Needs Help: Modesty Towel

Previous thread, clocked out due to inactivity.

Modesty Towel's current pic works but is noticeably grainy. From the previous thread, here's the suggestions that, IMO, are the best replacements and don't overlap with Non-Nude Bathing, which I'll be making a thread about shortly:

Actually uploaded:

Just links:

• Heather◊ from Total Drama
• Eloise and Nadine from Sandra on the Rocks (first panel)
• Love Hina: 1◊, 2, 3
• Different take on the second uploaded pic◊

We've got lots of good options here...right now, my favorites are either of the two uploaded pics and the last linked one.

edited 16th Mar '15 9:18:59 PM by Willbyr

Wait, I thought we decided on the second uploaded one? From Gundam Build Fighters.

Honestly the Code Geass one looks like a dress.

EDIT: The last linked one works even better actually.

edited 17th Mar '15 12:18:39 AM by Memers

I think that thread clocked out sometime when I wasn't online for an extended time, or I'd probably have said something. Anyway, there are certainly something to be chosen from all those suggestions, although I'm not sure which one I prefer.

The thread clocked out before much discussion was done on that one.

Correct me, but isn't the trope foremost about people wrapping themselves up in towels despite being all alone? I would vote for either 1.1. or 1.3.2

While that's certainly part of it, wearing the towel to preserve modesty when around someone else, especially if the sexes are opposite, makes it even more clear. I'm surprised that that isn't part of the description since it ties into the sexualized/fanservice aspects just as much as if the person is alone.

edited 17th Mar '15 4:16:00 PM by Willbyr

]

Enchanted example.

edited 17th Mar '15 5:41:45 PM by Ultimatum

That image isnt quite the trope really.

edited 17th Mar '15 5:38:02 PM by Memers

Its in the examples..

Nevermind.

That feels like something else aside from this.

That's more like an invoked version of Scenery Censor.

another suggestion from Majokko Megu-chan [1]◊

That's not bad...Image Links material for sure.

crowner?

Crowner; some of them need more information.

I like 1.1 because it's clear the "modesty towel" appeared before she even left the shower stall.

Although, an important part of the trope seems to be wearing a towel even though no one else is there, and there's another person there. Thoughts on that?

edited 30th Mar '15 12:22:30 PM by rodneyAnonymous

The rest of the staff and I were discussing that a week or so ago...I think the definition needs to be expanded, as is I think it's too limited. There's a definite fanservice element that the current definition is lacking; there's a great example (which turns into a subversion) in one chapter of the manga version of Neon Genesis Evangelion.

edited 30th Mar '15 2:00:32 PM by Willbyr

Calling this one. Can someone please upload and add the winner? Thanks in advance. Caption or no?

Done, low vote number nonwithstanding.

No caption discussion since the pic went up; locking up.