YMMV / Sega Superstars

The series may provide examples of:

  • Broken Base:
    • The "Clone" characters (Gum, Reala, Pudding and MeeMee) have gotten this reception. Fans of the franchises they come from like them, but others dislike them for being to similar to the original characters (Beat, NiGHTS, Ulala and AiAi), and would have preferred other franchises to be represented instead.
  • Ear Worm: Almost all of the songs are taken directly from the source games, so those songs that you can see under Ear Worm in the pages for Jet Set Radio and Samba de Amigo have found their way here as well. See also: Awesome Music.
  • Gateway Series: The series has helped bring new fans into old franchises. In particular, thanks to Transformed, a lot of people have become interested in trying out Skies of Arcadia, Panzer Dragoon and Burning Rangers and have even joined those asking for HD re-releases.
  • Most Annoying Sound:
    • Beat's "Go-go-gooooo!" line. Made even more annoying by the fact that he says it practically every time he scores a point in Superstars Tennis. Thankfully, he doesn't say it as much in Transformed.
    • The announcer in All-Stars Racing, who never shuts up. There's a reason they give you an option to turn him off. That said, many adore him because his lines are hilarious and said with Narm Charm.

Sega Superstars Tennis may provide examples of:

  • That One Level: Just TRY to get through the 8000 points Space Harrier Level on your first try.

Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing may provide examples of:

Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed may provide examples of:

  • 8.8:
  • Awesome Music: It has its own page.
  • Base Breaker:
    • Particular attention goes to Simon Lane of the Yogscast; to say that fans of the game weren't pleased with his announcement would be an understatement. The roots of this backlash can be found in the DLC character poll taken over a year priornote , combined with the fact that Simon previously had nothing to do with Sega prior to his appearance as DLC. The fact that all of the money made from the DLC goes straight to charity has actually made the backlash worse due to accusations that the DLC was created as a publicity stunt by Sega. The Simon supporters, on the other hand, silently made him outsell Metal Sonic by a wide margin on day one.
    • The final unlockable racer, AGES, a Composite Character of Daytona USA, After Burner, and the Dreamcast. One group loves this character for being an Unexpected Character who represents SEGA as a whole, while another group thinks it's taken up a spot on the roster that a more deserving character didn't get.
  • Best Level Ever:
    • Rogues' Landing is an insanely fun track to play, taking you through the docks, over the floating islands, through a sky tunnel and across a lake (or around it if you prefer) with a great layout, all with an awesome backdrop of the Valuan Empire flying overhead and attacking the islands. But it becomes truly amazing on the transition to Lap 3, when you're confined solely to the air and have to follow the Delphinus towards the Hydra, flying between Valuan and Blue Rogue airships shooting at one another. The final island even has a Valuan ship crash into it for dramatic effect admist the war and race. All this is set to exceptional music which really drives the atmosphere for the laps, and it's not a stretch to say it feels like you're actually playing Skies of Arcadia, at least ship travel-wise. Add in all the fan-pleasing cameos that still add something to those who have never played Skies like Rhaknam circling under the islands and you've got yourself an amazing, memorable level. And the cherry on top? When Sumo presented the Skies of Arcadia level to the game's original producer for feedback, she was moved close to tears. You know a level is amazing when you get a reaction like that.
    • Burning Depths is this for those who don't consider it That One Level, due to being amazing for drifting and boosting once you've got the hang of it, having an amazing atmosphere with backdrafts of fires exploding everywhere and the track progressively flooding. Chris's navigation lines are also a fantastic touch for the setting, as well as having the Burning Rangers fly around the track constantly. Did we mention how amazing the song is and how it goes hand in hand with the track?
    • Galactic Parade gets a lot of love for its ease, wide track and simplicity.
    • Adder's Lair is loved for epic visuals and an incredible remix of "Wilderness".
  • Broken Base:
    • NiGHTS and Reala being vehicles instead of actual characters are also victims of this.
    • The removal of several characters from the first racing title, most notably Ryo Hazuki and Opa-Opa.
    • The fact that the PC version has received a steady release of exclusive DLC characters while the console versions have been left to stagnate is also beginning to cause a bit of a rift between the console buyers who feel cheated out of content and the PC buyers who feel that having to wait for their copies entitled them to the extra content.
      • The matter was only made worse when Ryo finally appeared as a DLC character after winning the poll, but not for the console releases.
      • The DLC character choices themselves also split the base. Aside from Simon as mentioned above, some diehard fans of Sega's classic console and arcade properties aren't as familiar with Company of Heroes, Total War or Football Manager, all PC games and the latter two published by Sega, which left them scratching their heads who the characters were and were upset at Sega's decision to include them instead of characters from classic properties. Players familiar with the said games were perfectly fine considering the DLC was free, and many loved General Winter's wacky characterization.
    • While some fans were happy that Ristar ended up with a much bigger role than his cameo in the first title, many were upset that he still wasn't playable.
    • The DLC character poll. Fans used it in hopes to bring back characters who didn't return from the previous game, others tried to suggest bringing in other classic characters who didn't appear in the previous game, while others opted for new faces. But a good portion of fans were displeased that one of the characters leading the polls and appeared to be the most likely to win was the Vocaloid Miku Hatsune, who was commonly mistaken as a Sega IP at the time, and a Base Breaker within the Sega fandom even then note . While her supporters outside the Sega fandom came in droves to use the chance to get her to appear in the game and boost her exposure, detractors felt an actual Sega character was more deserving of the slot instead of a character that was relatively unknown to the game's core demographic and had a niche presence outside Japan, especially at the time. But there were also those who wouldn't mind it if she appeared in the game if it meant exposing the game to a wider audience, boosting sales and potentially building interest in Sega's classic properties. It didn't help that some of Miku's fans made it clear that they'd only buy the game if she was in it and weren't interested in the game otherwise or the other properties it represented. Ultimately, she didn't appear in the game due to licensing issues and Ryo was declared the winner of the poll regardless.
  • Ear Worm:
  • Good Bad Bugs:
    • A flaw in Alex Kidd's A.I. makes him race horribly. He'll often get stuck.
    • Sonic and Tails, when using specific mods, have performance that doesn't match their stats. This results them in having superior performance compared to the rest of the playable characters.
  • Game Breaker: Sonic and Tails, thanks to the fact that they're glitched using certain mods.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
    • All instances of Team Fortress 2 characters coming up when discussing the eponymous protagonist of Wreck-It Ralph (and vice versa) come full circle now that both are part of the roster for the PC version of the game.
    • Either this or harsher, depending on your point of view, but Bayonetta was considered for Transformed but eventually denied due to the developers not figuring out a way to keep her in-character while maintaining the rating. She would go on to star in a much higher profile crossover that operated under similar content restrictions.
    • As mentioned below, many people felt this game copied Mario Kart 7 with the water and air sections. Then Mario Kart 8 introduced anti-gravity, which both this game and the previous one utilized.
  • Just Here for Godzilla: Some fans bought the PC version of the game just because it had Team Fortress 2 characters racing in it.
  • Mondegreen: One of the lines shared by Meemee and Aiai when passing the player sounds like they're dropping a F-bomb on you. 3DS players are going to hear this a lot because of how the game is coded.
  • Most Annoying Sound: Simon Lane's high pitch "AAAAAAAUGH!" cry, which he makes whenever he passes another racer.
  • Most Wonderful Sound: The announcer yelling "All-Star!" You know you're ready to blast ahead when you hear it.
  • Nightmare Fuel: Allow this video to explain. Beat's skeleton doesn't even remotely resemble the human anatomy.
  • The Scrappy: Danica Patrick. Audiences and critics alike have criticized her for being unfitting in the game, considering unlike the other guest racers like Ralph or Team Fortress, she's not a video game character, she doesn't have any connection to video games like Simon Lane, and has hardly any connection to SEGA.
  • That One Level:
    • Burning Depths, the penultimate track in the game (not counting the Classic Cup), consists of a lot of extremely tight turns along very narrow corridors, and it's entirely different each lap. It's quite possibly the hardest track in the whole game. In contrast the final track, Race of Ages, is practically a Breather Level in comparison.
    • Chilly Castle has its share of awkward turns.
  • That One Sidequest: Traffic Attack challenges drive many players insane the most out of all the World Tour missions.
  • They Changed It, Now It Sucks: The Speed Star. It got more "realistic" and "modern". No announcer and the interface can count, too.
    • Also the watering down of the All Star moves. Where before, each character got a character specific skill or transformation, now it's a generic switch to jet form with limited attacks.
  • They Copied It, So It Sucks: Some Mario Kart fans accused Transformed of ripping off 7 just because it had similar vehicle transformation sections on water and in the sky. The producer retorted by saying that they were actually surprised that Mario Kart 7 had transformation sections as they started the game's development in November 2010, whereas no one knew about Mario Kart 7's features until the E3 2011 trailer, and that the boating and flying sections are very much different from MK7's underwater and gliding sections. In fact, Transformed better resembles Diddy Kong Racing than Mario Kart 7.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character: DJ Professor K of Jet Set Radio comments at the beginning of each lap in Graffiti City. Could you imagine if he did commentary for the entire race? Or how about if he was the announcer for the game?
  • Uncanny Valley:
  • What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs?: Sunshine Tour, Samba Studios, and Dream Valley.