A number of the What Ifs are hilarious due to the completely insane, but perfectly logical, conclusions (and, sometimes, the sheer insanity of what is being logically considered in the first place). Others are hilarious for the irrelevant but amusing tangents the author sometimes goes off on.
- Relativistic Baseball. A question about pitching nukes a city.
- of course, in that case, the question wasn't exactly straightforward. Still, the conclusion, in context, is arguably one of the funniest things on the site; A careful reading of official Major League Baseball Rule 6.08(b) suggests that in this situation, the batter would be considered "hit by pitch", and would be eligible to advance to first base.
- A Mole of Moles. No insane ending, but it nevertheless involves a moon-sized ball of meat and fur that periodically erupts in plumes of boiling guts.
- Glass Half Empty. The standard optimist-or-pessimist question leaves people with shards of broken glass embedded in their faces.
- Everybody Jump. A rather simple question of kinematics becomes a dire civilisation-ending catastrophe. Not because of the kinematics at all (which amount to nothing), but simply because the question presupposes magically gathering every human into one location, with no implied way back home.
- Cassini. A detailed and thoughtful exploration of climatic interactions concludes with A Prairie Home Companion being attacked by fire ants and alligators.
- Raindrop features some absolutely brilliant bits of wordplay, one in each of the last two paragraphs:
Fear reigns supreme as the world fears rain supreme.
...and the unexplained meteorological phenomenon is simply dubbed a “Skrillex Storm”—because, in the words of one researcher, “It had one hell of a drop.” (The book changed this to "dubstep storm".)
- Laser Pointer. A question on light ends with the moon becoming a rocket engine and Earth suffering a Class 4 Planetary Apocalypse How.
- Tie Vote. A question about elections ends with this gem, with an image to match:
...when one of the Florida electors reaches into the hat to draw a name, he or she is struck by a falling cocaine bale, the hat is hurled away within the next few seconds by a tornado, and the elector is obliterated minutes later by a meteorite impact.
- "Machine Gun Jetpack":
(Stick figure has attached a rear-facing GAU-8 Avenger to the top of a car.)
Do you know why I pulled you over? Stick:
No. Alt Text:
actually, what i'm confused about is 'how'.
- In "Short Answer Section II", Cueball has a hypothetical printer that can literally print a sheet of money once every minute. So, now he's trying to figure out what the annual income of that is.
- Model Rockets's punchline is a Call-Back to Up Goer Five.
- Interplanetary Cessna: The second illustration has a reluctant pilot screaming a Big "NO!" and is being forced to enter the airplane.
: i do not want to go to space today
- The description of how well a plane would fly on Venus:
- Longest Sunset kicks off the article by defining what qualifies as a sunset and what doesn't. Examples of the latter include the sun crossing the horizon partway and then reversing direction (Alt Text: "the sun changes its mind and goes back to bed"), the sun splitting in two via osmosis and half of it setting ("this is half a sunset"), the sun landing on the horizon and hatching like an egg ("you bred sun-raptors?"), and a square sun that doesn't get a chance to do anything before the narration cuts it off ("aww, man, you didn't even let me try").
- Train Loop discusses jet-engine-powered trains.
Sadly, they never took off. Fortunately, they never took off.
- "Ok, putting the jet engine on top didn't work. Maybe we should try something different." So he puts the jet engine on the bottom, so the train can't make contact with the tracks and tips over.
...why did we think that would work? Forget that idea.
- This excerpt from Alien Astronomers: "The Sun is really bright and its light illuminates the Earth." Funny enough by itself, but then you check the links...
- Another one links to the Wikipedia page for Cetacean.
- Sunless Earth. After a long list of the surprising benefits of a lack of sunlight, the ending bluntly points out we'd end up freezing to death.
It's the Sun. We need the Sun.
- Drain the Oceans. Sure, the oceans would be gone and with them most of the biosphere and planetary habitability, but the real major change is The Netherlands conquering the planet. Also, Munroe decides that since all that water has to go somewhere, the exit portal should be on Mars to avoid any risk of atmospheric re-entry. Innocuous enough as is, but he then specifies that it should be placed directly over the Curiosity rover, so that it can finally find water on Mars.
- In Drain the Oceans: Part II, after the ocean is finished being deposited at Mars, the Netherlands use the now-empty ocean-draining portal to conquer Mars as well.
- Dropping a Mountain calls back to Drain the Oceans. The mountain is dropped from high enough that it pulls an orbital slingshot around the Earth, and crashes into New Netherlands, the now-Dutch-and-watery Mars.
- At some point, Munroe started getting creative with his citations. Clicking the numbers in Random Sneeze Call reveals these gems:
However, given that sneezes are far more common than murders, 2 (...)
[The control group] was given no allergens at all; they just sat alone in a room for a total of 176 20-minute sessions. 5
The subjects in the control group sneezed four times during those 58 or so hours, 6 which (...)
- And again in Orbital Speed:
The X-15 aircraft reached space just by going fast and then steering up. 3
The ISS moves so quickly that if you fired a rifle bullet from one end of a football field, 7 the International Space Station could cross the length of the field before the bullet traveled 10 yards. 8
- When doing the research for Falling With Helium, Randall made so many requests to Wolfram Alpha that he got his IP address banned. The image of his ban-appeal request is icing on the cake.
Please provide us with detailed information about what you were trying to do (e.g. type of project, query types, etc.):
Calculating how many rental helium tanks you'd have to carry with you in order to inflate a balloon large enough to act as a parachute and slow your fall from a jet aircraft.
- On the ninth illustration with The Little Prince shooting a hoop in Little Planet
: Cleveland-area fans of French children's literature were disappointed by his decision to sign with the Miami Heat.
- Soda Planet concludes with a diagram of a person drinking directly out of an apatosaurus. With a straw.
- Star Sand is relatively tame by What If standards, but the final image's alt text is amusing: "Just to be clear, this image does not update every hour."
- Another image describes increasingly large stars as "stars that are heavier, bigger, bluer, younger, (the rest is crossed out) harder, better, faster, stronger". These are referred to as "Daft Punk stars" in the main text afterwards.
- Citation #5 in Paint the Earth goes off on a tangent listing things that are not buildings.
EXAMPLES OF THINGS THAT ARE NOT BUILDINGS: Ducks, M&Ms, cars, the Sun, cuttlefish, microchips, Macklemore, lightning, goat blood, zeppelins, tapeworms, pickle jars, those sticks you use to toast marshmallows, alligators, tuning forks, minotaurs, Perseid meteors, ballots, crude oil, sponsored tweets, and catapults that throw handfuls of engagement rings.
- Rocket Golf:
- The 237 mph diagram, comparing two circles of nearly equal size: "Bag Full of Golf Balls", and Earth ... which is labelled "Ball Covered With Golf Courses."
- Growth Rate states that if children kept growing at the rate they do just after birth, they would be as tall as Darth Vader by the time they were three. Then there is a picture of Dark Vader and a three-year-old that's caught a beetle.
I find the bug you found disturbing.
- One-Second Day starts off with this absolute gem:
"The Earth rotates,[Citation Needed
] which means its midsection is being flung outward by centrifugal force. 1
This centrifugal force isn't strong enough to overcome gravity and tear the earth apart, but it's enough to flatten the earth slightly and make it so you weight almost a pound less at the Equator than you do at the poles. 2
- Billion-Story Building, in which Randall attempts to explain to a four-year-old why building a billion-story building is impossible. It's quite hilarious, because you can tell he's making a genuine effort to let the young girl asking the question down gently, but what makes it even funnier is the utter absurdity of such a building once Randall draws a billion-story-tall skyscraper and compares its size with Earth (It's tall. Really tall. Like "reaches-past-the-Moon" tall.)
- In "Vanishing Water", Randall is asked what would happen if all the oceans and lakes on Earth were to instantly disappear. In the Alt Text of one of the pictures, he grumbles that this would cause yet another situation where all life on Earth would die horribly.
"Why can't the questions ever be, like, 'what if I saw a really good movie' or 'what if I adopted a puppy'?"
- In "Global Snow" a small duck pond full of an inch worth of water made into snow is shown shrinking due to its own weight with a small duck in winter gear sitting on top waiting for it to become a pond again.
- A hilarious aside near the beginning of Balloon Car, asked by a Cambridge father on behalf of his 12-year-old daughter:
Thanks for getting your dad to send in this question! He said not to worry about the "legal and insurance difficulties," so I think it's safe to assume he's taken care of all that.
Note to police: If you've recently taken into custody two unidentified underage drivers, a stolen Ferrari, and a bunch of helium balloons, the person you're looking for is Phil Rodgers in Cambridge, UK.
- Some of the questions go unanswered in the "Weird and Worrying Questions" segments. Such as:
Is it possible to drop your teeth's temperature so they shatter when drinking a cup of coffee?
Thank you for my new recurring nightmare.
How many houses catch fire every year in the U.S. and what would the best way to increase that amount by fifteen percent?
Hello, police? See, I have a website where people ask questions...
(asked by someone named Karl) Can you cry so much you get dehydrated?
...Karl, is everything OK?
(asked by someone named Brittany) Assuming a relatively uniform resonant frequency in a passenger jet, how many cats, meowing at what resonant frequency of said jet, would be required to "bring it down"?
Hello, FAA? Is there a "Brittany" on the no-fly list? ...Yes, with cats. That sounds like her. Ok, just making sure you were aware.
- Seeing as it's sealed tight to operate under the sea, could a submarine and its crew operate in space? This situation comes up while thinking about it:
Sonarman: Captain, according to sonar, we're re-entering the atmosphere!
Captain: No part of this makes sense.
- "Hair Dryer" discusses what would happen if an indestructible, continuously-powered hair dryer were put into an airtight 1x1x1 meter box. Who would've guessed that the box would burn the Northwest Territories and leave Earth's atmosphere?
- This gem from Lunar Swimming:
Swimming underwater would also feel pretty similar. The inertia of the water is the main source of drag when swimming, and inertia is a property of matter 1 independent of gravity.
- The same page also indicates that Munroe "nerd-sniped [him]self trying to figure out whether it'd be possible to do a Slip N' Slide loop-the-loop on the Moon".
- In "Stairs" the time and effort required to reach the top of really high stairs is measured in butter. With the note that alternatively one can just ride a motorcycle upstairs. It also talks about the time it would take a slinky to get down from those stairs ... and the result is also given in butter.
- "Phone Keypad" experiments with comprehensible phrases that can be produced with key restrictions. The resulting phrases and sentences are ridiculous, and become hysterical when illustrated. The Alt Text on each image is also very funny.
- This passage from Stop Jupiter, while talking about the budget cuts necessary to build enough probes to perform enough gravitational slingshots to, well, stop Jupiter.
At some point, in our desperate attempts to stop Jupiter's forward speed, we'd be reduced to stuffing handfuls of rocks and dirt into a burlap sack with a NASA logo on the side.
(picture of Cueball and Ponytail doing exactly that)note
- How Randall figured out the weight of a 20-inch pizza.
Footnote 1: Citation: I just ordered a pizza to check. I usually steer clear of experimental science in these articles, but am willing to make an exception when it involves eating a bunch of pizza.
- Discussing focusing the entire energy output of the sun into a 1-meter diameter beam in Sunbeam:
If you were standing in the path of the beam, you would obviously die pretty quickly. You wouldn't really die of anything, in the traditional sense. You would just stop being biology and start being physics.
My hobby: Vandalizing open-source ephemera libraries to say the Moon's phase was 'new' on the date the Twilight book/film was released.
- Discussing planets in a dual-sun system in Tatooine Rainbow:
In the first kind of system, the two stars are close together and the planet goes around them far away. This kind of planet is called a circumbinary planet. In the second kind of system, the two stars are farther apart, and the planet orbits one of them 1
while the other stays far away. This kind of planet is called [the other kind of planet]
- The conclusion of Sun Bug. A firefly large enough for its luminous organs to be as bright as the Sun turns out as large as our solar system, then collapsing under its own weight to become the biggest black hole in the universe.
- Eat the Sun has an interesting line near its conclusion.
At the end of this article
, we imagined a galaxy full of habitable planets, each one hosting 7 billion clones of former solicitor general Ted Olson. (Don't ask.