Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TreeOfSmoke

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: The Americans and Vietnamese are ultimately not so different from each other. See [[BlackAndGrayMorality Black And Gray Morality]]. There's also the Filipinos and the French settlers. One theme of the book seems to be that humans have more in common with each other than they assume.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


The closest thing to a "hero" the book has is Colonel Sands, a [[BadassGrandpa retired war hero]] who leads an operation in Vietnam with the help of the CIA. A bit [[CloudCuckoolander zany]] in his antics, although trust us when we say he's one of the most sane characters in the entire book.

to:

The closest thing to a "hero" the book has is Colonel Sands, a [[BadassGrandpa retired war hero]] hero who leads an operation in Vietnam with the help of the CIA. A bit [[CloudCuckoolander zany]] in his antics, although trust us when we say he's one of the most sane characters in the entire book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Surrealism}}: Much like ''Literatue/TheThingsTheyCarried'', this is a modern example of surrealist literature, although it does come back to Earth every now and again.

to:

* {{Surrealism}}: Much like ''Literatue/TheThingsTheyCarried'', ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried'', this is a modern example of surrealist literature, although it does come back to Earth every now and again.

Added: 87

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added image.


[[quoteright:306:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/tree_of_smoke.png]]



----

to:

----






* WorldOfSymbolism: Present throughout, but becomes more apparent in trippy passages.

to:

* WorldOfSymbolism: Present throughout, but becomes more apparent in trippy passages.passages.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Due to its slow pacing, penchant for [[SeinfeldianConversation low-key dialogue]], and [[SurrealHorror horrifically dreamlike]] atmosphere, the book has become known for being [[LoveItOrHateIt somewhat divisive]] among readers. There's no single protagonist (although there are several related plot threads), the protagonists are [[AntiHero deeply flawed]] at best and [[BlueAndOrangeMorality downright bizarre]] in their actions and motives at times.

to:

Due to its slow pacing, penchant for [[SeinfeldianConversation low-key dialogue]], and [[SurrealHorror horrifically dreamlike]] atmosphere, the book has become known for being [[LoveItOrHateIt somewhat divisive]] divisive among readers. There's no single protagonist (although there are several related plot threads), the protagonists are [[AntiHero deeply flawed]] at best and [[BlueAndOrangeMorality downright bizarre]] in their actions and motives at times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Useful Notes/ pages are not tropes


* {{Existentialism}}: Discussions about God and the free will of Man come up quite a bit, not to mention the notion of nature absorbing mankind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Think ''Literature/{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.

to:

Think ''Literature/{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY [[JustForFun/XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolOldGuy: Colonel Sands served in [[WorldWarII World War II]], and despite now being a civilian is practically worshiped by his subordinates.

to:

* CoolOldGuy: Colonel Sands served in [[WorldWarII World War II]], UsefulNotes/WorldWarII, and despite now being a civilian is practically worshiped by his subordinates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Tree of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[DoorStopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.

to:

''Tree of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[DoorStopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], UsefulNotes/TheVietnamWar, Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Tree Of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[DoorStopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.

to:

''Tree Of of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[DoorStopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.



!!''Tree Of Smoke'' contains examples of the following tropes:

to:

!!''Tree Of of Smoke'' contains examples of the following tropes:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Think ''{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.

to:

Think ''{{Ulysses}}'' ''Literature/{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FreudWasRight: "James dreamt of firefights: shooting useless bullets out of an impotent gun."



* WorldOfSymbolism: Present throughout, but becomes more apparent in trippy passages.

to:

* WorldOfSymbolism: Present throughout, but becomes more apparent in trippy passages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Skewed Priorities: [[SarcasmMode Remember kids]], when you're in the middle of a war zone it's best to get drunk as possible and as often as possible.

to:

* Skewed Priorities: SkewedPriorities: [[SarcasmMode Remember kids]], when you're in the middle of a war zone it's best to get drunk as possible and as often as possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Existentialism: Discussions about God and the free will of Man come up quite a bit, not to mention the notion of nature absorbing mankind.

to:

* Existentialism: {{Existentialism}}: Discussions about God and the free will of Man come up quite a bit, not to mention the notion of nature absorbing mankind.

Added: 1203

Changed: 287

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*AnArmAndALeg: There's a soldier with a leg that got blown off, using crutches to get around.



* BlackComedy: Some of the soldiers' antics are this with a healthy dose of [[MindScrew Mind Screw]].



* CoolOldGuy: Colonel Sands served in [[WorldWarII World War II], and despite now being a civilian is practically worshiped by his subordinates.

to:

* CoolOldGuy: Colonel Sands served in [[WorldWarII World War II], II]], and despite now being a civilian is practically worshiped by his subordinates.subordinates.
* DoorStopper: About 700 pages long, depending on the edition.
* {{Eagleland}}: Definitely a mixture of both types. Skip Sands and the colonel are Type 1, at least at first, while many of the American soldiers are more Type 2.
* Existentialism: Discussions about God and the free will of Man come up quite a bit, not to mention the notion of nature absorbing mankind.



* MindScrew: When shit gets weird, it gets ''really'' weird. Though considering how James and other characters are either drunk or high (or both) a lot of the time, this isn't too surprising.



** If you didn't know about the effects of [[Gorn white phosphorous]] before, you sure do now.

to:

** If you didn't know about the effects of [[Gorn [[{{Gorn}} white phosphorous]] before, you sure do now.now.
* Skewed Priorities: [[SarcasmMode Remember kids]], when you're in the middle of a war zone it's best to get drunk as possible and as often as possible.



* NotSoDifferent: The Americans and Vietnamese are ultimately not so different from each other. See [[BlackAndGrayMorality Black And Gray Morality]]. There's also the Filipinos and the French settlers.

to:

* SurrealHorror: On top of all the violence and symbolism, some things simply do not make much sense when taken at face value, but that doesn't make them any less unnerving.
* NotSoDifferent: The Americans and Vietnamese are ultimately not so different from each other. See [[BlackAndGrayMorality Black And Gray Morality]]. There's also the Filipinos and the French settlers. One theme of the book seems to be that humans have more in common with each other than they assume.

Added: 923

Changed: 488

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: And die they do. Horribly.



* FemalesAreMoreInnocent: Innocence which is then [BreakTheCutie utterly crushed]], particularly in Kathy Jones's plot thread.

to:

* BornLucky: Those who accompany him see Colonel Sands as invincible to an almost-supernatural degree.
* CloudCuckoolander: Sometimes [[PlayedForLaughs Played For Laughs]], other times for [[SurrealHorror Surreal Horror]].
* ColonelKilgore: Sergeant Harmon can come across as this.
* CoolOldGuy: Colonel Sands served in [[WorldWarII World War II], and despite now being a civilian is practically worshiped by his subordinates.
* FemalesAreMoreInnocent: Innocence which is then [BreakTheCutie [[BreakTheCutie utterly crushed]], particularly in Kathy Jones's plot thread.thread.
* FreudWasRight: "James dreamt of firefights: shooting useless bullets out of an impotent gun."
* NightmareFuel: Once our heroes enter Vietnam, things get ''very'' ugly.
** If you didn't know about the effects of [[Gorn white phosphorous]] before, you sure do now.



* Surrealism: Much like ''Literatue/TheThingsTheyCarried'', this is a modern example of surrealist literature, although it does come back to Earth every now and again.

to:

* Surrealism: NotSoDifferent: The Americans and Vietnamese are ultimately not so different from each other. See [[BlackAndGrayMorality Black And Gray Morality]]. There's also the Filipinos and the French settlers.
* {{Surrealism}}:
Much like ''Literatue/TheThingsTheyCarried'', this is a modern example of surrealist literature, although it does come back to Earth every now and again.

Added: 744

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Tree Of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[Doorstopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.

to:

''Tree Of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[Doorstopper [[DoorStopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.



Think ''{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.

to:

Think ''{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.
----
!!''Tree Of Smoke'' contains examples of the following tropes:

* AntiHero: '''Oh yes.''' In an ensemble of troubled protagonists, though, James Houston takes the cake. The Houston family as a whole is [[DysfunctionJunction pretty messed up]], really.
* BlackAndGrayMorality: And it's a fairly dark shade of gray.
* FemalesAreMoreInnocent: Innocence which is then [BreakTheCutie utterly crushed]], particularly in Kathy Jones's plot thread.
* SociopathicSoldier: Quite a few of them, it seems.
* Surrealism: Much like ''Literatue/TheThingsTheyCarried'', this is a modern example of surrealist literature, although it does come back to Earth every now and again.
* WorldOfSymbolism: Present throughout, but becomes more apparent in trippy passages.

Added: 819

Changed: 173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Tree Of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[Doorstopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. One could argue that ''Tree Of Smoke'' is the ''Ulysses'' of war novels.

to:

''Tree Of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[Doorstopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. One could argue that ''Tree Of Smoke'' Despite being advertised as an epic novel about [[TheVietnamWar The Vietnam War]], Johnson's work is about a lot more than just that.

Due to its slow pacing, penchant for [[SeinfeldianConversation low-key dialogue]], and [[SurrealHorror horrifically dreamlike]] atmosphere,
the ''Ulysses'' of book has become known for being [[LoveItOrHateIt somewhat divisive]] among readers. There's no single protagonist (although there are several related plot threads), the protagonists are [[AntiHero deeply flawed]] at best and [[BlueAndOrangeMorality downright bizarre]] in their actions and motives at times.

The closest thing to a "hero" the book has is Colonel Sands, a [[BadassGrandpa retired
war novels.hero]] who leads an operation in Vietnam with the help of the CIA. A bit [[CloudCuckoolander zany]] in his antics, although trust us when we say he's one of the most sane characters in the entire book.

Think ''{{Ulysses}}'' [[XMeetsY meets]] ''Literature/TheThingsTheyCarried''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-> ''"Young men, while you live," he told them, "find out how to wake up from this nightmare."''

''Tree Of Smoke'' is an [[MindScrew esoteric]] war novel written by Denis Johnson and first published in 2007, winning the National Book Award for Fiction. It is [[Doorstopper very long]], [[NightmareFuel very nightmarish]], and almost [[RuleOfSymbolism too metaphysical]] for its own good. One could argue that ''Tree Of Smoke'' is the ''Ulysses'' of war novels.

Top