Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / EthnicMenialLabor

Go To

OR

Changed: 114

Removed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Actress Lupe Ontiveros estimates she's played over 150 maids in her acting career (including Rosalita in ''TheGoonies''). Ontiveros is a graduate of Texas Women's University, with majors in psychology and social work. She narrated a documentary called ''Maid in America''.

to:

* Actress Lupe Ontiveros estimates she's played over 150 maids in her acting career (including Rosalita in ''TheGoonies'').''Film/TheGoonies''). Ontiveros is a graduate of Texas Women's University, with majors in psychology and social work. She narrated a documentary called ''Maid in America''.



* Rosalita in ''The Goonies''
* Baz Luhrmann's modern-day version of ''[=~William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet~=]'' turned the nurse Hispanic.

to:

* Rosalita in ''The Goonies''
* Baz Luhrmann's modern-day version of ''[=~William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet~=]'' ''Film/WilliamShakespearesRomeoAndJuliet'' turned the nurse Hispanic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Added: 785

Changed: 293

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This stereotype can also be seen in the United States with the au pair nanny, who is not menial in reality, but is often treated so in fiction. She is a young European girl, usually Swedish, Norwegian or Finnish, for some reason. Occasionally she'll be German or French.

to:

This stereotype can also be seen in the United States with the au pair nanny, who is not menial in reality, but is often treated so in fiction. She is a young European girl, usually Swedish, Norwegian or Finnish, for some reason. Occasionally she'll be German or French.
French. Germans and French were more common in the post-World War II period through the 1970s, as those countries were still rebuilding their ruined economies and a trip to America was a good way to get ahead.

'''North African Laborer'''
By virtue of the proximity of Spain, France, and Italy to North Africa, and the colonial links between them (Algeria and Tunisia were French colonies, Morocco was a joint French and Spanish colony, and Libya was an Italian colony), the stereotypical immigrant laborer in these countries is an Arabic-speaking North African. Many of them are illegal immigrants, but most are in the country legally; many are there on temporary work visas and intend to return home rather than stay permanently. Stereotypes of these are a peculiar mix of what Americans think of menial black labor and general Arab/Muslim stereotypes (i.e. covered women, bearded men, and general religious fanaticism), although the latter bit is only true of a small segment of the population.




to:

* Pete Campbell more or less rapes his neighbor's German au pair in Season 4 of ''MadMen''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''{{Machete}}'' centers on migrant workers, including the title character who seems to be just a day laborer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The whole point of ''The Help'' by Kathryn Stockett.

to:

* The whole point of ''The Help'' ''TheHelp'' by Kathryn Stockett.
Stockett, and it's 2011 film adaptation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lupe, Lucille's put-upon maid, in ''ArrestedDevelopment''. The stereotype is subverted in "Staff Infection," where (via one of the series' trademark chain of events solely subject to FinaglesLaw) Lindsay tries to put an end to a strike using Latino scabs, who turn out to be Lupe's family (whom Michael had directed to meet their bus for their Catalina Island family reunion at the Bluth Company's parking lot), at least one of whom is a professor of something-or-other.

to:

* Lupe, Lucille's put-upon maid, in ''ArrestedDevelopment''.''Series/ArrestedDevelopment''. The stereotype is subverted in "Staff Infection," where (via one of the series' trademark chain of events solely subject to FinaglesLaw) Lindsay tries to put an end to a strike using Latino scabs, who turn out to be Lupe's family (whom Michael had directed to meet their bus for their Catalina Island family reunion at the Bluth Company's parking lot), at least one of whom is a professor of something-or-other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected as I saw the movie recently and realized I wrote the entry up wrong.


* For about ten seconds, there's an unnamed black housekeeper visible in ''[=~Miracle on 34th Street~=]'' early in the film whose entire purpose is to tell Dorothy Walker where her daughter is and then never be seen again.

to:

* For about ten seconds, there's an unnamed black housekeeper visible in ''[=~Miracle on 34th Street~=]'' features a housekeeper named Cleo early in the film whose entire purpose is to tell Dorothy Walker where her daughter is and then never be seen again.again. She's later referenced by Mr. Gailey when he takes Susan up to the store, but that's the last reference to her. She was played by an uncredited Theresa Harris, who had a long acting career of mostly bit parts, a great deal of which were maids.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One recurring figure from this period is the "mammy", a nursemaid who would continue to provide an important mothering role well into adulthood. The Black Maid, Black Farmhand and Black Railroad Worker are also common. There are a lot of parallels between 'mammy' types and {{Magical Negro}}es.

to:

One recurring figure from this period is the "mammy", {{Mammy}}, a nursemaid who would continue to provide an important mothering role well into adulthood. The Black Maid, Black Farmhand and Black Railroad Worker are also common. There are a lot of parallels between 'mammy' {{Mammy}} types and {{Magical Negro}}es.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also, Martha Jones is stuck as a maid in the Human Nature/Family of Blood episodes in ''Series/DoctorWho''. But it seems a little bit different in her case, in that she's basically the undisputed protagonist for those episodes, the other characters are blatantly prejudiced toward her and she tries to demonstrate to them how wrong they are, and she's usually a [[HospitalHottie med student]].

to:

* Also, Martha Jones is stuck as a maid in the Human Nature/Family ''Series/DoctorWho'' two-parter "Human Nature"/"The Family of Blood episodes in ''Series/DoctorWho''.Blood". But it seems a little bit different in her case, in that she's basically the undisputed protagonist for those episodes, the other characters are blatantly prejudiced toward her and she tries to demonstrate to them how wrong they are, and she's usually a [[HospitalHottie med student]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A particularly insulting "Mammy" example can be seen with Eulabelle in ''{{Horror of Party Beach}}'', which was mercilessly called out and attacked in the episode of ''MST3K'' that featured it. The actress actually was named Eulabelle Moore, and her few acting credits have her playing the same type of role, though this was the only one to use her real name. Amusingly, Eulabelle is one of the only characters in the film to display any sort of common sense about the titular horror.

to:

* A particularly insulting "Mammy" example can be seen with Eulabelle in ''{{Horror of Party Beach}}'', which was mercilessly called out and attacked in the episode of ''MST3K'' that featured it. The actress actually was named Eulabelle Moore, and her few acting credits have her playing the same type of role, though this was the only one to use her real name. Amusingly, Eulabelle is one of the only characters in the film to display any sort of common sense about the titular eponymous horror.



* The titular character in ''[[MaidInManhattan Maid in Manhattan]]''
* Blanca from ''Fun With Dick and Jane''
* ''Meet The Fockers'' has Isabel, the Fockers' former housekeeper who runs a catering business. When she was working for the titular family, main character Greg lost his virginity to her. She also has a son, which leads to Jack (the father of Greg's fiancee Pam) trying to find out if Greg is the father of said son. [[spoiler:He isn't.]]

to:

* The titular eponymous character in ''[[MaidInManhattan Maid in Manhattan]]''
* Blanca from ''Fun With Dick and Jane''
''FunWithDickAndJane''
* ''Meet The Fockers'' ''MeetTheFockers'' has Isabel, the Fockers' former housekeeper who runs a catering business. When she was working for the titular eponymous family, main character Greg lost his virginity to her. She also has a son, which leads to Jack (the father of Greg's fiancee Pam) trying to find out if Greg is the father of said son. [[spoiler:He isn't.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One recurring figure from this period is the "mammy", a nursemaid who would continue to provide an important mothering role well into adulthood. The Black Maid, Black Farmhand and Black Railroad Worker are also common. There are a lot of parallels between 'mammy' types and {{Magical Negro}}es. There's the same thing of the character being respected and positive, even though they're always secondary, so that somehow makes them OK.

to:

One recurring figure from this period is the "mammy", a nursemaid who would continue to provide an important mothering role well into adulthood. The Black Maid, Black Farmhand and Black Railroad Worker are also common. There are a lot of parallels between 'mammy' types and {{Magical Negro}}es. There's the same thing of the character being respected and positive, even though they're always secondary, so that somehow makes them OK.
Negro}}es.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also, Martha Jones is stuck as a maid in the Human Nature/Family of Blood episodes in ''DoctorWho''. But it seems a little bit different in her case, in that she's basically the undisputed protagonist for those episodes, the other characters are blatantly prejudiced toward her and she tries to demonstrate to them how wrong they are, and she's usually a [[HospitalHottie med student]].

to:

* Also, Martha Jones is stuck as a maid in the Human Nature/Family of Blood episodes in ''DoctorWho''.''Series/DoctorWho''. But it seems a little bit different in her case, in that she's basically the undisputed protagonist for those episodes, the other characters are blatantly prejudiced toward her and she tries to demonstrate to them how wrong they are, and she's usually a [[HospitalHottie med student]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The whole point of ''The Help'' by Kathryn Stockett.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->-TomLehrer.

to:

-->-TomLehrer.
-->--TomLehrer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


They continued this role far into the next period, working alongside the Black slave and later Black Laborer.

to:

They continued this role far into the next period, working alongside the Black slave and later Black Laborer.
Laborer. (In the ante-bellum DeepSouth, they were hired for the work that was too dangerous for slaves, since it was cheaper to hire a new one than buy a new slave.)

Removed: 99

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** TruthInTelevision for the 2000s era Chicago. At least, for some subcontractors/maintenance work.

Changed: 140

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One recurring figure from this period is the "mammy", a nursemaid who would continue to provide an important mothering role well into adulthood. The Black Maid, Black Farmhand and Black Railroad Worker are also common. There are a lot of parallels between 'mammy' types and {{Magical Negro}}es (a concept further viciously DeConstructed in the theory of the "house negro" and the "field negro"). They're almost the DistaffCounterpart. There's the same thing of the character being respected and positive, even though they're always secondary, so that somehow makes them OK.

to:

One recurring figure from this period is the "mammy", a nursemaid who would continue to provide an important mothering role well into adulthood. The Black Maid, Black Farmhand and Black Railroad Worker are also common. There are a lot of parallels between 'mammy' types and {{Magical Negro}}es (a concept further viciously DeConstructed in the theory of the "house negro" and the "field negro"). They're almost the DistaffCounterpart.Negro}}es. There's the same thing of the character being respected and positive, even though they're always secondary, so that somehow makes them OK.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Irish immigrants to the United States were often considered "backwards" and only fit for menial labor. This led to many of them having no choice but to accept such jobs. Female immigrants often worked as washerwomen or maids; the term "bidie" or "bridget" meaning "maid" stems from their prevalence in that field. Males worked on farms, on the railroads, and at similar, back-breaking tasks. OfficerOHara is a subtrope of this.

to:

Irish immigrants to the United States were often considered "backwards" and only fit for menial labor. This led to many of them having no choice but to accept such jobs. Female immigrants often worked as washerwomen or maids; the term "bidie" "bridie" or "bridget" meaning "maid" stems from their prevalence in that field. Males worked on farms, on the railroads, and at similar, back-breaking tasks. OfficerOHara is a subtrope of this.
ccoa MOD

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Baz Luhrmann's modern-day version of ''[=~William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet~=]'' turned the [[strike:maid]] nurse Hispanic.

to:

* Baz Luhrmann's modern-day version of ''[=~William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet~=]'' turned the [[strike:maid]] nurse Hispanic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC:{{Webcomics}}]]
* SequentialArt has "Crazy Sven". Though he's actually a taxicab driver.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I love potholes!


* Hattie [=McDaniel=] played the role of many a Black maid, including Scarlett O'Hara's mammy in ''GoneWithTheWind''. She reputedly said that she'd rather play a maid for a weekly wage of $700 than be a maid for a weekly wage of $7.

to:

* Hattie [=McDaniel=] played [[TypeCasting the role of many a Black maid, maid]], including Scarlett O'Hara's mammy in ''GoneWithTheWind''. She reputedly said that she'd rather play a maid [[MoneyDearBoy for a weekly wage of $700 $700]] than be a maid for a weekly wage of $7.

Changed: 49

Removed: 61

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Baz Luhrmann's modern-day {{remake}} of ''RomeoAndJuliet'' turned the [[strike:maid]] nurse Hispanic.

to:

* Baz Luhrmann's modern-day {{remake}} version of ''RomeoAndJuliet'' ''[=~William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet~=]'' turned the [[strike:maid]] nurse Hispanic.



----
<<|CharactersAndCasting|>>
<<|RaceTropes|>>
<<|ServantTropes|>>

to:

----
<<|CharactersAndCasting|>>
<<|RaceTropes|>>
<<|ServantTropes|>>
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Irish Laborers'''

to:

'''Irish Laborers'''
!!Irish Laborers
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''The Irish Laborer'''

to:

'''The Irish Laborer'''
'''Irish Laborers'''

Added: 591

Changed: 36

Removed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Chinese Laborers
* ChineseLaborer
* ChineseLaunderer

!!Black Laborers

to:

!!Chinese Laborers
* ChineseLaborer
* ChineseLaunderer

!!Black Laborers
'''The Irish Laborer'''


Added DiffLines:

* In a rare modern example English actress Alice Eve [[FakeIrish played]] an Irish nanny in the second ''SexAndTheCity'' movie.

[[AC:WesternAnimation]]
* As noted below Mammy Two-Shoes in ''TomAndJerry'' was redrawn (and voiced) as an Irish maid.
* In an episode of ''TheSimpsons'' Marge is cleaning her house because she's afraid that a hired cleaning lady will gossip about how dirty it is. In her imagination three cleaning ladies with extremely sterotypical [[{{Oireland}} Oirish]] accents do just that.

!!Chinese Laborers
* ChineseLaborer
* ChineseLaunderer

!!Black Laborers

[[AC:{{Film}}]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**TruthInTelevision for the 2000s era Chicago. At least, for some subcontractors/maintenance work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Sam and Dinah Johnson, the resident handyman and cook of ''TheBobbseyTwins'' respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On {{South Park}}, you can hire the Mexicans at the Home Depot to read your Hemingway assignment. Just be clear when you ask them to write the essays.

to:

* On Also played with on {{South Park}}, you where one can hire the Mexicans at the Home Depot to read do your Hemingway assignment. Just (home)work. Twist is, they are quite competent when it comes to writing English essays on Hemmingway (just be clear when you ask them to write the essays.essays), or teach math.

Top