- Face of the Band: As with any female-fronted band, Lacey.
- Nightmare Fuel: The video to "All Around Me", mainly due to the way the walls bleed...
- Most Wonderful Sound: Lacey's voice is absolutely beautiful. Her range isn't anything to shrug at.
- Replacement Scrappy: Kristen never got past this despite arguably being a technically better singer. One thing in particular being fans complaining about her not screaming at first, despite them only performing two songs where Lacey screamed, and then complaining again when she tried, because she growled instead of Lacey's high screams.
- Signature Song: "I'm So Sick" and "All Around Me", though "Cassie" is quite popular too.
- They Changed It, Now It Sucks!:
- Their whole second album was criticized for this due to the Christian theme. Fridge Logic occurs when you notice that the first album was just as Christian, having songs that could easily relate to the religion and even referencing Jesus.
- Also, most of the fanbase's reaction to Lacey's departure and replacement.
YMMV / Flyleaf