Suggestion: Good Animals Evil Animals

While the picture is OK out of context, if you’ve seen the film you’ll know that the soccer game isn’t really a battle of good and evil and neither side is that great. So it feels a tad misleading. I feel this suggestion works better (from…what else, Doggie March) as Killer’s army consists of traditionally malicious animals (leopards, gorillas, hyenas) and the friends of the heroic characters are traditionally friendly animals like bunnies, squirrels and deer. Even if this image doesn’t work I feel this movie shows this trope rather well, as the climax has large predators and scavengers go up against cutesy dogs, bunnies and raccoons. Though I admit I’m probably biased.

Edit: Disregard. Something else should be used.

Edited by Fivey on Jan 22nd 2022 at 2:08:55 PM

Opening

Strong keep. The current displays the trope well, regardless of context (it doesn't really matter if you saw the movie or not. Every image is chosen with anti-Fan Myopia in mind). And it's also more concise.

The suggestion is incredibly busy.

Edited by Drope on Jan 22nd 2022 at 5:35:36 AM

Hm, that is a very good explanation. After comparing, I agree there is too much going on in my suggestion and wish I’d suggested something else (especially since out of the four animals on the “bad” image, only two are listed as evil (hyenas and gorillas)). Am I allowed to retract this or is it way too early?

Edited by Fivey on Jan 22nd 2022 at 1:41:35 PM

The suggestion is not better than the current, but the current could be something else. The pic needs to demonstrate that specific species of animals are Always Chaotic Evil, or at least meaner than specific other species.

Feel free to come up with other ideas while the thread is open. Also make sure to wrap the suggestions into "[[quoteright:350:" because we need to see how the images would look on-page.

Edited by Amonimus on Jan 22nd 2022 at 4:52:33 PM

The obscure wartime cartoon “Song of Victory” depicts this well, have cute bunnies and chipmunks as the Allies while the Axis are represented by a vulture, a hyena and a gorilla. However, it does show Nazi imagery (as all wartime cartoons did) and even a racist stereotype in the form of how the hyena looks. I can go get an image, but am reluctant because I don’t know if it will disturb visitors. Here’s the link. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bmd-UuP0-H8

Edited by Fivey on Jan 22nd 2022 at 2:09:46 PM

Keep Until Better Image Suggested

Keep Until Better Image Suggested. The animals on the right are all wearing blue and have friendly expressions, the animals on the left are in a comparatively searing yellow and have mean expressions.

Current > OP. That's enough consensus for it; locking up.