Recommendations for Perusal by 5P

Thanks. So there's that, people.

That show seems wacky*, but probably safe. We don't delete kinks, especially when not involving explicit scenes or children ("university student", says the page).

*) By "wacky" I mean, it's delightfully absurd I might see it some time.

edited 21st Apr '12 9:32:57 AM by Catalogue

Come to think of it, Panty And Stocking With Garterbelt does probably want a look-through. I'm not expecting a cut, but the humour is raunchy and transgressive enough that 5P should likely check it over just in case.

A GIS on Hen Zemi, however, seems to suggest that it's closer to Panty & Stocking's league than I thought. Inconclusive, still. I don't think these will be cut, but possibly there will be warning, curating, locking, or suchlike. *shrugs*

The TV anime was much lighter on well everything than the OAD and Manga.... The OAD has nipples in at least one scene and a 10 minute scene on crap from what my research tells me. (I have not watched it though.)

edited 21st Apr '12 9:43:02 AM by Raso

Well, there is a reason why P&SWG is widely considered to be the current reigning Most Triumphant Example of Refuge in Vulgarity.

Oops, sorry.

edited 21st Apr '12 10:36:14 AM by MarqFJA

Hmmm... We'll just put that in the queue for now.

In case anybody doesn't k know, P&S w/ G has been released in the US by Funimation, so it's definitely legal.

Ur-Example means oldest known.... wrong trope there Marq looking for Most Triumphant Example. (but I can think of plenty more that are much much worse... western shows... hell south park the movie was worse.)

Elaborating on the work...

Gross-Out Show, Lots of Imagery like a a D Day spoof of semen in military uniforms assaulting a beach that looks like something I dont want to say (its Fridge Brilliance if you see it)... English cussing, a monster made out of crap from a backed up toilet, non-explicit sex (you dont even see a boob), pole dancing for Transformation Sequence, and licensed by Funi in the US.

Review and clean yes.... reading our page.... VERY MUCH CLEAN IT!

edited 21st Apr '12 10:12:00 AM by Raso

Or Borat. ("We make a joke! We pretend to be husband and wife!")

All right, put that in the queue as well.

Going to go out on a limb here and ask for a mod to actually clean Panty And Stocking With Garterbelt now.... it is extremely vulgar, uncalled for usage of the word "Slit" just scratches the surface. (in the context you are probably thinking of).

edited 21st Apr '12 10:16:17 AM by Raso

When all this is over, I'm proposing a new trope. The Law Of Fetishism (or Encrypted's Law.): The more blatantly fetishistic something is, the harder it is to tell if it's meant to squick out that without those fetish, or pander to those who do. It'll be one of those no example things, but it can be noted for all the controversy over what "paedoshit" encompasses as well as why some works got cut.

edited 21st Apr '12 10:24:05 AM by encrypted12345

Or both.

ETA: I'm not sure "pedophilia for shock value" is a huge improvement over "pedophilia for arousal," though I'm probably influenced in this by the incontrovertible fact that people who do things for shock value are annoying.

edited 21st Apr '12 10:27:05 AM by HersheleOstropoler

Wait, how did Potty Failure have "creepy examples"? They looked fine...

edited 21st Apr '12 10:40:16 AM by Bookyangel2438

There were examples of watersports and porn that really didn't belong there. Trust me. They were creepy.

Oh.

What if some were legit examples? Do they get put back?

There is trope misuse though since a good amount of them refer to Played for Drama moments. I think one example was sexual, but it's hard to tell from the description itself.

Huh.

This is becoming a derail. Booky, if you really feel the need to defend watersports examples in a comedy trope, take it to another thread.

I'm not exactly thrilled about this, but if we're going to look through Panty And Stocking With Garterbelt... we should probably look through its main American inspiration, South Park. I'd love for someone else to read the trope pages and see if they need a clean-up, because I'm incredibly biased towards the show and would be the worst possible person to judge if it has inappropriate descriptions.

Oh sorry!

i will go away now

edited 21st Apr '12 11:01:09 AM by Bookyangel2438

It needs some cleaning to be sure.

That makes a lot more sense.

edited 21st Apr '12 11:56:24 AM by encrypted12345

In the spirit of Elle and dna, I'd like to ask about Mirai Nikki.

(This description will only mention the elements that bring it into conflict with site policy, but not exaggerate them: All of these things do happen during the story. I can also provide additional information if 5P desires.)

The male and female leads, Yukiteru and Yuno, are explicitly identified as 14 years old. Their internal/character conflict is driven by the fact that, as a result of the series' main premise, Yuno has a prophecy that the two of them will become become united in love at a certain point during the next few months, and is disturbingly enthusiastic about making sure that it comes to pass. Yukiteru moves from being deeply uncomfortable with this to the point of being squicked, to taking advantage of her devotion (with her consent) to accomplish his own personal goals, to ultimately relenting and inviting her to bed. The sex scene is depicted on-screen, though partially obscured. Yuno is also the subject of a considerable amount of sexual fanservice, especially in the anime adaptation, which for whatever reason gives her panty shots in a scene in which she is nearly raped.

I'm interested in hearing the panel's verdict.

I'm pretty sure that refers to them killing themselves, as I've seen the episode in question. Wow, the wording there. Just wow.

Kit N Kay Boodle

It's all about yiff. All yiff, all the time.

^What about Sonichu, on that note?