When Larry buys the condom at the convenience store, the store manager yells out the choices you made for your "lubber", resulting in random people popping out from behind store shelves to mock you for it.
Crowd: WHAT A PERVERT!
From the same scene, you can make a choice regarding the size. Only "Large", "Giant" and "Gonzo" are available, but no matter which one you pick, he'll always say "small-sized".
The censored sex scene with the hooker.
Larry's face when he calls the sex phone line, and gets called back.
Larry's face as he wins both the Dating Connection and the lottery.
The Dating Connection especially so, since he only wins because Barbara ends one of her sentences with "too", which the MC interprets as "number two", which is Larry. Sorry Barbara, no backsies.
Failing to escape the cruise ship will result in Barbara's mother accidentally suffocating Larry when she tries to have sex with him.
The KGB agents' reaction to Larry once wearing a swimsuit, shaved, with shoulder length blonde hair, and padding.
At the very end, Larry barges into Dr. Nonookee's Volcano Lair and triggers the security system, which ends up killing him.
As Peter Purser finishes up explaining the rules for the Thighs Man Trophy contest:
Peter: ...are there any questions?
Crowd: Are there any answers?
Peter: *annoyed* You may begin.
When opting to seduce Peggy.
Narrator: *flatly* Larry, a penis is a terrible thing to waste.
Even attempting to use a pick up line makes it clear Larry DOESN'T want her.
Larry: *thinking* Nooooooooooo...
Attempting to "look" at Peggy's chest will cause Neil Ross (the narrator) to break character and refuse to read the intended line, calling out Al (who can be heard laughing in the background) and claiming he has "standards".
Farting around long enough (or looking for the last remaining Dildos) after you've won the contest will result in this friendly little reminder from the ship's announcer.
Ship Announcer: LAFFER! GET YOUR ASS UP TO CAPTAIN THYGH'S CABIN!
After winning the contest and meeting Captain Thygh, she refuses to participate as she's filled with ennui, but Larry is obviously confused as to what she means. The narrator then gives the definition of ennui (boredom), explains the word's origins, and uses it in a sentence. Larry isn't the only one who hears him.
Captain Thygh: Who the hell is THAT?
Larry: I don't know. But I hear him all the time!
Larry accidentally, unknowingly killing Mr. Boning, derailing his wife's plan to get away with murder, and blackmailing her to the tune of half a million dollars. The One Dialogue, Two Conversations he and Annette have about the above is priceless.
"Lesbian Nights" — a parody of "Summer Nights" from Grease where Larry and Ione sing the story of their date from earlier in the game and how it traumatized her into out-and-out lesbianism.
Earlier, when Ione starts chewing Larry out for what he did, he attempts to deflect her criticism by blurting out "I'm gay!" We then get an I Knew It reaction...from Larry's own crotch.
One of Barbara Jo's conversations where Larry uses puppets to try and calm Barbara down, especially if you get some of the wrong options.
When Larry Lovage and Morgan plays some unspecified Tabletop Roleplaying Game (although It's obviously intended to be D&D, given the sheet design shown) Larry's solution to saving a princess from becoming a virgin sacrifice is to make sure she's no longer a virgin.