Follow TV Tropes


YMMV / Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains

Go To

  • Badass Decay: Poor Colby. He was unable to live up to his performance in Australia, where he set several challenge records that still stand. He knows, his teammates know and he isn't happy about it.
  • Designated Hero: A few of the heroes come across as this. Some of them were assigned to the hero role because they were compared to people worse than them in their respective seasons, but they look bad when compared to similar heroes. Standouts include James, who was angry and aggressive a lot, and Candice who defected to the Villains side. The latter, though, is treated as a Face–Heel Turn by the remaining heroes.
  • Designated Villain: Sandra: She may be hot-tempered and potty-mouthed, but nothing she did on her first season really justified her being placed on the Villains tribe. The fact that she was the mortal enemy of one of the show's most hated villains ever (Jonny Fairplay) should have made her a Hero by itself. Lampshaded by her when she states she should be with the Heroes, and tries repeatedly (and unsuccessfully) to join their alliance and warn them of each of Russel's plans.
    • Though perhaps her status as a villain could come from her willingness to backstab anybody, including her close friends. Seen best when, in her original season, she threw out all of the tribe's fish after Rupert got voted out, and then had no problem letting her best friend, Christa, be blamed for it.
      • Or possibly from the DVD commentary of Pearl Islands, where she revealed that she and Christa were planning to set the shelter on fire, and to throw a snake at Johnny.
    • A few of the villains in general can be this (such as Rob, Jerri, and Coach) because they've mellowed out and are much nicer this time around.
  • Never Live It Down: J.T giving Russell his idol - the very same idol that would cause his elimination.
  • Rescued from the Scrappy Heap:
    • Jerri, for generally being more pleasant. She finally ended up Vindicated by History when people realized she wasn’t even that bad on her previous two seasons, especially All-Stars. Which is all she really wanted in the first place.
    • Advertisement:
    • Coach, for not being a Spotlight-Stealing Squad this time around and being played sheerly for comic relief whenever possible.
    • Danielle to some extent, going from the villain that eliminated Terry, to The Woobie who got backstabbed by Russell where it hurt.
  • Rooting for the Empire: Some people ended up rooting for the Villain Tribe - if only because some Took a Level in Kindness while some of the Heroes also Took a Level in Jerkass, and were actively trying to take down the Big Bad Russell while the Heroes played into his hands. Hell, some of the Villains felt more like Heroes than the Heroes themselves!
  • Shocking Elimination: Stephenie, Cirie, Tom, Tyson, Boston Rob, JT, and Danielle.
  • What an Idiot!: JT handing over the idol to Russel, who is the scummiest person in the entire season. The confessionals seem to be edited to make him look like a giant dumbass for this move.
    • Tyson decides to ignore Rob's strategy for whatever reason, and chooses to quickly vote out Parvati rather than flush out the idol by splitting the vote between her and Russel. Parvati gets the idol as a part of Russel's Batman Gambit, and Tyson heads home. He even says he's a victim of his own stupidity.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: