Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / LieToMe

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* AmbiguousDisorder: Cal is utterly brilliant. He also has an awkward body language and very little regards to things like tact and the like, and the first line of his second book was, ‘[[spoiler:Let me be clear. I understand very little, least of all the people close to me]].’
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removal of malformed wicks to GCPTR per TRS thread.


%% * GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the future, please check the trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Overprotective Dad has been disambiguated


* OverprotectiveDad: Cal is ''very'' protective of his daughter Emily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OppressiveImmigrationEnforcement: "Depraved Heart" features Lightman and his team stumbling upon a forced surrogacy operation, revealed to be led to by ICE agent Mike Personick. Personick abuses his position to force immigrants into being surrogates to his wealthy clients, keeping them in appalling conditions and then [[DrivenToSuicide goading them into committing suicide]] when they are [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness no longer anymore use to him]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting Five Man Band ZCE tree as per cleanup requirement.


%%* FiveManBand
%%** TheHero - Dr. Cal Lightman
%%** TheLancer - Dr. Gillian Foster
%%** TheBigGuy - Ben Reynolds
%%** TheSmartGuy - Eli Loker
%%** TheChick - Ria Torres
%%** TagalongKid - Emily Lightman
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Dr. Cal Lightman (Creator/TimRoth) is a LivingLieDetector, able to calculate human honesty through facial expressions - called [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro-expression Micro Expressions]] - and body language. The pioneer of this field, he operates his own business, working with federal and private clients to solve criminal and civil cases. A case of TruthInTelevision (well, somewhat), as the show is based on the science of Paul Ekman.

to:

Dr. Cal Lightman (Creator/TimRoth) is a LivingLieDetector, able to calculate human honesty through facial expressions - called [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro-expression Micro Expressions]] - and body language. The pioneer of this field, he operates his own business, working with federal and private clients to solve criminal and civil cases. A case of TruthInTelevision (well, somewhat), as the show is based on the science (widely criticized, un-peer-reviewed, and largely unsubstantiated) "science" of Paul Ekman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cut trope


* MoralDissonance: Loker. Yay, you made it so thieves got put away. But the people they ruined ''stayed'' ruined. Nice work.

Added: 2198

Changed: 4529

Removed: 654

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Dr. Cal Lightman is a LivingLieDetector, able to calculate human honesty through facial expressions - called [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro-expression Micro Expressions]] - and body language. The pioneer of this field, he operates his own business, working with federal and private clients to solve criminal and civil cases. A case of TruthInTelevision (well, somewhat), as the show is based on the science of Paul Ekman.

Lightman is joined by a team of [[OddlySmallOrganization three other analysts]]. Dr. Gillian Foster is Lightman's close friend and the other senior staff member. She usually heads up another investigation while Lightman is busy on a separate case. Ria Torres is a "natural" deception-detector. Lightman found her as a security agent at the airport. Rounding out the band is Eli Loker, an utterly shameless flirt committed to [[WillNotTellALie 100% honesty]][[note]]His radical honesty disappears quickly in season 1[[/note]]. Lightman's precocious teenage daughter is part of the cast as well.

to:

Dr. Cal Lightman (Creator/TimRoth) is a LivingLieDetector, able to calculate human honesty through facial expressions - called [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro-expression Micro Expressions]] - and body language. The pioneer of this field, he operates his own business, working with federal and private clients to solve criminal and civil cases. A case of TruthInTelevision (well, somewhat), as the show is based on the science of Paul Ekman.

Lightman is joined by a team of [[OddlySmallOrganization three other analysts]]. Dr. Gillian Foster (Creator/KelliWilliams) is Lightman's close friend and the other senior staff member. She usually heads up another investigation while Lightman is busy on a separate case. Ria Torres (Creator/MonicaRaymund) is a "natural" deception-detector. Lightman found her as a security agent at the airport. Rounding out the band is Eli Loker, Loker (Creator/BrendanHines), an utterly shameless flirt committed to [[WillNotTellALie 100% honesty]][[note]]His radical honesty disappears quickly in season 1[[/note]]. Lightman's precocious teenage daughter is Emily Lightman (Creator/HayleyMcFarland) and his ex-wife Zoe Landau (Creator/JenniferBeals) are part of the cast as well.



The show stars Creator/TimRoth as Dr. Lightman. That's right, [[Film/ReservoirDogs Mr. Orange]] knows when you're lying.



* AmicableExes: Cal and Zoe.

to:

* %%* AmicableExes: Cal and Zoe.



* BlackComedy: "What's green and red and goes really fast?" "A frog in a blender." Creepy, but [[SociopathicHero it says something about Cal]] that he knew the punchline before the killer said it.

to:

* BlackComedy: BlackComedy:
**
"What's green and red and goes really fast?" "A frog in a blender." Creepy, but [[SociopathicHero it says something about Cal]] that he knew the punchline before the killer said it.



* BriefcaseFullOfMoney: What Dr. Lightman purported to be trying to hide when he tested Ria Torres at the airport. After he and Dr. Foster end their hiring pitch, they leave behind the briefcase; when Ria calls them on the "forgotten" item, Lightman says nonchalantly that's her hiring bonus.

to:

* BriefcaseFullOfMoney: BriefcaseFullOfMoney:
**
What Dr. Lightman purported to be trying to hide when he tested Ria Torres at the airport. After he and Dr. Foster end their hiring pitch, they leave behind the briefcase; when Ria calls them on the "forgotten" item, Lightman says nonchalantly that's her hiring bonus.



* CentralTheme: Systematic bias, and how it can affect judgment, cropping up whenever Loker or Torres get involved in a case. Let us say they are both ''passionate''. One episode also implies that bias caused a disaster for Lightman early in his work.
** Another theme that's been popping up is the loyalty between partners (usually a case-of-the-week parallel to Cal and Gillian) and when deception between partners is acceptable.
* TheChessmaster: Cal, shown ''wonderfully'' in "Blinded".
* ChurchOfHappyology: "Scientific Repatterning" in "Beyond Belief".
* ClearMyName: Reynolds in "Lack of Candor", Cal in "Headlock", Burns in "Exposure".

to:

* CentralTheme: CentralTheme:
**
Systematic bias, and how it can affect judgment, cropping up whenever Loker or Torres get involved in a case. Let us say they are both ''passionate''. One episode also implies that bias caused a disaster for Lightman early in his work.
** Another theme that's been popping up is the loyalty between partners (usually a case-of-the-week parallel to Cal and Gillian) and when deception between partners is acceptable.
* %%* TheChessmaster: Cal, shown ''wonderfully'' in "Blinded".
* %%* ChurchOfHappyology: "Scientific Repatterning" in "Beyond Belief".
* ClearMyName: ClearMyName:
%%**
Reynolds in "Lack of Candor", Cal in "Headlock", Burns in "Exposure".



* DatingWhatDaddyHates: Pretty much any boy Emily Lightman brings home isn't going to be good enough for Cal.
** He's warming up to Liam. Though not enough to stop calling him "Willy".

to:

* DatingWhatDaddyHates: Pretty much any boy Emily Lightman brings home isn't going to be good enough for Cal.
** He's warming
Cal. He warms up to Liam. Though Liam, though not enough to stop calling him "Willy".



** This was pretty much a HeroicSacrifice for a character we had only seen for that episode. And it was [[SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome awesome]].
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: The killer in "Headlock".

to:

** %%** This was pretty much a HeroicSacrifice for a character we had only seen for that episode. And it was [[SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome awesome]].
* %%* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: The killer in "Headlock".



* EnhanceButton: [[LampshadeHanging Lampshaded]]. "Can you blow up her eyebrows? And do that thing."

to:

* EnhanceButton: EnhanceButton:
**
[[LampshadeHanging Lampshaded]]. "Can you blow up her eyebrows? And do that thing."



* FiveManBand
** TheHero - Dr. Cal Lightman
** TheLancer - Dr. Gillian Foster
** TheBigGuy - Ben Reynolds
** TheSmartGuy - Eli Loker
** TheChick - Ria Torres
** TagalongKid - Emily Lightman

to:

* %%* FiveManBand
** %%** TheHero - Dr. Cal Lightman
** %%** TheLancer - Dr. Gillian Foster
** %%** TheBigGuy - Ben Reynolds
** %%** TheSmartGuy - Eli Loker
** %%** TheChick - Ria Torres
** %%** TagalongKid - Emily Lightman



* FriendOnTheForce: Detective Wallowski.

to:

* %%* FriendOnTheForce: Detective Wallowski.



* GiveGeeksAChance: Cal's ex-wife, Zoe.
* GoAmongMadPeople: Twice. Once in Pied Piper, and again in Funhouse.

to:

* %%* GiveGeeksAChance: Cal's ex-wife, Zoe.
* %%* GoAmongMadPeople: Twice. Once in Pied Piper, and again in Funhouse.



* HardWorkHardlyWorks: Dr. Lightman spent years studying microexpressions, while Ria Torres is a natural. He's somewhat bothered by the fact, but it's also largely subverted. While Torres is incredibly skilled considering her relatively limited experience, Lightman is still far better and doesn't have emotional blindspots.

to:

* HardWorkHardlyWorks: HardWorkHardlyWorks:
**
Dr. Lightman spent years studying microexpressions, while Ria Torres is a natural. He's somewhat bothered by the fact, but it's also largely subverted. While Torres is incredibly skilled considering her relatively limited experience, Lightman is still far better and doesn't have emotional blindspots.



* HugeGuyTinyGirl: Loker and his various love interests, including [[spoiler: Emily, in "Bullet Bump"]].

to:

* HugeGuyTinyGirl: HugeGuyTinyGirl:
**
Loker and his various love interests, {{love interest}}s, including [[spoiler: Emily, in "Bullet Bump"]].



* IHaveThisFriend: Gillian uses this one when asking Reynolds why [[spoiler: her boyfriend would have a passport in another name and charter a boat out of Baltimore for five hours every week]].
** Turns out he has a very good reason - [[spoiler: he's undercover DEA.]]
* InformedAttribute: Eli Loker is said to be a practitioner of "radical honesty", but apart from an occasional tactless line we don't ever see it, though supposedly it should be quite radical. In fact, a major story arc has him lying extensively and dragging Torres into his lies. He was caught lying about his feelings for a woman, and was insincere about his motives when pretending to be Emily's friend in order to keep an eye on her.

to:

* IHaveThisFriend: Gillian uses this one when asking Reynolds why [[spoiler: her boyfriend would have a passport in another name and charter a boat out of Baltimore for five hours every week]].
**
week]]. Turns out he has a very good reason - [[spoiler: he's undercover DEA.]]
* InformedAttribute: InformedAttribute:
**
Eli Loker is said to be a practitioner of "radical honesty", but apart from an occasional tactless line we don't ever see it, though supposedly it should be quite radical. In fact, a major story arc has him lying extensively and dragging Torres into his lies. He was caught lying about his feelings for a woman, and was insincere about his motives when pretending to be Emily's friend in order to keep an eye on her.



* LieDetector: Dr. Lightman points out all the ways polygraphs suck. One of them involves getting a guy to fail the control questions by use of a woman in a sexy outfit.

to:

* LieDetector: LieDetector:
**
Dr. Lightman points out all the ways polygraphs suck. One of them involves getting a guy to fail the control questions by use of a woman in a sexy outfit.



* MayDecemberRomance: A villainous example - Martin Walker and Helen Dezekis.

to:

* %%* MayDecemberRomance: A villainous example - Martin Walker and Helen Dezekis.



* MoralDissonance: Loker. Yay, you made it so thieves got put away. But the people they ruined ''stayed'' ruined. Nice work. * SarcasticClapping* He did get [[WhatTheHellHero called out on it]] beforehand and was punished afterwards.

to:

* MoralDissonance: Loker. Yay, you made it so thieves got put away. But the people they ruined ''stayed'' ruined. Nice work.
* SarcasticClapping* He did get [[WhatTheHellHero called out on it]] beforehand and was punished afterwards.



* MyMasterRightOrWrong: Torres has this for Cal, but in "Pied Piper", Loker calls it into question. Torres accuses him of being a rat fleeing the sinking ship, but Loker (rightly) points out that Cal [[spoiler: got an innocent man executed]]. Unfortunately, Gillian catches them and reams them out, proving her adherance to the trope:
-->'''Loker''': Do you expect us to just share this delusion that Lightman is infallible?
-->'''Gillian''': Without Lightman, you'd be in some university basement doing research, and you [Torres] would still be a glorified baggage handler. Maybe instead of polishing up your resumes, you might want to think about what you can do to help Lightman.

to:

* MyMasterRightOrWrong: MyMasterRightOrWrong:
**
Torres has this for Cal, but in "Pied Piper", Loker calls it into question. Torres accuses him of being a rat fleeing the sinking ship, but Loker (rightly) points out that Cal [[spoiler: got an innocent man executed]]. Unfortunately, Gillian catches them and reams them out, proving her adherance to the trope:
-->'''Loker''': Do you expect us to just share this delusion that Lightman is infallible?
-->'''Gillian''':
infallible?\\
'''Gillian''':
Without Lightman, you'd be in some university basement doing research, and you [Torres] would still be a glorified baggage handler. Maybe instead of polishing up your resumes, you might want to think about what you can do to help Lightman.



* NotSoDifferentRemark: In "The Royal We", Cal tells how to create a disturbed personality ("constant criticism and lack of affection"), talking about a pageant contestant. Torres points out, "you mean, [[TheChewToy the way you treat Loker]]". She's right - Cal's jerkass tendencies toward his employees (Loker in particular) have edged into downright cruelty.

to:

* NotSoDifferentRemark: NotSoDifferentRemark:
**
In "The Royal We", Cal tells how to create a disturbed personality ("constant criticism and lack of affection"), talking about a pageant contestant. Torres points out, "you mean, [[TheChewToy the way you treat Loker]]". She's right - Cal's jerkass tendencies toward his employees (Loker in particular) have edged into downright cruelty.



* OverprotectiveDad: Cal is ''very'' protective of his daughter.

to:

* OverprotectiveDad: Cal is ''very'' protective of his daughter.daughter Emily.



* PlatonicProstitution: The pilot.

to:

* %%* PlatonicProstitution: The pilot.



* RapeAsDrama: In "Blinded", the criminal [[EyeScream blinds]] and then rapes women.

to:

* RapeAsDrama: RapeAsDrama:
**
In "Blinded", the criminal [[EyeScream blinds]] and then rapes women.



* SexySurfacingShot: In "Control Factor", there's a gratuitos shot of Emily climbing out of the swimming pool in a bikini during her and Cal's vacation in a Mexican resort.



* TwerpSweating: Emily gets Cal to promise not to do any "covert science things", but...
--> '''Cal''': Hi, Dan!
--> '''Dan''': Hi, Mr. Lightman!
--> '''Cal''': Are you going to try to have sex with my daughter tonight?

to:

* TwerpSweating: TwerpSweating:
**
Emily gets Cal to promise not to do any "covert science things", but...
--> '''Cal''': Hi, Dan!
-->
Dan!\\
'''Dan''': Hi, Mr. Lightman!
-->
Lightman!\\
'''Cal''': Are you going to try to have sex with my daughter tonight?



* YouCanAlwaysTellALiar: The entire '''''point''''' of this series.
** Which, interestingly enough, it subverts in "Dirty Loyal", when [[spoiler: Cal teaches Wallowski to lie, and IA forces Gillian to decide if she's telling the truth. Gillian is torn between her loyalty to Cal, which would mean she'd lie for Cal/Wallowski and say Wallowski isn't corrupt, and her ability to discern truth, which would mean she sent Wallowski to prison because she ''is'' lying. Gillian ultimately lies, causing conflict between her and Cal.]]

to:

* YouCanAlwaysTellALiar: The entire '''''point''''' of this series.
**
series. Which, interestingly enough, it subverts in "Dirty Loyal", when [[spoiler: Cal teaches Wallowski to lie, and IA forces Gillian to decide if she's telling the truth. Gillian is torn between her loyalty to Cal, which would mean she'd lie for Cal/Wallowski and say Wallowski isn't corrupt, and her ability to discern truth, which would mean she sent Wallowski to prison because she ''is'' lying. Gillian ultimately lies, causing conflict between her and Cal.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Direct link.


* AmicablyDivorced: Cal and Zoe.

to:

* AmicablyDivorced: AmicableExes: Cal and Zoe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StPatricksDayEpisode: "Sweet Sixteen" takes place during St. Patrick's Day and deals with Foster and Lightman being forced to revisit parts of their past after Lightman's former Pentagon colleague is killed due to a car bomb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: In "The Royal We", Cal tells how to create a disturbed personality ("constant criticism and lack of affection"), talking about a pageant contestant. Torres points out, "you mean, [[TheChewToy the way you treat Loker]]". She's right - Cal's jerkass tendencies toward his employees (Loker in particular) have edged into downright cruelty.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: In "The Royal We", Cal tells how to create a disturbed personality ("constant criticism and lack of affection"), talking about a pageant contestant. Torres points out, "you mean, [[TheChewToy the way you treat Loker]]". She's right - Cal's jerkass tendencies toward his employees (Loker in particular) have edged into downright cruelty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WarmPlaceWarmLighting: Every outdoor daytime scene in Mexico is given an orange wash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseReligion: In the pilot episode, the family of a Jehovah's Witness kid accused of murder use some religious idioms that are seldom expressed in the JW world except in parody or sarcasm, such as "praying for your soul". Also, the JW child is afraid of being sent to Hell. This is a major research failure: Jehovah's Witnesses [[https://www.jw.org/en/bible-teachings/questions/what-is-hell/ don't believe in Hell.]] Further, it's highly unlikely they would "pray for your soul" given they don't believe in the soul in the terms most understand it. Body and soul are not viewed as separate things. Rather, people will be resurrected by God in their belief if righteous, while sinners are left dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FakeAssassination: The governor is suspected of attempting to ride a "Bullet Bump" to re-election, when an assassin who seemed to be aiming at him pretends to miss and kills a staffer. [[spoiler:It was actually his wife who ordered the hit, and the hitman did not miss his intended target: the staffer knew too much]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotTheFirstVictim: In "Beat the Devil", a college student is accused of waterboarding, resuscitating, and then trying to bury alive a classmate. The investigation leads the police to realize he has had many, many victims, and that he killed his sister years previously.

Added: 967

Changed: 1378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The show generally doesn't use this - we don't see pixellated pictures get all cleared up... because they're ''already'' all cleared up. It seems all cameras in the show's universe have ludicrously high resolution that lets them keep detail no matter how much one zooms in...

to:

** The show generally doesn't use this - we don't see pixellated pictures get all cleared up... because they're ''already'' all cleared up. It seems all cameras in the show's universe have ludicrously high resolution that lets them keep detail no matter how much one zooms in...resolution. Of course any photos not high enough quality to read would be tossed for this exact reason, and the recording often are being taken by the Lightman Foundation who would of course be using the highest quality cameras possible for their work



* HardWorkHardlyWorks: Dr. Lightman spent years studying microexpressions, while Ria Torres is a natural. In a mild variation, he's actually somewhat bothered by it. However it's also subverted, as Lightman is better at it than Torres and doesn't have emotional blindspots.
** Also subverted in that most of Torres' mistakes come from relying on her natural gift. Lightman does seem to enjoy calling her out on this a bit too much though.

to:

* HardWorkHardlyWorks: Dr. Lightman spent years studying microexpressions, while Ria Torres is a natural. In a mild variation, he's actually He's somewhat bothered by it. However the fact, but it's also subverted, as largely subverted. While Torres is incredibly skilled considering her relatively limited experience, Lightman is still far better at it than Torres and doesn't have emotional blindspots.
** Also subverted in that that, while her GutFeeling is right a good amount of the time, most of Torres' mistakes come from relying on her natural gift. Lightman does seem to enjoy calling her out on this a bit too much though.much, although arguably as his mentor it is his jo.



* HesitationEqualsDishonesty: Deconstructs it: Prepared lies in fact generally cause people to answer quicker, not slower, because they have already prepared their story for questioning. The show goes on to explain that the way to catch these people is to ask them to repeat their story ''backwards'', which is a definite case of ShownTheirWork - your average liar won't bother to practice enough to get this right, but someone telling the truth will obviously be able to draw on their memory to answer (e.g. "I went to the park at about midnight, before that I was at the restaurant, and before that I was out giving candy to orphans.")

to:

* HesitationEqualsDishonesty: Deconstructs it: Played with, but mostly subverted.
**
Prepared lies in fact generally cause people to answer quicker, not slower, because they have already prepared their story for questioning. The show goes on to explain that the way to catch these people is to ask them to repeat go their story ''backwards'', which is a definite case of ShownTheirWork - your average ''backwards''. A liar won't bother to practice enough to get this right, have thought it through, but someone telling the truth will obviously be able to draw on their memory to answer won't have any difficulty (e.g. "I went to the park at about midnight, before that I was at the restaurant, and before that I was out giving candy to orphans.")")
*** The show also emphasizes how getting details wrong in your story and correcting them is typically a sign of telling the truth. A prepared lie will almost always come out right the first time, while someone will often get details wrong when telling the truth.
** Meanwhile other things, like unconscious bias, can come out as hesitation. Someone with racist tendencies won't fail to associate positive words with people of other races, they'll simply be slower to do so, for example.



* HyperAwareness

to:

* HyperAwarenessHyperAwareness: The main characters all specialize in the ability to notice and interpret the "Micro Expressions" that reveal true feelings and lies of people they're speaking to. Good enough liars can still get past them and it doesn't really apply to anything outside of emotions, however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbusiveOffspring: In "Beat the Devil", Martin Walker, a serial killer who killed his sister and murdered multiple other women at his college by water torturing them and burying them alive, is shown despite being extremely polite to terrify his mother.

Changed: 267

Removed: 284

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: Half of Zoe and Cal's banter in "The Whole Truth", especially the scene where Cal's locked up and Zoe's deciding whether or not to bail him out.
** In "Killer App", while talking to a geeky web designer (basically Mark Zuckerberg without the movie), we have this delightful little exchange:
---> '''Zach''': "Great. Voice pattern analysis. Which one of you reads palms?"
---> '''Lightman''': "I'll bet yours are sweaty. And hairy."

to:

%% * GettingCrapPastTheRadar: Half of Zoe GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and Cal's banter in "The Whole Truth", especially the scene where Cal's locked up and Zoe's deciding whether or not to bail him out.
** In "Killer App", while talking to a geeky web designer (basically Mark Zuckerberg without the movie), we have
persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this delightful little exchange:
---> '''Zach''': "Great. Voice pattern analysis. Which one of you reads palms?"
---> '''Lightman''': "I'll bet yours are sweaty. And hairy."
in the future, please check the trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.

Removed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MentorShip: Cal and Helen, at Oxford.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Top