Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / EthnicMenialLabor

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* In the ''Series/{{Friends}}'' episode "The One With the Baby Shower", it's revealed that when Rachel was a child, she had a Latina nanny:
-->'''Rachel''': Mrs. K. Oh, she was sweet! She taught me Spanish. Actually, I think I remember some of it. ''Tu madre es loca!''\\
'''Mrs Green''': ''(oblivious)'' Such a sweet woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicBook/JewGangster'': Ruby's family are Jewish immigrants from Poland. His father Isaac works in a sweatshop as a fabric cutter, while his mother cooks for a small restaurant she runs from a rented storefront.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/{{Polandball}}'' comics often have Polandball working as Britain's plumber.

to:

* ''Webcomic/{{Polandball}}'' comics often have Polandball Poland working as Britain's plumber.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', the groundskeeper for Mary's condo building is Latino, and in fact appears to be [[MonochromeCasting the only person of colour in the entire town]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Comic Strips]]
* Played straight in ''ComicStrip/MadamAndEve'', which revolves around a black housekeeper (Eve Sisulu) and her middle-class white "Madam" (boss) Gwen Anderson.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/EccentricNeighborhoods: In 1950s Puerto Rico, wealthy matriarch Clarissa cannot find household help among locals because she is a MeanBoss. In the end, she hires a Guatemalan maid through an agency, but it does not occur to her or anybody that Xochil might be indigenous. Clarissa is floored when Xochil arrives in her traditional Mayan dress.

to:

* ''Literature/EccentricNeighborhoods: ''Literature/EccentricNeighborhoods'': In 1950s Puerto Rico, wealthy matriarch Clarissa cannot find household help among locals because she is a MeanBoss. In the end, she hires a Guatemalan maid through an agency, but it does not occur to her or anybody that Xochil might be indigenous. Clarissa is floored when Xochil arrives in her a traditional Mayan dress. dress and bare feet.



* ''Literature/TheHouseOnTheLagoon'': Whenever any of the Mendizábal daughters has a baby, she must have a nanny. These nannies and additional posts are filled by members of Petra's family. Petra, a Puerto Rican descendent of enslaved Africans, has been working for the Mendizábal since the beginning.

to:

* ''Literature/TheHouseOnTheLagoon'': Whenever any of the Mendizábal daughters has a baby, she must have a nanny. These nannies and additional posts are filled by members of Petra's family. Petra, a Puerto Rican descendent of enslaved Africans, has been working for the Mendizábal family since the beginning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Denial}}''. David Irving argues that he can't be racist because he employs black and Asian servants, saying that "some of them have very beautiful breasts." The dumbfounded reporter has to ask him to repeat that.

Added: 205

Changed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheJapaneseLover'' most of Irina's coworkers at a nursing home come from Mexico, Guatemala, and Haiti and earn low wages. She learns enough Spanish and French to make friends among them.



* ''Literature/ALongPetalOfTheSea'' takes place in Chile, a Spanish-speaking country. Here, the ethnic menial labor is of Indigenous ancestry. Juana Nancucheo, a woman of Mapuche ancestry starts working for the Vizcarra family when [[ChildLabor she is around six or seven]]. Then when daughter Laura Vizcarra marries Isidro del Solar, she brings Juana with her. Juana stays with the family for decades. After a centenarian Laura dies, Juana moves in with Laura's son Felipe.

to:

* ''Literature/ALongPetalOfTheSea'' takes place in Chile, a Spanish-speaking country. Here, country and the ethnic menial labor is of Indigenous ancestry. indigenous origin. Juana Nancucheo, a woman of Mapuche ancestry starts working for the Vizcarra family when [[ChildLabor [[OldRetainer she is around six or seven]]. Then when daughter Laura Vizcarra marries Isidro del Solar, she brings Juana with her. Juana stays with the family for decades. After a centenarian Laura dies, Juana moves in with Laura's son Felipe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TriangleOfSadness'': On the cruise ship, the passengers and "upstairs crew" of servers and attendees are predominantly Caucasian, while the "downstairs crew" of cleaners are predominantly Filipino. It becomes played with when they are stranded on a deserted shoreline and the Filipino cleaner Abigail is the only one with any survival skills, eventually ending up in charge of the mostly-white upperclass Caucasian survivors.

to:

* ''Film/TriangleOfSadness'': On the cruise ship, the passengers and "upstairs crew" of servers and attendees are predominantly Caucasian, while the "downstairs crew" of cleaners are predominantly Filipino.Filipino with a couple of Middle-Easterners in-between. It becomes played with when they are stranded on a deserted shoreline and the Filipino cleaner Abigail is the only one with any survival skills, eventually ending up in charge of the mostly-white upperclass Caucasian survivors.

Removed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now defunct


In modern incarnations, the ethnic group is often one of the AcceptableEthnicTargets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Language


Throughout history, there have been stereotypes that certain ethnicities are more prevalent in menial labor such as line cooks, maids, cleaners, nannies, and farmhands, often in service to white characters. This stereotype is often an exaggerated case of the truth: Certain minority groups ''have'' indeed been over-represented in menial jobs due to a variety of factors, such as colonial history, refugee status, and the immigration patterns of the creator's country. In PoliticallyCorrectHistory this will be carefully sidestepped, but in accurate or exaggerated {{Period Piece}}s and HistoricalFiction, the older versions of this trope can still be found.

In American works, an early propensity for Irish and {{Chinese|Laborer}} laborers in fiction as been replaced by Hispanic and Southeast Asian characters in contemporary times. Black workers were common post-slavery, and remain today in modern examples of {{Mammy}} and (occasionally) MagicalNegro. Western European works will feature Eastern European or North African characters in blue-collar jobs. Works set in Latin America might have indigenous menial labor to the Spanish-descended upper class. For the specific reasons, see [[Analysis/EthnicMenialLabor the analysis page]].

Reasons for choosing blue-collar work might be TheIllegal (they don't want to risk deportation by working for a reputable employer) or WorthlessForeignDegree (they are professionals in their home countries, but these credentials aren't recognized).

to:

Throughout history, there have been stereotypes that certain ethnicities are more prevalent in menial labor such as line cooks, maids, cleaners, nannies, and farmhands, often in service to white characters. This stereotype is often an exaggerated case of the truth: Certain minority groups ''have'' indeed been over-represented in menial jobs due to a variety of factors, such as colonial history, refugee status, not knowing the new country's language and the immigration patterns of the creator's country. In PoliticallyCorrectHistory this will be carefully sidestepped, but in accurate or exaggerated {{Period Piece}}s and HistoricalFiction, the older versions of this trope can still be found.

In American works, an early propensity for Irish and {{Chinese|Laborer}} laborers in fiction as been replaced by Hispanic and Southeast Asian characters in contemporary times. Black workers were common post-slavery, and remain today in modern examples of {{Mammy}} (a serving woman) and (occasionally) MagicalNegro. Western European works will feature Eastern European or North African characters in blue-collar jobs. Works set in Latin America might have indigenous menial labor to working for the Spanish-descended upper class. For the specific reasons, see [[Analysis/EthnicMenialLabor the analysis page]].

Reasons for choosing blue-collar work might be TheIllegal (they don't want to risk deportation by working for a reputable employer) employer), not knowing the new country's language, or WorthlessForeignDegree (they are professionals in their home countries, but these credentials aren't recognized).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Franchise/SuperMarioBros'': Prior to their more stable jobs as [[VideoGameSuperMarioBros1 plumbers]], Italians (Italian-American in the old American continuity) Mario and Luigi worked several blue-collar jobs among the [[NewJobsAsThePlotDemands many]] they've done. Mario debuted as a [[VideoGame/DonkeyKong construction worker]], while he and Luigi would go on to do [[VideoGame/GameAndWatch factory work]], [[VideoGame/MarioBros pest control]], and [[VideoGame/WreckingCrew demolition]].

to:

* ''Franchise/SuperMarioBros'': Prior to their more stable jobs as [[VideoGameSuperMarioBros1 [[VideoGame/SuperMarioBros1 plumbers]], Italians (Italian-American in the old American continuity) Mario and Luigi worked several blue-collar jobs among the [[NewJobsAsThePlotDemands many]] they've done. Mario debuted as a [[VideoGame/DonkeyKong construction worker]], while he and Luigi would go on to do [[VideoGame/GameAndWatch factory work]], [[VideoGame/MarioBros pest control]], and [[VideoGame/WreckingCrew demolition]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Franchise/SuperMarioBros'': Prior to their more stable jobs as [[VideoGameSuperMarioBros1 plumbers]], Italians (Italian-American in the old American continuity) Mario and Luigi worked several blue-collar jobs among the [[NewJobsAsThePlotDemands many]] they've done. Mario debuted as a [[VideoGame/DonkeyKong construction worker]], while he and Luigi would go on to do [[VideoGame/GameAndWatch factory work]], [[VideoGame/MarioBros pest control]], and [[VideoGame/WreckingCrew demolition]].

Top