have been voted out long ago. He rides this all the way to the Final Three, where he cinches the victory by playing Prescilla/Bonnie's Engineered Public Confession.
- Butt-Monkey: Fails epically at every single challenge... except the ultimate win.
- Chekhov's Gun: His built-in voice recorder was introduced as a gag for Starr's singing, and was made detachable in another gag. It was used to reveal Prescilla's facade.
- Cute Machines
- Dark Horse Victory: Most people thought the win would go to Sanza or Kathy. And then they get voted out, leaving Prescilla, Tofuchao, and Cherman. Prescilla, at this point, is the projected victor, as Tofuchao betrayed his alliance and no one had seen through her facade. Then Cherman exposed her, leading to his final win.
- Good Is Not Dumb: He's not as stupid as others assume.
- Kid-Appeal Character
- The Little Detecto: Has a "Hidden Immunity Idol Finder".
- Nice Guy: One of the most kind-hearted characters in the series.
- Out of Focus: The least focused-on winner so far. Word of God says that this was intentional to throw everyone off and think either Sanza or Kathy was going to win.
- Sole Survivor: The ninth, and is the first male to win since Season 5.
- Spanner in the Works: To Prescilla/Bonnie's plan.
- This Looks Like a Job for Aquaman: The only things he can do well are finding Hidden Immunity Idols, throwing confetti, and recording voices. Oh, and being the only one to see through Prescilla's facade and expose her with the aforementioned recorder.
- Unlikely Hero: Did anyone really expect Cherman to win this season?Madison: How the heck did we end up with a Tofuchao and Cherman Final 2?
Runner-Ups
A Chao who doesn't show up much, yet is perfectly game-savvy and enjoys spelling words for some reason.
Seventh Sonic The Hedgehog fan character.
- Deadpan Snarker
- Lethal Joke Character: Despite being the smallest member of the cast, he managed to win quite a few tribal challenges, and even maneuvered himself into the finals.
- Out of Focus: One of the most Out of Focus finalists in the series.
- Viewer Gender Confusion: In-Universe example, with several contestants mistaking him for female.
A sweet, elegant lady who makes sure she is nice to everyone... until you see her confessionals. "Prescilla" is really a facade, and the real Bonnie takes the game by force.
First Barbie fan character.
Came back for Season 10: Battle of the Tribes and Season 16: Blood VS Water.
- Batman Gambit / Xanatos Speed Chess: Improvises a plan which culminated in Starr getting voted out and Prescilla retaining possession of the hidden immunity idol.
- Bitch in Sheep's Clothing: For the first four episodes, she appears to be a sweet, naive girl who'd never say a mean word to anyone. Then episode 5 rolls around, and we learn that she's the one who framed Jewel and is practically salivating with glee about being able to manipulate everyone around her.
- Big Bad
- Card-Carrying Villain
- The Chessmaster
- Cluster F-Bomb: Beats out Jackie for filthiest fan character ever, if because of...
- Country Matters: She throws the taboo word around Cluster-like. She's not a nice person.
- Crying Wolf
- Dumb Blonde: Subverted. Not only is she a Bitch in Sheep's Clothing, she isn't even a natural blonde.
- Engineered Public Confession: How she goes down. Cherman gives his recorder to Barbie, Bonnie's visitor. Bonnie then proceeds to gloat about her villainous activities during the game, and Barbie records everything. Cherman then plays the recording where she admits to everything she did at the Final Tribal Council.
- Manipulative Bitch: Manages to fool everyone else with her facade... until it breaks at the Final Tribal Council.
- Nice Girl: Polite and friendly. Except not. She was faking it in order to win the game.
- Open Mouth, Insert Foot: Donovan warns her that her mouth could become her undoing, and it does indeed when she indulges in a bout of Evil Gloating with Barbie and unwittingly sets herself up for an Engineered Public Confession later on that she does absolutely nothing to mitigate by blowing up and screaming at the entire jury about how they're all "bitter bitches" and realizing a little too late that she just effectively wrecked any chance she had of convincing them that Cherman's recordings of her weren't true.
- Oh, Crap!: The look on her face when she realized that Cherman recorded her Evil Gloating to Barbie about how she was behind pretty much everything bad in the game, her only regret was that she didn't do anything more to hurt others, and how she was looking forward to the people she screwed over committing suicide, because she had a bet going (she apparently bet on three deaths). And after her epic Villainous Breakdown, when she realizes that now she's got no chance of convincing the Jury that Cherman's recordings were fake.
- Out of Focus: Until episode 5.
- Pink Means Feminine: Invoked.
- Playing the Victim Card: Goes hand-in-hand with her Bitch in Sheep's Clothing nature. She throws her own luxury item, along with almost everyone else's, into the campfire to frame Jewel and get her voted out, and then claims that Adrian sexually assaulted her to get him voted out after he outlives his usefulness.
- Politically Incorrect Villain: Refers to the new members on her tribe with racial slurs, although she makes sure to keep them restricted to her confessionals.
- Sore Loser: Walks offstage after Cherman's win.
- Vile Villain, Saccharine Show: Who'd have thought that the Barbie character would turn out to be the evillest villain of the series?
- Villainous Breakdown: Once Cherman reveals who she really is... let's just say that the Phoenix Wright rogue's gallery would be proud.
- Villain with Good Publicity: At least until the Final Tribal Council.
- Walking Spoiler: There's a lot of tropes about her that can't be shown to people who haven't seen the season through.
- The Woman Behind the Man: At least during the initial tribal stages; being integral to the all-male alliance taking control of the Carbo tribe, she was valued highly by Frank and Adrian.
- Why Did It Have to Be Snakes?: Does not like bugs.
The Jury
A girl who enjoys games of all kinds, and plans on using her skills in the Liar Game on Survivor.
First Liar Game fan character.
- Asian and Nerdy
- Berserk Button: Does not take it well when she almost gets voted off.
- Brainy Brunette
- Chronic Backstabbing Disorder: Spearheaded the eliminations of Ieaeka and Sanza, both former allies.
- Genre Savvy: She's a fan of reality games.
- Laser-Guided Karma: The round after she backstabs Sanza, she herself gets backstabbed by Tofuchao.
- Loophole Abuse: Uses the smartphone that she got at the family visit challenge to surf the Web for spoilers of the season.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Prescilla.
An anti-hero who considers himself a nice guy, but isn't afraid to make sneaky moves to further himself.
Second Teen Titans fan character.
Came back for Season 10: Battle of the Tribes.
- Anti-Hero: Type II.
- The Ace
- Ambiguously Brown
- Shocking Elimination: Was the clear frontrunner heading to the finale, but got eliminated at fifth.
- The Hero Dies: See Shocking Elimination.
- Turn Coat: The only one of his alliance to not vote for Tofuchao at the finals.
A complete idiot (who thought he was on The Amazing Race) who finds out that Survivor isn't really that hard.
First Backyard Baseball fan character.
- Brainless Beauty
- Crouching Moron, Hidden Badass: Although he HAS shown rare instances of random knowledge that seems irrelevant, such as easily identifying a type of tree and saying its scientific name.
- Epic Fail: Every time any remote usage of wit is involved. He did apply for Survivor thinking it was The Amazing Race.
- The Masochism Tango: With Madison.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Prescilla.
A kindly housewife and Survivor superfan who is set on disproving the negative stereotypes of people like her.
First Dead Rising fan character.
- Fish out of Water
- Out of Focus: While she is focused upon in the first few episodes and the last few episodes, she falls into this category until around the merge.
- Sassy Black Woman: Subverted.
- Shocking Elimination
- Shout-Out: Uses several fan-related terms when talking about how much of a threat Zachary was or would become, including the way viewers determine who has the best chance of winning via editing called "edgic".
- Team Mom: For the Latrines.
A pretty and athletic model who, nevertheless, is very shallow and thinks she needs to depend on a man.
First Baywatch fan character.
- Jerkass
- The Masochism Tango: With Brenton.
- Too Dumb to Live
A lion who appears to be a complete enigma to the rest of the cast. He is actually an angel who decided to play only to watch the typical drama unfold firsthand.
First Second Life fan character.
- Above Good and Evil: He reveals to Bonnie that since he's an omnipresent being of divine power, he's been well aware of their true nature since the beginning, but hasn't exposed them because he doesn't consider that fair. Besides, their antics amuse him.
- Animals Hate Him: Can do this to people he dislikes, specifically Robert and Prescilla.
- Berserk Button: Do NOT call him "Donny".
- Cloud Cuckoolander
- Disproportionate Retribution: Turns Robert's life into hell just because he called him "Donny".
- Eyes Always Shut
- Hidden Depths: Is highly cultured, and can apparently speak zombie.
- Kingmaker Scenario: Appears to be played straight, but is later subverted when he quits.
- My Death Is Just the Beginning
- Non-Gameplay Elimination
- Odd Friendship: With Mercy.
- Our Angels Are Different
- Would Hit a Girl
- You Just Told Me: At the Final Tribal Council to Prescilla:Donovan: "Bonnie."Prescilla: "Yes?"Donovan: "Checkmate."
A cheerful high-school girl who tries to fit in with the popular kids by acting shallow and aloof.
First Glee fan character.
Came back for Season 10: Battle of the Tribes and Season 20: Generations.
- Character Tics: Starts singing when she gets excited, as well as, like, having a Valley Girl accent and stuff.
- Hidden Depths
- Hidden Heart of Gold: Invoked and paired with Gretchen's actual Bitch in Sheep's Clothing status, which ultimately saves her from being voted out when Prescilla sees through her facade.
- Lipstick Lesbian
- Verbal Tic: Her saying "like" a lot, which is actually a subversion because she is capable of talking normally; after she drops her facade, the likes tone down a lot.
A member of the Sims council and a born leader, who would be well-respected if he didn't have incredibly antiquated views on gender roles.
Third The Sims fan character.
Came back for Season 10: Battle of the Tribes.
- A Father to His Men
- Idiot Ball: Has no problem with giving Brenton his Immunity Idol, not even thinking that Brenton would give it to Madison.
- Straw Misogynist
- Ugly Guy, Hot Wife: Implied by Aleksan.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Prescilla.
An average guy who experiences a very not-average brand of punishment throughout the game.
First Enchanted Arms fan character.
Eliminated
A very strong Russian who is the main challenge dominator on his team.
First Shaman King fan character.
A rocker girl who serves as the main opposition to Frank and his alliance.
First Rock Band fan character.
- Chekhov's Gunman: While a minor presence in her own season, she would later reappear in Season 13 as a family visitor for Tapioca, being rather important to the latter's backstory and plot.
- Only Sane Woman: Comes closest to being the most level-headed member of the cast outside of The Latrines. According to Season 13, it's because she was on a boat-load of medication due in part to a former friend's Jerkass tendencies.
- Sitcom Arch-Nemesis: For Frank.
- The Strategist
A mage who plans to use her magic skills to her advantage in the game.
First Chrono Trigger fan character.
- Asshole Victim: The one person screwed over by Bonnie you shouldn't feel very sorry for.
- Fifth Ranger: For the Latrines.
- The Friend Nobody Likes: The Latrines would love to tell her where she can stick it, but don't because they need her vote.
- Functional Magic
- Hypocritical Humor: Very bitter when Jewel cheats.
- Laser-Guided Karma: She was the most vocal person about eliminating Adrian with Prescilla's false charges of sexual assault, as well as the one that spied on the other teammates with one of her spells; one episode later, she herself gets the boot as well, courtesy of Prescilla.
- Screw the Rules, I Have Supernatural Powers!
A pilot who enjoys flirting with pretty women. He believes that he has found true love on the show. Poor guy.
First Mortal Engines fan character.
Came back for Season 10: Battle of the Tribes.
- Casanova Wannabe
- Gratuitous Italian: Whenever he gets angered.
- Ladykiller in Love: Genuinely believes that Prescilla is "the one" for him. Unfortunately, she's only using him and gets him voted out when she doesn't need him anymore.
- Laser-Guided Karma: He was the most vocal person about controversially eliminating Jewel; one episode later, he himself gets the boot undeservingly.
- Unwitting Pawn: To Prescilla.
The winner of the 67th Hunger Games, she is very strong but also has a hair-trigger temper.
First The Hunger Games fan character.
- Action Girl
- The Quisling: To the females on the tribe; she refused to be part of a female alliance because she wanted to be a member of the winners.
- The Scapegoat: When the Carbo members' luxury items are burned in the fire, she gets blamed for the incident.
A literal Witch that is heaped on sedatives to keep her from killing the cast.
Second Left 4 Dead fan character.
- Berserk Button: Like any witch, do NOT disturb her.
- Glowing Eyes of Doom
- The Load
- Odd Friendship: With Donovan.
- The Unintelligible
A sneaky, manipulative girl who plans to win the game.
Second Total Drama fan character.
- Bitch in Sheep's Clothing: Invoked, and paired with Starr's Hidden Heart of Gold-hiding facade. Prescilla manages to realize this only minutes before the vote and gets her voted out.
A young, confident cocky teenager who plans on taking control of the game.
Sixth Sonic The Hedgehog fan character.
- Evil Counterpart: Of Chris Thorndyke.
- Fatal Flaw: His cockiness.
- Sacrificial Lamb
- Smug Snake: Boasts repeatedly about how no one except Mercy would be going home first, which tips a lot of people off as to what would come if he were to stay.