Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Valiona's Stalker Diary of The Stalking Zuko Series
Valiona2014-07-25 22:40:39

Go To


SZ Chapter 1: The Observations Begin

Stalking Zuko

"You might have everyone else buying your... "transformation", but you and I both know you've struggled with doing the right thing in the past. So let me tell you something right now. You make one step backward, one slip up, give me one reason to think you might hurt Aang, and you won't have to worry about your destiny anymore. Because I'll make sure your destiny ends, Right then and there."
Katara

The first installment of the fic, Stalking Zuko, begins a few days after Avatar: The Last Airbender "The Western Air Temple", in which Zuko has been accepted into the Gaang, save for Katara.

Katara begins stalking and writing a diary on Zuko in order to see if she can catch him doing anything suspicious and learn his weaknesses. She calls him "Subject" to keep it confidential(although he'd know in a moment if he found her diary) distance herself from him, saying that "Subject will not endear himself to me again!" In any case, for the sake of clarity, and because I don't do things Katara's way, he and all other characters will be called by their proper names.

Katara then writes about Zuko's mother Ursa (whose name Katara doesn't know), conceding that she's missing and might be dead, but Katara thinks she got tired of Zuko's whining and ran off, which, even considering she admits it's "bitchy", is a low blow. It's also somewhat Harsher in Hindsight considering that in The Search, it turns out that Ursa abandoned the memories of a children for a new life, believing that she would never see them again, although I am actually more sympathetic toward Ursa than most.

Katara then notices that Zuko wakes up early, gets along well with Toph, and trains Aang in spite of the fact that Aang isn't the most diligent student and Zuko's own firebending is off. These details are nice touches, and appropriate considering this is about Katara's observations of Zuko. Katara is about to engage in some schadenfreude regarding Zuko's inability to firebend, but notices that he never smiles, an interestingly somber moment at the end of the observations.

In the next scene, apparently the next day, Katara is stuck doing the dishes, when Zuko comes in to help, over Katara's objections, and after some exchanged barbs, with Katara noting Zuko's betrayal at Ba Sing Se in their diary (it's perhaps a misnomer, as it can be argued that it was a case of Zuko choosing to keep opposing the Gaang, rather than choosing to help and going back on his word), Katara reluctantly accepts his help.

A word about the dialogue. Much of it, at least so far, appears to be Katara telling us about the conversations she's had, rather than showing them herself, not unlike what I'm doing in this liveblog, albeit with a different voice. This can be something of a cop-out for writers, but it can also be good at showing the dialogue from characters' perspective, as well as certain things about it from their point of view- their reactions, what they consider important, how they interpret the others' words and actions, and so forth.

Katara notes that Zuko feels bad about what happened, and again denies warming up to Zuko, denying that he will do so no matter how much he washes the dishes. After a few awkward attempts and an apparent Accidental Innuendo, Zuko asks for a truce, promising to help the Gaang if Katara doesn't hate him so much. Katara decides to think about it.

Katara notes that Zuko's firebending is useful for everyday tasks, and the many ways he is Adorkable, which is starting to turn her on.

Some would be skeptical about how Zuko and Katara could ever be friends, much less a couple, at this point. To that, I say that stories like telling of how people overcame the impossible, and much like how an underdog sports team defeats the champion, or how La RĂ©sistance overthrows The Empire, people overcoming a strong dislike of each other to fall in love is a popular story. It certainly makes for good drama, but like other dramatic techniques, it can sometimes strain belief. Why would Katara get together with Zuko after everything he's done? And what will happen with her burgeoning relationship with Aang? Only time will tell for this fic.

What I liked:

  • Good attention to detail
  • Katara's perspective is an interesting touch.

What I didn't like

  • Katara sometimes taking low blows at Zuko (saying his mother left him because she was annoyed with him, and enjoying his lack of firebending)

Comments

32ndfreeze Since: Dec, 1969
Jul 25th 2014 at 2:45:40 AM
The maternal bond thing really annoys me a lot in fanfiction. I really wish authors would stop using it. I mean sure break up Aang and Katara in order to get other pairings. Just don't use something that doesn't not exist. Plenty of other methods would work much better.
Valiona Since: Dec, 1969
Jul 25th 2014 at 3:00:38 PM
I agree; the Die for Our Ship page for Avatar notes that the age gap between Aang and Katara(a mere two years) is the same as the gap between Katara and Zuko). On the other hand, it's perhaps a tempting solution to retcon or explain away romantic feelings, which is a more gradual and easier task than creating an incident major enough to break up a canon pairing.

I do think that this might have been a better fic if it had started from the beginning and given Aang and Katara a platonic relationship; perhaps in an installment called "Stalked By Zuko".
romancechina88 Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 6th 2014 at 3:51:36 PM
That is always one real flaw i have found with any fic's that start from a certain point in canon rather than from the beginning of the series.

That the writer whether intentionally or not contradict, ignore or bash canon material of certain characters, events, background etc.

Which for me can lower the quality of their work, it's up to the author how, when and where they start their fic, and what they write about. But i think a good writer respects the canon material, even if they think it is bad, or could be better and uses it in a way that shows their attention to detail on the series they are writing. But still allowing them to make their mark with their own writing.
Valiona Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 6th 2014 at 8:59:32 PM
romancechina88,

I agree that respect for canon material is of the utmost importance. The problem I have with the Hate Fic genre (or even a Deconstruction Fic taken too far) is that it tends to read like more of a list of the author's grievances with canon, than an actual story, making such fics fail as stories in their own right, much less fanfics.

The author tends to occasionally correct certain things that she likely perceives as mistakes on the part of canon characters, such as having Aang try to learn healing (which seems to be a more involved and specialized form of training than offensive waterbending), or trying to break him of his predilection for airbending. Those aren't as major, but they are fairly noticeable, even without the author's notes pointing them out, and does make this series read like a Fix Fic at times.

Ultimately, for me, the most important thing is to remember that your fanfics are derived from canon, and because your fanfics can't exist without them, they should respect the source material.
Top