The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Well, if nothing else, the mechanics of the game system itself is so heavily based in overly meticulous and sterile math that it effectively kills any "hotness" that could go on.

Still say it should be stubbed, myself.

edited 4th May '12 4:23:02 PM by Raidouthe21st

STUB THE BEAST!

Stub sounds good. I kinda want it kept around so we can make fun of it more.

edited 4th May '12 4:27:09 PM by Arha

There's always the YMMV page...

Maybe we should make a huge banner for the FATAL page, a la the old banner on the Lolita page: "THIS PAGE BROUGHT TO YOU BY OUR OWN PERSONAL SCHNADENFREUD."

Again mentioning Kuso Miso Technique because even as a fan of yaoi and Slash Fic, this is one that is a pretty clear-cut case of pure porn without plot. While I'd argue (even to the extent of being a Devil's Advocate) that Okane Ga Nai and Ai No Kusabi, from what I see of them, have some degree of plot - even if it's squicky or typical Excuse Plot yaoi version (e.g. Excuse Plot with 10000 times more angst and sobbing).

Kuso Miso Technique has NO plot. It's "story" if you can call it that, is "high school student runs into mechanic on bench, mechanic unzips suit to show cock, they go into a bathroom and have scat sex."

The only reasons it's notable are that it is So Bad Its Horrible and has spawned three Memetic Mutations which are, unlike the source material, relatively SFW: the Yaranaika meme (and its related Ear Worm song based off of Balalaika), one of its characters as "generic gay guy," and the "their faces plastered onto other things" meme.

I'd say the page is a DEFINITE cut (and why it's sitting with one devilhead while stuff with more plot and more reason for debate has two is beyond me), but I'd say the examples using it on Memetic Mutation should stay so long as they don't describe the source material beyond "it's a Bara Genre explicit manga with a high degree of squick."

... I wish that I didn't know this.

Well, it's only 10 pages, according to the work page.

Komodin, you are not the only one. Got some of that Brain Bleach left over?

"Only ten pages" in regard to Kuso Miso Technique is like "it stops in ten minutes" in regard to a "how many times can you be kicked in the crotch" contest. That said, I find it hilarious to prank yaoi newbies with (and the memes are hilarious at points and are pretty good Brain Bleach - look up "yaranaika" on Know Your Meme) but... yeeesh. we don't need it here.

edited 4th May '12 4:51:17 PM by AGroupie

Why is everyone on the P5 council so prone to "Pass me the brain bleach"ism? :P I would think the council would be best served by people with a high tolerance to general smut and depravity :P

Yeah, Kuro Miso Technique's ten pages is roughly equivalent to trying to sit through ten minutes of A Serbian Film. -shivers from the memories of both-

I'm not on the council xD

Sorry, but I have absotively no tolerance for stuff like scat porn. 2 Girls 1 Cup had a direct hand in that...

Well, okay, scat I can understand.

Has anyone mentioned that FATAL has 3000 inbounds?

I do, but the reason I haven't nominated myself for council candidancy (and interview with the mods/admin to verify my qualifications) is that Real Life seems to have it for me these days, so I'm not sure I'd find the time to be able to contribute for now. Maybe in a month or two, if there's still an empty spot and nobody has stepped forward...

edited 4th May '12 5:30:07 PM by MarqFJA

... Rats. Guess we'll have to just clean and lock it, then.

Ninja'd.

I'm just saying that we should at least check how much of those are "good" inbounds and how much are "bad" — and how are just looking for the word "fatal" rather than the all-caps title.

Princess Maker was tagged. At it's most objectionable, I think the series is mostly just boring. There's no sex or fanservice so far as I know.

Princess Maker 2 includes a patch that includes making the princess nude. In addition, the uncensored version has beach scenes wherein the princess is wet, showing visible nipples.

Oh, does it? Then again, you have to patch the game for that to show up.

Pretty sure that the see-through clothing at the beach is just the original Japanese version, but yeah-the official english version is censored.

I'm only really familiar with the second game due to a Let's Play I read, but from what I've seen, it's just a Raising Sim sorta thing, it practically never dips anywhere into pedophile-pandering material in the slightest, and anything potentially fanservicey (the kinds of outfits she wears in some of the the endings, for example) happens when the princess you're raising becomes 18 years of age.

In terms of what it does have that might be objectionable...well, I know there's a "Buxom Pill" you can buy the titular princess after she reaches a certain age, which supposedly enhances her breasts...but that doesn't really do anything at all except increase a few numbers, there aren't any actual visible changes as far as I know, so it's just...sorta there to make you feel awkward.

edited 4th May '12 6:01:26 PM by Raidouthe21st

Ah, Gendo Shinkicker, you're the best caretaker ever.

I've played the English. Her nipples are censored.

Well, it was never officially released, but it's great. I wish they'd bring out some of the sequels.

edited 4th May '12 6:42:30 PM by animeg3282

Ahhh.

Well okay then. The game has a bleached underpants version in the US. Doesn't seem like the kinda thing we'd cut.

For the record, the game is fun. Like, seriously. Totes awesome.

edited 4th May '12 6:36:16 PM by TheyCallMeTomu