- Jossed by Word of God, as seen here.
- He laughs it off, but he doesn't actually offer a better explanation. Of course it's a scary story fitting for Halloween, but why would that make it invalid? I posit that not only every comic since, but also every comic before the 23rd are part of the delusion. And Davis doesn't know.
- Considering Davis created and owns the IP to Garfield, he would know better than anyone else.
- He laughs it off, but he doesn't actually offer a better explanation. Of course it's a scary story fitting for Halloween, but why would that make it invalid? I posit that not only every comic since, but also every comic before the 23rd are part of the delusion. And Davis doesn't know.
- Maybe it's a good thing he didn't try to get out of the ruined house. Who knows what he would've found wandering around out there...
The town has been re-populated, but coal fires continue to burn underground. Jon's supposed Flanderization as the strip progresses is a result of the subtle smoke from the underground slowly damaging his mind, which would also explain Irma's "slow in the head" demeanor. (It's possible that Liz's sharpness results from her living and working on the edge of town, away from the most concentrated coal fires underground) The town, for the most part, lived in peace, unaware of the unspeakable things lurking within the lower two "planes" of its existence.
But in one week in 1989, something happened: the town called for Garfield the cat, and like James before him, poor Garfield had no choice but to answer.
In the infamous Halloween week series of strips, Garfield awoke within the second "plane" of Silent Hill: the seemingly-abandoned, broken-down town.
Silent Hill, mind, does not tend to pull in its chew toys without a good reason: one of the key reasons a protagonist will find themselves drawn to Silent Hill is a sort of guilt within them, an internal conflict as brutal as the creatures they encounter within the town. With that in mind, let's look at Garfield.
He's a lazy Jerkass who takes Kick the Dog to a literal extent, who spends his time deriding and lashing out against Jon, the only person in the world who even gives him the time of day. These attitudes have been pushing him away from everyone else in his life, creating an unparalleled sense of isolation; the Town finally makes him confront this fact with a terrifyingly real depiction of where this road will take him. Garfield is forced to come to grips with the simple fact, which he states in anguish: "I don't want to be alone!"
And suddenly, everything is back to normal; Jon and Odie are there, and the dessicated landscape is replaced by normality. He had learned what the Town tried to teach him, rather quickly; thus, he was allowed to return from it. It's quite a good thing he did not leave the house, as well; Silent Hill aficionados know well that an empty room is far, far preferrable to the things lurking elsewhere.
But it didn't take him long to resume his Jerkass ways. Thus, the Town may soon call on him once more, to teach a more permanent lesson...
- For clarity, this would mean it was the movie version of Silent Hill, as in the games the "normal" version is an ordinary resort town, with no coal fires to speak of.
- Real Life injection: The October 28, '89 strips started to gain wide Internet attention around the same time period parodies like Garfield Minus Garfield started to become big. Shortly after that, so did Allegro Non Troppo when people started accusing Jim Davis of having ripped it off for these strips. If you're willing to believe Davis, the "rip-off" theory itself is Jossed.
- Odie: Oh, boy, oh, boy, it's a brand new day with brand-new adventures and brand-new discoveries to be had and new friends to meet and I can't wait to go outside and enjoy this lovely, beautiful, sunny, sunny morning with no clouds in the sky and it's a beautiful lovely morning and I can't wait to start this brand-new day with new things to do and places to go! Ooh, there's a lump in a box with a blue blanket covering it up! I bet something is under this blue-colored blanket that is blue! I want to see what it is! It's an orange kitty! Ooh, it's Garfield! Oh, boy! Oh, boy! I love you, Garfield! Can I lick your face? I am licking your face now because you are my friend and I love you! I love you I love youIloveyouIloveyouIloveyou! Owie! Garfield hit me in the nosey! My nosey hurts and it is painful! Owie! Oh, well, it was probably an accident, so it is okay now! I will go get my dingleball now because I want to play! I want Garfield to throw the dingleball so I can fetch it because I love fetch and it is my favoritest favorite game ever and I love it! I have my dingleball now! Come on Garfield! Let's play! Hey, Garfield! Let's play! Let's play fetch! Come on! Throw the ball so I can fetch it! Let's play! Come on! Let's go play! Let's play fetch! Come on, let's go play! Let's play! (etc...)
If Odie had thoughts, hyperactive Odie would never shut up.
- Think about it. We all know from day one that Jon is a cartoonist, but we never see what strip he draws, so who's to say it's not Garfield itself? Plus, they were both born July 28, and "Jon" and "Jim" booth start with "J" and go Consonant-Vowel-Consonant.
- The last strip will have Jon and Garfield going on their usual antics, but in the last panel, it zooms out to Jim Davis working on the computer on the comic (since the strip is computer-generated now) with a realistic Garfield next to him and realistic versions of all the human characters (even Lyman) watching him.
- Garfield is a completely normal cat in real life, but Jon loves his cat and is inspired by his IRL Garfield's affinity for human food, occasional spats with Odie, etc.
- He killed his best friend Lyman because he wanted his dog.
- What's so unusual or strange about talking to a cat?
- Jon's not suicidal. Low self-esteem, sometimes; but he's energetic and enthusiastic too often to be depressed, much less suicidal. On the other hand, some kind of mild psychosis...
- Reality is unrealistic. Many a suicidal person can appear normal enough in public — even moreso for depression, especially if meds are a factor. We do frequently see Jon being enthusiastic and upbeat in private, though. Perhaps bipolar disorder? He does seem to have manic episodes, come to think of it... Or else he includes Garfield (whom he thinks is sapient and cartoon) among the "people" he needs to maintain his act for.
- The manic states lend credence to the bipolar theory, but don't necessarily joss the depression. Reality Is Unrealistic indeed, as depressed people can still have upbeat times even in private, and in some cases these aren't infrequent.
- Reality is unrealistic. Many a suicidal person can appear normal enough in public — even moreso for depression, especially if meds are a factor. We do frequently see Jon being enthusiastic and upbeat in private, though. Perhaps bipolar disorder? He does seem to have manic episodes, come to think of it... Or else he includes Garfield (whom he thinks is sapient and cartoon) among the "people" he needs to maintain his act for.
- A couple websites have tried imagining what the comic would actually look like if we saw this from an objective view. Realfield presents edited comic strips that have replaced the wise-cracking, bipedal cartoon cat with a much more realistic one that reacts just like a real cat (that is to say, hardly at all) while leaving Jon's behavior untouched. Meanwhile, Garfield Minus Garfield takes it a step further by removing the cat altogether, which leaves us with Jon literally talking to himself "as he fights a losing battle against loneliness in a quiet American suburb."
- This also explains why his dates tend to run away from him in terror.
- Also of note is Arbuckle, a project started by Tailsteak, but thrown to the viewing public. (Who haven't been doing much lately...)
- Are Liz and the Mailman hallucinating, too? Maybe they're both in Jon's head, too... but that still wouldn't account for the stuff that happens when Jon isn't around to hallucinate it. Maybe it's all Jon's dream - or all someone's dream.
What we've been taking as normal flanderization has been deliberate. Jon is suffering from schizophrenia, and the series is showing the account via an unreliable cat narrator. We don't see him working because he's on disability, or his parents have been funneling him money to support him. His assorted freakouts and "comedic" moments are how Garfield sees him react to his delusions and hallucinations.
Right now in the series, he seems to be having a moment of normalcy, perhaps because he's gone on medication and Garfield hasn't noticed. He seems to have gotten his life together slightly; he's begun dressing normally again (this most recent weekend had Jon wearing a somewhat ratty brown suit, purple shirt and matching checkered tie — it may sound a little unusual, but it's more basic and less eye-burning than his former standard outfit, a yellow plaid jacket, neon green tie, and massive daisy in lapel) and dating Liz.
However, this could just be a Hope Spot. Jon's schizophrenia may yet lead to him having a massive freakout that scares even Liz away.
- Of course Jon's insanity may be a result of Garfield's deliberate attempts to drive Jon insane Gone Horribly Right.
- This has been Jossed by Garfield's Judgement Day, where it is revealed that Garfield - and by extension, all cats - can talk, and the fact that nobody (not even Jon) could communicate with them before is a plot point.
- He is too lazy to use it much.
- They look similar, and Garfield's mother is named Sonja.
- He once used it on Lyman.
- Scarily enough, Garfield actually has a "Depth Note" in Garfield Gets Real (probably a 3D gag, as Gets Real was Garfield's first All-CGI Cartoon). So this is highly plausible.
- Near gave a speech at the end of Death Note about how a normal person might have tried the Death Note once, as a gag, and then would've been horrified, guilt-stricken and locked it up as soon he realized that it actually works. Clearly Jon is that normal person. He tested it on Lyman after they had an argument over the chores, found out it's real when Lyman died, and has kept it hidden ever since (and is taking care of Odie out of guilt). Garfield's hanging around for the lasagna and because Jon hasn't relinquished the Death Note to anyone else, and Jon seems to a bit of a Cloud Cuckoolander because living with the temptation of being able to kill anyone without getting caught would take its toll on anyone (especially when you're the world's Butt-Monkey).
- This also explains why Garfield often seems to be Jon's hallucination: only the people who have touched the Death Note can see Garfield, so most of the time, Jon seems to be talking to himself. Liz, the mailman and a few other humans have, for one reason or another, ended up touching the Death Note by mistake, and Jon takes Garfield to Liz for checkups not only to hit on her, but also to keep her convinced that Garfield's an ordinary cat.
- Living over ten years of age - definitely
- Reaching one kan (3.75 kg or 8.25 lbs) in weight - also definitely
- Growing its tail too long - could be
And he shows several abilities that Bakeneko/Nekomata are known to have:
- Walking on its hind legs: he has done so for years now.
- Menacing sleeping humans: Jon frequently suffers from things Garfield does to him. Several older comics focus on Garfield roughly waking Jon up.
- Talking: in a way, because Jon does apparently understands Garfield's snarkiness according to his facial expressions.
- Changing into a more menacing form, as seen in an early 1978 Halloween comic...
- Will throwing fireballs/snowballs come next?!
- Wow. Must have had a REAL change of heart to discourage being lazy to his new owner.
This is also why the strip stopped following the Arlene/Garfield romance, and why Arlene dropped out of the strip for so long. These aren't the original Garfield and Arlene; in fact, this Arlene could actually be this Garfield's younger sister.
- This explains his odd behaviors and creepiness, not to mention the evil grin he had at the beginning of the Garfield Halloween Special.
- Or he could be one of the Killer Klowns from Outer Space.
- She never shows her teeth even once which indicates that she doesn't want Garfield to suspect her true identity(which explains why she doesn't correct Garfield when he addresses her as Mai Tai) and start matching wits with her nor to start insulting the gap between her teeth.
- I think Odie really is dumb, but not THAT dumb, and the other characters simply overestimate how dumb he really is, partially due to the fact that the others can't understand his thoughts. I believe that Odie does have thoughts, but is unable to transmit his thoughts to the others due to a brain injury of some sort when he was a puppy, possibly from Garfield being abusive to him as usual. Sort of like the whale dude in "Finding Dory" whose ECHO thingy didn't work quite right due to a head injury. He's actually really quite smart for a dog— he can finish a sudoku in record time, order dingleballs off the internet, figure out how to operate Jon's car (which he drove through the house), etc. (I think the "Odie reading War and Peace" strip was a joke and wasn't meant to be taken seriously.) Also, he's a dog; dogs pant and lick and slobber, which is part of the reason why Odie looks so stupid all the time. He does show good judgement sometimes, though. Even when Garfield doesn't. Overall, he's still pretty stupid, but still intelligent enough to function. I think a good example of Odie being "not that dumb" would be the strip from September 7, 2010.◊ To a normal person, it looks like Odie just left the conversation with the purple dog because he's stupid. But the purple dog has been shown to bark at everyone and sometimes become violent and chase them. Odie might know about this. Remember that Odie can't transmit thoughts to others and enjoy my interpretation of what really happened.Purple dog: How's it going?What Odie may be thinking in the first panel: Hmm. I'm not sure about this dog. He's a bit mean. He might be being nice to us to try to trick us! I don't trust this guy. Come on, Garfield, let's go.[Odie turns to leave; however, since his telepathy powers don't work properly, neither Garfield nor the dog register that he's "said" anything, and therefore are surprised when he walks away.][About a second later, Odie realizes that Garfield isn't moving at all.]What Odie may be thinking in the second panel: Well, Garfield, it's your funeral.Purple dog: Has that guy bumped his head?Garfield: More times than you'd believe...
- Or he retired/got a transfer to a better neighborhood. Actually. I think they sort of did that plot in the cartoon, didn't they...?
- Plus they're both young, under-appreciated, and have names that begin with the letter 'L'.
Same physical build? Check.
No appearances together? Check.
- And when Garfield was in the abandoned house that everyone here is obsessed with, he simply traveled too far into the future and momentarily panicked.
- Remember that strip when his past self meet him?◊
- Calvin and Hobbes actually appeared as background characters once.
- Or perhaps Get Fuzzy is a deconstruction of Garfield, being more realistic and edgy than Garfield, and containing more three-dimensional characters.
- He's just not completely aware of it. He can hear most of Garfield's thoughts, and cats can use the Wit to speak with whomever of the Old Blood they choose to, and all the cats you meet in Tawny Man seem to have Garfield's attitude about humans and self-importance.
- That iguana was then bought by a blond nerd, and named Quincy.
- That Cat and Snoopy annoy each other, and the cat likes to destroy Snoopy's Doghouse. It doesn't seem like a stretch that Garfield, who loves to cause Odie pain, wouldn't be up for destroying a doghouse. Plus, there could be another reason as to why Lucy hates dog kisses: Odie keeps kissing her
- That giant foot that squashed Gnorm Gnat at the end of his final comic? That was Jon, on his way home from the pet store after picking up Garfield.
- Even if one thinks they look like raisins, they certainly wouldn't smell the same, especially to a cat. Unless of course Garfield has an unusually poor sense of smell, which is possible since he doesn't seem to use it much.
The strip is ending. And it will end when Jon and Liz get engaged or married.
Note: this comic did what the author intended it to do. And it has been in print for approximately thirty years. He's not doing it for the art; this won't be a 10-Minute Retirement.
- Considering that Jon and Liz have been a couple for over five years, Jossed.
- Jossed. That birthday has come and gone, and no status changes.