- All of the phone conversations you can have with Nancy's friends are very funny.
- Heck, imagining all the screwball things Bess and George get up to while Nancy's off solving mysteries can be hilarious, especially as a contrast to the darker games.
- The Running Gag of Frank and Joe getting stuck with cases they found annoying, and envying Nancy's cases, was pretty amusing too.
- Any of the "Good News, Bad News" segments.
- Many of the game over scenarios were also rather twisted.
- The occasional "Blooper" stingers after the end credits.
- Some of the conversations are unintentionally hilarious. Once a conversation ends, a new topic appears and the transition into it is a bit jarring.
- "It's locked."
- In the original version, if you call Eloise, you get to hear her answering machine message, where she is trying to figure out how to use the answering machine.
- Also, you can call Jake's locker combination. Seriously. And you get a "Hello, this is Jake's locker," as if the locker is sentient or something.
- Prop master of DEATH!
- Rick and Mattie's acting. How are they both acclaimed actors, again?
- The culprit's parting words if you fail to stop them.
"So long, losers!"
- Hotchkiss: I'm usually not much of a meat eater, but...very well: 50 drumsticks, please. Chicken, that is. Cluck. Cluck.
Hotchkiss: Ooooooh look, a peephole.Hotchkiss:.....shall I peep?Hotchkiss: OH I DO BELIEVE I SHALL PEEP!Hotchkiss: Where's my medallion? It fits! HIGH-FIVE TEAM HOTCHKISS!
- On that note, all of Hotchkiss's video recordings:
- "Hello, dead end, my name's Nancy Drew."
- One unintentionally funny moment happens during one playthrough. Right after getting stuck in the elevator, this happens.
Dexter: Did you see I fixed your radiator?Nancy: I was in the elevator and it got stuck between floors!
- You can find a bottle marked "Prograin: Extra strength hair treatment for men. Results may occur eventually." Becomes a Chekhov's Gun for the series.
- Simone's nonchalant comment about Nancy climbing through her wardrobe.
"I may have to cut this short. Someone just climbed out of my wardrobe."
- Some of Nancy's snappier dialogue is really quite hilarious.
"Don't 'hey you' me, Brady, you rotten fraud.""Sounds like an invitation to the swamp of no return!"
- The debut of Sonny Joon's screwy mindset and doodles, particularly the ones of his co-workers.
- Nancy: You're not a people person, are you?Red: I'm here to see birds, not people!
- One sign that warns you about the rotting floorboards can only be accessed by... moving Nancy over to the spot where the floorboards are rotted through.
- Harlan: "Sorry, I don’t feel like talking right now; my back’s kinda sore. Probably because someone just got done stabbing me there."
- Arglefumph's reaction to that makes it even better.: "OHH!!!! Sarcasm BURNS!"
- Leave the iron in the hotel room on and it'll burn down the hotel.
- When you describe the fabled Cadborosaurus to The Hardy Boys:
Frank: What does it look like?Nancy: Like a very long, fat snake with flippers, a head shaped like a horse's, and a back that humps when it swims.Joe: That pretty much describes everyone you've ever dated, doesn't it, Frank?
- "Oh, no! She wrecked her roux!" And George just says it in the most melodramatic, sarcastic tone ever.
- Arglefumph makes a "ruined the roux" joke but is then disappointed when Bess says the same thing unironically, spending several minutes making an attempt at a better one, eventually failing miserably.
- Come on, it's just fun to poison Katie. What other game lets you feed someone an ancient mayonnaise-Koko Kringles Ice Cream-jellyfish-mustard-baking soda-peanut butter-tomato sandwich on bad bread?
- What's even more hilarious is watching a 10-year-old play and be completely unaware that 1994 isn't when the game came out, and wonder how the heck the sandwich he/she made poisoned Katie.
- The look on Katie's face after eating the extremely disgusting sandwich is worth poisoning her.
- Given that the game only checks for the bad ingredients and not a combination of ingredients that should be absolutely disgusting when combined together, watch as Katie scarfs down a peanut butter, meat, lettuce, ice cream, ketchup, mustard, tomato, jelly, and lettuce sandwich.
- The message after Nancy gets hit on the head with a brick is downright hilarious in a pretty twisted way.
- Bess: "You're there investigating phantom horses, and what are we doing? A big fat nothing! That does it, George. We're suing the airline."
- Shorty's attempt to yodel. Shortly after this, he storms off muttering his plan to become a gazillionaire.
- Keep an eye on Dave during that scene. His grimace while Shorty yodels is amusingly pained, and when Tex storms off in a huff, Dave's body language suggests he's trying hard not to burst out laughing at both his fellow cowboys.
- The fact that picking underripe vegetables twice can get you kicked off the ranch.
- Intentionally screw up the birthday cake and blow up the kitchen.
- Half of Loulou's lines could count.
- Inadvertently scaring off Nigel Mookerjee by moving the statue of Mercury in the library.
- If you translate Alan's coat-of-arms motto from the Latin, you find that it's an in-joke for computer programmers: "Garbage Out".
- Teeters into Black Comedy territory, but Nancy getting eaten by the giant plant is surprisingly amusing.
- Delivering a second telegram to the Observatory yields this dialogue.
Nancy: Hello, Dr. Bob. I've got a telegram for Professor Randall.
Dr. Bob: I'll get it to him later. As you can see, he's a little busy at the moment.
Nancy: What's he doing up there?
Dr. Bob: He's undertaking the very delicate task of cleaning the lens-
Professor Randall: Uh oh.
(something crashes offscreen)
Dr. Bob: Randall, what have you done?!
Nancy: Hi, Doctor Bob. Woody got another telegram.
- While delivering a third, you can hear Woody sweeping up glass in the background.
- The fifth? "Dr. Bob, if Professor Randall still works here, I've got another telegram for him."
- And then:
Dr. Bob: I'll take care of it. Right now I must make sure Randall seats this new lens properly. [to Randall] I said, carefully rotate it about three degrees to the left-
Randall: Uh oh.
(something crashes offscreen)
Dr Bob: Randall?!
- The orphanage matron shouting to a child offscreen, "Of course it tastes bad, Clarence! It's a pinecone!"
- Arglefumph references this in context with a line from a different game about Nancy saying something tastes bad because it's a squirrel. He says now the reference makes perfect sense.
- Joe is able to cause of fit of giggles with one word.
Joe: It's not like it was written by Mark Twain or anything. (beat) What?
- About Hurley's letter:
- In your first meeting with Tino, he browbeats you into listening to a long, boastful story about arrests he's made. Both of your replies are delightfully snarky:
"I heard all they had was a knife from a carry-out chicken place."
—> "I heard they stopped because you accidentally rear-ended them."
- Nancy's attempts to say "Traquenard" are...nothing like French.
- When Ned points out that you are traipsing around the jungle studying bugs for free while the Hardy Boys are getting paid to hang out at the beach.
Ned: Nancy, if you're wondering what that thing you're holding is? It's the short end of the stick.
- If you've played enough of the series to understand the Continuity Nods, giving Mystico the wrong answers to his question is very funny. "So, Nancy Drew, what secrets from the beyond do you seek?"
A hint: "Ack! What do you think I am? An insurance salesman? A pair of underage detectives? A starstruck teenager? A washed up police officer? An elderly housekeeper? A parrot?"A reason for being: "Ack! Who do you think I am? A librarian? A witless actress? A retired schoolteacher? The hapless owner of a ski lodge? A kidnapped teenage reporter? A ne'er do well curator? A freaked out home owner? An amusement park owner? A tour operator? A ranch owner? A neighbour? A distant friend? A clueless socialite? A worried investor? An entomologist?"Some spice in my life: note "Ack! Who do you think I am? A gun-toting thug? A washed up actor? An antiques dealer? A diamond thief? An old man? An art aficionado? A hillbilly? An art director? A whale lover? A flannel wearing cuisiner? A snivelling brat? A quack? A social climber? A flaneuse? A two-headed monster?
- Among the victims Nancy interviews is an overwrought mother. At the end of the call, Nancy tries to reassure her...but this only makes the mother remember yet another chore she'd forgotten to do.
- Having Nancy eat Renee's Koko Kringle bars until she gets sick to her stomach.
- Bess's audible reactions to sniffing the hoodoo powders at Zeke's, from bawling her head off to little-girlish giggles.
- The money-earning minigame: Nancy must don a catsuit and mime various gestures in front of a live audience.
- It's really only applicable if you're a fan of Doctor Who but the main villain being called Il Dottore (the Doctor) is quite amusing.
- This "Good News, Bad News" when you get caught snooping in Fango's office:
The Good News: The GdiF put up your bail.The Bad News: You have to be smuggled out of the country dressed as a goat herder. Baahhh!
- The sheep-shearing minigame will often result in mohawked sheep, or neon-green sheep.
- Coucou's idle dialogue includes conversations she overheard from other tourists, and a lot of tense scenes happen in Coucou's room. So George can have just finished talking about stalkers when the parrot squawks, "Teeny! Stop teasing your sister!"
- Some of the orders Nancy gets at the snack bar are so bizarrely funny to think about that they've become an in-joke for fans. Who orders a sandwich with nothing on it but two pieces of lettuce?
- At the end of the game, when Nancy solves the final puzzle and goes after chasing The Black Cat ( Corine)...
Mel: You just entered my room through the wall! I demand an explanation!
- Just being able to inflict multi-car pileups when driving with no consequences, until you get a "Good News/Bad News" screen.
- Frosty's scream upon seeing the mice. Debbie's utterly deadpan response makes it even funnier.
- The Reveal that Kasumi deliberately hid her will so that only her two daughters could find it...and only if they worked together. This was a woman who had to mediate a lot of sibling fights.
- Nancy: How’s Joe?Frank: He’s great. He says hi. Oh also he wanted me to tell you something, hang on I had him write it down because it was too weird to remember… There we go, ‘Dear Nancy Drew’, he used your last name for some reason. ‘I am glad that you and Ned are back together. You go together like peanut butter and jelly. When you’re apart, it’s like peanut butter and sadness. Or jelly and uncomfortable silences. Either way, you’re looking at a sandwich that no one wants, and probably no one wants to buy it ever.’Nancy: That sounds very much like Joe.Frank: Oh you wish that was the end of the note. It goes on: ‘A world where Ned and Nancy are not together is as disturbing as it is dangerous to the quantum makeup of our interstellar plant of reality-’ You know what, I’m just going to stop reading there.
- A couple of the outtakes have some humorous Shout Outs
Flashback Monster: Doo doo doo do-do-do! Puttin' on the ritz!Nancy: Hello? Hello? Open up please!Lukas: No thank you! We already have one!Nancy: What?Lukas: What is your name?Nancy: Nancy Drew.Lukas: What is your quest?Nancy: My quest?Lukas: What is your favorite color?Nancy: Can I talk to someone else about coming in?Lukas: No!
- All three of the hotline messages in the outtakes, which essentially make the monster sound more like a Punch-Clock Villain or Affably Evil than anything.
- Karl won't cancel the upcoming festival because he's already paid for its fancy centerpiece cake.
- Bess lamenting her overindulgence in ice cream at the end of Alibi. She's watching a suspect at the ice cream store, and to keep her cover up she had to keep ordering ice cream. All through the day. It's even funnier if you never ate ice cream when playing as her.
- If Ned gets caught rummaging through Alexei's trunk, one of his reactions is a Girly Scream.
- The credits scene where Frank calls and- having discovered the culprit's true identity and fearing for her life- makes a desperate confession of love to Nancy over the phone...only to be cut off by the answering machine. And later, his sheepish retraction of said confession.
- When you're allowed to snoop in Mason's area, you can troll him by messing with his neatly organized pencils, markers, paperclips and notepads.
Deirdre: Hey you know, you should volunteer at neurological study places, because you have been knocked out a lot, my friend.Nancy: I'll keep that in mind.Deirdre: Maybe not the safest place to keep it in your case.
- In The Deadly Device, you can ask Ryan to help distract Victor so you can snoop in his office by getting him to yell at her. After a few times of this she draws a graph of how it's negatively affecting her personal well-being, complete with doodling in the margins that involves a frowny face, a dog on a skateboard, and a dragon.
- Hell, just Ryan in general. Try asking her for a second gummy bear.
- Hotchkiss, as always, is full of these.
- Asking Wade about his Dark and Troubled Past.
Nancy: Is it true that you have a questionable past?Wade: You asking if I really went to jail? Yeah. I don’t recommend it.Nancy: Why not?
- In the game's finale, the eponymous mansion catches fire. Nancy's recorded even this in her journal, despite ostensibly running for her life.
- Despite the fact that it's a very dark game in general, the messages on Jessalyn's phone are really funny - mostly because Clara's autocorrect is acting up:
- Clara: DID YOU GET THE INVERTEBRATESJessalyn: What?Clara: INVERTEBRATESJessalyn: Mom, that does not clarify thingsClara: NO, INVERTEBRATES!!!!Jessalyn: I'll make a note of that. No invertebratesClara: I am sending this PHOTOGRAPH BACKWARDS!@!!Jessalyn: Okay. I hope that works out for youClara: I am typing slowly, and angrily.
- Before they start shifting into Nightmare Fuel, Jessalyn's phone recordings are very funny.
Addison: Remember when Elizabeth got married and we all watched romcoms and ate caramel corn? I was just thinking, at no point that evening was I like, 'I'll die here!' It just didn't come up.
Jessalyn: All my life I'd been told that Harper was crazy.Harper: What a coincidence! Me too!
- The Easter Egg conversation you can have while making Harper a cart in the finale.
Ned: Hi, Nancy!Nancy: (casually) Thornton Hall's on fire.
- Nancy can find Samantha Quick's passport in Zoe Wolfe's hotel room, revealing that "Samantha" is one of Zoe's aliases.
- "I'm sorry I burgled your house."
- Moira's sarcastic tirade about old people.
- Alec talking with Nancy about her luggage.
Alec: I gotta say, if you're so attached to your mom's jeans, why'd you take them on an international flight?Nancy: Those are mine.Alec: Oh....Alec: You look nice today, he said with a hopeful smile.
- At the end, Carson sits down to tell Nancy how he met her mother.
"Yeah, you'd better sit tight. This'll take about nine seasons..."Carson: You remember that filing cabinet you picked?Nancy: Which one?Carson:...I'll pretend I didn't hear that.
- An injured George falling asleep in the middle of talking to you.
- Sonny Joon. Every single thing he says.
Sonny Joon: You've been a member for a few years now.Nancy Drew: Do most of the members [of S.P.I.E.D.] not know they're members?Soony Joon: Yeah, that's, like, item number one on the list of things to fix.Nancy Drew: What are the benefits of membership?Sonny Joon: Surprises. Like this one: Surprise! Your life is dangerous now! (Beat) ...I can make you a badge if you want.
Joon: Aside from this awesome belt I had made?Nancy: Yes. Aside from the belt.
- Nancy asks if he has any real proof aliens exist.
- Leena declaring herself a Pacific Run 'superfan'.
Nancy: Really? You seem a bit...smart.Leena: I'm smart all day. At night, give me someone falling down and a bag of popcorn.
- The show announcer's gradual descent into frustrated snarking.
- In the closing letter, Nancy cheerfully tells Ned that she's coming to kidnap him, and to keep his windows open. note
- This entry in Nancy's diary:
Locked tablet entries? This looks like a job for Nancy "One Woman NSA" Drew.
- Grigor provides a good deal of comedy by being the game's Deadpan Snarker; the letter he writes at the end of the game is both hilarious due to the idle tone it's written in, and sad because he's talking about how Thanos is going to murder him.
- Some of the bickering that the cast members engage in during their rehearsals is fairly amusing if you listen to the recordings, not least because Xenia's so preachy about others' godawful performances while refusing to acknowledge that the actual script is lame too.
- After Nancy traps Thanos in the Underworld cell, the player can make her unlock it.
Nancy: Why did I do that?!
- "Nothing says I love you like a new murder tool."
- Interestingly enough, that quote comes in handy. During this game, it's revealed that Nancy forgot her anniversary with Ned. Deciding to make it up to him, she decides to buy him a gift from the Culture Center's gift shop. One of the options is an "Original Replica" Viking Sword. If you save up and buy the sword (which isn't cheap,) the ending letter mentions how much Ned absolutely loves it, saying he takes it everywhere: to parties, football practice, even to shower.
- In her journal, Nancy ponders one of the series' greatest mysteries:
Why aren't I getting paid for this?...Why don't I ever get paid?
- A friend's utterly cavalier response to Dagny's breakup with her girlfriend:
Terribly, terribly sorry to hear that. Condolences, plenty of fish in the sea, single and ready to mingle, no time like the present, you're an absolute gem, et cetera!
- Dagny realizing what Gunnar's nickname for her means.
I hate this town.
- Dagny asks Nancy her opinion on the treasure's rightful owner. One of the options?
Nancy: Give it to me!
- Nancy's kleptomania becomes increasingly blatant:
"I don't know whose boat this is, but I'll just...borrow it for a little while."
- Nancy (obviously) lies to protect someone's feelings, prompting Dagny to reply sarcastically:
"Ooh, I like you. Tell me my hair looks fab."
- Nancy repairs Dagny's heater which does not look like a wiring puzzle at all. Upon completion, Nancy says "That was the strangest wiring I've ever seen."
- The opening of his 'Nancy Drew Rap'
Warning: This video contains spoilers for the first 22 Nancy Drew games.
- Failing the dancing minigame in Design. "Well, ahm sorry!"
- In Alibi in Ashes, Alexei gets mad at you as Bess for breaking a vase in his antique store as soon as you walk in. He simply tries to shoo you off if you attempt to talk to him again. This exchange occurs :
Bess: You're really mean!Alexei: I can live with that. Now go make friends with the outside world!Michael: Oh wow... Let's try talking to him again.Alexei: Out!Michael: (Does it again)Alexei: Out!Michael: What's the opposite of "in," Alexei?Alexei: You again!? Get out!Michael: Oh, oh, aww... I thought he was going to say "out" again!
- Seeing him freaking out over the minigames in Secret of the Old Clock is simply hilarious. It's very odd yet funny seeing Michael, a typically mellow and nice kind of guy, freaking out over losing mini-golf and being unable to do the sewing game right. It gets even funnier with the chase scene at the end.
- Specific moments: In the sewing game, during one of the failed attempts, his mouse glitched and sent it flying left and right all over the place. And during one failure at the chase mini-game, he yells EESH! SQUEESH! AJA!!
- His Let's Play of The Oregon Trail. "I KILLED NANCY DREW?!"
- During part 10 of The Final Scene, his drifting off topic while talking about the Blackmoor family.
"Okay, well, what is supposed to happen is that Brady disappears to, uh...do whatever Brady does, write a letter to Jane Penvellyn, maybe...You know, I actually had to look up Jane's name in order to make that joke, that's a reference to Nancy Drew: Blackmoor Manor and, uh- I don't believe this! I checked on Wikipedia, and somebody's written a whole history of the Penvellyn family. Somebody has way too much time. They've got like a three-page article with the generations of the Penvellyn family going back- going to twenty-four generations. Somebody's got way too much free time. And this is from a guy who's made, like a hundred Nancy Drew videos, okay? Way too much free time! I'm sorry, guys."
(Gasps) Great googly moogly!
- And about a minute after that, in response to a certain discovery:
- "AAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!!!! LEAVE THE MANSION NOW? OHHHH, I'M AFRAID!!!!!!"
- His reactions to Connie not impressed with him being the student of the month in September.
B-but I was the student of the month in September! Connie thinks I'm a self-centered jerk! (starts sobbing) Oh, this is not awesome anymore...
- His explanation to the reason why he's "Student of the Month" in the game (It Makes Sense in Context) degenerates into "Ten minutes of freaking out later..."
- Hearing him read through most of the opening letter for Shattered Medallion in a "tough German guy" voice, then belatedly realize it's Bess who wrote the letter and he has to switch to "perky girl" instead.
- When showing off the death sequences in The Phantom of Venice, one of the "Good News, Bad News" endings for getting caught snooping in Fango's office is "The Good News: You only spent half a day in jail. The bad news: you spent the other half on the phone getting chewed out (and fired) by Prudence Rutherford."
Michael: Aw, man! Chewed out by Prudence Rutherford? I wouldn't want that to happen to me. [as Prudence] "Nancy, I'm entirely ashamed of your behavior! I hired you to catch these criminals, not get arrested and join them in prison!"
- In part 21 of Alibi in Ashes, a rock is thrown through a window with a threatening message:
Michael: "Arsonists will get a taste of their own medicine!" Oh no, everybody, oh no! All the townspeople are rising up against Nancy! They're grabbing their torches! They're grabbing their pitchforks, and they're all going to rise up in a mass and storm the castle and destroy Nancy! Here's a dramatic representation of what that will look like.[Cuts to the mob scene from Beauty and the Beast]
- To entertain viewers while solving a tedious word game, he shows footage of his pet cat sleeping. While unfitting music plays.
- His imitating Frosty's freaking out over the mice in "Trail of the Twister" is downright hysterical
Michael: (in a high pitched voice) Ohohoho, there are mice every where and ooh, I'm scared!
- Listening to Ned's snarky voice-mail message in Sea of Darkness, Michael manages to sound like a Soap Opera fanatic scandalized by The Reveal:
Ned has an older sister?! And he HATES her!?!
- During his Danger by Design playthrough as part of his Mega Marathon, Michael opens the emails on Nancy's computer. One of them is from Emily Griffen from Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake. It's not the letter so much as the Southern accent that Michael puts on as he reads the letter all the way through.
- In his playthrough of Phoenix Wright: Trials and Tribulations, he remarks that not all Americans are the same...and then asks:
"Who told this German girl all of our American secrets?"
- In Danger on Deception Point, he accidentally gets a game over twice in the span of five minutes, first when he gave Nancy food poisoning, and again when he didn't put a helmet on when she went biking.
- Then he didn't realise that it was the mayonnaise that was bad after he gave Kate food poisoning and finally just angrily made a peanut butter sandwich, wondering how it was so hard to make sandwiches in this game.
- His speedrun, wherein he gives Katie a ketchup sandwich.
- Him singing Irish folksongs while herding sheep.
- In his 2014 playthrough of Ransom, Arglefumph mutters; "The things we do for random hobos on the beach..."