Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DavidCopperfield

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 1999 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation features a number of actors who would go on to feature in the ''Film/HarryPotter'' films.
** Young David himself is Creator/DanielRadcliffe.
** Betsey Trotwood is Creator/MaggieSmith.
** Jane Murdstone is Zoe Wanamaker.
** Mrs. Micawber is Creator/ImeldaStauton.
** Mrs. Crupp is Creator/DawnFrench.
** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and Creator/HarryLloyd as young James Steerforth.

to:

** The 1999 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation features a number of actors who would go on to feature in the ''Film/HarryPotter'' films.
**
films:
***
Young David himself is Creator/DanielRadcliffe.
** *** Betsey Trotwood is Creator/MaggieSmith.
** *** Jane Murdstone is Zoe Wanamaker.
** *** Mrs. Micawber is Creator/ImeldaStauton.
** *** Mrs. Crupp is Creator/DawnFrench.
** *** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and Creator/HarryLloyd as young James Steerforth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 1974-75 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation featured two actors who would play major roles in ''Series/BlakesSeven'' a few years later: Creator/GarethThomas as Mr. Murdstone and Creator/Jacqueline Pearce as Rosa Dartle.

to:

** The 1974-75 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation featured two actors who would play major roles in ''Series/BlakesSeven'' a few years later: Creator/GarethThomas as Mr. Murdstone and Creator/Jacqueline Pearce Creator/JacquelinePearce as Rosa Dartle.

Added: 359

Changed: 132

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: The 1999 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation features a number of actors who would go on to feature in the ''Film/HarryPotter'' films.

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition: RetroactiveRecognition:
** The 1974-75 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation featured two actors who would play major roles in ''Series/BlakesSeven'' a few years later: Creator/GarethThomas as Mr. Murdstone and Creator/Jacqueline Pearce as Rosa Dartle.
**
The 1999 [[Creator/TheBBC BBC]] adaptation features a number of actors who would go on to feature in the ''Film/HarryPotter'' films.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpiritualSuccessor: The 1993 AnimatedAdaptation is one to the Disney's RobinHood right down to Murdstone being a lion.

Added: 617

Changed: 312

Removed: 311

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut.


* FoeYay: Uriah gets very touchy-feely with David, who for his part, is fascinated by Uriah's strange appearance. Once he compares Heep's reddish brown eyes to "two glowing suns", and another time, when Uriah has wormed himself into David's home, David gives in to an irresistible temptation to watch him sleep.



* HoYay: The entirety of Steerforth and David's friendship is loaded with it, especially since in order to heighten the dramatic impact of Steerforth's ultimate betrayal Dickens gives David a number of unabashedly gushy rants that read exactly as though David has a crush on his older, handsome, hugely charming friend.

to:

* HoYay: HoYay:
**
The entirety of Steerforth and David's friendship is loaded with it, especially since in order to heighten the dramatic impact of Steerforth's ultimate betrayal Dickens gives David a number of unabashedly gushy rants that read exactly as though David has a crush on his older, handsome, hugely charming friend. friend.
** Uriah gets very touchy-feely with David, who for his part, is fascinated by Uriah's strange appearance. Once he compares Heep's reddish brown eyes to "two glowing suns", and another time, when Uriah has wormed himself into David's home, David gives in to an irresistible temptation to watch him sleep.

Added: 346

Changed: 343

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Indentation fixes


* TearJerker: So many! Like [[spoiler: Mr. Mell being fired and humiliated]], [[spoiler: David being told that both his mother and half-brother died]], [[spoiler: Barkis' death]], the revelation that [[spoiler: Steerforth betrayed David and Ham via seducing Emily]], and [[spoiler: Dora's death.]]

to:

* TearJerker: TearJerker
**
So many! Like [[spoiler: Mr. Mell being fired and humiliated]], [[spoiler: David being told that both his mother and half-brother died]], [[spoiler: Barkis' death]], the revelation that [[spoiler: Steerforth betrayed David and Ham via seducing Emily]], and [[spoiler: Dora's death.]]



* TheWoobie: David as a child. Also his mother, Dora and Little Emily.

to:

* TheWoobie: TheWoobie:
**
David as a child. Also his mother, Dora and Little Emily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Young David himself is Harry Potter.
** Betsey Trotwood is Professor [=McGonagall=].
** Jane Murdstone is Madame Hooch.
** Mrs. Micawber is Professor Umbridge.
** Mrs. Crupp is The Fat Lady in ''Film/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban''.
** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and [[Series/GameOfThrones Harry Lloyd (Viserys Targaryen)]] as young James Steerforth.

to:

** Young David himself is Harry Potter.
Creator/DanielRadcliffe.
** Betsey Trotwood is Professor [=McGonagall=].
Creator/MaggieSmith.
** Jane Murdstone is Madame Hooch.
Zoe Wanamaker.
** Mrs. Micawber is Professor Umbridge.
Creator/ImeldaStauton.
** Mrs. Crupp is The Fat Lady in ''Film/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban''.
Creator/DawnFrench.
** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and [[Series/GameOfThrones Harry Lloyd (Viserys Targaryen)]] Creator/HarryLloyd as young James Steerforth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not supported in the text. David's first conversation with Uriah involves the boy's assumption that Uriah will be a partner soon; it's Uriah himself that suggests it's too much to hope for.


* InformedWrongness: While Uriah's ''methods'' of obtaining his promotion to partner aren't exactly laudable, it's treated as a travesty that he should be promoted to partner at all even before this is known for sure, despite the fact that Uriah has been working for Mr Wickfield since he was eleven years old, appears to have done most of the work of the business for a substantial period of that time, and is, if nothing else, a capable lawyer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: In the 1999 miniseries Mrs Micawber is played by Creator/ImeldaStaunton, who treats David (played by a young Creator/DanielRadcliffe ) with great affection. Their next encounter is not [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix so pleasant...]] The inverse is true with Zoe Wanamaker, wicked Jane Murdstone in this series but playing the SternTeacher Madame Hooch in the Potterverse. Creator/MaggieSmith is stern and caring to Radcliffe's character in both.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: In the 1999 miniseries Mrs Micawber is played by Creator/ImeldaStaunton, who treats David (played by a young Creator/DanielRadcliffe ) Creator/DanielRadcliffe) with great affection. Their next encounter is not [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix so pleasant...]] The inverse is true with Zoe Wanamaker, wicked Jane Murdstone in this series but playing the SternTeacher Madame Hooch in the Potterverse. Creator/MaggieSmith is stern and caring to Radcliffe's character in both.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: In the 1999 miniseries Mrs Micawber is played by Creator/ImeldaStaunton, who treats David (played by a young Creator/DanielRadcliffe ) with great affection. Their next encounter is not [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix so pleasant...]] The inverse is true with Zoe Wanamaker, wicked Jane Murdstone in this series but playing the SternTeacher Madame Hooch in the Potterverse. Creator/Maggie Smith is stern and caring to Radcliffe's character in both.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: In the 1999 miniseries Mrs Micawber is played by Creator/ImeldaStaunton, who treats David (played by a young Creator/DanielRadcliffe ) with great affection. Their next encounter is not [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix so pleasant...]] The inverse is true with Zoe Wanamaker, wicked Jane Murdstone in this series but playing the SternTeacher Madame Hooch in the Potterverse. Creator/Maggie Smith Creator/MaggieSmith is stern and caring to Radcliffe's character in both.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Insufficient context...and hate.


* DamselScrappy: Agnes, for some readers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mr. Dick is portrayed fairly positively for a mentally challenged character in an older book.

to:

** Mr. Dick is portrayed fairly positively with an unusual amount of respect for a mentally challenged character in an older book.book, wherein such were more usually the ludicrous comic relief (this is the point of Aunt Betsey's repeated insistence that Mr Dick's actually a very deep and practical thinker, which would've amused contemporary readers ''much'' more than modern ones).

Changed: 28

Removed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Mr. and Mrs. Micawber, Steerforth, even Dora Spenlow, and a host of others. Many have noted that the least interesting character of ''David Copperfield'' is Davey himself.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Mr. and Mrs. Micawber, Steerforth, even Dora Spenlow, and a host of others. Many have noted that the least interesting character of ''David Copperfield'' is Davey himself.



* JerkAssWoobie: Yes, Rosa Dartle is a massive bitch, but in some interpretations a very tragic one as well.
* PinballProtagonist: David, increasingly towards the end of the book, is a mere looker-on at the dramatic resolution of others' subplots, including Micawber's expose of Heep and (less plausibly) Dan Peggotty's rescue of Emily.

to:

* JerkAssWoobie: JerkassWoobie: Yes, Rosa Dartle is a massive bitch, but in some interpretations a very tragic one as well.
* PinballProtagonist: David, increasingly towards the end of the book, is a mere looker-on at the dramatic resolution of others' subplots, including Micawber's expose of Heep and (less plausibly) Dan Peggotty's rescue of Emily.
well.



* TearJerker: So many! Like [[spoiler: Mr. Mell being fired and humiliated]], [[spoiler: David being told that both his mother and half-brother died]], [[spoiler: Barkis's death]], the revelation that [[spoiler: Steerforth betrayed David and Ham via seducing Emily]], and [[spoiler: Dora's death.]]

to:

* TearJerker: So many! Like [[spoiler: Mr. Mell being fired and humiliated]], [[spoiler: David being told that both his mother and half-brother died]], [[spoiler: Barkis's Barkis' death]], the revelation that [[spoiler: Steerforth betrayed David and Ham via seducing Emily]], and [[spoiler: Dora's death.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: In the 1999 miniseries Mrs Micawber is played by Creator/ImeldaStaunton, who treats David (played by a young Creator/DanielRadcliffe ) with great affection. Their next encounter is not [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix so pleasant...]] The inverse is true with Zoe Wanamaker, wicked Jane Murdstone in this series but playing the SternTeacher Madame Hooch in the Potterverse. Creator/Maggie Smith is stern and caring to Radcliffe's character in both.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InformedWrongness: While Uriah's ''methods'' of obtaining his promotion to partner aren't exactly laudable, it's treated as a travesty that he should be promoted to partner at all even before this is known for sure, despite the fact that Uriah has been working for Mr Wickfield since he was eleven years old, appears to have done most of the work of the business for a substantial period of that time, and is, if nothing else, a capable lawyer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Among other instances, a lot of readers think Dickens' shipping of the Peggottys to Australia after Emily's fall from grace is unfair, but the book actually was a fair look at prostitution at the time (and that kind of thing really happened, too). Not to mention the local prostitute, Martha, is treated as a sympathetic figure. Her OnlyFriend Emily clearly cares for her, helps her to go to London and start her life all over again, and later [[spoiler: she helps Daniel and David to find Emily again.]] Besides, even in their exile, both Emily and Martha's stories have happy endings endings [[spoiler: (Martha gets married, while Emily lives a good life of caring for those in need)]], in an era when "fallen woman" characters were more typically [[DisposableSexWorker killed off.]]

to:

** Among other instances, a lot of readers think Dickens' shipping of the Peggottys to Australia after Emily's fall from grace is unfair, but the book actually was a fair look at prostitution at the time (and that kind of thing really happened, too). Not to mention the local prostitute, Martha, is treated as a sympathetic figure. Her OnlyFriend Emily clearly cares for her, helps her to go to London and start her life all over again, and later [[spoiler: she helps Daniel and David to find Emily again.]] Besides, even in their exile, both Emily and Martha's stories have happy endings endings [[spoiler: (Martha gets married, while Emily lives a good life of caring for those in need)]], in an era when "fallen woman" characters were more typically [[DisposableSexWorker killed off.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FairForItsDay: Among other instances, a lot of readers think Dickens' shipping of the Peggottys to Australia after Emily's fall from grace is unfair, but the book actually was a fair look at prostitution at the time (and that kind of thing really happened, too).
** Not to mention the local prostitute, Martha, is treated as a sympathetic figure. Her OnlyFriend Emily clearly cares for her, helps her to go to London and start her life all over again, and later [[spoiler: she helps Daniel and David to find Emily again.]]

to:

* FairForItsDay: FairForItsDay:
**
Among other instances, a lot of readers think Dickens' shipping of the Peggottys to Australia after Emily's fall from grace is unfair, but the book actually was a fair look at prostitution at the time (and that kind of thing really happened, too).
**
too). Not to mention the local prostitute, Martha, is treated as a sympathetic figure. Her OnlyFriend Emily clearly cares for her, helps her to go to London and start her life all over again, and later [[spoiler: she helps Daniel and David to find Emily again.]] Besides, even in their exile, both Emily and Martha's stories have happy endings endings [[spoiler: (Martha gets married, while Emily lives a good life of caring for those in need)]], in an era when "fallen woman" characters were more typically [[DisposableSexWorker killed off.]]

Changed: 6

Removed: 75

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrowningMomentOfAwesome: " ... and the name of that scoundrel is - HEEP!"



* EnsembleDarkhorse: Mr. and Mrs. Micawber, Steerforth, even Dora Spenlow, and a host of others. Many have noted that, that the least interesting character of ''David Copperfield'' is Davey himself.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Mr. and Mrs. Micawber, Steerforth, even Dora Spenlow, and a host of others. Many have noted that, that the least interesting character of ''David Copperfield'' is Davey himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: "I have loved you all my life!"
** "I'll take my chances with the boy."
** The scene where David gets home from his trans-continental vacation of perpetual depression and meets up with his old buddy Traddles.
* CrowningMomentOfFunny: Aunt Betsy's... ''bizarre'' reaction to young!David showing up on her doorstep and telling her who he is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Mr. and Mrs. Micawber, Steerforth, even Dora Spenlow, and a host of others. Many have noted that, that the least interesting character of ''David Copperfield'' is Davey himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TooCoolToLive: Many critics have complained about Steerforth's usurpation of the story.

Added: 227

Removed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Designated Hero}}: David, increasingly towards the end of the book, is a mere looker-on at the dramatic resolution of others' subplots, including Micawber's expose of Heep and (less plausibly) Dan Peggotty's rescue of Emily.


Added DiffLines:

* PinballProtagonist: David, increasingly towards the end of the book, is a mere looker-on at the dramatic resolution of others' subplots, including Micawber's expose of Heep and (less plausibly) Dan Peggotty's rescue of Emily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Mr. Dick is portrayed fairly positively for a mentally challenged character in an older book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and Creator/HarryLloyd as young James Steerforth.

to:

** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and Creator/HarryLloyd [[Series/GameOfThrones Harry Lloyd (Viserys Targaryen)]] as young James Steerforth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** From other works: Creator/IanMcKellen is Mr. Creakle and Creator/HarryLloyd as young James Steerforth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FreudWasRight: {{Inverted}}, as Freud may have been influenced by this novel!

Added: 108

Changed: 445

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FoeYay: Uriah gets very touchy-feely with David, who for his part, is fascinated by Uriah's strange appearance. Once he compares those reddish brown eyes to "two glowing suns", and another time, when Uriah has wormed himself into David's home, David gives in to an irresistible temptation to watch him sleep.
* FreudWasRight: {{Inverted}}, as Freud may have been influenced by this novel?
* JerkAssWoobie: For some, [[spoiler: Rosa Dartle]] is a massive bitch... but as a very tragic one as well.

to:

* FoeYay: Uriah gets very touchy-feely with David, who for his part, is fascinated by Uriah's strange appearance. Once he compares those Heep's reddish brown eyes to "two glowing suns", and another time, when Uriah has wormed himself into David's home, David gives in to an irresistible temptation to watch him sleep.
* FreudWasRight: {{Inverted}}, as Freud may have been influenced by this novel?
novel!
* HoYay: The entirety of Steerforth and David's friendship is loaded with it, especially since in order to heighten the dramatic impact of Steerforth's ultimate betrayal Dickens gives David a number of unabashedly gushy rants that read exactly as though David has a crush on his older, handsome, hugely charming friend.
* JerkAssWoobie: For some, [[spoiler: Yes, Rosa Dartle]] Dartle is a massive bitch... bitch, but as in some interpretations a very tragic one as well.



** The 1935 adaptation, David, after finding his mother has married Murdstone and is booted from his old bedroom to a crappy, broken down guest room, tearfully reads his Crocodile Book, and then breaks down crying. It's hard not to feel for him.
* ValuesDissonance: Tons, most notably in the treatment of women. The entire emotional impact of Emily's subplot depends on assumptions re: female virtue that are very nearly unimaginable today.

to:

** The In the 1935 adaptation, David, after finding his mother has married Murdstone and is that he's furthermore been booted from his old bedroom near hers to a crappy, broken down guest room, tearfully reads his Crocodile Book, and then breaks down crying. It's hard not to feel for him.
* ValuesDissonance: Tons, most notably in the treatment of women. The entire Much of the emotional impact of Emily's subplot depends on assumptions re: female virtue that are very nearly unimaginable today.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TearJerker: So many! Like [[spoiler: Mr. Mell being fired and humiliated]], [[spoiler: David being told that both his mother and half-brother died]], [[spoiler: Barkis's death]] and the upcoming revelation that [[spoiler: Steerforth betrayed David and Ham via seducing Emily]], and [[spoiler: Dora's death.]]
** The 1935 adaptation, David, after finding his mother has married Murdstone and is booted from his old bedroom to a crappy, broken down guest room, tearfully reads a crocodile book, and then breaks down crying. It's hard not to feel for him.
* ValuesDissonance

to:

* TearJerker: So many! Like [[spoiler: Mr. Mell being fired and humiliated]], [[spoiler: David being told that both his mother and half-brother died]], [[spoiler: Barkis's death]] and death]], the upcoming revelation that [[spoiler: Steerforth betrayed David and Ham via seducing Emily]], and [[spoiler: Dora's death.]]
** The 1935 adaptation, David, after finding his mother has married Murdstone and is booted from his old bedroom to a crappy, broken down guest room, tearfully reads a crocodile book, his Crocodile Book, and then breaks down crying. It's hard not to feel for him.
* ValuesDissonance ValuesDissonance: Tons, most notably in the treatment of women. The entire emotional impact of Emily's subplot depends on assumptions re: female virtue that are very nearly unimaginable today.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Flame Bait. Also, I believe sue tropes should be reserved for (bad) fanfiction, and not criticising classic works of literature, due to Values Dissonance - that fits better half the time.


* PuritySue: Agnes Wickfield, David's 'dearest sister'. Albeit somewhat more realistic than most examples, and even quite likeable in spots, she's clearly intended as the 'angel in the house' archetype beloved of most authors of the period. Kinda hard to ignore when she's ''introduced'' standing in the light of a stained-glass window, 'pointing upward'.

Top