YMMV / Silent Hill 3

  • Awesome Music: "You're Not Here", the opening theme. Harsh, discordant and unnerving, but a powerful and pulse-pounding piece of alt-rock all the same.
  • Big-Lipped Alligator Moment:
    • The ghost in the subway and the Happy Birthday phone call in the hospital.
      Unknown caller: Happy birthday, dear... I'm sorry. I forgot your name.
      Heather: Who are you?
      Unknown caller: Oh... okay. Happy birthday dear "Hooaryou"...
    • On subsequent playthroughs, in the sewers you have the option to drop the steel pipe into the water. This spawns a fairy who presents two pipes, one made of silver and another made of gold. If you refuse both you get to keep both and you get your steel pipe back. There are no future references to it other than Heather thinking about pawning the gold pipe. It only happens in New Game+, so it's really just a shout out to an old legend that's been referenced by pretty much everything ever.
  • Demonic Spiders: The Slurper enemies, which are fond of repeatedly knocking Heather to the ground and crawling on top of her for damage.
  • Ear Worm: "You're Not Here", which plays over the opening montage.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Considering he doesn't actually appear except his body, there is a surprisingly large number of Stanley Coleman fanfics on the net.
    • Vincent. A lot of fans found him to be one of the most interesting psychos in the series.
  • Good Bad Bugs:
    • It's possible to force the Missionary Boss into a corner, making him much easier to fight.
    • Nurses can sometimes get stuck near corners making it hard for them to hit you but easy for you to hit them.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: Douglas' already bittersweet declaration "Nobody's gonna cry over my grave anyway," in response to the risk he is about to take, driving Heather to Silent Hill. His actor, Richard Grosse, died three months after completing his dialogue and two months before the game's initial release.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Having Heather run around the hellish landscape of Silent Hill in her Magical Girl costume is pretty amusing since the popularity of Puella Magi Madoka Magica.
  • It's Short, So It Sucks!: Well, not "sucks", per se, but the relative shortness of the game was a major criticism of some reviews, such as the one for the unofficial PlayStation Magazine (PSM).
  • It Was His Sled: Good luck finding anyone who doesn't know that Heather and her father are Cheryl (the second) and Harry Mason from the first game.
  • Moral Event Horizon: Claudia crosses this when she murders Harry.
    • Alternatively, messing with Heather in the chapel in order to get her to birth God. The Vincent-stabbing was justified, though, what with the whole backstabbing and all.
  • Narm / Nightmare Retardant: Joe Rybicki of the Official PlayStation Magazine found the Closers to be this in his overall positive review of the game, dismissing them as giant sock monkeys and wondering how he was supposed to be afraid of them.
    • In general the Closers can be this. Whether they're sock monkeys or Taokaka, many players have considered it to be the least scary monster in the game.
    • The Insane Cancers may not have the intended result of scaring the player, given that they're not the most mobile and their obese figure may make them hard to take seriously.
    • Heather receives a bizarre "Happy Birthday" call with a creepy tone to it and by the time it's finished, all she can say is "But...it's not my birthday..."
  • Narm Charm: "SHUT YOUR STINKING MOUTH, BITCH!" Stupid as that line may be, it's delivered so passionately it crosses over into awesome.
  • Paranoia Fuel: "They looked like monsters to you?" ...Oh no. Though possibly subverted in that Douglas flat-out states at the end of the Mall level that he also sees the monsters.
    • Yet, killing too many monsters pushes you towards the Bad Ending...
    • Valtiel. He never attacks you, and is always just out of reach, and just... watches. He's a thoroughly disturbing reinforcement of the stalker theme that Stanley represents.
  • Player Punch: Harry's death. Doubly so for those who played the first game.
  • Suspiciously Similar Song: "You're Not Here" in the main-menu idle trailer sounds very similar to "New Year's Day" by U2, albeit probably by coincidence.
  • Tough Act to Follow: It was itself subjected to this a bit after the magnificent Silent Hill 2, which is commonly regarded as one of the finest works of horror in the medium. It's also an example itself, as after this game, the series never really hit the same level of success again.
  • Visual Effects of Awesome: For a PS2 game the visuals of this game is both excellent and horrifying, allowing for very memorable and detailed Otherworld locations and overlay effects on both enemies and the scenery. The character models have also improved from Silent Hill 2, allowing for more expressive facial animations and detailed clothing and hair.
  • The Woobie: Heather for a good chunk of the game. Her character design was made to make it seem like she was constantly slightly teary-eyed, which fits for the first portion of the game where all she wants is to get home and get away from the hellish surroundings. It gets worse when she finds out her father has been murdered.
    • Claudia is this as well. Her father used to beat her so badly that memory of it was burned into Vincent's brain somehow. Then her best friend when she was a little kid disappeared, as did the woman who rescued her from her father.