Recommendations for Perusal by 5P

Sonichu probably needs to be looked at regardless, especially given its rep on this wiki.

@Adannor - Please elaborate, I just took a look at the actual comic and it appears to be just mind-numbingly awful art and inane writing. Did I not read far enough? Does it descend into some kind of horrifying furry pedoshit gore-porn?

"Did anybody invent this stuff on purpose?" - Phillip Marlowe on tequila, Finger Man by Raymond Chandler.

It does. It discusses the mechanics of electric hedgehog reproduction in fetishistic detail, and includes, among other things, a poorly-drawn illustration of the author's penis. Not that a well-drawn one would be better, mind you, but you get the picture.

What's precedent ever done for us?

Ha ha ha...that last bit of your post made me actually laugh. Okay, I'll look at a few more issues, maybe after I'm drunk or something, so it won't be quite so horrible. That's the worst art I've seen this side of an untalented seven year-old's scribblings.

"Did anybody invent this stuff on purpose?" - Phillip Marlowe on tequila, Finger Man by Raymond Chandler.

I believe Issue 8 contains most of the horrible shit. Well, an increased amount of horrible shit, anyway.

What's precedent ever done for us?

Huckleberry Ann, explicit porn. Also, possibly, Jay Naylor, who is on the wiki as an artist/author of several furry porn and regular porn works, including Huckleberry Ann, Fall Of Little Red Riding Hood, and Better Days.

He Is My Master: from the trope page: young girls in stripper-esque maid uniforms, being lusted after by the 14-year old protagonist. Violates the underage guidelines; should be reviewed for deletion by 5P.

High School DXD: porn-based plot about a guy who becomes a sex-demon and tries to build his own harem.

edited 21st Apr '12 1:21:32 PM by GliderGuy

^Ann goes down (it is pure porn), Better Days - not so much. It has porn spinoffs, but by itself shouldn't trip the line. Just a bit of cleanup.

Just noticed that Tenchi Muyo and Sailor Moon are on the review list, the first because of the Token Mini-Moe among the harem (Sasami) and the second because of "implicit teenager sex." And both of them being under Essential Anime no less, Tenchi for the Harem Genre and Sailor Moon for the Magical Girl and Magical Girl Warrior genres. I seriously hope this is a joke.

edited 21st Apr '12 1:43:19 PM by TwoGunAngel

I did appreciate the obvious -_- faces put next to the requests, but it's true, someone requested they be looked at. -shrug-

I'd like to object to Glider Guy's suggestion of Highschool DXD, but I know this isn't the right place. Where is the right place?

Nowhere, yet. However, do note that material like Sailor Moon is most definitely not the kind of thing we want to remove.

"If you aren't him, then you apparently got your brain from the same discount retailer, so..." - Fighteer

Nowhere yet or nowhere ever? Or do you mean "nowhere yet, but there's a place to protest after things are removed"?

The child is father to the man —Oedipus

I'm well aware that Sailor Moon of all things isn't likely to get removed, but just skimming Highschool DXD is likely to give the wrong impression, especially after a gross misrepresentation like his proposal.

I mean that there may be threads for debates in the near future, when Fast Eddie has finished all work in this subforum. Starting threads is beyond anyone's ability at this point and that includes moderators. Only the P5 can start threads. And Fast Eddie.

"If you aren't him, then you apparently got your brain from the same discount retailer, so..." - Fighteer

Noted. I'll drop it for now, then.

RE-TAKE Is not entirely sex, qualifying as PlotWithPorn (arguably Kimigabuchi's least explicit work), as evidenced by the fan-recut "all ages" version. However, it contains graphically explicit depictions of underage sex, as well as underage pregnancy and marriage (the protagonists are stated to be 14 years old in the source work).

Visionary Replay Of Homu Homu Graphically explicit underage sex / Fanservice intended to cater to pedophiles - the main character is 14 according to the original work. As eviidenced by the danbooru links given on the page, the doujin primarily consists of sex scenes and contains lolicon.

Disregard, they are all pool links there.

edited 21st Apr '12 2:09:53 PM by SeptimusHeap

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman

Re-Take should be fine so long as we stick to the All-Ages version. I think there's some indistinct suggestions of on-screen sex left over, but that's about it.

edited 21st Apr '12 2:10:45 PM by Iaculus

What's precedent ever done for us?

Not to mention that Sailor Moon is a children's show and Tenchi is only rated 13+ in the US.

edited 21st Apr '12 2:15:07 PM by ThatHuman

something

"Just noticed that Tenchi Muyo and Sailor Moon are on the review list
...
I seriously hope this is a joke."

Suggested for review means that somebody did with all seriousness put them there.
It doesn't mean that P5 would share that overzealous opinion.

The Sailor Moon manga is rated 13+ in the US*. I remember that Tenchi was on Toonami in America- aimed at the over ten set maybe, but... and about Potty Failure, I didn't even know that was a fetish thing. I thought it was a joke like when Yosuke in Persona4 pees on a wall, or even a character development thing, like when Lotte in Lotte No Omacha gets scared on a ride, wets her pants, and has a sweet heart to heart with Naoya about how he used to wet the bed, but now he's a fine adult.

• I checked the back of a library copy.

edited 21st Apr '12 4:44:24 PM by animeg3282

Well, the Sailor Moon anime was aimed towards kids in... pretty much every market, right?

something

Do we need Sailor Moon proposed at all? I have watched most of the series, and yes Haruka and Michiru were lovers, but nowhere does it ever make a point of implying they were actually sleeping together, although they did live together. Any implication that I'm aware of is only through Fridge Logic.

The relationship was one of the things that was Bowdlerized, but only by changing them to cousins. As far as I know they didn't censor all the hand-holding, etc - the problematic bit was that they were in a lesbian relationship and that's a Moral Guardian issue that Japan doesn't have as much.

Hey, I was genuinely concerned, but I am less so by now.

But seriously, is it ok to take things off the list, or do they have to stay there and go through once nominated?

edited 21st Apr '12 5:12:12 PM by Elle

It seemed like a kid's show to me when I watched it as a child in the early 90s. There were some edits, but they could mostly show the show.

No. It only gets brought up by people who want to make a point by drawing laughable analogies. Still, if it makes them happy, let 5P have a look at it and conclude it's okay.

Unbent, Unbowed, Unbroken. Unrelated ME1 Fanfic