Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs A Perfect Cliche Storm: Let's Read Adventurers Wanted
FreezairForALimitedTime2011-01-28 12:16:55

Go To


That's just not my bag, baby!

Welcome back to Fantasyland, brave adventurers! Don't worry; we're not in any danger just yet! Unless you count this book as a pressing danger.

Chapter 3: Magic Bag

Is it yellow and covered in little black Xs?

As we open up this chapter, Alex is schmoozing with Andy. Andy thinks Alex is lucky, because for a first-timer, he gets to go on a really exciting adventure! Well, I suppose that's one way to look at things.

Alex looks at Andy and realizes he's pretty young, too—no older than 25. On a whim, Alex makes the decision that he's going to like Andy.

Translation: "You're my new best friend, whether you like it or not!"

So what better way to celebrate their Plug-'N'-Play-Friendship than with a shopping montage! OMG SHOES! And a lot of adventuring gear. What kind of gear? Well, some pots and... I dunno; the book won't tell me! Just... gear, apparently. It says they went around to a lot of shops, and got lots of "other camping gear," but doesn't specify.

Hmm. Well, I'll just fill in the blanks myself, then. They picked up some Potions and Elixirs, a heaping helping of POW Blocks, plenty of Pokeballs, some WorldLeaves, and—of course—rope. Lots and lots of rope.

Alex wonders about money, but Andy tells him not to worry about it. It's all on Dwarfbeard's tab. More specifically, Dwarfbeard has offered to "stand good" for Alex. Having lived above a bar most of his life, Alex knows that just because it's on the house doesn't mean you drink all you can. But, nope—Dwarfbeard is determined to "stand good" (there's that phrase again), and if you don't get exactly everything you need when a dwarf is "standing good" for you (what happens if he "stands bad" for you?), you gon' make Dwarfbeard cry, boy. You don' wanna make a grown dwarf cry, do ya?

Alex is mystified by fantasy money! I'm guessing he's never played an RPG before, otherwise the fact that thirteen silver coins equals one gold coin wouldn't come as such a shock. Wait a minute—wasn't it 13 Sickles to the Galleon in Harry Potter, too? Let's hope that's another Shout Out, too.

Andy's reaction to Alex's monetary not-knowledge is bafflement, considering how he's not sure he ended up adventuring otherwise. "Badgered by an insane shopkeeper" not a good enough explanation for you? (Also, the fact that he doesn't know about money is the most confounding thing to you?) Alex explains about the sign.

Andy is surprised he saw it! After all, no one's seen it for a long time, though he knows a few people a few years ago who—

...Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Hold the phone!

Just two chapters ago, Mr. Clutter was saying how no one had seen it for a couple hundred years!

Lord, we're only three chapters in, and we have our first plot hole. Unless Andy is waaay older than he appears to be.

Just... move on. Let's just move on. I don't need the headache. Let's go on. NEXT SHOP!

Oooh. We actually get to see what they're buying this time. They're visiting a master bag maker for a magic bag! Poor little Andy is so confused! Luckily, the Master Bag Maker (...that's a hard title to take seriously) has a nice "Try before you buy" model for display. Standard passwords. Speak "Enter" and friend!

...It's a Bag Of Holding.

There's rooms inside this one, but it's a Bag Of Holding. The page moves on. Yep, it's still a Bag Of Holding! Oh, look, we're learning about passwords. ...Still a Bag Of Holding. Yes, you can go inside it. Still a Bag Of Holding.

...Hold on a second, how long does this go on for? I mean, it is the thing that titles the chapter, so—

...Six pages!?

...OK, look. Remember how I took issue with the whole "We've gotta kill him 'cuz he's evil!" thing? And I took some time to ruminate on the nature of fantasy and all that? Yeah. Allow me to do that again.

Here's the Thing About Fantasy: Even if you are writing your book mindful of the hypothetical person who has never read another fantasy novel before, you have to remember something. Some concepts are so famous, and so well-known, you can expect Joe and Jane Ignorant to have a reasonable understanding of them via Popcultural Osmosis. You don't have to spend years describing them for us. Oh—a cursory explanation is still nice. Just to refresh our memory and to help us paint a picture of what your [insert concept here] is like. Quick appearances and such. But if you are going to spend this much time on something, you need to show us why your take on it is novel. Save long explanations for things that you know you're doing entirely differently.

This is not a unique take on a Bag Of Holding. The only sort of different thing about it is that you structure it sort of like a computer, with the rooms acting like file folders and the passwords needed to get in. And even then, six pages is a lot. If you were introducing a new character, that'd be fine. This is just padding.

Continuing the illogic, Alex wants to know why it is unacceptable to sleep in your magic bag. Andy posits, "What if you climbed out in the morning and were surrounded by goblins? You couldn't warn us!"

To which I add, wouldn't you be much safer inside the password-protected bag? Warning seems like it'd be pretty irrelevent—unless you're one of those people who makes your password "Password," the goblins couldn't get at you or your gear!

Bother this nonsense; let's go to the next store. Dwarfbeard's good-standing is gonna buy Alex a weapon next. Mr. Blackburn can "measure" anybody and find them the perfect weapon, so let's go see him!

Calling it right now:

They go to Mr. Blackburn's marvelous smithy. He takes some vague measurements of Alex, all the while muttering and going "Interesting." Why am I reminded of Mr. Ollivander's from Harry Potter?

I'm sort of glad now that there's only about three-ish fantasies the average person is familiar with, because I'd hate to see what else this story would rip off if there were more.

Mr. Blackburn finishes sizing up Alex like a show dog, and the "Interestings" continue. It appears Alex would be most suited to a sword (I Knew It) or... a staff.

HUBIDAH-WAAAA? But... but... staves are a wizard's weapon! And wizards are super-rare!

Damn. I'm not sure if I called both of those correctly, or just the first, since I'm not sure if the wizard thing counts.

In yet another Potter-esque scene, Alex fiercely denies being a Slytherin wizard, and just asks for the sword. He shops around and picks a "blue-black blade" just hanging out on the wall. Hey, guess what? Mr. Blackburn didn't actually make it! Some random adventurer brought it to him from some hoard! And Alex thinks he sees words in the gold swirls on the hilt! But in a land full of magic, why, that's crazy talk.

...*sigh* And I called them both right after all.

Let's see if I can predict the rest of the party's weapons with the same accuracy:

  • Arconn: Bow
  • Dwarfbeard: Axe
  • Dwarfaxe Jr.: Another axe
  • Andy: Maybe a lighter sword of some kind
  • Olaf Leaderson, Tayo, and Scald: Spears and WTF ever

Whatever; let's just get back to dinner. "Now we are eight," Olaf says. (What, like you weren't eight before?) Blah blah formally welcoming last member everyone hears he could be a wizard both Dwarfbeard and Mc Playboy look smug. Everyone then thinks it'll be hilarious to get Alex wasted on honey beer. Typical obfuscating Dwarfbeard says it's not strong enough to "muddle your wizardly senses," but Tayo still says it'll give you a doozy of a hangover. Well, which is it?

Oh, never mind. It's just enchanted so you temporarily become Immune To Alcohol. You know, considering that many alcohols, meads, grogs, etc. were less about taste and more about preservability and drunkenness, it seems kinda pointless to take away half of that.

Scald wants to die in battle! But he doesn't want to die; only if he has to. I'm guessing he's going to be our Proud Warrior Race Guy. Tayo says some incredibly generic things. He's more talkative than alleged. Not one pithy truth has come out of his mouth so far. If he even has a personality, I haven't yet found it.

Pillow Before-Bed talk with Scald and Alex! More talk of "not keeping secrets," which I have a feeling is going to be some kind of theme here. Scald also reveals that he, Tayo, and Olaf are from "Norsland."

Since they're all drifting off to sleep now, I'll leave them be until Chapter 4. But I will leave with this one last comment on our group's national background:

I come from the land of the ice and snow, where the midnight sun and the hot springs glow...

Comments

BonsaiForest Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 28th 2011 at 1:04:18 PM
Some things should just be handwaved or simply accepted, rather than trying to explain them. Alex mentioning that it's possible to sleep inside a Bag Of Holding and the lame explanation why he can't only makes readers wonder just why he doesn't?

A better explanation might have been "because goblins could pick up the bag and throw it in the water, and you'd drown." Or "it's impossible to climb back out of a bag of holding. It's not meant for living things." Or better yet, Alex should have just not asked the question. Wait, why did he ask a question anyway?
FreezairForALimitedTime Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 28th 2011 at 1:22:51 PM
You actually can go inside the Bags of Holding in this universe; they are meant to be traveled into by people. Which just makes the excuse all the lamer, especially when it seems like a perectly reasonable question.
Myrmidon Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 29th 2011 at 10:40:13 AM
I'm betting on Andy as the most likely Wizard canidate. Him or Alex.
SapphireBlue Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 29th 2011 at 12:15:39 PM
Actually, having the group sleep in a Bag Of Holding is a pretty ingenious idea. Just have one person outside the bag on lookout duty, and rotate every hour or so.

It honestly would've been better in this case if Alex hadn't asked the question at all. Then we wouldn't have gotten the stupid answer.
vifetoile Since: Dec, 1969
Jan 29th 2011 at 12:59:46 PM
This could be made interesting if: Any actually was that old. So old in fact that he can't tell the difference between a few years and a couple of centuries. He's actually a God in Disguise or an Eldritch Abomination masquerading as a charming human youth, but not doing so well at it, so he's gotten into the habit of adventuring, so that he doesn't spend enough time in one place to get notice, and so that if people do notice, he can kill them and it will look like an accident...
EponymousKid Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 12th 2011 at 2:32:22 PM
Ha. "Now we are eight" is a The Magnificent Seven reference. Also, good to know that Scald, Tayo, and Olaf are fair-haired Aesir from the North, I guess.

I think one thing you're having a hard time keeping in mind is that Tropes Are Tools. A sword is considered the standard, most common weapon in this setting, and Alex is a Standardized Hero. It flows fairly naturally that he would have a sword - and that his would be special since he's The Hero. Besides, would you really like this book any more if Alex had an oak club or a pickaxe or something?
FreezairForALimitedTime Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 12th 2011 at 3:43:37 PM
Actually, yeah, I probably would, since it'd be at the very least a glimmer of originality.

I know that Tropes Are Tools, but imagine you were using your tools to build a birdhouse. If you wanted to learn how to build one, you'd look in a guidebook, and follow the "basic birdhouse" pattern to the letter. That'd be fine. But if you want that birdhouse to win a competition, following the book pattern exactly won't endear you to anyone because it is basic, unadorned, and nothing anyone's never seen before.

This book follows every template as to-the-letter as it gets, and without anything like unique (or even lively) characterization, fascinating worldbuilding, or well-crafted prose, there's nothing worth looking at except for the So Bad Its Good factor.
EponymousKid Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 12th 2011 at 3:55:41 PM
Eh, fair enough. Sorry, I'm a compulsive Devil's Advocate. Still, despite running straight into some of my pet peeves, I really do like this LB. Keep up the good work.
Top