Disambiguating Works / Subpage Collision Discussion

The steps should be added to the OP on the project thread, not here, and they don't necessarily involve history moves.

If we are considering pinned posts -

Can we add something to explain the scope of this thread vs. Making disambigs for works that share names..., as they're in different subforums but sometimes get used interchangeably?

, What do you think, ~War Jay 77, since you opened the thread?

Wasn't there talk of morguing one and keeping the other?

Uh, yeah, if you ask me personally I firmly believe this thread should be been quietly abandoned after the debate ended. There was indeed talks of morguing one of these threads (there's one here and one in LT/P). I've never really been in agreement with people using this as a project thread in the first place, so IDK how I really feel about having a sticky.

So what is going to happen with UNDERTOW?

In that case, how about we get this one closed/locked, with a final post or updated sticky that basically says "use the other thread instead", complete with a link to it?

Any ongoing discussions can be moved over.

Sound like a plan?

As someone who follows both threads but pretty much only posts in the thread at Long Term Projects, I'm on board with this.

Edited by BlackFaithStar on Jul 28th 2023 at 6:13:45 PM

I proposed this months ago but it was other way around. This thread was more active so I wanted to move to LTP and close the other one. It's probably easier to just lock this one though.

We don't need a sticky though. We don't do that for other locked threads. The last post of the thread should explain the lock.

Edited by MacronNotes on Jul 28th 2023 at 8:36:29 AM