Main Ambiguously Bi Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

lavendermintrose
Topic
08:24:41 PM Jul 20th 2016
If a character's Ambiguously Bi is based on them supposedly being attracted to two characters, one of whom is male and the other is female, but I think that the troper who listed it there was wrong about one or the other... I don't think it means the character can't be bi, so I don't want to remove it, but at the same time, there's nothing between the character that's listed there. (Mostly opposite-sex close friends). So... I'm not saying they're definitely 100% same sex, I'm saying there's just nothing between them and that character. I hate to remove examples because of that, but...
rightyo
Topic
02:22:01 AM Apr 4th 2015
It seems to have been mildly discussed but I think it is actually a very good idea to make it a YMMV trope, since it is "ambiguously" gay or bi characters it's by it's nature very subjective and open to interpretation. And it seems like whenever a character is labeled as Ambiguously Bi/Gay on their respective work's main or character trope list it's often flagged because there's not canonical evidience that the character is attracted to the same gender, even if it is, again, specifically those who are only "ambiguously" gay/bi not characters who are definitely-in-the-closet or Bi the Way.

So I guess long point short it definitely should be a YMMV trope (I originally thought it was), it's too much controversy and hassle as a main trope.
SeptimusHeap
03:02:51 AM Apr 4th 2015
While I would agree, I am not sure if the forum would agree.
supergod
07:53:17 AM Aug 21st 2015
I just think it should just be made less subjective, so that it only examples that are very clearly intentional. I think if the trope was made YMMV, people would just add examples of intentionally ambiguous characters to the Bi the Way page, which should remain for characters that are pretty much confirmed as bi.
Eaterman1995
Topic
08:18:59 PM Mar 24th 2015
edited by Eaterman1995
The Tom & Jerry and Megamind examples seem like they should probably be removed. They're both stretching it.
SeptimusHeap
12:57:42 AM Mar 25th 2015
Even if they are, ban evasion is not acceptable behaviour.
MsPickles
Topic
06:50:17 AM Jan 15th 2015
I personally think Sam and Dean Winchester, Megamind and Yu Narukami should all be removed, this page isn't supposed to be for discussing characters that yaoi fangirls ship with guys, and the first three fall pretty strongly into that category especially Dean since his actor confirmed he's straight. There's a case to be made for Yu, but I always saw his semi-flirtatious behavior with the guys as his idea of a joke.
Larkmarn
08:18:34 AM Jan 15th 2015
Yeah. Sam and Dean have plenty of Ho Yay, but they've only actually shown attraction to women. They've shown love towards men, but it's pretty clearly and explicitly brotherly love.

As for Yu... given he's a bit of Cloud Cuckoolander and Troll (especially in The Golden Animation), it's not a great examples.

Honestly, this page is so full of stretches I think it wouldn't be a bad idea to make it YMMV.
MissKitten
Topic
06:11:02 PM May 20th 2013
No offense but a lot of these examples seem very Shipping Goggles-y.
Pannic
Topic
11:20:34 PM Mar 3rd 2013
Some of these are a bit of a stretch. I mean, Harry Potter? Doncha think maybe we could tone down the shipping goggles just a smidge?
Telcontar
01:27:20 AM Mar 4th 2013
Yeeeah, he doesn't fit. Pulling fangirl shipping paragraph that digs at and reinterprets everything:

  • Harry Potter:Harry Potter himself. While he's shown to have a crush on Cho and later fall in love with Ginny, he also had plenty of Stupid Sexy Flanders moments when Bill Weasley is around, when watching Tom Riddle in the Pensieve, and another moment with Cedric Diggory who Harry describes as handsome... and he can't refer to Sirius's teenage self without dropping the word "handsome". In Half-Blood Prince there's also his strange preoccupation with Draco and his massive boycrush on the eponymous Prince.

I'll also post in the fora to ask if someone can do more thorough cleaning.
Larkmarn
06:19:16 AM Mar 4th 2013
Haha, yeh no. That needs to be pulled.

Any other ship-y examples?
LoserTakesAll
Topic
01:56:37 AM Mar 18th 2012
Removed:

Because isn't the entire point of everything after the word "Note" in the trope description specifically intended to keep people from posting examples that are just characters fandom wants to be bi or gay when nothing in the original work suggests they actually are?
Collapse/Expand Topics
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/remarks.php?trope=Main.AmbiguouslyBi