Main Tropes Index

Troperville

Editing

Tools

Toys

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

Custom Search

Even Captain America is powerless against these Cosmopolitan, racially diverse civil servants

"Everyone's a hero in their own way.
Everyone's got villains they must face.
They're not as cool as mine,
But folks, you know it's fine
To know your place."
Captain Hammer, Dr Horribles Singalong Blog.

In many works of fiction, the hero does good deeds on a level that would be difficult, if not impossible, for anyone in the real world to emulate. They stop wars, dismantle criminal syndicates, Save The World so often it becomes part of their regular schedule, and never shy away from performing a Heroic Sacrifice (sometimes even giving their lives for the greater good several times). Yet if the hero runs into a firefighter, volunteer worker, or soldier (if they're on the idealistic side of the spectrum), the hero will often make a comment along the lines of, "You guys are the real heroes."

The idea of such a scene is usually to pay tribute to real life heroes who may not have their own TV shows or look like supermodels, but still give of themselves to save other people's lives. This is a noble motive on the writer's part, but it can create some problems if the story's Fourth Wall is firmly in place. The characters don't know they're fictional, after all; from their perspective, Superman tossing a nuclear bomb into outer space is no less real than a firefighter saving someone from a burning building. This can make the audience wonder why the story's hero considers him/herself a lesser hero than some guy who's never even saved the world once. If the main character is a superhero, writers might justify this by pointing out that rushing into danger takes a lot more courage if you're not Nigh Invulnerable.

The rationale for this without making it cheesy even with the Fourth Wall in place is that even though the firefighters and police can't toss a bomb into the sun, they go out every day to do their jobs without superpowers and they save the world on a much smaller scale than Superman or Green Lantern or Spider-Man or Thor is able to. Even in a world with superheroes, they are still real heroes. The people in Emergency Services would just count as heroes for what they do. Then again, if so many stories didn't make them look so ineffectual, it would make more sense to consider them heroes along with the superheroes.

It gets worse. These same heroes will just as soon say "Never Be A Hero".
Examples:
  • Played with in The Non Adventures Of Wonderella: Wonderella, being a Jerkass, refuses to acknowledge The Real Heroes. After all, she has a cape
  • This was pretty much the premise of the kids' show Higglytown Heroes. Although there were no superheroes in that show, it was all about "normal" people being heroic for different reasons.
  • Happens in an episode of The Fairly Odd Parents.
  • Hancock did it... reluctantly.
  • Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal: "Lex Luthor had a much easier time killing all the 'real' superheroes."
  • The Looney Tunes short "Super Rabbit" had Bugs Bunny receive a supply of Supercarrots that turn him into the titular Super-Rabbit. At the end of the cartoon, the carrots run out and Bugs reverts to his old self, at which point he says, "Hmm, this looks like a job for a real hero!" He then runs into a phone booth and emerges wearing a Marine uniform, then he marches off to fight in World War Two.
  • This... Meatloaf... thing..
  • This was the Broken Aesop of Marvel Comics' Civil War event. It didn't exactly make sense within the context of the universe because, you know, Captain America's a real hero too, when you get down to it. Firefighters are brave, and all, but how many of them fight the Serpent Society or the Red Skull? It sort of seems services like the police would be much less appreciated in a comic book world, really.
    • As the page pic show, the above was parodied in I don't need you civil war, these 'real heroes' are "The Nine Elevens", one of Stark's home-brew superteams. They fight for national security.
  • A great number of comic books companies and creators rushed to publish stories featuring The Real Heroes in the aftermath of 9/11. And with good reason. Of course, they probably shouldn't have been set in the mainstream superhero universes considering that A) it didn't make sense that it happened, and B) even if it did, the average supervillain does stuff 10 times worse a couple of times per week, so seeing Doctor Doom and Magneto (especially Magneto, who you may recall is himself a terrorist who has repeatedly tried to kill all nonmutants) cry over it when they've blown up countries was more Narmful than anything.
    • That fact that a few months before 9/11 Magneto turned New York into a death camp didn't help matters either
      • That's why Magneto was crying. He was just jealous he didn't think of it first. (Too Soon?)
  • Subverted and deconstructed in Superman: Doomsday. Superman and Lois discuss a reporter who is going to Afghanistan to cover the war. Superman says that, because he's invulnerable, he's not putting his life on the line when he does what he does, as opposed to the people who are fighting fires, fighting for freedom, and bringing the truth of such feats to the world. He even explicitly states that he's not brave, he just can take a bullet better than others. Of course, the reporter that sparks this discussion is Clark Kent, so there might be some ego stroking in this statement.
  • Near the end of Doctor Horrible's Sing-along blog, Captain Hammer sings a song with this message. Unfortunately, his massive ego prevents him from going too far with this, repeatedly pointing out just how much cooler a hero he is:
    "Everyone's a hero in their own way/In their own not-that-heroic way".
  • Taken to a logical conclusion in the Rescue Heroes cartoon based on the toyline, where the characters are a team of firefighters, police and other professions (mountain climber, construction worker) who operate like superheroes, who focus on disaster relief and rescues rather than fighting crime. (no, not a superhero version of the Village People)
    • We'll leave that to Kingdom Come, shall we? (Look close and don't blink.)
  • Rush deals with this theme in the song "Nobody's Hero.
  • Played with in Watchmen as the police and normal citizens eventually grow to resent the costumed vigilantes who take the hero-ing business into their own hands. This fake PSA advertising the movie mentions "real American heroes" who "don't need to wear masks", and at one point a group of rioters is seen with a sign reading "Police, not masked freaks".
  • The whole point of the show Dirty Jobs
  • A City Of Heroes fan story published in the monthly comic had a short tale about a hero defeating a gang of Trolls that were threatening a young couple - the hero denied that he receive any praise for what he did, as the Trolls were of no threat to him, but instead drew attention to the fact that the young man stood up to the thugs, protecting his girlfriend - even though he could have been killed with a single punch.
  • Played For Laughs in Monty Python's Flying Circus, where all the normal Supermen stand in awe of their hero, Bicycle Repair Man.