Author's Saving Throw
An especially brave idea is set forth to turn a character on his head and change the status quo in a big way
... and the fans revolt.
The writer then does a retcon
which seems openly apologetic. This is the saving throw. It assures the fans that the character either was not in control of his actions, or he was Actually a Doombot
or events were not as they seemed.
Some "brave ideas" that have caused popular fandom backlash resulting in a saving throw have been depowering a Super Hero
for dramatic purposes and turning a good character evil
. Depowering super-heroines
, in particular, is a "brave idea" that is nearly always good for causing a fan revolt.
Note, however, that not all Author's Saving Throws are necessarily a good
thing; many authors try to "fix" things that didn't really need it
. This can be a highly subjective thing; one fan's Jumping the Shark
moment is another fan's Growing the Beard
If the screwup stays prominently in the fandom's memory, it adds to that character's Dork Age
. Contrast with Rescued from the Scrappy Heap
, where an originally loathed character or idea is made serviceable.
If an Author's Saving Throw attempts to fix an episode-specific problem (typically within that episode) and fails, then it becomes a Voodoo Shark
. Generally, the best tool for making such a save is to provide for the possibility of a Schrödinger's Gun
. Often, clumsier tools such as the Cosmic Retcon
or the regular Retcon
are used instead.
Compare Canon Discontinuity
, which just flat out ignores something instead of trying to Retcon
or otherwise explain it.
This is a subtrope of Pandering to the Base
Not to be confused with Only the Author Can Save Them Now
, where the in-story characters are trapped into a corner and escape through contrived circumstances.
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- Vegeta shaving off his mustache in Dragon Ball GT. It might have been too little, too late for some, but it marks the point in the series where it switches from early Dragon Ball-style slapstick to DBZ-style save-the-world fights.
- Many City Hunter fans were angered when they learned that Ryo Saeba's partner, Kaori Makimura, was killed off in its sequel Angel Heart. Because of this, Tsukasa Hojo, the author of both titles, went on to proclaim that Angel Heart was not actually a City Hunter sequel, but a spin-off set in an Alternate Universe featuring most of the same characters. However, most fans that got over Kaori's death in Angel Heart now accept it as a genuine sequel to City Hunter.
- When Naruto reached the Pain arc, characters started kicking the bucket left and right, and it actually seemed like it would conclude some character development, but then Nagato sacrificed himself to save all of his victims. On the other hand, some fans wonder if the series really would have been better with the deaths intact.
- Perhaps done even more extremely in the same arc when Hinata is struck down in a fight with Pain. There's no reason Pain would have chosen not to or fail to cause a mortal wound, and writing wise said above sacrifice would have rendered the loss moot anyway, but despite that, she is only 'heavily wounded' seemingly for the sole purpose of not enraging the fans a few chapters until everyone else is restored to normal as well.
- One of the many, many ways to interpret the results of Mobile Suit Gundam Seed Destiny. The Spotlight-Stealing Squad made up of the old cast taking over, then occasionally losing focus could be the result of the staff trying to decide which way to throw the series.
- The Compilation Movies tried to mitigate the suddenness of the old cast's return by making Athrun the viewpoint character (via some minor editing and casting him as the narrator). This works to an extent, as the old cast doesn't really take front and center until Athrun joins up with them late in the show.
- Many fans had started to disapprove of the incredible over-the-top antics and Monster of the Week aspects of Tenchi in Tokyo, especially since all signs pointed to it being a sequel to Tenchi Universe (Tenchi says it's been two years since they all got together and when Noboyuki mentions Achika, the young, schoolgirl version from Tenchi Muyo in Love appears). Episode 13 and 14 later revealed that it was firmly an AU.
- DokiDoki! Precure is a serious saving throw for the Pretty Cure franchise. It absolves the non-existence of Myth Arc during Smile Pretty Cure! and the general lack of suspense of Suite Pretty Cure ♪. Furthermore, it brings back just enough the widely-liked Darker and Edgier aspects of HeartCatch Pretty Cure!. On the other hand, there is Mana and the notorious Sixth Ranger...
- Cyborg009 was originally intended to end at the Yomi arc, with the apparent deaths of 002 and 009. This would end the manga at volume 15 (or volume 10 in the USA release, which is where Tokyopop did in fact end things). Fan revolt and the popularity of the series convinced Ishinomori to resume the manga soon enough, and he threw in a retcon stating that 001 managed to teleport the two to safety before they could die (they still wound up comatose and having to be rebuilt, but were alive).
- Dan Slott's She-Hulk run did this for a controversial issue of The Punisher, when he poisoned and blew up a bar filled with two dozen C-List villains, revealing that they survived and had their stomachs pumped.
- Subverted with Slott's handling of the issue of She-Hulk's one-night stand with the Juggernaut; Slott had She-Hulk deny it, while using it to slut shame She-Hulk via everyone accusing her of being a whore whenever She-Hulk denied the charge. The pay-off to the whole thing was her pulling out an alternate universe counterpart who claimed to have slept with Juggernaut, but the plotline was so widely reviled, that Peter David (who took over after Slott left the book) denounced it as lies and later writers have She-Hulk have the character herself wondering that maybe she did sleep with Juggernaut after all.
- X-Men: The return of Jean Grey in the '80s where it was revealed that the Phoenix (and thus Evil Planet Killing Dark Phoenix) was not Jean Grey at all. This, like the Green Lantern example below (which it clearly inspired), was not done by the same author, but the co-plotter of the original saga was involved.note Since then, to what degree Jean and Phoenix are or are not the same person is something no two writers agree on.
- The Marvel Universe had the potential for saving throws with the revelation that Skrulls have been secretly replacing people, as discovered by the New Avengers. This is even lampshaded when the characters, upon discovering this, discuss how this could provide an explanation of everything from Iron Man's sudden turn into a jerk, to why loner Wolverine is on so many teams, and even why Peter Parker would publicly reveal his identity. Iron Man himself (once he finds out) engages in it, wondering if it means Captain America (Steve Rogers) really isn't dead, and that Jean Grey didn't get a bridge dropped on her. But ultimately, the Skrull situation didn't touch any of those alleged problems, leaving them all as they were. Especially the big one: Iron Man's Face-Heel Turn during Civil War. Totally not a Skrull, and Tony Stark must now deal with what he's done. The biggest change to come out of it is that Mockingbird is back, the one who got Stuffed into the Fridge having been a Skrull.
- Played With in regards to Quicksilver. He successfully made the world think that his actions during House of M and Son of M were the work of a Skrull impostor, but in reality it was all him. Only his daughter, Luna, knows the truth, and while she refused to rat him out, she disowned him as a result.
- The Hobgoblin was created by writer Roger Stern as a replacement for the Green Goblin, complete with a mysterious true identity. The character was initially a success due to good writing, but then Stern departed from the title. At once, the Hobgoblin joined up in a gang war and the mystery surrounding his identity got out of hand. Finally, it was decided that Ned Leeds was the Hobgoblin... which was revealed after Leeds had already DIED (and at the hands of common snipers too, even though the Hobgoblin was supposed to have super-strength!) The Smug Snake Jason Philip Macendale took over the role of Hobgoblin and became such a poor villain that Roger Stern finally returned to write the three-part Hobgoblin Lives miniseries that killed off Macendale, explained how Leeds was NOT the original Hobgoblin in a way that actually made sense, tied up all loose ends left by the mystery, and revealed the true Hobgoblin to be Roderick Kingsley, as Stern had always intended. Unfortunately, this was just after Norman Osborn came Back from the Dead. Since it was clearly felt that with the original Green Goblin now back in action the Hobgoblin was now redundant, Roderick Kingsley was sent off to a Caribbean island in his next story, which in effect turned Hobgoblin Lives into nothing more than an officially sanctioned Fix Fic. Roderick Kingsley was eventually brought back many years later in the post-OMD continuity, resuming his Magnificent Bastard career and filling the villain franchising void left by Justin Hammer.
- During The Clone Saga, it was stated that new character Ben Reilly was the original Spider-Man and the character that had been in comics for the past 20 years was the clone, which wasn't even the original intention of the hook. This didn't sit well with fans and was taken out again; a hook had been added by the writer in case they needed to. The whole thing was really kind of a mess.
- One Moment in Time attempts to do this, trying to address the issues that arose out of the extremely controversial One More Day. Unfortunately, the attempt to answer the many questions that arose from One More Day only ended up disappointing the fanbase even more given that many felt the main characters acted out of character, and came off serving as a mouthpiece for the views of the author regarding their relationship rather than as an honest attempt to fix the problems with the original story. In the end, it comes off more as an Author Tract rather than an attempt to solve the concerns of the fans. Many are waiting for an Author's Saving Throw for an attempted Author's Saving Throw.
- The New 52 revamp of Voodoo operated on a Black and Gray Morality scale, with a loathsome protagonist, despite a few scattered hints that there was some good in her. After the first four issues, the original writer was fired, and the replacement quickly revealed that the Voodoo we'd been reading about was actually her evil clone, and that the real Voodoo was a likable, heroic figure. If nothing else, this allowed for Voodoo to be usable in the wider DC Universe once the book was cancelled.
- Hal Jordan, the Green Lantern, went Ax-Crazy after the destruction of his city becoming the villain Parallax. Some fans were not happy, seeing it as a Bridge Drop in favor of the Younger and Hipper Kyle Rayner, although others thought it was a logical and fitting end to Hal Jordan's story. Geoff Johns eventually retconned this into Parallax being an ancient alien fear monster who was responsible for the Lanterns' weakness to yellow and who slowly pulled Hal over to Brainwashed and Crazy. Many of the named characters Hal had killed were brought back to life, as well. This produced highly mixed reactions from fans, considering that many had warmed up to Kyle in the interim, and plenty had liked the "Emerald Twilight" story, and thought it made perfect sense given Hal's character. The subject remains a Base Breaker among Green Lantern fans.
- Johns continued to arc weld Parallax with other existing Green Lantern concepts and expand on them to much critical and fan acclaim, arguably being an Authors Saving Throw for the Parallax retcon. It helped that while Hal was now the new "star" Lantern, Kyle was also written with respect and given a prominent place in the franchise instead of getting a reciprocal Bridge Drop. It doesn't hurt that both Green Lantern: Rebirth and Sinestro Corps War, the storylines providing the Saving Throws, are both awesome and made of win.
- The editorially influenced attempt in the Batman comics to recreate Batgirl III/Cassandra Cain as Robin's erudite Dark Action Girl nemesis (explained by her returning to her supposed Assassin roots) provoked rather justifiable complaints that the writer and editor involved hadn't bothered to read Batgirl's solo title. A few months later, we found out that Deathstroke was feeding her mind-control drugs, really. Never mind that Cassandra's entire origin involves her complete and utter hatred of killing, even more so than Batman! Oh, and the whole mind-control drug thing doesn't really work when in a Batgirl/The Ghost crossover she was able to overcome the effects of a deadly poison by herself. Yeah, no antidote or anything. Still, it was better than being stuck with the villainess that's Cassandra In Name Only.
- DC then gave the writer of the screw-up a new Batgirl miniseries to allow him to explain all the events that led into her Face-Heel Turn, thus tearing open a wound that was already considered closed (even if badly closed). General fan consensus was that he only succeeded in messing up the character even further. Even more confusing, parallel to this she also showed up in Batman and the Outsiders, coming out at the same time as the miniseries but taking place after showing her back to her normal awesome self. She then went into Comic Book Limbo for several years, and only starting appearing again in Batman Inc.. They were probably trying to make Batgirl into the new Jason Todd...the only problem with this is that people actually like Cassandra Cain.
- An issue of Robin managed three author's saving throws in one fell swoop to dispose of the controversial ill-treatment of the franchise's female characters in the "War Games"/"War Crimes" arcs: Stephanie Brown never died, Leslie Thompkins only faked her death to keep Black Mask away from her. Batman suspected this—though he wasn't certain—and to give Stephanie Brown privacy never told Robin. This is why he never added Stephanie's Robin suit to the memorial (an Author's Saving Throw for using her absence from that memorial to justify the claim that she was never an official Robin) - along with Jason Todd, who was already Back from the Dead at the time.
- Making Stephanie Brown the new Batgirl could be an added Saving Throw for both the above Cassandra/Stephanie issues. Fan reaction has been divided, especially among the Cassandra fans.
- This itself resulted in yet ANOTHER saving throw, with it being retconned that Cassandra willingly gave the title to Stephanie as part of a plan that had her Commuting on a Bus to Batman Inc. and taking on the new identity of Blackbat... and it's now moot since Stephanie has been demoted to Spoiler again, and it's uncertain just how much of her history is intact. Oh, comics.
- Whenever a period of time goes by where Batman acts more dickish than usual, it seems to be traditional to reveal that he's been unable to shake off a dose of Scarecrow's Fear Gas.
- Hey, speaking of fear gas: remember all the wackiness that happened across the entire DC universe during the Silver Age, with Batman being the most out-of-character for getting into it? You know, the stuff that at least three Crisis Crossover events and numerous side-stories have either made non-canon or explicitly happened in an alternate dimension? Somewhere along the lines, Grant Morrison explained in Batman R.I.P. that a good chunk of that was a series of hallucinations that Batman went through during a combination fear gas/sensory deprivation experiment.
- At the end of the first Power Pack series, one of the kids had turned into a Kymellian (a horse-headed alien), their mother was going crazy, their father had developed superpowers, and they were all headed off to live on the Kymellian homeworld, all the result of a change in authorship designed to revive the series' popularity by going Darker and Edgier. A couple of years later, the original creators did a holiday special that wrote the whole thing off as a deception by the kids' enemies.
- Even though it seemed pretty dickish of the characters to immediately stop giving a damn about the one who'd turned into a Kymellian when it was revealed that he was a clone who was made to think he was the real Alex - he wasn't a bad guy, and had worked alongside them since before the first time Alex's human hair had started falling out.
- Back in the Silver Age, Hal Jordan used to call his Inuit sidekick Tom "Pieface", a slur used against people of Asian descent. Later issues showing their first meeting tried to Retcon this by claiming Hal called him this in reference to Eskimo Pies (a brand of ice cream treats). This didn't really do much to make the name less offensive, so Geoff Johns later decided to flat out do away with it altogether in his Green Lantern: Secret Origin mini-series by having Hal defend Tom and claim that the name "Pieface" (which was now given to Tom by another coworker) was racist.
- A curious example of an Author's Saving Throw that was held in reserve but wasn't used: Marv Wolfman, writer of Crisis on Infinite Earths, wrote in the intro to a collected edition that he left an "out" for bringing Barry Allen back from the dead if the fans objected too strenuously to his being replaced. He eventually revealed that the out was for someone to pull Barry through one of the "time windows" he was experiencing as he ran to his death.
- A Legion of Super-Heroes one-shot later uses that exact plotline, leaving it open as to whether or not it actually happened or was just an inspirational story. Issues of Final Crisis hint at making this canon, thus explaining Allen's re-appearance, even though Barry's death was part of a Stable Time Loop that resulted in his own origin, so if you pull him out, he never becomes the Flash in the first place. However, Marv Wolfman thought about that also, and would've set up that Barry Allen had to eventually return to fulfill his role in the Crisis and that Barry wouldn't know when that would happen, thus having the Fastest Man Alive living on borrowed time. Geoff Johns thought of that as well, establishing at the end of Flash: Rebirth that Barry and Wally's race to stop Professor Zoom from killing Iris in the past is the catalyst for giving Barry his powers and that Barry was pulled from the Speed Force after he had died.
- In The Sandman by Neil Gaiman, something called the "soft places" were introduced where time itself grew thin. Gaiman put that in there as an "escape hatch" in case something happened to his characters that he couldn't fix any other way. It was never used for that purpose, however.
- The Toyman, a B-list Superman villain, was traditionally just a funny man in a striped suit who built dangerous giant toys to rob banks and give the Man of Steel a hard time, but in the Dark Age he was re-imagined as a bald child murderer in a black cloak. This didn't go over too well. Fast-forward to 2008, when it's revealed that the bald Toyman was a defective robot decoy created by the real Toyman, who is now once again a funny man in a striped suit, albeit a dangerously insane one, who will do anything (up to and including murder) to protect children. Funny thing - the Darker and Edgier Toyman actually started out as a parody of the trend; he adopted the new persona and modus operandi because he was left out of the latest line of Superman action figures for not being a dangerous enough villain.
- After being saddled with the Fantastic Four during the Character Derailing events of Civil War, Dwayne McDuffie made an attempt to explain why Reed Richards, who had opposed the concept of Superhero Registration in the past, had become a fanatical supporter of the SHRA as well as a total Jerk Ass under Mark Millar. Turns out that by using a new branch of science which predicts future events, he had learned that the Civil War was one of 31 possible future cataclysms that were on the horizon. He postulated that the Civil War was the only such event that could be faced without the utter destruction of mankind, making it the Lesser of Two Evils.
- Magneto had long been established as a Jewish Well-Intentioned Extremist, but when Marvel decided to move him back into full-out villainy in the early 90's, they were worried about accusations of Antisemitism. So they presented the Retcon that he was really a Gypsy, delivering the Family-Unfriendly Aesop that Gypsies are Acceptable Targets. When people realized what a bad idea this was a few years later, Marvel established that Magneto's Gypsy identity was false, returning him to his Jewish roots.
- Speaking of Magneto, the Retcon of the Planet X storyline counts too. Grant Morrison sees Mags as a Draco in Leather Pants and so when writing him, took Ron the Death Eater Up to Eleven to show him as he "truly" was in Morrison's eyes, and ended with him (intended as) Killed Off for Real. Needless to say, that didn't last very long. The retcon was exceptionally sloppy (two authors who didn't know what the other was doing each wrote the story of who Xorn-Magneto "really" was) but hey, Magneto's back to being the Magneto we know and that's what it was to accomplish. To Morrison's credit, he himself left an "escape hatch" of sorts for this story, showing that numerous characters within it suspect that "Magneto" isn't really who he claims to be. And even if he was, the final issue of Morrison's run reveals he was a victim of Demonic Possession.
- During Avengers Disassembled, Scarlet Witch went Ax-Crazy and killed The Vision, Ant-Man and Hawkeye. Then during House of M, she depowered the vast majority of the world's mutant population, leading to many of their deaths. A few years later came Avengers: The Children's Crusade, which established that she had actually been possessed, and that her actions were the result of Doctor Doom's manipulations. Additionally, the series resurrected Ant-Man (while Hawkeye and the Vision returned in separate titles). Following this, she played a pivotal role in Avengers Vs X-Men, where she not only helped defeat the Phoenix, but inadvertently helped restore the mutant race as well. She's not off the hook though: in a surprisingly realistic move, the Vision still has not forgiven her, and Rogue makes a point of constantly reminding her of what she did in nearly every issue of Uncanny Avengers.
- An issue of New Avengers drew some Internet Backdraft over a scene where Hawkeye had sex with an amnesiac Scarlet Witch, which some fans argued constituted rape. The Childrens Crusade retconned this out by revealing the Scarlet Witch Hawkeye slept with was Actually a Doombot. Which, incidentally, meant that Hawkeye was now the one who'd been raped.
- In 2004 (before the New 52) Supergirl, Kara Zor-El, was reintroduced with a shockingly bad origin: Zor-El was evil and sent Kara to Earth to kill baby Kal-El. Fans hated it. Author after author has stepped up to try a saving throw (no, wait, she was sent back to babysit him, no, wait, Zor-El wanted her to kill him after all but she didn't want to but got brainwashed, no, wait, she was sent back to fight off ghosts from the Phantom Zone, and so on, and so forth). Supergirl #35 hand waved off all of the previous origins as dementia caused by Kryptonite poisoning and gave her back the classic Silver Age Origin Story, and Supergirl #34 had her finally take a Secret Identity (Linda Lang. Cute, DC Comics, very cute), so things seemed to finally be looking up. Then New52 hit and it was all rendered moot.
- There's a bit of a Saving Throw War going on between people at Marvel who like Squirrel Girl and those who don't: Originally, Squirrel Girl beat Doctor Doom by herself. A later comic indicated it was a Doombot. Another later comic revealed that it was not a Doombot. Then, Squirrel Girl beats Thanos (offscreen) and the Watcher himself is there verifying that it is not a "robot, clone, or simulacrum" and is indeed the real Thanos. Later on, Thanos reveals he can make really good clones that even fool the Watcher. But according to Word of God, that really really was the real Thanos. And to make things goofier, everything about the Thanos fight was written by Dan Slott. An even later Deadpool comic has her visit Doom in order to borrow a time machine, and Victor just face-palms, shakes his head and points it out. An inset from Tippy-Toe points out that Squirrel Girl pwning Doom was written by Steve Freakin' Ditko, and is thus, so canon.
- The JLA arc featuring the Milestone characters and the female Dr. Light, started off with a monologue by the character used by Dwayne McDuffie to address conflicting appearances in other titles and attempt to fix the continuity problems that resulted from them.
- An extremely similar tactic was used to explain the inconsistencies regarding Thunder's status after she was rendered comatose in Batman and the Outsiders. It is revealed that she had been "in and out of hospitals" since her accident, explaining how some stories had her out and about while others still had her in a coma.
- The Zoo Crew were given a horrific fate at the end of their Final Ark mini-series where the editors ordered the creators to make trapped on the main DC Earth as mute ordinary animals. It was always intended that they could return in "The Final Ark", but that reappearance turned out to be a very brief and mostly inconsequential cameo. They got restored to normal, but they're still stranded on Main Earth, and their home Earth is still a flooded-out dystopia ruled by Starro. And who knows what's become of them post-Flashpoint.
- The Punisher began life as a Spider-Man villain whose idea of "justice" was "anyone committing any crime eats lead" and went around killing people over things that were not heinous. The character as we know him today is actually a Retool made once Darker and Edgier came into vogue and it was decided he worked as a dark hero. So what do we do about his early appearances, which have things like him shooting a couple for littering, and a driver for running a stop sign when he was fleeing from the shots? In the first Punisher miniseries, it was explained away as Jigsaw arranging for him to be exposed to mind-altering drugs in prison.
- The Titans: Villains For Hire one-shot managed to spark racial controversy after the series ended with Ryan Choi, the second Atom being killed and a new Atom series starring Ray Palmer (Choi's white predecessor) being launched during the same flipping event. The 2011 DC relaunch completely retconned the events of the story, with Ryan Choi once again retaking the Atom identity in the new Justice League series and Ray being demoted to a supporting character (for now) in the separate, now sadly cancelled Frankentsein: Agents of SHADE book.
- Sort of. Choi is back to life, but for now, the new Atom is a Latina college student named Rhonda Pineda. This still counts however, since it seems like she was created to address the criticism over DC constantly killing its non-white legacy heroes in order to restore their white predecessors. Of course, now she's turned out to be an evil mole from Earth-3.
- The entire idea behind the one-shot Faces of Evil: Prometheus. The author didn't like the fact that the title character, created by Grant Morrison to be a Badass Normal so Badass that he could take on the whole JLA and only be defeated by cheating, had undergone Villain Decay to the point where he'd become little more than an Elite Mook for Batman villains. So the whole plot of the story is given over to explaining that the Prometheus who'd been appearing for the past nine years wasn't the real Prometheus, but rather a Costume Copycat, and showing us the real deal's Roaring Rampage of Revenge to get him back. Then the real Prometheus made one more appearance in a thoroughly reviled miniseries, which ended with Green Arrow shooting him in the head.
- The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck has one for the richest duck in the universe, describing the incident where he chased a bunch of African villagers out of their homes as the biggest regret of his life that made his sisters sever all ties with him until years later.
- Possible example from the ever-editorially-entroubled Archie Comics' Sonic the Hedgehog; after a Time Skip, Antoine broke up with Bunnie, got an eye patch out of nowhere, and tried to force Sally into an Arranged Marriage. It turns out it was his Evil Twin from the Mirror Universe (previously established, mind) and the real Antoine came back and married Bunnie.
- You might say that Ian Flynn's first year or so on the title was a series of Author's Saving Throws. Sonic going out with Fiona? She was in love with Evil Sonic/Scourge the Hedgehog and thought he'd be the same. Sonic's Jerk Ass attitude towards Tails? The little guy finally blows up and socks it to him, making him admit he was wrong. Sally and Sonic are back together, and Sally is de-chickified back to her Action Girl roots.
- It is very possible that the post-Sonic The Hedgehog Mega Man Worlds Collide comics is this after the Screwed by the Lawyers effect due to the case by Ken Penders and Archie basically deciding to give back all of his creations instead of letting him control the comic by proxy.
- Another X-Men one: Early issues of X-Men: Legacy, when it was an Xavier solo title, had him revisit all the Jerk Ass things he did over the years. It was sometimes revealed that the more egregious ones weren't quite as dickish as they seemed at the time. For instance, the reason he didn't release Danger when he realized she was sentient wasn't because she was just so gosh-darned useful, it was because he didn't know how to remove the code that made her a slave without affecting the code that made her sentient in the first place.
- The controversial mini-series Justice League: Cry for Justice saw Roy Harper having his arm ripped off and his daughter Lian being violently crushed to death. This lead to an unpopular period where Roy relapsed and became addicted to heroin (which he had kicked in the 70's) and even became a member of Deathstroke's decidedly less-than-heroic Titans team. This whole series of events has been retconned out by the 2011 DC relaunch, with Roy once again clean and sober and with both arms intact.
- Similarly, there was an outcry over the death of Tasmanian Devil, one of the few openly-gay superheroes DC has, calling James Robinson anti-gay despite being the one who established the Mikaal Tomas Starman as bisexual-identifying as gay and using him as a main member of CFJ and his JLA team. Whether he had planned it from the start or decided to invoke this trope, he later wrote a JLA story that ended in Tasmanian Devil's resurrection.
- In Thor issue 301, Thor is visiting the various pantheons of Earth to gather energy to revive the Asgardians. All's well and good, until he gets to the Hindu gods, and Shiva demands a fight in exchange for the energy, and thanks to some rules-screwing, Thor manages to defeat him. This did not sit very well with Hindu fans, as Shiva is the Big Good to more than a few Hindus and his power is said to be limitless, and besides that it just didn't make much sense from a storytelling perspective, as Shiva was stated to be equal to Vishnu, who is stated to be equal to Odin; would changing the setting of the battle really make up for the power gap? Anyway, next time the Hindu gods showed up, it was revealed that Shiva was out that day and Indra, a far less powerful god, was filling in for him. The saving throw is hammered home even further by the Encyclopedia Mythologica, which states that the limits of power possessed by Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva are completely unknown.
- Similar to the Ryan Choi example above, a Spider-Man oneshot featured the apparent death of Sabra, a Jewish superheroine, by being ignominiously shot In the Back by Crossbones, a Neo-Nazi and the Red Skull's personal Elite Mook. This went over about as well as expected (though fans were less upset at the Unfortunate Implications than at the fact that Sabra is a Nigh Invulnerable powerhouse capable of trading punches with the Incredible Hulk, so a normal sniper round shouldn't have even hurt), and ultimately resulted in the writer having to go on Twitter and confirm he'd just grazed her. Whether this was intended the entire time or an example of I Meant to Do That is debatable, but she's since reappeared without a scratch on her. The Kangaroo, who died in the same issue, is still dead, though, and since Japanese killing Australians carries no Unfortunate Implications (that we know of...unless you count the veterans of the Kokoda Trail...), he'll probably stay that way.
- Blackest Night revealed that Nekron allowed the frequent resurrections, so that he would have sleeper agents to aid his Black Lantern corps, when the time came, explaining how nobody stays dead in the DCU.
- Kieron Gillen, one of Marvel's current golden boys, seems to be making a career out of this.
- During his Uncanny X-Men run, he managed to undo the apparent Designated Villain treatment of Cyclops by reestablishing him as a competent leader and his opening story arc gave each of the 'Extinction' Team a Crowning Moment Of Awesome.
- Following Siege, he took over the Thor Book, reinventing it as Journey Into Mystery (the name of Thor's first comic) and following the adventures of a child version of Loki, reborn following his death in the aforementioned crossover. By writing Loki as a well meaning-if-occasionally trouble making Guile Hero, this didn't so much as undo a particular event to redeem a poor writing decision, but instead redefined Loki to a character much closer to the traditional mythology, something that fans of Norse Mythology have taken issue with for years.
- Following Avengers Vs X-Men, Gillen wrote Consequences, which as well as stopping Cyclops from being completely destroyed by the bad handling of AVX by exploring what happens to someone who gets blamed for crimes they're not completely guilty of and played him in sympathetic light, also explored many plot holes and Fridge Logic fans pointed out, such as noting Wolverine being ultimately at fault for the whole incident and points out how he nearly destroyed the earth by attempting to kill Hope Summers.
- And now, his second Story Arc in his Iron Man run, The Godkiller explored what happened to the universe now that the Phoenix is no more, and the moral implications of Tony and the Avengers attacking it.
- Gillen also managed to, somehow, resolve the above-mentioned Xorn-Magneto debacle in a way that actually made sense, by claiming that, essentially, all the explanations of Xorn's identity are Metaphorically True. Magneto, in a meeting with the X-Men's publicist, claims that while Xorn wasn't him, he likes people to think it was so nobody thinks he's gone soft.
- Uncanny X-Force seemed to be indicating that Bishop's Face-Heel Turn and subsequent transformation into a mass-murdering baby-killer were the result of Demonic Possession. It ultimately turned out that it was more complicated than this; the heel turn was genuine, but after being marooned in a post-apocalyptic Earth he made an equally-genuine face turn to fight the demons that lived there, and was ultimately possessed by them.
- In The New 52 Martian Manhunter told off his Stormwatch teammates for referring to him as a Justice League member, which is apparently shorthand for "established superhero", despite the fact that the Justice League has never had more than seven members (until JLI). So, any author wants to refer to, say, Metamorpho or Green Arrow as "Justice League heroes", that's what it refers to. A related saving throw came later, when the Manhunter wiped the team's memories of him when he quit, with the implication he'd done this kind of thing before. This could be used to explain why Stormwatch thought of him as an established superhero, but when he cameoed in other books as a vaguely sinister representative of the secret organisation, no-one had any idea who he was.
- The New 52 version of Harley Quinn managed to set some kind of record by having an Author's Saving Throw in the first issue for something that happened in pre-publication publicity. DC announced an art contest based around drawing a page for the #0 issue that ended with a panel described in the script as a naked Harley about to commit an Electrified Bathtub Bath Suicide. This sparked Internet Backdraft over an apparent misogynistic eroticisation of a woman's suicide, made worse by the fact that the script didn't include any of the dialogue, or indicate that it was meant to be contextualised as a fantasy sequence. When the issue was published, the final panel of the page showed a fully-clothed (well, as much as she ever is in the New 52) Harley Riding the Bomb instead.
- Mr. Freeze had one in the mid-90's. In the second mini-series starring the Tim Drake Robin, The Joker finds his gang taken over by Freeze. Joker puts an end to that by dousing Freeze's armor with acid, then electrocuting him to death. Around this time, Batman: The Animated Series had started and Mr. Freeze's introductory episode "Hearts on Ice" was insanely popular, going so far as to net the series an award. Thus, DC had a problem: Freeze was now popular, but they killed off Freeze in the comics! Solution? When they reintroduce Freeze during Knightquest, they reveal that Freeze had indeed survived, using a device in his old armor to put him in suspended animation.
- Nobody Dies had a particularly weak fourth season, with lots of weird changes to the status quo that really didn't do much to move the overall plot forward and is generally considered the point of where all the stories weak bits began showing. This eventually required the author to retcon almost the entire season into being a shared dream.
- Past Sins underwent a major rewrite and revamp in order to deal with various characters being out of character and add a few more characterizations.
- In Lisa Is Pregnant, the author points out that Lisa is older in this fic after reviewers complained that she was too young to get pregnant.
- The Sliders fanfic, Slide Effects, is set after Season 5, but sets out to explain three seasons of bad writing, resurrect three dead characters, and let the show resume within a few weeks of Season 2. The Author's Saving Throw in this fanfic was taken from an interview with the series creator and is at least transcribed from the Word of God. The solution is to explain that Seasons 3 - 5 were the adventures of 37 different sets of sliders, with their disparate experiences combined and streamed into Quinn Mallory's brain due to the Kromagg implant from "Invasion" reacting to the rip in time in "As Time Goes By." This fanfic manages to keep all the events of the last three seasons in continuity (as the adventures of different doubles) while restoring the original four characters and letting them resume their adventures.
- Readers of the Poké Wars story, The Subsistence were baffled by Dawn's sudden prowess with guns, and most complained that it was an Ass Pull. Then Cornova wrote The Incipience and did some minor rewriting which better explained Dawn's sudden gain of Improbable Aiming Skills.
- Da only reson Dumbledeor swor is coz he had a hedache ok an on tup of dat he wuz mad at dem 4 having sexx!
- The Total Drama Island reimagining, The Legend of Total Drama Island has a downplayed example in the first Boney Island challenge. Chris was supposed to warn the contestants during the challenge briefing (as per canon) that a curse would befall anyone who took anything from the First Nations burial ground located there. For whatever reason, the author forgot to include that bit, and didn't discover the oversight until well after posting the chapter. Rather than go back and revise the scene, the author wrote a scene for the following chapter wherein one contestant who happens to know the legend warns another contestant who has innocently picked up an artifact from the area.
- Several early fanworks based on the Beast Wars cartoon had hasty explanations edited in or explained in later workds relating to the incongruities of the BW characters sizes, as until the end of Season 2, most fans assumed they were the same size as their G1 counterparts (it was revealed they were merely a quarter of their size). This was an especially present problem in crossover fics.
- An early (if arguable) example of this trope is the Palinode of Stesichorus (a Greek poet, who lived in the 7-6th centuries BCE), which recants an earlier poem. Legend says that having been struck with blindness after he wrote his original poem, in which the author bashed Helen for causing The Trojan War, he came up with a new story, and was immediately cured. The new version implausibly claims that the real Helen had spent the whole duration of the war in Egypt, and the Helen who went to Troy was just a duplicate made out of clouds. Euripides used a version of this story in his Helen. The palinode became a recognized literary form, in which a poet writes a second poem to disavow an earlier one.
- Euripides, for his part, also had to recant one of his works. It is known that he wrote two versions of the story of Hippolytus. Only the second version survives, but it is widely believed that in the original version outraged the audience because Phaedra (wife of the great hero Theseus) lusts without shame after her step-son Hippolytus, and brazenly attempts to seduce him. The second, surviving version bends over backwards to make Phaedra blameless (she's deeply ashamed of her feelings, and only seems to come on to her step-son because her nurse betrays her). She still comes to no good end, committing suicide and attempting to frame Hippolytus for rape.
- Another Older Than Feudalism example is the opening of The Aeneid. Vergil was in the difficult position of turning the losers of The Trojan War, the ones who fell for the Trojan Horse, into the heroes of his story. His solution was to add a Greek playing a sacrificial victim. This Greek actor was just too deceptive for the kindhearted, trusting, and heroic Trojans to disbelieve when he told them a story that made bringing the horse inside seem like a great idea.
- Jurassic Park: Ian Malcolm didn't survive the novel, but he lived through the movie. When it was decided that he would be the star of the next book/movie, Michael Crichton took advantage of the fact that his death took place offstage and said he was reported dead, but had in fact just barely survived his severe injuries.
- A well-known example can be found in Sherlock Holmes stories. In The Adventure of the Final Problem Doyle had both Holmes and his nemesis Moriarty apparently die in a waterfall; after public outrage (and big sacks of cash) he retconned the event, allowing the detective to defeat the Big Bad and survive.
- Another modern example is in the novels of Evelyn Waugh. In Vile Bodies, his fictionalized Britain becomes a little too fictional, with the inclusion of the King of Ruritania as a minor character, and the novel ends with a badly predicted second world war which has trench warfare and the French as the allied army with Britain. His later novel, Put Out More Flags has some of the same characters several years older, but is set in real World War II Britain. The film of Vile Bodies, Bright Young Things showed awareness of these problems by changing the King of Ruritania to one of Romania and depicting the war at the end as it actually occurred in Britain.
- The Magic: The Gathering novel Scourge had the Big Bad, Karona, gather five powerful beings representing the colors of magic, namely Multani, Teferi, Fiers, Llowalyn, and Yawgmoth, "revealing" that Yawgmoth (the Big Bad of the Weatherlight Saga), who was dramatically killed, was hanging on in some form. A few years later, the Time Spiral novel had Teferi deny his meeting with Karona in Scourge and suggest that it was a dream of hers. The next book, Planar Chaos, had several characters state that they'd personally confirmed that Yawgmoth was dead.
- This is actually a double saving throw, it is implied that Karona might have brought them from different timelines (as in, Yawmoth from when he was still alive and Teferi sometime after denying meeting Karona), the fans can go by whichever theory they like the most.
- In Piers Anthony's Xanth series, the novel Geis of The Gargoyle was used to both lampshade and explain numerous continuity errors that had crept up into the latter books (for instance, the Invisible Giants had shrunk to a third of the size they originally were, and The Gorgon's powers inexplicably worked on women, when they originally explicitly only worked on men). The explanation was that the Realm of Madness was expanding throughout Xanth, altering reality in increasingly drastic ways. Ironically, such errors seem to crop up in all of Anthony's extended series (most notably, Apprentice Adept, where several Adepts' magic powers were altered or changed outright between the third book and the fourth).
- Harder to notice, but there is a minor saving throw about swearing. In the third book, the protagonist says "Hell!" out of exasperation. In later books, "Hell" became a forbidden word for minors to say or even to know, and it's magically enforced. So, how did it happen in the third book? It was an error by an in-world historian who miswrote the word "Well". Saving throw passed.
- Word of God here is that "There are no continuity errors, only alternate pasts."
- The Vampire Lestat begins with the title character reading the previous novel, Interview With A Vampire and dismissing much of it as either lies or misinterpretations by Louis. Anne Rice decided she liked Lestat better than the somewhat whiny Louis, and did this to somewhat redeem him so that he could become the protagonist of the series.
- Similar to Holmes, Ian Fleming killed James Bond off in From Russia with Love the novel at the hands - or shoes - of Rosa Klebb. He had to bring him back for Dr. No.
- Thanks to the magic of serial publication, not to mention possible litigation, Charles Dickens changed Miss Mowcher in David Copperfield from villain to hero in mid-plot.
- Dickens also made a belated saving throw in Our Mutual Friend, where he intended Jewish good guy Mr. Riah to make up for stereotypical Jewish bad guy Fagin in Oliver Twist.
- One happens in the Anita Blake series, as Richard's rather... erratic behavior is finally explained as ANITA'S fault... he was possessed by her anger. When the possession is cured, he reverts to a more stable psyche.
- Star Wars Expanded Universe:
- The franchise has been up to its elbows in these. First the controversial New Jedi Order books introduced Vergere, and her philosophy that the Force was too complex to be summed up as simple light vs. dark. This ticked off a lot of fans, so the writers did the Dark Nest Trilogy and Legacy of the Force in response, which had Jacen Solo (Vergere's main pupil) become a Knight Templar and fall to The Dark Side as a result of her teachings. Problem was, many fans felt bothered with Jacen's fall, so the current Fate of the Jedi series is retconning it to have been not because of Vergere's teachings, but because he encountered something during a journey through the galaxy that made him go crazy. The jury is still out as to whether Fate of the Jedi will need an Author's Saving Throw too.
- Karen Traviss's novels have been very polarizing, due to her single minded approach to storytelling. After four novels of vicious anti-Jedi sentiment at the hands of the Mandalorian characters, she included two scenes in her last novel to try and fix things up. First, she made Maze call out Skirata for being an asshole, and the renegade clones a bunch of brainwashed slaves, effectively comparing Skirata to the Jedi he was trying to save his troops from. Then, she revealed Djinn Altis' rogue Jedi convent, giving a fresh perspective that was separate from both the Republic Jedi and the Mandalorians, putting a lampshade on the whole series focus.
- Another Karen Traviss example: Her first Halo book, Halo: Glasslands, was despised by the fandom for demonizing the scientist Catherine Halsey while portraying her rival Admiral Parangosky as a model of honesty. In reality, both of them have committed plenty of unethical acts to defeat the Covenant. Thus, in her second book Halo: The Thursday War, Parangosky was now depicted as more sinister and ruthless (willing to starve an entire species by secretly making their crops and meat inedible) while Halsey gets some sympathetic reveals, such as that she still cries over the death of her daughter Miranda Keyes.
- In-universe, and somewhat more literal, example in the fifth Captain Underpants book (sorry, EPIC NOVEL), Captain Underpants and the Wrath of the Wicked Wedgie Woman. Ms. Ribble (who, via a screwed-up hypnosis session — apparently the Hypno-ring George and Harold used works in reverse on women — turned into Wedgie Woman) sprays spray starch on Captain Underpants, rendering him powerless. George and Harold, in an effort to save the Captain, quickly write a comic book to try to negate this weakness. To make a long story short... it worked.
- In the Honor Harrington novels, the People's Republic of Haven started the series as a welfare state gone wrong, with the majority of its citizens on welfare, not contributing to the economy, forcing the Republic to conquer in order to survive. A lot of people have taken this as an attack on the concept of a welfare state. In the novella I Will Build My House of Steel, found in the Manticore companion book House of Steel, Weber mentions that several other star systems, influenced by Haven, enacted similar reforms, but they actually pulled it off without gutting their economies, by virtue of having relatively honest politicians... until, that is, they got conquered by Haven.
- In Twilight, Bella's narration indicates that Jessica doesn't really like her, she's only using Bella for her own popularity. The thing is, only Bella's narration indicates this, as opposed to anything Jessica says or does throughout the novel. Of course, in the P.O.V. Sequel Midnight Sun, Edward can use his Mind Reading to discover that yes, Jessica really is a nasty False Friend. Presumably Bella didn't need actual evidence because she's just so smart and perceptive!
- Greg Farshtey did this at least twice for LEGO's BIONICLE story:
- Stephen King's The Dark Tower epic series saw many incongruities and errors in fact creep in. Some were merely revised in later versions of the earlier books, while others (Eddie Dean's home Co-Op City being in Brooklyn vice New Jersey) became plot points showing their world was created by an Unreliable Narrator (King himself is in the later books as a character who is telling their tale).
Live Action TV
- In Buffy the Vampire Slayer's sixth season, magic was portrayed as akin to a drug, which was highly dangerous and addictive, and could even lead to users becoming "junkies" willing to do anything for a "fix," as happened to Willow slowly over the course of the season. Joss Whedon himself didn't like this development, and fans agreed; season seven's first episode featured a scene where Giles explicitly states that magic is not addictive, and it's explained that Willow's actions were actually due to her not using magic. This, of course, made hash of most of the storyline of season six.
- It does qualify as an author's saving throw, or at least close, but it's not a retcon. Giles' line is "This isn't a hobby or an addiction. It's inside you now," implying that this is a change for Willow due to her actions at the end of the last season. Willow got addicted to magic because she has an addictive personality, as much to power as to magic. What with Tara expressing her concern in Season 5, this was already on its way to becoming Willow's character arc, and "Tabula Rasa" is very much in tune with her behavior in the rest of the series. Unfortunately, "Smashed" and "Wrecked", which bring her addiction to its climax, are about the most Anvilicious episodes in the whole series. In the latter, she realizes she has a problem because she hurt Dawn with magic. Or rather, wrecked the car she and Dawn were in because she was high on magic. Just like addicts in real life!
- The writers of the Disney Adventure Power Rangers S.P.D. comic conveniently retconned the reasons behind A-Squad's defection, turning it into Mind Control instead of a voluntary Face-Heel Turn. Apparently, they don't like the idea of Not Brainwashed Rangers (up until then, most evil Rangers were either created that way as monsters, or were Brainwashed and Crazy if they were to join the team). As well, the turn itself was considered fairly random, and the Big Bad had already-established Mind Control powers.
- Kamen Rider Decade throws a rather tricky one. The very serious and nihilistic Doctor Shinigami suddenly appears in the first film, after being Natsumi's rather quirky grandfather for the whole season. Seriously, that doesn't make sense. So, in the second film, they make him that way again. But this time, they reveal that he's under the effect of a "Doctor Shinigami" type Gaia Memory. Which is an obvious throw, as those are introduced in the next, only-barely-related series, Kamen Rider Double.
- On the other hand, many, many other confusing problems with characterization are simply ignored.
- The series also tried to address the controversy around Tackle, the Second Rider from Kamen Rider Stronger, who was killed off and never officially declared a Kamen Rider, mostly due to the fact that she's a woman. In Movie War 2010, Decade meets an Alternate Universe version of Tackle, whose entire backstory revolves around the fact that she was murdered and then quickly ignored and forgotten about by everyone around her. Tackle ends up pulling a Heroic Sacrifice near the end, but not before helping out Decade and taking her killer out with her.
- The manga Kamen Rider Spirits also tried to offer a non-sexist explanation as to why Tackle isn't considered a legitimate Kamen Rider. Fan opinion on said explanation is still divided.
- Years earlier, Kamen Rider Black RX tried to mitigate the fan backlash over the series' Lighter and Softer tone (as well the general Sequelitis complaints from fans of the beloved Kamen Rider Black) by bringing back the previous Kamen Riders as part of the show's final storyline. Prior to this, both Black and Black RX were supposed to have been part of a new continuity.
- A month after the Prison Break Season 3 finale, it was announced that, in part due to fan reaction, it wasn't Sara Tancredi's head in the box, and she'll be back next season. The other big part of the decision was the fact that Sara had only been killed in the first place because of behind-the-scenes drama between the then-pregnant actress and the executive producers. By the fourth season, everyone was friends again so the character returned.
- And ironically got pregnant.
- The third season finale of Bones: Zack is revealed to have been manipulated into becoming the apprentice to a cannibalistic serial killer, and claims to have murdered a man. During an episode of the fourth season, he says that he didn't actually kill anyone himself, he just told the Gormogon where to find a victim and claims he would have killed the victim himself if the Gormogon had told him to. In Zack's mind, this equated to having done the deed himself.
- In The Sopranos, Tony entertained a number of gangster cronies while wearing shorts. On the DVD commentary, the Voice of God admitted that a mobster of his position would never wear shorts in such a situation. A few seasons later, one of Tony's respected business associates commented to him that "A Don doesn't wear shorts," making it no longer a mistake of the show, but just another of Tony's quirks.
- Heroes has had multiple saving throws: reducing a character's powers (Peter, Sylar) and granting powers to others (Mohinder, Ando). A full list of all the throw attempts over the life of the show would take a while... And in addition to these throws, people involved in the show have publicly apologized to fans.
- Reportedly, creator Tim Kring actually went into several interviews personally apologizing for Volume 2 "Generations" suckiness.
- During Elisabeth Rohm's time on Law & Order, her character (Serena Southerlyn) was often used as a Liberal counterpoint to Arthur Branch's staunch Conservative. Problem was, when she wasn't basically arguing the defense's case for them, she came across as a Fox News Liberal so frequently whiny and petulant, it was a wonder how she kept her job. So when Rohm left the show, the writers used Serena's frequent petulance as the reason for her firing (She was acting more like a defense attorney than a prosecutor). But then they had to crap on things with those six infamous last words.
- Doctor Who:
- Steven Moffat has installed a universal saving throw in his run of Doctor Who: "Rule One: The Doctor lies". Corollaries are "Rule Two: River Song lies" and "Rule Zero: Steven Moffat lies".
- The Doctor Who 1996 TV movie included a scene in which the Doctor says that he is half-human; this was widely disliked and subject to Fanon Discontinuity. However, in the Doctor Who Expanded Universe comic Doctor Who: The Forgotten, the Doctor notes that he said that just to screw with his enemy's head. Moffat has stated, when asked about the canonicity of this, that the Doctor did indeed utter those words, very carefully not specifying whether they were true. After all, "the Doctor lies".
- He has gone further, arguing that "a television series which embraces both the ideas of parallel universes and the concept of changing time can't have a continuity error — it's impossible for Doctor Who to get it wrong, because we can just say 'he changed time — it's a time ripple from the Time War'."
- There was an earlier attempt at Saving Throwing the half-human line by some of the Eighth Doctor Adventures writers. Unfortunately other EDA writers liked the half-human idea, but had their own radical interpretations of it; there was an Armed With Canon war; and the whole question became a Continuity Snarl.
- A smaller-scale saving throw took place after "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit", in which the Happiness in Slavery depiction of the Ood as a happy servitor race and the Doctor's acceptance of it as unproblematic were seen by many fans as gross breaches of the series's and the character's usual moral positions. Two years later the "Planet of the Ood" story returned to the same setting and revealed that the slave Ood were only happy because the evil humans had been lobotomising them, and that the Doctor only accepted their servitude because he was a bit preoccupied with a planet orbiting a black hole and Satan trying to kill them all. ...shut it.
- The show's first example of this occurred with The Daleks and The Dalek Invasion of Earth: in the first, Terry Nation killed off his malevolent creations, but when it came time to bring them back for a sequel, he said: "the trusty TARDIS came along and took me to a point in time before they were exterminated!"
- There are some fans who have shown distaste for the Cybus Cybermen from "Rise of the Cybermen" and "Age of Steel". When "The Pandorica Opens" aired, the Mondasion Cybermen make their return (Steven Moffat confirmed that these were the Mondas Cybermen; they just didn't have the budget to change the costume.) However, it's not much of a throw. All "reappearances" of the old Cybermen are the new Cybermen looking and acting exactly as they always have. People who really want the old Cybermen back often consider merely saying they're back a cop-out, and people who don't (or just don't care) wonder why bother pretending.
- The Daleks got a multicolored upgrade in Victory of the Daleks, and the bright, colorful Daleks were presented as what a Dalek would look like forevermore, the "New Dalek Paradigm," as they put it. It turned out even this Narm Charm loving fanbase has its limits. So the next time a Dalek had to be a threat, it was a sorta petrified-looking run-down one, and then we discover later still in Asylum of the Daleks that all Dalek variants still exist out there, and the overwhelming majority look the way we're used to them looking; the candy-colored ones were sorta sitting in back as a Continuity Nod and stayed well out of the way.
- A season two episode changes Charlie into a baby-napping maniac who may or may not have been using heroin again. And then Locke beat the crap out of him while everyone else watched. The season two finale basically rebooted his relationship with Claire, and in the third season, when Locke asked for Charlie's help, Charlie asked why he should after Locke falsely accused him of using heroin, beat him up, and exiled him from the camp.
- The producers originally intended for Paolo and Nikki to be major characters. After a fan revolt, they changed their plans by not only killing off the characters, but doing so in an incredibly sadistic way.
- On Smallville, Season 3 ended with Chloe walking into her house, closing the door, and the house promptly exploding. Then, in the beginning of Season 4, we see a flashback of Lex and his guys getting Chloe and her family out before the explosion goes down. Never mind that it happened the second the door clicked shut. Or that, per the Season 3 finale, Lex was too busy being poisoned at the time to actually have been there. Most viewers don't really mind, it seems.
- In the seventh season finale of House the titular character drives his car through Cuddy's dining room window in revenge for breaking up with him and escaping to a tropical beach. This caused a full blown fan revolt with claims that House became no better than a psychotic murderous Domestic Abuser and that his stunt could have ended with the deaths of several people. The creators responded to this on Twitter claiming that House had made sure that everyone was gone by looking through the window which prompted the fans to point out that Cuddy's daughter was likely in the room and she wasn't tall enough to be seen. Come the season 8 premiere and we get a scene where House turns himself in to the authorities and explains that he had made sure that everyone in the room had left and that he knew that Cuddy's daughter was at a sleepover. YMMV if this makes things that much better, mind you.
- For the first three seasons of Star Trek: Enterprise the show was criticised for wasting the potential of its prequel setting by neglecting the Romulans as recurring villains (rather than properly leading up to the known canonical Romulan War) and instead embarking on a long confused Myth Arc involving a "Temporal Cold War" which soon fell prey to The Chris Carter Effect, as well as for depicting the Vulcans as a race of hypocritical Jerkasses. When Manny Coto took over as showrunner for the fourth season, multiple Saving Throws were given: the Temporal Cold War was resolved in the two-part premiere, a three-part story involved a major spiritual revolution in Vulcan society that brought them closer to the aliens we knew and loved, and a major story arc throughout the season involved a resurgence in Romulan aggression which also served to forge alliances between the future founding members of the Federation. The Enterprise relaunch books manage to take this even further by retconning Trip's death into a faked death, as well as dealing with the Romulan War and founding of the Federation.
- At the end of Season 3 of The Mentalist, Jane kills Red John and sits peacefully waiting to be arrested. In the first episode of Season 4, it turns out that that wasn't Red John and he's found not guilty in a spectacular example of Hollywood Law, so the series can continue as before.
- In Supernatural's fourth season, Sam was revealed to be in a sexual relationship with the demon Ruby. Even putting Shipping aside, the fanbase took a major issue with this. As Ruby was a demon with no corporeal body of her own, she had to possess another woman to use for her, uh, interactions with Sam. By having sex with her, Sam was either raping the host (who had not given consent) or engaging in necrophilia (if the host was a corpse). The writers "solved" this by revealing that Ruby's host was a comatose girl about to be taken off life support, whose body was still alive but spirit had moved on to the afterlife. Mileage varied as to whether or not this made the situation any less squicky.
- In the crossover movie between Tensou Sentai Goseiger and Samurai Sentai Shinkenger, we're given the first cameo appearance of the Kaizoku Sentai Gokaiger, who transform into all Red Rangers. However, it's revealed in the first episode of Gokaiger that the only reason they could do that was because of the Ranger Keys, which they wouldn't get until the time between Gosei and Gokai. How do they solve that? Reveal that the team had been sent back in time on a mission by Domon of the Mirai Sentai Timeranger and they decided to give the two teams a hand while no one was looking.
- On the other hand, we're still not sure how it is that the Gokaigers keep their ability to turn into other Rangers after the past Rangers' powers were restored at the end of the regular series. Not that anyone is complaining.
- Greg and Tamara from Once Upon a Time and their absurd magic-defeating tech, which the show's producers quickly were driven to regret. The next season premiere reveals it actually was all magic, and they were just suckers unknowingly working for Peter Pan.
- The Community episode "Repilot" dismisses the entirety of the widely-hated Season 4 (the only season not overseen by Dan Harmon) by claiming that the school had suffered a massive gas leak, explaining everyone's inconsistent and decidedly Out of Character behavior.
- Daniel Bryan's poorly handled stint with the Wyatt family. Bryan was supposed to have fallen over the Despair Event Horizon after the Authority's constant screwing leading up to a gauntlet match against the members of the family one-by-one, ending with Bray Wyatt ordering the others to just beat Bryan down, regardless of the match's outcome. But Bryan's response to this? Join their family/cult. Not only did he wear a plain sleeveless jumpsuit that made him look like '90s throwback Duke "The Dumpster" Drose, wrestling garbage collector, but he didn't act all that different than before. Plus, not only did the fan base not buy into Bryan's "motivation" to join them, but every crowd he wrestled in front of absolutely refused to boo him. So what happens? Two weeks later, he and Bray are in a steel cage match against the Usos. Once the Usos win, Bray attempts to discipline Bryan and, in a fit of Bullying a Dragon (heh) goads him into fighting back. Which he does, running interference on the other Wyatts who try to get back in the cage, and kicking Bray Wyatt up and down the ring...to thunderous "YES!" chants.
- There's an apocryphal story stating the Prophet Muhammad once spoke positively of three pagan Meccan goddesses (why is not clear). However (the story goes) Muhammad later recanted these passages, claiming that Satan must have influenced him to say them. The tale lived on in the folklore of many Muslim countries, and the story was transmitted to the West by means of Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses, whose title is a reference to the tale.
- Invoked by Warhammer 40,000. Any piece of fluff that ends up badly written or ends up painting any faction as a Mary Sue can be safely written off as in-universe propaganda.
- The same goes for BattleTech, although its more clear on which is just an historical error and which really happen.
- Persona 2 Eternal Punishment (English version) pretty much serves as a retroactive Author's Saving Throw for the badly translated first game by compensating for the lousy translation of most of the names like how Takahisa Kandori became Guido Sardenia by breaking even and establishing his real name was Guido Kandori (since Guido is spoken in the first game cutscenes, this was unavoidable), and that his name in the first game was an alias. They also pretend Kei/Nate never had his last name changed from Nanjo to Trinity, among a few other changes to compensate for both continuity and to apparently apologize for doing such a miserable job.
- Fallout 3's ending caused some rather... negative reactions, in no small part thanks to its Diabolus ex Machina. The DLC/Expansion pack Broken Steel changes the ending, allowing the game to remain playable after this. Word of God says the game's default endings (without the expansion) are non-canon.
- After many players called out Metal Gear Solid for its extremely loose understanding of basic genetics (as relayed by the main antagonist, Liquid Snake), Hideo Kojima stepped up and established that Liquid himself has an extremely flimsy grasp on the subject and didn't actually know a word of what he was saying. It doesn't explain how a man with a supposed I.Q. of 180 and a fluency in seven languages could get such simple scientific facts wrong, or why Ocelot refers to Solid as the "inferior one".
- Metal Gear Solid 3 introduced a Close-Quarters Combat (CQC) system that allows the player to subdue enemy soldiers using various martial art techniques. This combat system is explained in the game's plot as a fighting style that Naked Snake (the protagonist, who later becomes Big Boss) learned from his mentor The Boss. Solid Snake (the protagonist of the previous games and the cloned son of Big Boss) couldn't use this style in the previous MGS games, so when the CQC system was implemented in Metal Gear Solid 4, they had to come up with a reason why Solid Snake never used it in previous games. It turns out Solid Snake always knew CQC, but refused to use it because of his disdain for Big Boss, who taught him the style. After the events of Operation: Snake Eater were "declassified" (i.e. MGS3 came out), many soldiers began developing their own variations of the CQC style, leaving Solid Snake with no choice but to use the skills he learned from Big Boss.
- Prince of Persia: Warrior Within was written with a mandate from marketing to turn the series away from the Arabian Nights feel and make it Darker and Edgier, complete with emo antihero Prince and heavy metal music. The fans bashed the change mercilessly, and the writers answered rather innovatively by working the Dork Age into the plot of Prince of Persia: The Two Thrones, making the Warrior Within Prince into a manifestation of the hero's irresponsibility and not the real thing. It also acknowledges the selfishness inherent in trying to fix the timeline in order to Set Right What Once Went Wrong, and when the Dark Prince taunts him with this near the end, he finally realizes that he needs to stop trying to change the past and solve his problems in the present.
- Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days pulls this to retcon Axel and Roxas' previously ambiguous Ho Yay relationship into one of big brother/little brother — while still leaving plenty of potential Ship Tease for those who choose to see it that way. Turns out that when Roxas was formed without memories, Axel basically took it upon himself to raise him.
- Speaking of Kingdom Hearts, Birth By Sleep and Re:coded both feature additional bosses that, gameplay-wise, turn out to be close enough to the ones previously exclusive to the Final Mix version of Kingdom Hearts and Kingdom Hearts II, and therefore confined to Japan. So, the "Unknown" (Xemnas) gets an expy through the new Unknown in Birth By Sleep, thus covering KHIFM territory, while Terra's Lingering Will from KHIIFM+ gets his expy thanks to Vanitas' Lingering Will, still in BBS. Also, you get to play as Terra's Lingering Will near the end of his storyline. About Roxas, upgraded from a cutscene (KHII) to a full-fledged boss (KHIIFM+), the fact he was still a storyline boss instead of a bonus boss allowed him to be used as a Final Boss instead, in Re:coded. You can basically see Tetsuya Nomura saying "sorry, western fans".
- Not to mention the new "HD 1.5 Remix" Collection that are coming out, giving all non-Japanese fans Kingdom Hearts Final Mix for the first time, and re:Chain of Memories to the rest of the world (after it was given a downplayed Western release in America only) along side remastered cutscenes from 358/2 Days. Demand was high enough for a 2.5 to be announced for a 2014 release which includes the Final Mix versions of the second game and Birth By Sleep as well as Re:coded scenes thrown in.
- The King of Fighters had this in the 2002 edition. After '98, the gameplay was changed as there would be four characters being selectable for the fight, with one (or more, in 2001) being a Striker, a supportive character that would be called to perform a move in order to stop an opponent or open his guard for your attacks. This, of course, didn't work well, with several bugs and infinite combos as result. In 2002, the game went back to 3-on-3 fights with no strikers, like '98 and the titles before it.
- Also, there's one involving the storyline. See, most fans were unhappy (euphemism) about Ash Crimson taking the role of protagonist previously covered by Kyo and K', just as much as they were unhappy about him stealing both Chizuru and Iori's Sacred Treasures powers. Come XIII, Ash enacts a Heroic Sacrifice to stop the Big Bad of that Story Arc. Mind you, he doesn't die... he is erased from existence. Retroactively! So he never really existed in the first place!
- XIII itself counts as an example. XII was labelled as a Dream Match Game, but it really was an Obvious Beta released to earn SNK Playmore some quick cash in order to alleviate the production costs for redrawing the large cast of characters in high-definition. The end result? XII was crawling with bugs and infinites, not to mention a drastically reduced roster total from previous games. XIII addressed these complaints by ironing out most of the gameplay problems and bringing back several fighters who skipped out on the last few titles. Also, while the Kizuna Encounter/Marvel vs. Capcom/Neo Geo Battle Coliseum-esque Tactical Shift system in 2003 and XI was actually well-liked by most fans, XIII assumes the traditional 3-on-3, round-robin format from the series' inception.
- In Dissidia: Final Fantasy, Kuja, originally an arrogant, cunning, cruel, and poetic mage was reduced to what was essentially a child throwing an eternal temper tantrum, throwing fits when his plans failed, being mocked by the other villains and having his arrogance and faux-Shakespearean dialogue exaggerated heavily. Then Dissidia 012 was released as a prequel, and it reveals that Kefka set Kuja up to be killed in the 12th cycle of the war, and used this time to implant false memories in him that twisted him into the Kuja seen in the 13th cycle of Dissidia. The "real" Kuja seen in Dissidia 012 unaffected by Kefka's manipulations is much more affable, calm, and collected, and even tries to help the heroes before the other villains catch onto his ruse. This both made him a much deeper and sympathetic character and brought his characterization back in-line with the redeemed Kuja glimpsed at the end of his original game.
- Half-Life 2: Episode 1. After the second game, the fanbase was extremely displeased by what, to Gordon, amounts to a Shoot the Shaggy Dog even worse than the first. The Episode blows the rage away through a Crowning Moment Of Awesome for the Vortigaunts that both retcons Alyx's implied death, and changes the whole storyline, showing the G-Man isn't as all-powerful as thought before.
- The debut trailer for the 2011 SSX game had an extremely Darker and Edgier feel, realistic and "gritty" graphics, some plot revolving around rival teams of boarders competing to race in the most inhospitable places on Earth and the title SSX: Deadly Descents. Cue derogatory nicknames like "Call of SSX: Winter Assault" and variants. Every single game related media since then has the developers insisting that the characters and the cartoony and over the top feel of the game are still there and that the "Deadly Descents" are just a small part of the game, the others being the classic racing and trick modes. The subtitle was eventually removed.
- Perhaps the Ur Example for Video Games: Zilpha Keatley Snyder agreed to allow Spinnaker to make a game based on the Green Sky Trilogy…On One Condition. She realized her True Art Is Angsty ending to the books was a huge goof and wanted the game's plot to center around one of Raamo's True Companions coming to his rescue. This being made in 1984, makes it possibly the first Canon sequel in video game form to something written for other media.
- Remember the outrage that ensued when it was revealed that DmC: Devil May Cry was some odd preboot set before 3, but with drastic changes to Dante's character and backstory that made it completely incompatible with pre-existing canon (to the point of sounding like a Self-Insert Fic running on Canon Defilement)? Yeah, about that.
- Although one could argue that Capcom is attempting damage control; especially when one considers that Capcom first announced this new DMC as a prequel, then a reboot, and now an installment that only has Devil May Cry in the name.
- It also looks fishy; the official description of the game reads things like "rediscover Dante and Vergil" - if we are in an alternate universe, then why is every canon character present and why do we rediscover them as opposed to simply discovering them?
- The ending of Syphon Filter 2 apparently had Teresa permanently killed off, but the third game retconned this as Faking the Dead.
- When Ratchet & Clank came out, a recurring complaint among critics was Ratchet's characterization (acting like a selfish Jerkass towards the much more sympathetic Clank). When Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando was in development, Insomniac made sure to include several cutscenes where Ratchet defends Clank and worries for him, all with the explicitly stated purpose of "fixing" Ratchet's character.
- In World of Warcraft: Cataclysm, Forsaken have begun using Val'kyr necromancy against their human enemies in order to replenish their numbers. Unlike Scourge undead, however, Forsaken undead retain the free will they had in life after being raised. When this was revealed, Alliance players began complaining that a human being killed by the Forsaken, raised into undeath by them and then choosing to aid the Forsaken in slaughtering their former comrades of their own free will broke the Willing Suspension of Disbelief. Blizzard eventually addressed this in one of their Ask Creative Development sessions, saying that though new Forsaken are free-willed, many of them are raised in a frenzied and malleable state in which they can be easily manipulated into attacking their allies by the Forsaken. This effect is apparently only temporary and the new Forsaken do eventually get to make their own choice afterward.
- Valkyria Chronicles III introduces Shin Hyuga, whose mother comes from "somewhere in the Far East"; he himself is modeled to be Feudal Japanese in a mid-20th-centurish fantasy pastiche world. His inclusion is a reaction to the criticism of the Darcsen in the first game: they were designed as an obvious expy of European Jews persecuted during World War II, but the art style and cultural cues used for the Darcsen people, combined with a conspicuous lack of an expy-Japan, made it look like the story replaced the Jews with the Japanese. Shin's inclusion is most likely meant to help dissolve that particular image.
- Really, VC 3 is a huge, multiple die saving throw. Throughout the franchise, the Darcssens has been portrayed as a whole-race woobie who have never done any wrong in the history of Europa. VC 3 revolves around fighting an elite imperial battalion who are (almost) entirely Darcssen, and whose aim is establishing a Darcssen homeland through any means, even utilizing a WMD (Hmm...). Of the three Darcssen in your unit, one is gloomy fatalist, one is consumed by Revenge Before Reason, and the other betray you to join the aforementioned battalion and is set on obliterating the capitol of his former-country.
- The best ending of Mass Effect 3 had caused an Internet Backdraft of epic proportions. Official polls from Bioware showed ninety-plus percent of people hated the ending for various reasons. The outrage culminated in several campaigns aimed at getting Bioware to notice, including donating tens of thousands of dollars to Child's Play. Finally, two weeks after the game's release, Bioware announced they'd be releasing an extended version of the endings to (hopefully) clear up everything that happened. Only time will tell if this pacifies the fanbase or just makes them angrier.
- While the new scenes did introduce some additional plot holes, most jarring parts of the fan complaints about the original ending were addressed, though opinions vary on how successful they were. A couple of major Retcons went a long way to mollifying the fanbase upset over the Inferred Holocaust of the original ending (things aren't nearly as bad as Fridge Horror believed).
- The Citadel DLC is also an example. Among other things, it addressed the biggest non-ending related complaint about the game, which was the relative lack of time given to most of the surviving Mass Effect 2 squad, particularly the love interests. While none of them figure into the main plot of the DLC, a slew of additional scenes were added with all of them, which were all well-received by fans for the most part. The Thane-related content seems to be the most divisive, though, especially among Thanemancers. Kolyat and Shepard hold a funeral for him at the apartment. While the funeral itself seems to be liked, some feel that it's jarring given the otherwise goofy and lighthearted tone of the DLC. And while Thanemancers had their grievances addressed for the most part, the romanced content created something of a Broken Base. Some are angry that the DLC only starts after his death, thus robbing them of additional interactions with him. Ghost!Thane showing up Patrick Swayze-style at the end of the DLC is widely seen as Narmy, even by people who generally liked the content.
- After Microsoft Studios received a massive Internet Counterattack about several poorly received features on the new Xbox ONE, they released a statement detailing changes made for damage control, such as no universal DRM on used games and no required 24-hour internet checkup, even though it still needs an initial internet connection to set up.
- Super Robot Wars Operation Extend is possibly being one after the monumental failure Heroes Phantasia was, as Keroro Gunsou (who appeared in that game) appears in SRW, despise appearing in another crossover game in less of a year, and despise Keroro Gunsou NOT being (technically) a Mecha series per se.
- Collar 6. After the drugging incident, Wolfe took two months real-time having the characters discuss how dysfunctional their relationship had become.
- College Roomies from Hell!!!: early on in the comic, Maritza wanted to kill off Dave, but there was such an outrage among the fans that she decided to bring him back. Thank God.
- In Survival of the Fittest, Madison Conner's Face-Heel Turn and subsequent Ax-Crazy rampage was explained to have been because she suffers from bipolar disorder, which had been hinted at but never elaborated on. It didn't work too well.
- The creepypasta Happy Appy, which was experiencing a massive drop in quality due to the Narminess of the later posts, decided to remove all posts that weren't by Dronian. It became better as a result.
- The NChick team were getting a lot of flack over the "Nella abuse", which Fan Dumb took way too seriously and thought it was happening in real life. So Lindsay made a "Thanks For Your Feedback", detailing that The Nostalgia Chick had sinfully low self-esteem and was paying Nella to make her look better.
- This seems to have also influenced "the Dark Nella Saga," where the evil entity possessing Nella gets revenge on the Chick for all the hell she put her through. (Note that the "Nella abuse" has pretty much stopped since the Saga ended.)
- Atop the Fourth Wall writer Lewis Lovhaug acknowledged in the commentary of "Pokemon: The Electric Tale of Pikachu" during The Entity storyline why Missingno was afraid of Lord Vyce, aware that with how he built it up as an unstoppable universe devouring Lovecraftian demon. He used the plot that Vyce's attacks were able to hurt it, but, according to Missingno, at least, couldn't kill it, but found getting rid off him to be enough of an inconvenience that it hid out in our dimension so Linkara would defeat Vyce. Note that even Lewis comments that Vyce not being able to kill it was at least from Missingo's point of view, and Missingno is full of itself even for a god.
- "Janine, You've Changed" from The Real Ghostbusters is generally considered to be one of the most tragically hilarious attempts at this ever made; the show's former writer, J. Michael Straczynski, is asked to come back and try to explain all the design changes made to a member of the secondary cast over the years. The end result... was actually fairly funny, had a pretty era-relevant Aesop for female viewers and had a bit of payoff for long-time watchers. That it needed to be done at all is where the tragedy lies.
- In Teen Titans Cyborg was always shown firing his sonic Arm Cannon from his right arm, until one day he used his left. Fans pointed out this apparent plot hole, and some time later, during a crucial fight, he simply converts both arms to cannons. It's hard to tell whether it was planned or this trope, since it makes perfect sense that he can convert both arms, and is simply right-dominant.
- The Fully Absorbed Finale for Batman Beyond had it revealed that CADMUS had overwritten Warren McGinnis' genetic material with that of Bruce Wayne, making him Terry and Matt's biological father. According to the creators, this was due to a realization on their part that the boys' black hair is genetically improbable given Mary's hair is red and Warren's light brown. Fanon also takes this as an explanation for why the McGinnis parents were amicably divorced—Warren suspected Mary of infidelity, straining the marriage, but without any actual infidelity taking place there wasn't much room for real animosity.
- In order to make his Heel-Face Turn work, Kevin 11's character was changed from Ben 10 to Ben 10: Alien Force, going from an Ax-Crazy sociopath to a perfectly sane Jerk with a Heart of Gold. His powers were also different; from absorbing energy to absorbing physical matter. All of Alien Force passed with no explanation. Finally, in Ben 10: Ultimate Alien, it was revealed that Kevin is half Osmosian and absorbing energy turns Osmosians insane; undergoing the tutelage of The Obi-Wan when imprisoned taught him to suppress that side by absorbing physical matter. Thus, the explanation behind Kevin's conflicting character presentations and use of powers was finally given a plausible explanation.
- They also fixed another problem: in the original series Kevin claimed he had no parents, with Alien Force in fact revealing that his dad was a Plumber & he knew his mom. It was later revealed that, his mom & stepfather had thrown him out of the house after his Osmosian powers manifested themselves and nearly blew up the place; so in a sense, he really didn't have any parents, since they disowned him.
- Also, there was the problem of the others trusting Kevin so quickly in Alien Force, as if he hadn't been someone who just wants to watch the world burn last time they'd seen him. A later Time Travel adventure has young Ben meet the new Kevin, and it's explained that though he won't remember it clearly (hence Teen Ben not having experienced any of it as Kid Ben) he'll remember it vaguely, as if a dream... and just enough to perhaps trust Kevin when they meet again. Ironically, in this episode, Kevin is forced to absorb the Omnitrix's energy once more in this episode, and becomes Ben and Gwen's enemy again. Ben seems really quick to decide "Ultimate Kevin" is irredeemable.
- Also, Gwen's powers. It got overshadowed by the new Kevin being a horse pill of galactic proportions, but in the original series, Gwen was learning magic, casting the spells she learned in the spell book she nicked from magical villainess Charmcaster. Alien Force sees her creating pink force fields, period, like a Green Lantern without the ability to make more complex shapes, and her abilities were revealed to be due to alien heritage. Again, UA makes it make more sense: spellcasting is one way of channeling her alien powers. It's around this point that she starts to use spells again instead of all force fields all the time, and in flashbacks to the original series era, a mostly spell-focused young Gwen also adds force fields to her repertoire. We still get no word on why it went from blue to pink between seasons. Apparently her energy colors changed out of the blue (no pun intended) between the final episode of the original series and the earliest-set flashback to its era.
- It should be noted however that most of these problems were addressed by Dwayne McDuffie on the Q&A part of his website long before the respected episodes aired.
- Inverted in what fans of My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic have dubbed "Derpygate," where the creators of the show changed the voice acting in a scene where beloved background pony Derpy Hooves is given spoken lines. A small group of parents protested this scene, finding it offensive (the name "Derpy" and the voice acting, which was a misunderstanding where the VA thought the character was male). The studio took the original episode off of iTunes and replaced it with one where Derpy's voice was changed and her name was not mentioned. This was the point where the fandom revolted , leading to quite a few webpages calling for the scene to be changed back. Eventually, the creators apologized to both sides. After being absent for most of Season 3, Derpy was finally re-inserted during the Season finale.
- At the end of "Dragon Quest", Spike takes Peewee a baby phoenix from his parents and adopted him. Many fans complained about the kidnapping and the Broken Aesop because the same episode began with Spike complaining about not knowing where he comes from. In "Just for Sidekicks", it is revealed that Spike returned the phoenix to his parents. However this again has not been unanimously welcomed, due to how abrupt this felt, leading to some people thinking They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character.
- After Meghan McCarthy gave a poorly thought out statement that indicated she thought becoming a princess was something every girl dreams of, and was bombarded with complaints about how reductive that was, "Princess Twilight Sparkle" features the tomboy Rainbow Dash saying it's not the case. Though due to Animation Lead Time, chances were that RD's line had always been there.
- A lot of the fanbase wasn't happy with how Season 3 portrayed Spike as being quite incompetent (in "Spike at Your Service" he causes massive damage whenever he tries to help, and in "Just for Sidekicks" he screws up pet-sitting so badly that he ends up on a train in another country). As a result, the season 4 episode "Power Ponies" is pretty much based on the premise that Spike is helpful and the rest of the cast don't view him as The Load.
- In South Park, Kenny was killed off for the sixth season and the status quo was experimented with. By the last scene of the season finale, Kenny inexplicably walks back in because, in Trey Parker's own words, "that's just what he does." However, the big change in the status quo (Butters as the fifth main character) stuck; it's just "unofficial".
- "The Coon Saga", gave an explanation for his continual appearance; Kenny turns out to be the heroic Mysterion, a "superhero" in South Park with the power to be reborn continually after death; his mother spontaneously gives birth to a new Kenny after the last one's death, which then proceeds to grow to the previous one's age. And he remembers everything, but everyone else forgets his death almost instantly.
- The Japanese dub of The Simpsons Movie tried to pull an inverted Poor Man's Substitute by replacing the cast used in the regular series with bigger-name actors, but fell straight into The Other Darrin instead, forcing them to try and make up for it by redubbing the movie with the original cast for DVD.
- Some fans say the SpongeBob SquarePants episode "The Cent Of Money" is this for having Mr. Krabs, whose been a Karma Houdini for the past few seasons, finally getting some comeuppance. It can also make up for "A Pal For Gary", as SpongeBob is being overly protective of him here instead of being a jerk to him.
- Season 2 of The Legend of Korra features quite a few in response to criticisms of the first season:
- The tension between benders and non-benders being too easily resolved, given the very legitimate grievances of non-benders? The Republic City council made up entirely of benders is replaced by a democratically elected non-bender president.
- Korra learning how to airbend while still having no real understanding of the philosophy behind it? Tenzin chastises her for this, and how it results in a very limited version of the art only suitable for combat.
- Mako constantly lying to Asami about his feelings for Korra and stringing her along? This time he does the same thing in the opposite direction, except the show doesn't let him get away with it, and he ends up admitting what a jerk he was and that he doesn't deserve either girl.