Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / Manhattan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* NerdsAreVirgins: One of the scientists in Frank's group is still a virgin. Helen tries to fix that by [[JustForPun hooking]] him up with the local prostitutes, but he still doesn't sleep with them.

to:

* NerdsAreVirgins: One of the scientists in Frank's group is still a virgin. Helen tries to fix that by [[JustForPun hooking]] hooking him up with the local prostitutes, but he still doesn't sleep with them.

Changed: 25

Removed: 332

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Your Cheating Heart is a redirect to Infidelity Index (infidelity in itself is not a trope, please see the index to find a trope the example may fit under)


* YourCheatingHeart:
** [[spoiler: Frank Winter has an affair with his housekeeper, Paloma.]]
** [[spoiler: While suspecting Charlie of cheating on her, Abby sleeps with her neighbor and coworker Elodie. He hadn't cheated on her, but does so later on with Helen.]]
** [[spoiler: Robert Oppenheimer has an affair with a woman named Jean in San Francisco.]]

to:

* YourCheatingHeart:
** [[spoiler: Frank Winter has an affair with his housekeeper, Paloma.]]
** [[spoiler: While suspecting Charlie of cheating on her, Abby sleeps with her neighbor and coworker Elodie. He hadn't cheated on her, but does so later on with Helen.]]
** [[spoiler: Robert Oppenheimer has an affair with a woman named Jean in San Francisco.]]
----

Added: 229

Changed: 361

Removed: 160

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableBreaksFromReality: Callie Winter, singing with her fellow girl scouts, sneaks away with a soldier before the songs are even over. This goes unnoticed by the audience and the scout leader. It's good for their story, showing them sneaking off, but in reality Callie leaving the group mid-song and her absence would be brazenly obvious and noticed by the song leader and the audience.

to:

* AcceptableBreaksFromReality: Callie Winter, singing with her fellow girl scouts, sneaks away with a soldier Cole Dunlavey before the songs are even over. This goes unnoticed by the audience and the scout leader. It's good for their story, showing them sneaking off, but in reality Callie leaving the group mid-song and her absence would be brazenly obvious and noticed by the song leader and the audience.



* ClassifiedInformation: Figures strongly into the story. The scientists can't even tell their wives what they are doing.

to:

* CharacterDeath: [[spoiler:Sid Liao and Reed Akley die in Season 1. In Season 2, Mr. Fisher[=/=]Occam is murdered by Jim Meeks's contact while interrogating Meeks, while Nora murders Fritz's wife Jeannie to keep her silent when she figures out that Jim is a spy.]]
* ClassifiedInformation: Figures strongly into the story. The scientists can't even tell their wives what they are doing.doing, and the different groups are forbidden from collaborating with each other to maintain compartmentalization.



* KilledOffForReal: [[spoiler: Sid Liao and Reed Akley die in Season 1. In Season 2, Mr. Fisher is murdered by Jim Meeks's contact while interrogating Meeks.]]



** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler:Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with the Soviets. He's also joined by another mole, Nora.]]

to:

** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler:Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with for the Soviets. He's In Season 2 he's also joined by another mole, Nora.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilledOffForReal: [[spoiler: Sid Liao and Reed Akley.]]

to:

* KilledOffForReal: [[spoiler: Sid Liao and Reed Akley.Akley die in Season 1. In Season 2, Mr. Fisher is murdered by Jim Meeks's contact while interrogating Meeks.]]



** Averted again in "The Second Coming" , when news of the Holocaust starts to trickle in. Abby mentions that over a million people in Minsk are missing, before she breaks down saying she doesn't even know how to imagine that many people.

to:

** Averted again in "The Second Coming" , Coming", when news of the Holocaust starts to trickle in. Abby mentions that over a million people in Minsk are missing, before she breaks down saying she doesn't even know how to imagine that many people.



** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler: Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with the Soviets. He's also joined by another mole, Nora.]]

to:

** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler: Meeks, [[spoiler:Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with the Soviets. He's also joined by another mole, Nora.]]

Added: 1321

Changed: 583

Removed: 628

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DirtyCommunist: Babbit is suspected of being one because he knew a physicist who defected to the Soviet Union. [[spoiler: He turns out to have had a romantic relationship with him, but turned down an opportunity to defect with him]]
* DrivenToSuicide [[spoiler: Reed Akley [[AteHisGun shoots himself]] in "The Gun Model"]]

to:

** Multiple pregnant women are seen smoking and drinking alcohol.
* DirtyCommunist: DirtyCommunist:
**
Babbit is suspected of being one because he knew a physicist who defected to the Soviet Union. [[spoiler: He turns out to have had a romantic relationship with him, but turned down an opportunity to defect with him]]
him.]]
** A number of times characters make it clear they believe that once the war is over Russia will become the enemy.
* DrivenToSuicide DrivenToSuicide
**
[[spoiler: Reed Akley [[AteHisGun shoots himself]] in "The Gun Model"]]Model"]]
** [[spoiler: Oppenheimer's mistress Jean kills herself after Abby (pretending to be Kitty Oppenheimer) tells her Oppenheimer will never see her again]].



%%* LoveHurts

to:

%%* LoveHurts* LoveHurts: There are not many stable, happy relationships in the series.



** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler: Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with the Soviets]].

to:

** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler: Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with the Soviets]].Soviets. He's also joined by another mole, Nora.]]



* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech:
** Charlie, sick of the ribbing he's been getting over his mathematical work on the diffusion and transport of neutrons in a material, proceeds to correct everybody else's math on their boards, proving that he is legitimately smarter than them.
** Frank dresses down a doctor whose specialty was obstetrics, pointing out that he's not qualified to treat cases of accidental radiation exposure (which in the 1930s and 1940s was still very much terra incognita in many respects).
** Charlie [[spoiler:imagines Reed Akley giving him a rather nasty and harsh one after he mentions the spontaneous fission problem with plutonium-240.]]



* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech:
** Charlie, sick of the ribbing he's been getting over his mathematical work on the diffusion and transport of neutrons in a material, proceeds to correct everybody else's math on their boards, proving that he is legitimately smarter than them.
** Frank dresses down a doctor whose specialty was obstetrics, pointing out that he's not qualified to treat cases of accidental radiation exposure (which in the 1930s and 1940s was still very much terra incognita in many respects).
** Charlie [[spoiler:imagines Reed Akley giving him a rather nasty and harsh one after he mentions the spontaneous fission problem with plutonium-240.]]

to:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech:
** Charlie, sick of the ribbing he's been getting
TyrantTakesTheHelm: Colonel Darrow, who takes over his mathematical work on the diffusion base in season 2, is considerably less likeable and transport of neutrons in a material, proceeds to correct everybody else's math on their boards, proving that he is legitimately smarter much more devious than them.
** Frank dresses down a doctor whose specialty was obstetrics, pointing out that he's not qualified to treat cases of accidental radiation exposure (which in the 1930s and 1940s was still very much terra incognita in many respects).
** Charlie [[spoiler:imagines Reed Akley giving him a rather nasty and harsh one after he mentions the spontaneous fission problem with plutonium-240.]]
Colonel Cox.



** [[spoiler: While suspecting Charlie of cheating on her, Abby sleeps with her neighbor and coworker Elodie. He hadn't cheated on her, but does so later on with Helen.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: While suspecting Charlie of cheating on her, Abby sleeps with her neighbor and coworker Elodie. He hadn't cheated on her, but does so later on with Helen.]]
** [[spoiler: Robert Oppenheimer has an affair with a woman named Jean in San Francisco.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreenEyedMonster: Abby gets rather irritated when she learns that Charlie is on a work trip with a woman, which he didn’t tell her.
* HeadbuttingHeroes: The different teams are working towards the same goal but in different ways, which leads to friction. Winter, especially, butts heads with almost everyone.



** [[spoiler: "You can fix Thin Man," said to Charlie Isaacs by Reed Akley in "The Gun Model." Akley was trying to convince Charlie to stay with the project, but had insisted all along that Thin Man worked. At this point Charlie realizes he was just ''hoping'' it would.]]



*** He reappears in the season finale.

to:

*** He reappears in the season finale.finale.
* YourCheatingHeart:
** [[spoiler: Frank Winter has an affair with his housekeeper, Paloma.]]
** [[spoiler: While suspecting Charlie of cheating on her, Abby sleeps with her neighbor and coworker Elodie. He hadn't cheated on her, but does so later on with Helen.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A couple to UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks, especially DC Comics. Including a few of the scientists trying to discern just how high Superman can leap based on the radio show's intro and Fritz's girlfriend comparing his [[spoiler:inhalation of plutonium]] to [[Character/TheFlash Jay Garrick's]] origin.[[note]]The episode where she does this ironically enough aired the same week as [[Series/TheFlash2014]] TV show premiered beating ''them'' to making a reference to Garrick[[/note]].

to:

** A couple to UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks, especially DC Comics. Including a few of the scientists trying to discern just how high Superman can leap based on the radio show's intro and Fritz's girlfriend comparing his [[spoiler:inhalation of plutonium]] to [[Character/TheFlash [[Characters/TheFlashTheFlashes Jay Garrick's]] origin.[[note]]The episode where she does this ironically enough aired the same week as [[Series/TheFlash2014]] TV show ''[[Series/TheFlash2014 The Flash]]'' premiered beating ''them'' to making a reference to Garrick[[/note]].

Added: 226

Removed: 219

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS, this was renamed to Sex Starts Story Stops


* CoitusEnsues: Charlie and Abby Isaacs, at times, find their sex drives peaking to the point of engaging in sex in some risky places. Narratively, though, the sex seems more about the {{Fanservice}} than anything else.


Added DiffLines:

* SexStartsStoryStops: Charlie and Abby Isaacs, at times, find their sex drives peaking to the point of engaging in sex in some risky places. Narratively, though, the sex seems more about the {{Fanservice}} than anything else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AluminumChristmasTrees: Yes, people who sat and did busywork math all day were called "computers" - they ''[[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin computed]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: Despite despising each other, Frank and Charlie are really [[JerKass not that]] [[InsufferableGenius different.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even darker is when [[spoiler:Liza discovers that everything in town, even the [[InfantImmortality newborn babies in the base's maternity ward]], is irradiated and poisonous. Subverted by the reveal that this might have been a hallucination.]]

to:

** Even darker is when [[spoiler:Liza discovers that everything in town, even the [[InfantImmortality [[DeathOfAChild newborn babies in the base's maternity ward]], is irradiated and poisonous. Subverted by the reveal that this might have been a hallucination.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: The first words out of Private Dunlavy's mouth after he [[spoiler:shoots Sid Liao]] is "What did I do?"

to:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: The first words out of Private Dunlavy's mouth after he [[spoiler:shoots Sid Liao]] is are "What did I do?"

Added: 125

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroicBSOD: PFC Dunleavy isn't really firing on all cylinders after shooting [[spoiler: Sid Liao]]

to:

* HeroicBSOD: PFC Dunleavy Dunlavy isn't really firing on all cylinders after shooting [[spoiler: Sid Liao]]



* IntimateHealing: A WAC invites PFC Dunlavey into her house for this, being attracted to him due to the stories floating around the base about his alleged heroism in shooting a "spy". However, he's been suffering from a form of PTSD over it.

to:

* IntimateHealing: A WAC invites PFC Dunlavey Dunlavy into her house for this, being attracted to him due to the stories floating around the base about his alleged heroism in shooting a "spy". However, he's been suffering from a form of PTSD over it.


Added DiffLines:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: The first words out of Private Dunlavy's mouth after he [[spoiler:shoots Sid Liao]] is "What did I do?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Your Cheating Heart is an index, not a trope.


*** He reappears in the season finale.
* YourCheatingHeart:
** [[spoiler:Frank Winter, with the maid who barely speaks any English.]]
** Worked almost to death in "The New World", with Charlie and Abby both shown in situations that test their marital commitments. It does not help one bit that in both cases, the would-be partner in an affair knows about the Isaacses being married.

to:

*** He reappears in the season finale.
* YourCheatingHeart:
** [[spoiler:Frank Winter, with the maid who barely speaks any English.]]
** Worked almost to death in "The New World", with Charlie and Abby both shown in situations that test their marital commitments. It does not help one bit that in both cases, the would-be partner in an affair knows about the Isaacses being married.
finale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking per TRS decision.


* BiTheWay: [[spoiler:Abby and Elodie.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope is being cut


* NobodyOver50IsGay: Averted with [[spoiler:Glen.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing comma placement.


** Fritz is testing the plutonium, and because in the 1940s, its properties were not well-understood he did not know that under certain conditions, it is pyrophoric in air. He accidentally causes it to "poof" into the air when he uncovers the heated sample, leading to the line below. [[spoiler:It's later discovered he breathed in and swallowed the vaporized plutonium.]]

to:

** Fritz is testing the plutonium, and because in the 1940s, 1940s its properties were not well-understood well-understood, he did not know that under certain conditions, it is pyrophoric in air. He accidentally causes it to "poof" into the air when he uncovers the heated sample, leading to the line below. [[spoiler:It's later discovered he breathed in and swallowed the vaporized plutonium.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fritz is testing the plutonium, and because in the 1940s, its properties were not well-understood, he did not know that under certain conditions, it is pyrophoric in air. He accidentally causes it to "poof" into the air when he uncovers the heated sample, leading to the line below. [[spoiler:It's later discovered he breathed in and swallowed the vaporized plutonium.]]

to:

** Fritz is testing the plutonium, and because in the 1940s, its properties were not well-understood, well-understood he did not know that under certain conditions, it is pyrophoric in air. He accidentally causes it to "poof" into the air when he uncovers the heated sample, leading to the line below. [[spoiler:It's later discovered he breathed in and swallowed the vaporized plutonium.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Tennessee plutonium breeder reactor starts warming up even after it's been taken offline due to an unplanned shutdown. [Charlie starts seriously considering that the reactor might explode and contaminate the town. It turns out that a fission product, iodine-135, decays into xenon-135, which swallows up neutrons[[note]]it has a large neutron-capture cross-section[[/note]]. The resulting radioactive decay was generating the excess heat, so paradoxically, adding ''even more'' fuel rods solves the problem, by "burning up" the xenon-135 with the sudden burst of neutrons from the extra uranium[[note]]xenon-136 is a stable isotope with a much smaller capture cross-section[[/note]].

to:

** The Tennessee plutonium breeder reactor starts warming up even after it's been taken offline due to an unplanned shutdown. [Charlie Charlie starts seriously considering that the reactor might explode and contaminate the town. It turns out that a fission product, iodine-135, decays into xenon-135, which swallows up neutrons[[note]]it has a large neutron-capture cross-section[[/note]]. The resulting radioactive decay was generating the excess heat, so paradoxically, adding ''even more'' fuel rods solves the problem, by "burning up" the xenon-135 with the sudden burst of neutrons from the extra uranium[[note]]xenon-136 is a stable isotope with a much smaller capture cross-section[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As the incident on which this is based happened in real life, it's actually not really worth spoiler tagging.


** The Tennessee plutonium breeder reactor [[spoiler:starts warming up even after it's been taken offline due to an unplanned shutdown. Charlie starts seriously considering that the reactor might explode and contaminate the town. It turns out that a fission product, iodine-135, decays into xenon-135, which swallows up neutrons[[note]]it has a large neutron-capture cross-section[[/note]]. The resulting radioactive decay was generating the excess heat, so paradoxically, adding ''even more'' fuel rods solves the problem, by "burning up" the xenon-135 with the sudden burst of neutrons from the extra uranium[[note]]xenon-136 is a stable isotope with a much smaller capture cross-section[[/note]].]]

to:

** The Tennessee plutonium breeder reactor [[spoiler:starts starts warming up even after it's been taken offline due to an unplanned shutdown. Charlie [Charlie starts seriously considering that the reactor might explode and contaminate the town. It turns out that a fission product, iodine-135, decays into xenon-135, which swallows up neutrons[[note]]it has a large neutron-capture cross-section[[/note]]. The resulting radioactive decay was generating the excess heat, so paradoxically, adding ''even more'' fuel rods solves the problem, by "burning up" the xenon-135 with the sudden burst of neutrons from the extra uranium[[note]]xenon-136 is a stable isotope with a much smaller capture cross-section[[/note]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistory: For people familiar with the actual Manhattan Project, the series is this. The broad strokes of the Manhattan Project and WorldWarII seem to all be correct, but different people were involved in the details in this timeline. The policies regarding the project are also altered to reflect modern interpretations of military policy and government secrecy.

to:

* AlternateHistory: For people familiar with the actual Manhattan Project, the series is this. The broad strokes of the Manhattan Project and WorldWarII UsefulNotes/WorldWarII seem to all be correct, but different people were involved in the details in this timeline. The policies regarding the project are also altered to reflect modern interpretations of military policy and government secrecy.



* ShellShockedVeteran: Frank Winter is a veteran of [[WorldWarOne The War to End All Wars]]. This explains at least some of his over-the-top behavior.

to:

* ShellShockedVeteran: Frank Winter is a veteran of [[WorldWarOne [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI The War to End All Wars]]. This explains at least some of his over-the-top behavior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It was picked up for a second season to air in 2015.

to:

It After running for two seasons, it was picked up for a second season to air in 2015.
cancelled on February 3, 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A black man, Dr. Theodore Sinclair, has been shown to be relegated to fetcher-and-carrier for a white man who knows little about nuclear physics compared to him.

to:

** A black man, Dr. Theodore Sinclair, a black nuclear physicist, has been shown to be relegated to fetcher-and-carrier for a white man who knows little about nuclear physics compared to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In fairness, this remark might be interpreted as merely emphasizing how bad FDR looked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In fairness, this remark might be interpreted as merely emphasizing how bad FDR looked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** J. Robert Oppenheimer so far has been depicted as cold, aloof, and something of a JerkAss. In reality he was quite friendly and tender-hearted. He was the one who made arrangements for [[RichardFeynman Richard Feynman's]] first wife, Arline, to stay in a hospital in Albuquerque while he was working on the Manhattan project.

to:

** J. Robert Oppenheimer so far has been depicted as cold, aloof, and something of a JerkAss. In reality he was quite friendly and tender-hearted. He was the one who made arrangements for [[RichardFeynman [[UsefulNotes/RichardFeynman Richard Feynman's]] first wife, Arline, to stay in a hospital in Albuquerque while he was working on the Manhattan project.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler: Meeks]].

to:

** As of the first season finale, the real culprit is revealed to be [[spoiler: Meeks]].Meeks, who is later shown in "The Threshold" to very likely be working with the Soviets]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the second season, in "Fatherland", [[spoiler:Frank Winter discovers how Kafkaesque the spy game really can be. He finds out the entire prison he was put into was a test, and that the "Nazi material" he was told indicated the German bomb project's state of affairs actually was just a set of his own equations doctored up to look like someone else's blackboard.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadassBoast: In March 1944, with no visible proof of whether such an ambitious goal can be met, Charlie Isaacs declares, "On July 4th, 1945, we're going to put on the biggest firework show since the Book of Genesis." The actual Trinity atom bomb test occurred on July 16th, 1945.

Top